Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to complaint to the police.

216 replies

NurseInTraining · 29/09/2022 20:53

So first of all I generally have always had a really good relationship with police officers that I come into contact with - they do an incredibly difficult job and don't need any extra hassle but...

For context I have mental health problems and sometimes self harm. A few weeks ago I contacted the local crisis team to say I was struggling and they contacted the police who came around. They asked me to come outside my house and then immediately handcuffed me behind my back (I had cut my wrist) and detained me under section 136 of the mental health act (you can't be detained under a 136 if you are in your home hence why he asked me to come outside).

I have no history of violence and I don't believe that handcuffing me behind my back was necessary. The officer's partner apologised for how it was handled afterwards and the next pair of officers that looked after me in hospital (police have to wait with you while you are waiting for an assessment) also said that he was heavy handed.

I don't think I should have been handcuffed but if they needed to for safety I think they could have handcuffed me with my hands in front of me rather than behind. Afterwards I had bruised wrists and I needed stitches as the wounds in my wrist were so bad. I don't think this was helped by the handcuffs.

It was very traumatic but I didn't think much of it afterwards as I was unwell however I have since found out that I have tendon damage in my wrist (not sure where or when from - could easily have come from elsewhere but might have come from this event).

I was mentioned this to a mental health support worker at my uni and he said that he thinks I should make a complaint to the police about this. It never occurred to me to do so before but I am also a student mental health nurse (ironic) and I believe that education about helpful way to work with people with mental health problems is really important and that nothing changes if problems aren't reported.

So should I complain?

OP posts:
NurseInTraining · 30/09/2022 07:31

startfresh · 30/09/2022 07:24

@NurseInTraining please read the above article. Police are being shaped by past complaints. They don't act fast enough, they act too quickly. They made the right choice. Nobody died.

https://bylineinvestigates.com/2017/06/20/leaked-official-report-of-probe-into-murder-by-schizophrenic-patient-nicola-edgington/

I think this is a fair comment and argument towards handcuffing me. No one is perfect and I am sure that the officer believed he was doing the right thing. I honestly don't doubt that for a second. Psychosis and schizophrenia is terrifying and I want this to be what I work in as I think this is the most significant mental health condition affecting society. I can't imagine how terrifying it must be to not be able to trust what you see and hear.

OP posts:
startfresh · 30/09/2022 07:30

You weren't ignored, you weren't beaten, you didn't have someone kneeling on your neck whilst you begged you couldn't breathe until you died.

You were swiftly detained, taken to hospital for care and accompanied until completion.

Sounds like you were lucky.

This is not the minimum level of standard, but how are the police or yourself to know if you would have went willingly. You weren't acting rationally.

You are still here. Possibly because of that police office. We will never know, but they may have saved your life, your next step might have been fatal.

You are possibly alive because of the actions those police officers took. And you want to complain. Please think about that.

ThinkingForEveryone · 30/09/2022 07:30

So you are cutting yourself to the point you regularly need hospital treatment but are complaining about sore wrists from being handcuffed to keep yourself and the people responding to you safe?
You are being so unreasonable and the fact you are a student mental health nurse is a scary thought.

Wibbly1008 · 30/09/2022 07:30

I think it comes down to lack of understanding rather than a malicious act. The police do a very challenging job and I think on this occasion they just wanted to make sure you were safe. I don’t think cuffs were right, but you were not hurt and got safely to help that you yourself had requested. In the long run it was probably best to section you as otherwise you are sent home with some weak referral somewhere and a phone call.
I wish you all the best OP.

Badgirlriri · 30/09/2022 07:26

WeepingSomnambulist · 30/09/2022 04:49

There was nothing stopping you from going to the hospital first. You could have self presented and the crisis team could have seen you.

Part of the problem is that you want the theatre of it. All the attention from having someone sent out to talk you round is part of what you want. You respond quickly because you're craving the attention, once you get it, you feel better and then want everything dealt with quickly so you can get home.

He didnt give you that. He detained you because you were a danger, got you straight to a hospital, then he left you with other officers. No drama or attention or long, drawn out pandering to talk you round. Your angry with him because you didnt get the attention the way you wanted it. But you got the medical and mental health care you needed, quickly. And other police stayed with you and said what they felt you needed to hear to keep you calm.

Complaining about him should not be on your priority list right now.

I agree with all of this.

startfresh · 30/09/2022 07:24

@NurseInTraining please read the above article. Police are being shaped by past complaints. They don't act fast enough, they act too quickly. They made the right choice. Nobody died.

https://bylineinvestigates.com/2017/06/20/leaked-official-report-of-probe-into-murder-by-schizophrenic-patient-nicola-edgington/

NurseInTraining · 30/09/2022 07:23

TabithaTittlemouse · 30/09/2022 07:21

What year are you in op?

Just starting year 2. I'm doing theory right now but due to go on placement next at the end of October.

OP posts:
startfresh · 30/09/2022 07:23

Also, I will say, I've studied policing and MH, especially focusing on problems. I can't see this as a complaint. I can understand it caused you undue stress, however if you weren't acting rationally (and you are not a reliable witness to rational in a crisis) then the police officer made a quick and reliable decision which kept them and you safe.

Tendon damage is a small price to pay for the life of you, the officers and any possible bystander.

And I say this knowing of people in crises who have phoned for help, not received police help, murdered someone and then blamed it on the lack of immediate response.

bylineinvestigates.com/2017/06/20/leaked-official-report-of-probe-into-murder-by-schizophrenic-patient-nicola-edgington/

The trial also heard how, hours before her attacks in 2011, Edgington pleaded with police and staff at the Queen Elizabeth Hospital in Woolwich that she urgently needed to be detained because of her deteriorating mental condition.

TabithaTittlemouse · 30/09/2022 07:21

What year are you in op?

Mollymalone123 · 30/09/2022 07:15

Firstly I’m sorry you were so unwell but you are being unreasonable
you cut yourself and needed help
the police officers who attended maybe going on experiences they have come across previously and they have to protect themselves first.They are not there to deal with mental health crises but I’m sure they do the best they can.You said yourself you weren’t entirely sure what happened that day.There are two sides to every story.The second set of officers that looked after you would have been rushing around for you and you say they were so kind to you.That’s great but also the reason why one went off to get medication and you say they sped to get you to a meeting in time was probably because they had another long list of calls they were supposed to be on and needed to get in eith asap.No wonder the police are moaned at for never having time to deal with anything. I like others on this post would suggest that maybe a break from your course until you are fully well would be better.I really hope you get the help you need

Sally090807 · 30/09/2022 07:11

An elderly neighbour a few doors from me was having some sort mh crisis yesterday and that involved 5 police cars and a large police van and numerous officers, what a massive drain on resources.

NurseInTraining · 30/09/2022 07:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Yeah it is super fun. I love being in resus and having emergency surgery. I love the feeling of confusion that comes from significant blood loss and I definitely chose to "stab myself in the wrist'. I super enjoyed being stripped in resus and nearly dying. Thanks for your compassion.
BTW - sarcasm if anyone is doubting.
And yes, being well enough weeks later means that I can't have been unwell weeks before.

OP posts:
startfresh · 30/09/2022 07:09

I am simply asking whether I should complain about the behaviour described or not. That's it.

And you you replied to any of my other posts, you'd see I said NO you shouldn't complain about this situation.

But you only pick posts that support you or you can say "no actually" to. Rather than posts that are balanced, have points and are telling you not to complain.

eastegg · 30/09/2022 07:09

Joelijane · 29/09/2022 21:22

I'm utterly shocked 32% say your being unreasonable, christ almighty. The recent expose of abuse in mental health hospital says it all, people don't care enough and something systemically needs to change. Take a look at the movement 'A Disorder 4 Everyone' I think you might like their take on things. Go easy love x

It doesn’t ‘say it all’, as shocking as it was. That was that and this is this.

marvellousmaple · 30/09/2022 07:06

OH , your title. It's complain not complaint.

marvellousmaple · 30/09/2022 07:04

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Prescottdanni123 · 30/09/2022 07:03

I would definitely take this further. Its does sound heavy handed especially if you had the intention and gave every indication of complying. I would request details on what the crisis team said to police and why the police officers made the decisions that they did. I would also ask about what mental health training the police officers had received. If they are going to attend these types of situations, they could probably benefit from a brief course on various situations and how to handle them.

I know medical restraints are a last resort so I do also wonder if an ambulance had attended you, whether paramedics would have wanted them used in this situation.

Badgirlriri · 30/09/2022 07:00

NurseInTraining · 29/09/2022 21:10

No, I didn't. He didn't give me any opportunity to go with them willingly either. I know the Mental Health Act well (due to being a student nurse) and under normal circumstances it would have occurred that he wanted me outside purely to S136 me but I wasn't thinking straight.

To be fair to the other police officers, they were brilliant, they kept me entertained for hours, went out of their way to push for me to be seen quickly by the mental health team, were really empathetic and drove like crazy to get me home in time for a online counselling appointment. They even split up so one of them could go to the pharmacy and pick up antibiotics for me and still get me home in time for my appointment.

I have been handcuffed once previously. On that occasion they handcuffed my hands in front of me. It was because they wanted to search me (fair enough) but the police officer explained what he was doing to do before and during and it didn't hurt. This last time I had black bruises around both wrists afterwards.

No wonder actual crimes aren’t being investigated anymore!

NurseInTraining · 30/09/2022 06:56

startfresh · 30/09/2022 06:42

Until they all get complained about and put on suspension/desk duty pending investigation over following procedure over a disgruntled member of the public who got the care that was offered, instead of the care they wanted. Then who will be there?

Oh yeah, the ambulance, that the OP wanted, whilst other people lay with dying relatives needing CPR and other assistance. All those complaints about people dying, waiting for ambulances after a fall etc. and this is why!

If you wanted something specific, you weren't in crisis. In a crisis you can't think for yourself clearly and the team made the best call for you that they could.

Hey to confirm, I am not thinking about what I want or need during a crisis. I'm simply not well enough make that decision. I'm not arguing whether or not the police arriving is the right decision - ideal world all responses would be made by mental health staff but we don't live in an ideal world.
I am simply asking whether I should complain about the behaviour described or not. That's it. You might have views about me as a person but I don't need to hear about how bad a person I am. Please stick to my question about complaining or not.

OP posts:
gaymeanshappy · 30/09/2022 06:55

cansu · 30/09/2022 06:20

They should not be manipulating the law. The use of 136 when you were at home is terrible. They should not have deliberately got you into the street in order to section you. They should have called an ambulance or git you to call a family member or friend to take you to a and e if your wrists needed attention. Complain.

I don't know about other regions but where I used to work, amb would have required police attendance anyway, and wouldn't have entered the property without a police presence (due to OP having a 'weapon'). They also wouldn't have been permitted to rely on someone else to take the OP to get medical attention (what if they said they would then didn't-police liable).

Also if OP didn't let ambulance staff in (even if she'd just fallen asleep) she'd be classed as in danger, so ambulance would need police (or fire service) to force entry. In other words, ambulance staff being present could have resulted in the exact same outcome.

startfresh · 30/09/2022 06:42

Snowberry3 · 30/09/2022 06:31

Why didn't the crisis team call your mental health worker or ambulance.
Because only the police can be relied on to turn up I suppose.

Until they all get complained about and put on suspension/desk duty pending investigation over following procedure over a disgruntled member of the public who got the care that was offered, instead of the care they wanted. Then who will be there?

Oh yeah, the ambulance, that the OP wanted, whilst other people lay with dying relatives needing CPR and other assistance. All those complaints about people dying, waiting for ambulances after a fall etc. and this is why!

If you wanted something specific, you weren't in crisis. In a crisis you can't think for yourself clearly and the team made the best call for you that they could.

NurseInTraining · 30/09/2022 06:39

Snowberry3 · 30/09/2022 06:31

Why didn't the crisis team call your mental health worker or ambulance.
Because only the police can be relied on to turn up I suppose.

My mental health support worker is uni based so he only works 9-5 Monday to Friday so can only support me during this time. He has contacted NHS repeatedly saying that I need extra support outside of these times. Crisis probably called ambulance but as I explained earlier there can be a 12 hour wait. Yeah, police have to turn up but that doesn't change the original question about whether their behaviour was right or not.

OP posts:
startfresh · 30/09/2022 06:39

I see you ignore comments that you can't try and make the poster sound unreasonable. Very good work.

If you complain, I hope the department see it for what it is.

The other police officers were clearly just trying to pacify you as you were probably spouting off about your knowledge etc. and they wanted to calm you down. It does not mean that they wouldn't have done the same with that officer's experience and situation.

Snowberry3 · 30/09/2022 06:31

Why didn't the crisis team call your mental health worker or ambulance.
Because only the police can be relied on to turn up I suppose.

Snowberry3 · 30/09/2022 06:27

ipreferthecat · 29/09/2022 21:09

I don't think they are encouraged to handcuff to the front since the officer got murdered in Croydon

i think they always handcuff behind - so that someone like you cannot get something out of their pocket and cut themselves, so that no one can stab or shoot them.

I don't think you'll get far wanting to change that habit.

Swipe left for the next trending thread