Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cause of death (sorry a bit morbid. Maybe triggering)

115 replies

HelloDoggy · 29/09/2022 21:55

Was reading that the queen's official cause of death was 'old age'. Which got me thinking - what is this? When someone old dies, what actually happens? I always assumed there was something which caused the death like a heart attack, cancer, malnutrition, or something. What does dying by 'old age' actually mean? Surely something in the body must have 'broken'/'stopped working'? Why isn't that something noted as the cause of death?

Age can't kill you surely. It must be the consequence of aging that kill you?

OP posts:
GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 29/09/2022 22:53

I’ve known of two over-90s who’d had no actual health problems, who were just found to have died in their sleep. So technically I dare say they died of heart failure, as a result of old age.
Great way to go, if you can manage it!

SylvieB74 · 29/09/2022 22:52

I think I remember that Harold Shipman recorded one or two deaths as old age. But really, I don’t know why these things have to be public
for anybody let alone the queen.

HelloDoggy · 29/09/2022 22:51

lingle · 29/09/2022 22:39

A good way to go anyway. I’ll choose that death any day

Yes me too

OP posts:
nokidshere · 29/09/2022 22:51

My MIL died aged 96 of 'old age'. She had no medical issues, she was just old, tired and frail. She was poorly for 2 days before she died. The Dr said it could have been any number of things but essentially her body just got to the end.

AgeingDoc · 29/09/2022 22:48

Back in the dark ages when I was doing lots of death certificates as a junior doctor "old age" or similar was not permitted. You had to give some pathology as the cause of death even when it was fairly obvious that an elderly person had just naturally reached the end of their lives and was basically just "worn out". Bronchopneumonia or ischaemic heart disease were regularly given as causes of death in those circumstances. How accurate that was, I couldn't say, but without doing post mortems on lots of very old people, with no real benefit to them, their families or society there is no way of knowing.
And in fact even a post mortem isn't guaranteed to give you the full story. As a pathologist colleague of mine was always very fond of quoting " A post mortem will tell you what the patient died with but not necessarily what they died of." Meaning that there might be various abnormal findings at post mortem, but you can't always tell which of them actually led directly to death. Or indeed if one thing did - it could well be a combination of things, and probably often is, especially in elderly people with multiple long term conditions.
I think the change to allow old age was a sensible one, as you do get generally healthy elderly people who just die because they've reached the end of their natural life span, without any obvious final illness. There are however specific conditions that need to be met before this can be given as the sole cause of death and I agree that it seems a bit questionable whether they were met in the Queen's case. However, that is a matter for the doctor who signed the certificate and the registrar who registered the death, and only her medical attendants and close family will have all the information so there's not really much point in speculating.

bloodyunicorns · 29/09/2022 22:46

Who do we feel the need to know the queen's cause of death? That should be private to her and her family. How would you like everyone poring over your Gran's death cert?

bloodyunicorns · 29/09/2022 22:44

gah2teenagers · 29/09/2022 22:09

My relative had just Alzheimer’s on her death certificate and the register had to get her book out to check it was allowed as she said you never just see that. Apparently it’s allowed after a certain age.

Of course you do. Advanced Alzheimer's means you can't swallow or eat. It's not an unusual cause of death. 💐

WOPTF · 29/09/2022 22:42

Yes if you're over 80 old age is a totally valid cause if death IF there was no other significant recent medical history. If a doctor hasn't seen the deceased within the 28 days preceding death then the coroner would get involved, but that wouldn't necessarily mean a post mortem would be performed.
I'd be totally happy to have old age as my cause of death! We see it a lot on death registrations. Of course, someone may have declined due to an undiagnosed cancer or other illness, but at an advanced age is it really necessary for their family to know for sure, by delaying a funeral and carrying out invasive tests on their deceased loved one?

Georgeskitchen · 29/09/2022 22:40

There's nothing covered up or mysterious about the Queens death. Like the old car mentioned, she just wore out. She had been visibly diminishing over the years and that seemed to speed up rapidly when Philip died. She was 96. She had lived a long and full life

lingle · 29/09/2022 22:39

A good way to go anyway. I’ll choose that death any day

GrimmTales · 29/09/2022 22:32

My gran had this on her death certificate -old age. She was 99. It definitely wasn’t heart failure. It was her kidneys that started to fail first -but they’re just part of the system if organs that “fail” as you start the dying process.

2bazookas · 29/09/2022 22:28

Very old bodies can just wear out.

In recent months, she was very tiny and frail, had shrunk height and lost weight, was walking with a stick if at all, tired easily or feeling weak (cancelled planned meetings etc) . All of which suggest her digestive system was absorbing fewer nutrients which is common in old age. At that stage it doesn't take very much for the heart and lung function to slow right down until there's not enough oxygen reaching the brain and they just fade out. Very peaceful.

Lemonyfuckit · 29/09/2022 22:27

HelloDoggy · 29/09/2022 22:05

That's really interesting. I guess there must just come a point when the body can't keep going. I just always assumed.it would be one specific part that gave up the ghost first, and that would be what's considered the cause of death. But maybe it's the mind that gives up, and that kind of sends signals to the body to say 'ok body, you can just shut down now, I'm ready to stop"?

I've often thought this about the mind - and also with people who go do have a specific illness too but who hang on for a key date like an anniversary or a loved one's wedding but then die not too long afterwards.

Lemonyfuckit · 29/09/2022 22:26

I don't know what my Grandmother's actual cause of death was listed as, but I'd always sort of assumed it was 'old age' - she didn't have any specific disease but was very frail and had been for years and spent most of her time sleeping so I always imagine her body had just sort of eventually given out. Come to think of it my great uncle who passed away quite recently and was the last relative I had of that generation was similar, no specific illness that I'm aware of, spent most of the day asleep, body just slowing down until it stopped I think. But then I have no medical background so maybe that's not the case at all in fact.

Dotcheck · 29/09/2022 22:25

Why is this triggering ? Is someone out there unaware the queen died?

MrJi · 29/09/2022 22:24

And my Mum also took time to die.
I don’t think they are covering something up. Elderly people can just fade away. My mother had moderate dementia but not severe, she’d had some strokes over the years, but she just ate less and less in the months leading to her death. She slept more, she very gradually became less present, even though she was her normal chatty self when awake, she would tire more easily. In the end she stopped eating. There was no one reason, just her body gradually deteriorating and winding down.

Slowgrowingelm · 29/09/2022 22:23

OP our bodies can’t go on for ever. Our cellular turnover slows, our bodies don’t heal or recover as well as they did, our organs start to shut down. And we die. Sometimes it really is the body slowly shutting down.

honeyfox · 29/09/2022 22:22

You can totally die of old age and your organs just giving up. It's generally put down as heart failure, have seen this with at least 4 family members. Luckily we have good genetics and live into our nineties.

RiverSkater · 29/09/2022 22:21

I thought the term used was natural causes. But I'm guessing her heart and body were worn out from age and just stopped working. 😞

maddening · 29/09/2022 22:20

HelloDoggy · 29/09/2022 22:09

I don't know! I think I just thought that something would have to be the ultimate cause. Like when you have a really old car - it's clearly not going to last forever, but there will be one thing which ultimately causes it's final demise - the battery dies or the door falls off and it's too old to be fixed.

It is definitely old age then with a car, sure you can keep mending buy when it it too old to fix then that is old age 😁 my micra had done 130k, engine fine, floor was falling apart and had been previously welded and just not worth it given the age and miles.

RunnerDown · 29/09/2022 22:20

“Old age “ as cause of death does not mean heart failure.
Alzheimers disease is a terminal illness and is the cause of death for many people , including some younger folk .www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/dementia
According to the WHO dementia is the seventh leading cause of death around the world.
Old age is acceptable on a death certificate in Scotland as cause of death if the patient is over 80 and certain other criteria are met, including there being a general ongoing decline and no other discernible cause for the death.

MrJi · 29/09/2022 22:20

My mother’s death certificate also says “old age” . She was a decade younger than the Queen.

Queuesarasarah · 29/09/2022 22:17

There will be a cause or (more likely) multiple causes. I would assume the doctor, being aware that it would be published was keeping her dignity a bit. It’s not inaccurate.

Ramsbottom · 29/09/2022 22:16

They are protecting her privacy, you don’t die of old age, you die of something else , there is always a cause, but old age can hasten it or leave you unable to fight it. But old age is never the primary cause and it’s a rare situation it’s permitted, a 105 year old would be an exception;

she also didn’t go suddenly. They basically reported she was gravely Ill a few hours before they announced she was dead. So it was something else and they aren’t saying.

I don’t quite think it’s ok either, but it may have been her wish, especially if she’d been suffering from cancer or something. They did the same with Philip. And we know he didn’t just die of old age. The fact it’s on both certificates makes me think it was the queens wish

UthredofBattenberg · 29/09/2022 22:15

The human body is finite. I think ultimately there comes a point where it is just worn out.

Maybe not cancer, dementia, stroke or heart failure etc, it's just accumulated years of wear of tear

Swipe left for the next trending thread