Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cause of death (sorry a bit morbid. Maybe triggering)

115 replies

HelloDoggy · 29/09/2022 21:55

Was reading that the queen's official cause of death was 'old age'. Which got me thinking - what is this? When someone old dies, what actually happens? I always assumed there was something which caused the death like a heart attack, cancer, malnutrition, or something. What does dying by 'old age' actually mean? Surely something in the body must have 'broken'/'stopped working'? Why isn't that something noted as the cause of death?

Age can't kill you surely. It must be the consequence of aging that kill you?

OP posts:
GrimmTales · 30/09/2022 09:13

Dying of old age suggests someone had been bed bound and deteriorating for weeks.

No, that’s not right. “Bed bound and deteriorating for weeks” would indicate illness, not old age.

Farahilda · 30/09/2022 09:10

PermanentTemporary · 29/09/2022 21:59

There's some interesting tweets from doctors saying they'd expect to be called up by the Medical Examiner if they put that on a death certificate and that it's not sufficient. Apparently 'frailty of old age' would be better and I can see that - i see a lot of very old patients who just don't have the reserves to get through one more infection.

I should imagine that her privacy is being protected. Which is actually not really OK. I think either release an accurate death certificate or don't release it.

Medical Examiner is a US term, and HMQ died in Scotland, so if the death were unexpected/unexplained, it would be reported to the Procurator Fiscal (parallel function to Coroners elsewhere in UK)

Old age/frailty owing to old age is an acceptable cause of death provided that the deceased is over 80 and there is no obvious other cause such as stroke or acute infection.

BooksAndHooks · 30/09/2022 09:10

DH grandmother’s was similar and was very odd it said something like grand old age, she was 98.

Sally090807 · 30/09/2022 09:07

My aunt just gradually ate less and drank less until she couldn’t eat or drink as she could no longer swallow, then over the next 2 days you could visibly see her body was shutting down. The skin colour changes, the breathing changes and then she passed away.
It also says old age on her death certificate.

Sidge · 30/09/2022 09:04

Liila · 30/09/2022 08:00

I'm pleased the Queen was allowed some privacy in death but you're right, dying of old age is an odd thing to put on a legal document. You die of a stroke, or a heart attack. Dying of old age suggests someone had been bed bound and deteriorating for weeks. Not someone who was doing official duties on the Tues and clearly had some sudden event on the Thursday.

Not necessarily, a stroke or heart attack is an acute event usually caused by some underlying pathology such as heart disease or a clotting event.

Old age causes a general decline in organ function and biochemistry. Sometimes very old people just go to sleep and don’t wake up, especially if they’ve become frail and aren’t eating as well as they used to. The Queen had become visibly thinner, more frail and looked very old fairly quickly.

Human bodies are essentially complicated machines, and don’t last forever.

Noteverybodylives · 30/09/2022 09:01

Our organs have an expiry date and there’s only so many times our cells can renew themselves.

When they finally get to a certain point the cells stop renewing and the organs start to work less and then ultimately fail.
Like a bouquet of flowers, they slowly start to gradually die.

I don’t know what organs shut down first or if it’s the same for everyone or if they all simultaneously start failing.

I find it really interesting and weird to die of old age and that your body just expires.

Dotjones · 30/09/2022 08:48

Like when you have a really old car - it's clearly not going to last forever, but there will be one thing which ultimately causes it's final demise - the battery dies or the door falls off and it's too old to be fixed.

The car analogy doesn't work because a car is never "too old" to be fixed. Too expensive to fix, definitely, but not too old. Look at some of the early cars from the 1890s that are still running. Many of them are like Trigger's broom in Only Fools and Horses in that barely anything of them is original. Things have been replaced at different times, new wheels here and new bodywork there.

The human body is not the same. There comes a point where it can't be fixed.

Skinnermarink · 30/09/2022 08:36

Sorry the quote didn’t post, but I was saying that while no autopsy in this case was necessary, there would be instances where it probably is, despite ‘old age’

Skinnermarink · 30/09/2022 08:35

Well in the case of Harold shipman, they definitely should have! He was able to get away with so much because of ‘old age’.

nothing to do with the Queen obviously. She really did just wear out I think.

BonnieWeeJeannieMcColl · 30/09/2022 08:32

RiverSkater · 29/09/2022 22:21

I thought the term used was natural causes. But I'm guessing her heart and body were worn out from age and just stopped working. 😞

The term might be "natural causes" in England. but the Queen died in Scotland. "Old age" is a perfectly acceptable cause of death.

Worthyornot · 30/09/2022 08:31

Does it really matter though. At 96, a reason is hardly going to be useful.

CatSpeakForDummies · 30/09/2022 08:29

My dog died of old age, over 24 hours his organs all just slowed down until his heart stopped, the vet told us that all his organs were just too fragile to cope with any of the others upsetting the balance, although none were technically damaged or diseased.

He was given painkillers and an appointment to be PTS the next day but slipped away peacefully in his sleep.

ditalini · 30/09/2022 08:22

3 out of 4 of my grandparents have "old age" as the cause of death on their certificates (all well over 90 and died at home with no specific preceding illness).

Maybe it's a difference between Scottish and English rules?

Not sure why there's this odd conspiracy theory around the death certificate of a frail 96 year old.

lljkk · 30/09/2022 08:02

Does Scotland have its own guidelines about when to say "Old Age" on a death certificate, different rules from England?

Weird events of the morning... Teen DS (on paper round) found a dead person (customer). DH went round to wait for ambulance & tried giving the body chest compressions. We were just talking about how much might that death be investigated. We have impression the deceased was an older person, had ambulances around his home often, was in chronic poor health.

Liila · 30/09/2022 08:00

I'm pleased the Queen was allowed some privacy in death but you're right, dying of old age is an odd thing to put on a legal document. You die of a stroke, or a heart attack. Dying of old age suggests someone had been bed bound and deteriorating for weeks. Not someone who was doing official duties on the Tues and clearly had some sudden event on the Thursday.

Metabigot · 30/09/2022 07:58

HelloDoggy · 29/09/2022 22:05

That's really interesting. I guess there must just come a point when the body can't keep going. I just always assumed.it would be one specific part that gave up the ghost first, and that would be what's considered the cause of death. But maybe it's the mind that gives up, and that kind of sends signals to the body to say 'ok body, you can just shut down now, I'm ready to stop"?

She was really not happy with the Truss appointment then....

BMW6 · 30/09/2022 07:57

I think it's right not to do Post Mortems on very elderly people to establish (if possible) the exact cause of death.

My Mum died suddenly at 76, PM established death from Pneumonia. Great way to go, was obviously instant and "easy" judging by the way she was found.

If she'd been 90+ I'd not expect or want a PM to have been carried out.

J0y · 30/09/2022 07:54

I think for somebody over 90 that is explanation enough. At 74 though you'd expect more detail.

BoopBoopBoDiddley · 30/09/2022 07:43

All I can see, was at the Platinum Jubilee, Our Queen was only able to do some of the celebrations with us. Remember, she nearly didn't appear on the balcony at the end, but then showed up in an emerald outfit. She looked like the Queen always did, but the next time we saw her was with the new PM and she looked very frail all of a sudden. I didn't think she was going to die, but she looked very frail. Thank God Anne and King Charles got there in time

ThirtyThreeTrees · 29/09/2022 23:11

I think old age is a nice way of saying no chronic or acute medical conditions. Just overall slow down of everything after a long time living.

Bobbybobbins · 29/09/2022 22:59

I am glad they have put this as it almost seems more of a human way to put it. Tbh I list a little bit of faith in death certificates when my uncle's was recorded as covid and he had tested negative!

HelloDoggy · 29/09/2022 22:55

AgeingDoc · 29/09/2022 22:48

Back in the dark ages when I was doing lots of death certificates as a junior doctor "old age" or similar was not permitted. You had to give some pathology as the cause of death even when it was fairly obvious that an elderly person had just naturally reached the end of their lives and was basically just "worn out". Bronchopneumonia or ischaemic heart disease were regularly given as causes of death in those circumstances. How accurate that was, I couldn't say, but without doing post mortems on lots of very old people, with no real benefit to them, their families or society there is no way of knowing.
And in fact even a post mortem isn't guaranteed to give you the full story. As a pathologist colleague of mine was always very fond of quoting " A post mortem will tell you what the patient died with but not necessarily what they died of." Meaning that there might be various abnormal findings at post mortem, but you can't always tell which of them actually led directly to death. Or indeed if one thing did - it could well be a combination of things, and probably often is, especially in elderly people with multiple long term conditions.
I think the change to allow old age was a sensible one, as you do get generally healthy elderly people who just die because they've reached the end of their natural life span, without any obvious final illness. There are however specific conditions that need to be met before this can be given as the sole cause of death and I agree that it seems a bit questionable whether they were met in the Queen's case. However, that is a matter for the doctor who signed the certificate and the registrar who registered the death, and only her medical attendants and close family will have all the information so there's not really much point in speculating.

Thanks agingdoc, helpful to know

OP posts:
Mrsjayy · 29/09/2022 22:54

We are not immortal so a 96 year old woman heart just stopping or organs failing is dying with old age, I thought it was "lovely " that HM died of old age.

Kedece2410 · 29/09/2022 22:53

They basically reported she was gravely Ill a few hours before they announced she was dead. So it was something else and they aren’t saying

Not necessarily. My Gran died of old age & the care home she was in called us to come in. She was pretty unresponsive when we were there but we had enough notice to get there. The staff knew the signs. Probably was the same with The Queen

HelloDoggy · 29/09/2022 22:53

bloodyunicorns · 29/09/2022 22:46

Who do we feel the need to know the queen's cause of death? That should be private to her and her family. How would you like everyone poring over your Gran's death cert?

I don't need to know the queen's cause of death. It just made me think about cause of death more generally, which is what the thread is about

OP posts: