Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to complaint to the police.

216 replies

NurseInTraining · 29/09/2022 20:53

So first of all I generally have always had a really good relationship with police officers that I come into contact with - they do an incredibly difficult job and don't need any extra hassle but...

For context I have mental health problems and sometimes self harm. A few weeks ago I contacted the local crisis team to say I was struggling and they contacted the police who came around. They asked me to come outside my house and then immediately handcuffed me behind my back (I had cut my wrist) and detained me under section 136 of the mental health act (you can't be detained under a 136 if you are in your home hence why he asked me to come outside).

I have no history of violence and I don't believe that handcuffing me behind my back was necessary. The officer's partner apologised for how it was handled afterwards and the next pair of officers that looked after me in hospital (police have to wait with you while you are waiting for an assessment) also said that he was heavy handed.

I don't think I should have been handcuffed but if they needed to for safety I think they could have handcuffed me with my hands in front of me rather than behind. Afterwards I had bruised wrists and I needed stitches as the wounds in my wrist were so bad. I don't think this was helped by the handcuffs.

It was very traumatic but I didn't think much of it afterwards as I was unwell however I have since found out that I have tendon damage in my wrist (not sure where or when from - could easily have come from elsewhere but might have come from this event).

I was mentioned this to a mental health support worker at my uni and he said that he thinks I should make a complaint to the police about this. It never occurred to me to do so before but I am also a student mental health nurse (ironic) and I believe that education about helpful way to work with people with mental health problems is really important and that nothing changes if problems aren't reported.

So should I complain?

OP posts:
cansu · 30/09/2022 06:20

They should not be manipulating the law. The use of 136 when you were at home is terrible. They should not have deliberately got you into the street in order to section you. They should have called an ambulance or git you to call a family member or friend to take you to a and e if your wrists needed attention. Complain.

NurseInTraining · 30/09/2022 05:58

Poppyblush · 30/09/2022 05:55

Sorry, I don’t think you should complain and you weren’t in a good place then either but it’s great you’re getting better now. I’d cease the discussion with your case worker as it sounds like they have their own agenda. Focus on you. Sadly mental health funding and staffing is so low and it’s the job of hospitals, not police, but police get called in. You don’t know what they were told or have encountered before, and their safety matters too.

My support worker isn't pushing it at all he just mentioned it. I foolishly thought that Mumsnet would help me make a decision - lesson learned.

OP posts:
Poppyblush · 30/09/2022 05:55

Sorry, I don’t think you should complain and you weren’t in a good place then either but it’s great you’re getting better now. I’d cease the discussion with your case worker as it sounds like they have their own agenda. Focus on you. Sadly mental health funding and staffing is so low and it’s the job of hospitals, not police, but police get called in. You don’t know what they were told or have encountered before, and their safety matters too.

NurseInTraining · 30/09/2022 05:40

nancydroo · 30/09/2022 05:28

I'm doubting much of what you say given the way you enjoy sparring with people who don't agree with you. But I'll bite...your days as a student mental health nurse are clearly numbered. Should you even graduate very unlikely you would get a position at the end of it. Be grateful to the police. They don't need to be hanging around for this. To then want to make a complaint shows the person you are. Tricky. Very tricky.

Hi, thankfully the people who matter don't agree with you. As you will see in my OP I didn't think about complaining but this was raised by a mental health support worker and I was purely asking for what people think. I will pass your comments on to him. I am sure he will be hurt by your opinion. I asked for opinions nor personal attack based on how you perceive me. I think it is clear that I am currently vulnerable so hopefully you feel some sort of power from telling me my student nurse days are numbered. Are you a mental health nurse? Or do you work as a nursing lecturer? Otherwise your ability to judge me as a student mental health nurse will be ignored and I will continue asking for opinions based purely on whether I should complain or not as this is all I asked. I didn't say in the OP that I would complain - all you needed to say was "no, you didn't agree" and I would take opinion on board.

OP posts:
startfresh · 30/09/2022 05:38

Your MH support worker is not helping you by telling you to complain, they should be explaining why this happened and understanding of the police. We get nowhere if these services turn on each other.

If they actually suggested the cuffs caused tendon damage when you cut your own wrists they are doing a massive disservice and causing delusions. You damaged your own tendon. Whether that be by your cut (most likely) or the handcuffs over your cut, you initiated it.

MarshaMelrose · 30/09/2022 05:34

Then I had a few personal difficulties and things have gone a bit crazy.

I've been dealing with MH issues for over
25 years and I totally get this. I never know what it will be that knocks me off my axis. But the fact that you managed to hold it together for so long, shows that you have the ability leave the patterns of behaviour behind you - even if you maybe, like me, find them weirdly comforting.
After being diagnosed, I changed career and had a very successful 20 years. There's no reason why you shouldn't be the same. Mental health issues make us do stupid things but it doesn't make us stupid people. We need good nurses so I wish you all the best.

nancydroo · 30/09/2022 05:28

I'm doubting much of what you say given the way you enjoy sparring with people who don't agree with you. But I'll bite...your days as a student mental health nurse are clearly numbered. Should you even graduate very unlikely you would get a position at the end of it. Be grateful to the police. They don't need to be hanging around for this. To then want to make a complaint shows the person you are. Tricky. Very tricky.

startfresh · 30/09/2022 05:27

WeepingSomnambulist · 30/09/2022 02:11

At this point, you are now known to the police. They know who you are and they know what you do. You slit your wrists and then call for help.

NHS is on it's knees. Ambulances are non existent. They get a call from you, again, to say you've split your wrists and now want help, so they do what they need to do to get you treatment. Sitting in your living ro for 12 hours waiting for the correct service to attend your home, or sitting for hours trying to convince you to go in voluntarily is a waste of everyone's time.

He got you out of your house, rightly detained you because you need help and he got you to the hospital all within a matter of minutes.

You're known to them now. You'll be detained when you do this now. Rightly.

This, and everything stillvicarinatutu has been saying. Along with an earlier poster, I can't remember.

OP clearly would have preferred immediate ambulance attention to save their life, as they praised the care they received that time.

However the urgent ambulance might have been saving the life of someone who had a heart attack. Or a baby who has stopped breathing in the night. Surely you can understand the need for these resources.

I say this as someone who has suffered with MH issues for decades. You can't be the ambulances priority in these cases, when someone who needs help for something that isn't self inflicted could die.

The police are struggling. This shouldn't fall to them, but it does. And they need to deal with it swiftly so they can also do their jobs with crimes that are committed.

YABU and you should not complain.

How would you like it if next time the police didn't show and left your crisis to unfold, unaided. (Not saying they would do this because of the complaint, just saying another scenario where you received no urgent attendance).

NurseInTraining · 30/09/2022 05:14

MarshaMelrose · 30/09/2022 04:56

OK. But you, understandably and for good reason, don't think they should complain. You've explained why and given well thought out reasons. You can't do more,abd by keep going over the same grounds is more likely to be injurious to your cause.
Now, I'm doing a you and keep repeating myself! So I'll stop.

I hope you get better soon, op, and you can find a better way through the maze of reporting your self-harm than by keep getting detained by the police. I don't see how that is helping anyone, tbh.

Hi, thanks, the last few weeks have been tough as I had nearly twelve amazing months of my mental health being brilliant.
Then I had a few personal difficulties and things have gone a bit crazy.
Uni have been brilliant and seem to understand that a few difficult weeks doesn't undo twelve amazing months. I was up front at the start of the course about my mental health (I hadn't self harmed for twelve months before the last few weeks) and with every supervisor on every placement I have been on. I also can't hide it as despite tattoos it is obvious under scrubs. Before starting the course I declared that I self harmed to the course lead as I was concerned it would cause problems and was told that I might get some awkward questions but that this wouldn't hold me back.
Understandably there is supervision on my work currently - of course there is and I get that. I am currently waiting for NHS occupational health to assess me next week and decide whether I can continue training unrestricted.
I don't want to sound like I am bragging but I really good with patients, I understand them, I can explain things in a way they can understand and they seem to naturally trust me. I also have great clinical skills - in one year I have picked up on a patient who had developed sepsis - I was the first person to flag concerns during her routine physical observations and could well have saved her life.
Most of the mental health cohort have mental health problems so it seems like you would have no future mental health nurses without us.

OP posts:
MarshaMelrose · 30/09/2022 05:09

I think the police do a great job overall in very trying circumstances. They often can't win no matter what they do. But just know that you are appreciated. 🙂

stillvicarinatutu · 30/09/2022 05:00

Marshalmelrose

Good point well made Flowers

MarshaMelrose · 30/09/2022 04:56

stillvicarinatutu · 30/09/2022 04:49

Hey - they can complain all they like . The facts are the facts . Person with knife or blade = handcuffs and detained on mh grounds .

OK. But you, understandably and for good reason, don't think they should complain. You've explained why and given well thought out reasons. You can't do more,abd by keep going over the same grounds is more likely to be injurious to your cause.
Now, I'm doing a you and keep repeating myself! So I'll stop.

I hope you get better soon, op, and you can find a better way through the maze of reporting your self-harm than by keep getting detained by the police. I don't see how that is helping anyone, tbh.

stillvicarinatutu · 30/09/2022 04:49

MarshaMelrose · 30/09/2022 04:46

But can't you see that you keep going on that they shouldn't complain, doesn't actually achieve anything. In fact, it's more likely to push them into complaining. I know it would me. You stated well-argued reasons why the officer did what they did and why the op shouldn't complain. Keep repeating your point comes across as a bit browbeating, to be honest. And I say that as someone who is is sympathetic with the position the police find themselves in and who agrees with your reasoning.

Hey - they can complain all they like . The facts are the facts . Person with knife or blade = handcuffs and detained on mh grounds .

WeepingSomnambulist · 30/09/2022 04:49

There was nothing stopping you from going to the hospital first. You could have self presented and the crisis team could have seen you.

Part of the problem is that you want the theatre of it. All the attention from having someone sent out to talk you round is part of what you want. You respond quickly because you're craving the attention, once you get it, you feel better and then want everything dealt with quickly so you can get home.

He didnt give you that. He detained you because you were a danger, got you straight to a hospital, then he left you with other officers. No drama or attention or long, drawn out pandering to talk you round. Your angry with him because you didnt get the attention the way you wanted it. But you got the medical and mental health care you needed, quickly. And other police stayed with you and said what they felt you needed to hear to keep you calm.

Complaining about him should not be on your priority list right now.

onlythreenow · 30/09/2022 04:49

You really need to stop looking for someone to blame and look at how you can improve your own circumstances. This blame game is ridiculous. You cut your own wrists deep enough to need stitches and cause nerve damage . What exactly do you want ? You're actions caused this . Not the poor sod who happened to be free when the ambulance call came in to police.

I agree with this, and yes, YABU. Surely you can understand that if police are called to someone who has cut their wrist they need to treat that person as if they are still armed, and possibly dangerous. I feel sorry for the police, they get it in the neck because they aren't responding to criminal incidents, and yet they are also expected to spend half their day talking to people with a MH crisis which shouldn't even be part of their job. You would do better to move past this and try to focus on your recovery.

stillvicarinatutu · 30/09/2022 04:47

And I'm sorry op but if you've cut yourself so deeply as to require stitches and caused nerve damage then the crisis team aren't going to simply talk you through it - you know that though. They have to get you medical attention. They are also duty bound . And the fact ambulances will not attend these incidents without police back up - you must know that too ?

Are you seriously studying to be a mental health nurse ? Because you must know this if you are - you will be required to do the same in future if a patient is self harming- you do realise that ?

MarshaMelrose · 30/09/2022 04:46

But can't you see that you keep going on that they shouldn't complain, doesn't actually achieve anything. In fact, it's more likely to push them into complaining. I know it would me. You stated well-argued reasons why the officer did what they did and why the op shouldn't complain. Keep repeating your point comes across as a bit browbeating, to be honest. And I say that as someone who is is sympathetic with the position the police find themselves in and who agrees with your reasoning.

stillvicarinatutu · 30/09/2022 04:44

Op
If you've already cut your wrists then the police would be duty bound to take you to seek medical attention.

If you are a trainee mh nurse you MUST know that ?

They can't just desculate and leave you . That would be classed as a dereliction of duty - what if you then bled to death ?

You are not operating in the real world . You do clearly need more help here than has been given by mh services .

What follow up appointment has been made ?

NurseInTraining · 30/09/2022 04:39

MarshaMelrose · 30/09/2022 04:26

Don't know what you read but I haven't had any "quick" visits from a mental health nurse

You sort of did imply this when you wrote...

If I hadn't been detained on a S136 then I would have been seen and released quicker because in my area I would have only needed to see a mental health nurse from the crisis team

... but you probably just meant you didn't have to wait as long. Could you not just take yourself to the hospital to see the crisis team? Then you don't have to wait as long and you don't have to wait with police officers which you say is far from pleasant for you?

It's clear you're having serious mental health struggles so I'm not sure what's to be gained by keep having a go at you over making a complaint. I doubt police officers are big into self-reflection but if you think it would be helpful for him, why don't you write him a letter? Then it's up to him whether he takes your concerns on board or not.

Hey, as I say, I would have gone to the hospital willingly but wasn't given that option. I called crisis for support - that doesn't necessarily mean they call the police as different nurses in the crisis team will deal with it differently. Some can distract me and support me to get through the crisis however some will go straight to calling the police. It can be a bit of a lucky dip contacting them but it is still the official advice during any crisis if you don't have friends or family for support which I don't.
I think my post is confusing as I don't want him to get in to trouble but I would like him to consider other ways of dealing with the situation. De-escalation techniques are so important in mental health and I know I respond really quickly to them so maybe it could help him in general if he had the opportunity. I have recently spent time with police talking about the training they receive but I didn't think to ask what de-escalation techniques they learn and the other officers responses sort of led me towards thinking that he could improve his skills as they seem to manage it.

OP posts:
stillvicarinatutu · 30/09/2022 04:34

Actually if this patient hadn't been 136 and had gone to a&e as well they know - they'd have been waiting longer . If on a 136 then a psychiatrist on call has to come out and see them.

If they just go to a&e they'd likely be waiting 8 hours for a nurse to triage then send them home with the crisis team number which op clearly already has .

But op isn't happy with whatever course of action is taken .

If they make a complaint it will be looked into but to be honest no one is going to discipline a police officer for cuffing someone whose just used a bladed weapon to slash their own wrists . Officer safety is paramount and that officer did what they thought would keep them , the patient and everyone else safe . They aren't going to get disciplined for that .
But while the complaint is investigated they'll likely be taken off front line duties and so out more pressure on their already overstretched colleagues. But hey ho . As long as the op feels validated.

MarshaMelrose · 30/09/2022 04:26

Don't know what you read but I haven't had any "quick" visits from a mental health nurse

You sort of did imply this when you wrote...

If I hadn't been detained on a S136 then I would have been seen and released quicker because in my area I would have only needed to see a mental health nurse from the crisis team

... but you probably just meant you didn't have to wait as long. Could you not just take yourself to the hospital to see the crisis team? Then you don't have to wait as long and you don't have to wait with police officers which you say is far from pleasant for you?

It's clear you're having serious mental health struggles so I'm not sure what's to be gained by keep having a go at you over making a complaint. I doubt police officers are big into self-reflection but if you think it would be helpful for him, why don't you write him a letter? Then it's up to him whether he takes your concerns on board or not.

WeepingSomnambulist · 30/09/2022 04:26

NurseInTraining · 30/09/2022 03:39

I agree 75%. But three out of four police apologised and said it was heavy handed. I don't want him to get in trouble but I also think that he could benefit from support to improve his practice. In student nursing (ignoring those that don't believe I deserve to be a student nurse) we are constantly writing essays about reflective practice and how to improve practice and I assume policing is the similar.
This PC didn't stick around and had nothing to do with me being seen quickly. If I hadn't been detained on a S136 then I would have been seen and released quicker because in my area I would have only needed to see a mental health nurse from the crisis team rather than them finding a psychiatrist and social worker who I didn't know. It generally takes several hours to contact a social worker and psychiatrist even without the complication of finding someone I don't know compared with the nurse from the crisis team just coming downstairs if I wasn't on a S136.

This is what I'm talking about.

You're complaining because by detaining you, you had to wait for more in depth help. If they hadn't detained you then all you would need was a chat with the crisis team nurse. Instead, you had to wait for more in depth help.

That is what you need. Stop moaning. If you dont want the help, then get a taxi to the hospital, get your stitches and go home.

NurseInTraining · 30/09/2022 04:15

stillvicarinatutu · 30/09/2022 04:06

No op - when you post on a PUBLIC forum inviting opinions you don't get to censor those opinions or tell anyone who is actually doing the job you're complaining about they can't comment further !

I have absolutely no vendetta against you - I don't know you - and that is the entire point of my replies to your complaining abkut the police !

I do not know you . All I do know is you cut your wrists so deeply as to require stitches and cause nerve damage- and on that information alone I'm saying that your complaint against the police is wholly unfounded because faced with a potential suicidal person with a weapon any police officer in their right mind would have cuffed you !

You cannot seriously be saying they shouldn't when you had a weapon that you had already used to cause self harm !

My opinion might not be welcomed by you but when you listed on an open public forum I'm afraid you lost the right to dictate who can and can't agree or reply .

You might not like what I'm saying but that's not going to stop me saying it .

You were a potential threat to any person attending you're address at that point and that's why the police were required. They did their job .
When you're doing yours feel free to come back to me and comment .

You have not dealt with violent mental health patients yet clearly ! Well the polic will have and taking no chances is absolutely nothing to complain about.

The police are people just like you who want to go home to their families at the end of their shift. Why should they risk being slashed with a blade ? They do t know you or what you are capable of doing g with the blade you have already used .

Hi, thanks for yet again commenting. Most of your points are answered in my posts so I will direct you to them.
Thanks.

OP posts:
NurseInTraining · 30/09/2022 04:13

WeepingSomnambulist · 30/09/2022 03:47

But you need more than a quick visit from a mental health nurse. You have repeatedly slit your wrists and called for help. Then you want them to just drop you at the hospital and leave you alone? Treat you quickly and let you go?

It sounds like you want s taxi service. You just want them to collect you and drop you off and then to get stitches sorted and sent off home.

That's not how it should work. It's a good thing they got you a social worker and longer term support.

They gave you exactly what you needed. You are not in the correct state of mind to decide that all you needed was for them to drop you off at hospital. If that's what you want then stop calling for help and just call a taxi.

Don't know what you read but I haven't had any "quick" visits from a mental health nurse in the last decade of struggling and I certainly don't have a social worker.
I never said I want a taxi service but I am also advised to contact crisis when I am struggling. In future I will ignore official advice and follow your advice which seems to be to call a taxi. I am sure local taxi companies will appreciate this.

OP posts:
stillvicarinatutu · 30/09/2022 04:06

No op - when you post on a PUBLIC forum inviting opinions you don't get to censor those opinions or tell anyone who is actually doing the job you're complaining about they can't comment further !

I have absolutely no vendetta against you - I don't know you - and that is the entire point of my replies to your complaining abkut the police !

I do not know you . All I do know is you cut your wrists so deeply as to require stitches and cause nerve damage- and on that information alone I'm saying that your complaint against the police is wholly unfounded because faced with a potential suicidal person with a weapon any police officer in their right mind would have cuffed you !

You cannot seriously be saying they shouldn't when you had a weapon that you had already used to cause self harm !

My opinion might not be welcomed by you but when you listed on an open public forum I'm afraid you lost the right to dictate who can and can't agree or reply .

You might not like what I'm saying but that's not going to stop me saying it .

You were a potential threat to any person attending you're address at that point and that's why the police were required. They did their job .
When you're doing yours feel free to come back to me and comment .

You have not dealt with violent mental health patients yet clearly ! Well the polic will have and taking no chances is absolutely nothing to complain about.

The police are people just like you who want to go home to their families at the end of their shift. Why should they risk being slashed with a blade ? They do t know you or what you are capable of doing g with the blade you have already used .