Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to complaint to the police.

216 replies

NurseInTraining · 29/09/2022 20:53

So first of all I generally have always had a really good relationship with police officers that I come into contact with - they do an incredibly difficult job and don't need any extra hassle but...

For context I have mental health problems and sometimes self harm. A few weeks ago I contacted the local crisis team to say I was struggling and they contacted the police who came around. They asked me to come outside my house and then immediately handcuffed me behind my back (I had cut my wrist) and detained me under section 136 of the mental health act (you can't be detained under a 136 if you are in your home hence why he asked me to come outside).

I have no history of violence and I don't believe that handcuffing me behind my back was necessary. The officer's partner apologised for how it was handled afterwards and the next pair of officers that looked after me in hospital (police have to wait with you while you are waiting for an assessment) also said that he was heavy handed.

I don't think I should have been handcuffed but if they needed to for safety I think they could have handcuffed me with my hands in front of me rather than behind. Afterwards I had bruised wrists and I needed stitches as the wounds in my wrist were so bad. I don't think this was helped by the handcuffs.

It was very traumatic but I didn't think much of it afterwards as I was unwell however I have since found out that I have tendon damage in my wrist (not sure where or when from - could easily have come from elsewhere but might have come from this event).

I was mentioned this to a mental health support worker at my uni and he said that he thinks I should make a complaint to the police about this. It never occurred to me to do so before but I am also a student mental health nurse (ironic) and I believe that education about helpful way to work with people with mental health problems is really important and that nothing changes if problems aren't reported.

So should I complain?

OP posts:
WeepingSomnambulist · 30/09/2022 04:04

NurseInTraining · 30/09/2022 03:55

At no point have I suggested that I am not taking responsibility. You have commented repeatedly and seem to have a personal vendetta against me.

  1. I am working hard to improve my situation.
  2. I am literally training to work in a job that will allow me to help others in my situation.
  3. I am purely asking about feedback for this specific situation.

You have registered your feedback multiple times. Thanks for that but you are literally commenting repeatedly and we have all heard your opinion. Thank you but maybe your interest in this post is unhealthy.
Thanks for your comments but I think that is enough now. I am still open to other peoples opinions and I am capable to balancing one view per poster.

You're not though. You're only accepting views which agree with your own and support you making a complain. Anyone who disagrees with that and tells you that they got you the help you needed is ignored or spoken to very rudely by you.

They did what they had to do for their own safety and for yours. They did what they had to do to get you in there quickly. You cant slit your wrists, call for help and then say, "I'm fine now, you can leave."

You need help. Engage with the help. Dont complain that you had to stay there and wait for social workers etc. That's exactly what you need.

NurseInTraining · 30/09/2022 03:55

stillvicarinatutu · 30/09/2022 03:48

Op

We don't have TIME for "reflective practice ". You go from one job to the next . After yku that officer may have been blue lighting to a domestic assault , a robbery, and assault or another suicidal person .

You really need to stop looking for someone to blame and look at how you can improve your own circumstances. This blame game is ridiculous. You cut your own wrists deep enough to need stitches and cause nerve damage . What exactly do you want ? You're actions caused this . Not the poor sod who happened to be free when the ambulance call came in to police .

Try taking some responsibility? Instead of seeking to blame others - is it a distraction from your own issues ? You need to do you . Stop looking to blame those who helped you .

At no point have I suggested that I am not taking responsibility. You have commented repeatedly and seem to have a personal vendetta against me.

  1. I am working hard to improve my situation.
  2. I am literally training to work in a job that will allow me to help others in my situation.
  3. I am purely asking about feedback for this specific situation.

You have registered your feedback multiple times. Thanks for that but you are literally commenting repeatedly and we have all heard your opinion. Thank you but maybe your interest in this post is unhealthy.
Thanks for your comments but I think that is enough now. I am still open to other peoples opinions and I am capable to balancing one view per poster.

OP posts:
stillvicarinatutu · 30/09/2022 03:52

And no - it's not heavy handled to cuff someone with a bladed weapon .

That officer doesn't know you from Adam . The 3 chivvying yku along and as you put it "entertaining " you built a rapport and probably got to know you a little better- but cuffing you was not wrong - it is a dynamic risk assessment based on what's presented- and what was presented was a person with a bladed weapon whose cut their wrists . What do you not understand? They didn't know you or know if you were a risk to them or not - how could they know that ?

stillvicarinatutu · 30/09/2022 03:48

Op

We don't have TIME for "reflective practice ". You go from one job to the next . After yku that officer may have been blue lighting to a domestic assault , a robbery, and assault or another suicidal person .

You really need to stop looking for someone to blame and look at how you can improve your own circumstances. This blame game is ridiculous. You cut your own wrists deep enough to need stitches and cause nerve damage . What exactly do you want ? You're actions caused this . Not the poor sod who happened to be free when the ambulance call came in to police .

Try taking some responsibility? Instead of seeking to blame others - is it a distraction from your own issues ? You need to do you . Stop looking to blame those who helped you .

WeepingSomnambulist · 30/09/2022 03:47

NurseInTraining · 30/09/2022 03:39

I agree 75%. But three out of four police apologised and said it was heavy handed. I don't want him to get in trouble but I also think that he could benefit from support to improve his practice. In student nursing (ignoring those that don't believe I deserve to be a student nurse) we are constantly writing essays about reflective practice and how to improve practice and I assume policing is the similar.
This PC didn't stick around and had nothing to do with me being seen quickly. If I hadn't been detained on a S136 then I would have been seen and released quicker because in my area I would have only needed to see a mental health nurse from the crisis team rather than them finding a psychiatrist and social worker who I didn't know. It generally takes several hours to contact a social worker and psychiatrist even without the complication of finding someone I don't know compared with the nurse from the crisis team just coming downstairs if I wasn't on a S136.

But you need more than a quick visit from a mental health nurse. You have repeatedly slit your wrists and called for help. Then you want them to just drop you at the hospital and leave you alone? Treat you quickly and let you go?

It sounds like you want s taxi service. You just want them to collect you and drop you off and then to get stitches sorted and sent off home.

That's not how it should work. It's a good thing they got you a social worker and longer term support.

They gave you exactly what you needed. You are not in the correct state of mind to decide that all you needed was for them to drop you off at hospital. If that's what you want then stop calling for help and just call a taxi.

NurseInTraining · 30/09/2022 03:39

gaymeanshappy · 30/09/2022 03:22

I agree with this unfortunately :(

I am an ex police despatcher. Sometimes, so many calls were about this sort of thing. Nobody around to help other than the police. The aforementioned dicking around was commonplace. Police can section someone if they're deemed to be a danger to themselves and they did-it fast tracked you. The number of units the force I worked for had on, in comparison to how many emergencies, non-emergencies but fairly urgent incidents, and overall how many people they were serving was truly shocking. Those two officers would have been in trouble if they hung about longer than they had to, not to mention all the other things going on (some of them involving people being in grave danger in other circumstances) that could have been neglected as a result.

MH care is abhorrent in this country, and so much more of it falls to the police than should. They do their best IME, I wish there were systems in place that meant they didn't have to work the way they do though, and I am sorry for what happened to you. It sounds as if overall it was a positive experience with the police for you, I wouldn't complain 1) because nothing will come of it and 2) because it sounds as if overall they looked after you extremely well.

I hope your MH improves :)

I agree 75%. But three out of four police apologised and said it was heavy handed. I don't want him to get in trouble but I also think that he could benefit from support to improve his practice. In student nursing (ignoring those that don't believe I deserve to be a student nurse) we are constantly writing essays about reflective practice and how to improve practice and I assume policing is the similar.
This PC didn't stick around and had nothing to do with me being seen quickly. If I hadn't been detained on a S136 then I would have been seen and released quicker because in my area I would have only needed to see a mental health nurse from the crisis team rather than them finding a psychiatrist and social worker who I didn't know. It generally takes several hours to contact a social worker and psychiatrist even without the complication of finding someone I don't know compared with the nurse from the crisis team just coming downstairs if I wasn't on a S136.

OP posts:
gaymeanshappy · 30/09/2022 03:22

CaptainBarbosa · 29/09/2022 23:55

I mean I can tell you the real and probable reason this happened but you aren't going to like it.

Basically Police are fed up of being on call mental health support by people like the crisis team and CMHT. They are not trained mental health specialists and they never will be.

He wanted you outside because he just wanted to get you to hospital under a 136 not dick about with you for hours in the flat whilst you ummed and arred about going in "voluntary" or waiting hours for a ambulance and then being stuck there with you whilst "other professionals" on the end of the phone decided "what could be done".

There's nothing worse than being stuck at a call whilst adult social services, crisis team palm shit off, and make no decisions and default to "well they have capacity so up to them" when the police officer stood there can clearly see someone needs help .

As you said it's a 12 hour wait for an ambulance, those coppers would have had to stay with you till the ambulance arrived.

So he did what he did, tricked you outside, cuffed you behind to prevent you from further harming yourself, drive you in the van to hospital for you to get treatment.

Something tells me this PC before has become frustrated with "crisis" mental health teams and has learnt a trick or two about getting unwell patients seen quickly and appropriately.

Like I said, it's not great, but it's all he could do.

I agree with this unfortunately :(

I am an ex police despatcher. Sometimes, so many calls were about this sort of thing. Nobody around to help other than the police. The aforementioned dicking around was commonplace. Police can section someone if they're deemed to be a danger to themselves and they did-it fast tracked you. The number of units the force I worked for had on, in comparison to how many emergencies, non-emergencies but fairly urgent incidents, and overall how many people they were serving was truly shocking. Those two officers would have been in trouble if they hung about longer than they had to, not to mention all the other things going on (some of them involving people being in grave danger in other circumstances) that could have been neglected as a result.

MH care is abhorrent in this country, and so much more of it falls to the police than should. They do their best IME, I wish there were systems in place that meant they didn't have to work the way they do though, and I am sorry for what happened to you. It sounds as if overall it was a positive experience with the police for you, I wouldn't complain 1) because nothing will come of it and 2) because it sounds as if overall they looked after you extremely well.

I hope your MH improves :)

WhoAre · 30/09/2022 03:02

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

BadNomad · 30/09/2022 03:00

I don't think you have the empathy you think you do. It sounds like you only have sympathy for people with mental illness because it validates your own. You don't seem to have any awareness or compassion for the other people affected by it. You talk so disrespectfully to people who are negatively affected by others with mental illness. Another professional reveals a distressing example of having to deal with a murder caused by a mentally ill member of the public, and your response is "Maybe time to get a new job love." That is horrible. You have a serious lack of awareness or understanding of anyone beyond yourself.

Remember this in your future career when your patient puts in a complaint about you. It happens to most nurses at some point. I'm sure you'll say you were just trying your best under the circumstances too.

MarshaMelrose · 30/09/2022 03:00

I don't want to be a drain on resources but can't make my mental health problems go away.

I understand. I have had mental health problems for over 25 years. But you're a well informed professional in the area of mental health, including procedures and the law. When you contacted the local crisis team, you must have had an idea what would happen next because you've been in this position several times. If you don't need the police to be with you, why do you not take yourself to hospital and get checked over without involving the police?
Again, I sympathise that MH care is poor and underfunded but it's not what the police are for. There are unfortunate situations where they need to be involved, such as in cases of violence to others, or maybe where they need to break in to rescue someone who needs resus, as you have previously done. But if there are times when you can sort yourself out without involving the police, surely that will make you feel empowered over your illness?

stillvicarinatutu · 30/09/2022 02:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

WhoAre · 30/09/2022 02:57

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

marvellousmaple · 30/09/2022 02:55

How did you cut your artery? Was that an accident or another mh crisis?
And yes you are being unreasonable. If you don't want help don't call people for help.

NurseInTraining · 30/09/2022 02:45

MarshaMelrose · 30/09/2022 02:33

I have been critical of some police actions on these threads but, reading this, I actually feel quite sorry for them and for victims of crime who are left waiting whilst 4 police officers are sat in a&e, entertaining mental health patients for hours and then ferrying them around for meds and appointments.
Mental health problems are awful. I suffer from them and have cut myself in the past so I sympathise, but what a waste of time and resources.

Unfortunately it isn't up to patients to ask them to leave - I have done so but, in my area at least, legally they have to stay. I didn't ask them to do so but they have to be there. If you have to have someone observing you 24/7 then it helps for them to be able to show empathy, kindness and humour. If a male takes you to the toilet then you at least want them to be able to laugh about it.
When I am in that situation then I quickly calm down and want to be left alone but I can't make that happen. Equally I can't control things during the specific situations that a crisis happens (this doesn't happen when I am working).
90% of police are brilliant - they spend time unwillingly with me but treat me like a human and we can just have random chats - I have literally helped officers chose their next car before as I am stuck with them for hours.
I don't want to be a drain on resources but can't make my mental health problems go away. I also think that if my supervisor and the head of professional standards is happy with me studying then some random from Mumsnet can probably be ignored.

OP posts:
stillvicarinatutu · 30/09/2022 02:43

From the op :-

"To be fair to the other police officers, they were brilliant, they kept me entertained for hours, went out of their way to push for me to be seen quickly by the mental health team, were really empathetic and drove like crazy to get me home in time for a online counselling appointment. They even split up so one of them could go to the pharmacy and pick up antibiotics for me and still get me home in time for my appointment. "

And this is exactly why we can't to get to actual crimes that are happening or have happened.
We are the entertainment for people like the op . Their taxi. Their pharmacy.

This is the crux of the issue and then - people like the op actually want to complain that the police out the nasty handcuffs on when they had obviously used a blade deep enough to cause nerve damage and require stitches.

I think the op is right . I need another job . This is why . Because I can't do MY job for this type of incident. Expertly explained by the op . And when that complaint goes in for that officer trying to get the help the op needed they'll get suspended or put on restricted duties so that's another police officer of the shift who can't attend actual crimes .

MarshaMelrose · 30/09/2022 02:33

I have been critical of some police actions on these threads but, reading this, I actually feel quite sorry for them and for victims of crime who are left waiting whilst 4 police officers are sat in a&e, entertaining mental health patients for hours and then ferrying them around for meds and appointments.
Mental health problems are awful. I suffer from them and have cut myself in the past so I sympathise, but what a waste of time and resources.

NurseInTraining · 30/09/2022 02:33

SuperLoudPoppingAction · 30/09/2022 02:23

Op, I think opinion is divided between people who don't know much about police procedure who think you should complain, and people who do, who think you shouldn't.

I think it's worth you putting everything in place that you possibly can to ensure you're not in this situation again. It's all well and good that student support are keeping in touch with you, but what are they doing to support you in developing better coping strategies?

While it's good that your director of studies supports you, this is what university staff do. Once someone is on the course, it's quite tricky to kick them out. There will be a 'stay on course' policy to follow.
You can't only rely on that as an indicator of whether you're a good nurse. Listen to people who are saying you need to focus on your recovery.
If you can do that while studying, then that's fab.

Casting around for people to blame isnt the best use of your energy.
I say that as someone who is part of a minorities group who are often mistreated and misunderstood by police.
My solution was to teach police in an appropriate way, rather than complain about them.

Police really are on their knees just now, and repeat callers are a particularly difficult issue to deal with.

People are mentioning burglaries that can't be attended because police are with you, but there will also be calls due to domestic abuse.
Someone could be getting badly harmed and traumatised with no support from police, because there just aren't enough officers to do everything at once.

It sounds like you found the experience distressing, and that's a shame. It also sounds like most of your experiences with police were positive.
You could ask to meet the officer and talk about it with them, rather than complaining. It might help to hear why they acted as they did, and help you to make sense of it. But not everything needs to be a complaint.

Agree with you mostly but we were told that approximately 50% of the course wouldn't make it to graduation and 1/3 have already dropped out on year in. Seems pretty easy to chuck people out particularly at the end of the year. We have exams which we have to get 100% to pass on - pretty easy to fail.
And just as a minor point it is the director of professional standards supporting me not director of studies- she answers directly to the NMC, safeguarding boards etc.

OP posts:
mustbetheseasonofthewitch · 30/09/2022 02:25

While that must have been distressing for you, they weren't to know you had no history of violence or weren't potentially about to act out (further) with a blade. It was for their protection and your own, I expect.

SuperLoudPoppingAction · 30/09/2022 02:25

*minoritised (autocorrect)

SuperLoudPoppingAction · 30/09/2022 02:23

Op, I think opinion is divided between people who don't know much about police procedure who think you should complain, and people who do, who think you shouldn't.

I think it's worth you putting everything in place that you possibly can to ensure you're not in this situation again. It's all well and good that student support are keeping in touch with you, but what are they doing to support you in developing better coping strategies?

While it's good that your director of studies supports you, this is what university staff do. Once someone is on the course, it's quite tricky to kick them out. There will be a 'stay on course' policy to follow.
You can't only rely on that as an indicator of whether you're a good nurse. Listen to people who are saying you need to focus on your recovery.
If you can do that while studying, then that's fab.

Casting around for people to blame isnt the best use of your energy.
I say that as someone who is part of a minorities group who are often mistreated and misunderstood by police.
My solution was to teach police in an appropriate way, rather than complain about them.

Police really are on their knees just now, and repeat callers are a particularly difficult issue to deal with.

People are mentioning burglaries that can't be attended because police are with you, but there will also be calls due to domestic abuse.
Someone could be getting badly harmed and traumatised with no support from police, because there just aren't enough officers to do everything at once.

It sounds like you found the experience distressing, and that's a shame. It also sounds like most of your experiences with police were positive.
You could ask to meet the officer and talk about it with them, rather than complaining. It might help to hear why they acted as they did, and help you to make sense of it. But not everything needs to be a complaint.

WeepingSomnambulist · 30/09/2022 02:22

NurseInTraining · 30/09/2022 02:16

And the people on Panorama on Wednesday night had lots of experience too. Maybe time to get a new job love.

That's a pretty nasty way to speak to someone when you're meant to be in training as a mental health nurse, and are currently going through a period of slitting your own wrists.

You're a student. You dont have the experience others do. All students think they know everything, so of course you think you know all you need to. But other people have been in the job decades and they know more than you. Dont speak to them like that.

Focus on yourself and what you need. Focus on getting yourself into a better place. You got a place on a good course. That isnt easy. You just be doing something right. Keep doing it. Focus on you, your needs, your support. And maybe try to be understanding regarding the police. They're spending most of their job dealing with mental health, when they're not trained for this level of involvement. They can spend an entire shift with one person, just waiting on other services to turn up and take over.

This officer got you to a hospital and you got help. They previously saved your life.

What he did wasnt perfect. There are many ways he could have handled it, but his way got you help within minutes without messing around with waiting.

stillvicarinatutu · 30/09/2022 02:21

I read them . And that's my answer.

You asked my experience and I've told you .

I've probably dealt with more mh patients at this point than you have as a student nurse .

You posted in aibu. My answer is yes you are .

I hope you get he support and help you need but I find myself increasingly frustrated by this type of question. You cut your wrists deep enough to require stitches and cause nerve damage and that's now the fault of the police who detained you to get you the requisite help and support ?

I wish we could just say no - not our job . And this is a prime example of why .

The officer had no choice but to cuff you . Did you still have the blade ? Does that officer know that ? If your mentality unstable enough to cause that kind of damage to your own wrist how does he know you won't go for his jugular?

This is everything that's wrong with mh services and policing today . This should not be the remit of the police and yet the ambulance wouldn't have attended without police back up which you will well know if indeed you are a trainee mh nurse .

NurseInTraining · 30/09/2022 02:16

stillvicarinatutu · 30/09/2022 02:09

Op
My experience of working with mh is probably significantly more than yours as a student nurse with what sounds like significant mh issues yourself.

My experience is 14 years worth . The last mh health patient I had dealings with had just bludgeoned his neighbour to death for calling him a nonce .

What's your experience?

And the people on Panorama on Wednesday night had lots of experience too. Maybe time to get a new job love.

OP posts:
NurseInTraining · 30/09/2022 02:14

stillvicarinatutu · 30/09/2022 02:11

That was 3 weeks ago . Pretty recent . And you wonder why you were handcuffed?

Wait until you're out there in the field . Then come back and tell me what your experience is .

Hi, please taken a moment to read my posts - thanks.

OP posts:
WeepingSomnambulist · 30/09/2022 02:11

At this point, you are now known to the police. They know who you are and they know what you do. You slit your wrists and then call for help.

NHS is on it's knees. Ambulances are non existent. They get a call from you, again, to say you've split your wrists and now want help, so they do what they need to do to get you treatment. Sitting in your living ro for 12 hours waiting for the correct service to attend your home, or sitting for hours trying to convince you to go in voluntarily is a waste of everyone's time.

He got you out of your house, rightly detained you because you need help and he got you to the hospital all within a matter of minutes.

You're known to them now. You'll be detained when you do this now. Rightly.

Swipe left for the next trending thread