Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to complaint to the police.

216 replies

NurseInTraining · 29/09/2022 20:53

So first of all I generally have always had a really good relationship with police officers that I come into contact with - they do an incredibly difficult job and don't need any extra hassle but...

For context I have mental health problems and sometimes self harm. A few weeks ago I contacted the local crisis team to say I was struggling and they contacted the police who came around. They asked me to come outside my house and then immediately handcuffed me behind my back (I had cut my wrist) and detained me under section 136 of the mental health act (you can't be detained under a 136 if you are in your home hence why he asked me to come outside).

I have no history of violence and I don't believe that handcuffing me behind my back was necessary. The officer's partner apologised for how it was handled afterwards and the next pair of officers that looked after me in hospital (police have to wait with you while you are waiting for an assessment) also said that he was heavy handed.

I don't think I should have been handcuffed but if they needed to for safety I think they could have handcuffed me with my hands in front of me rather than behind. Afterwards I had bruised wrists and I needed stitches as the wounds in my wrist were so bad. I don't think this was helped by the handcuffs.

It was very traumatic but I didn't think much of it afterwards as I was unwell however I have since found out that I have tendon damage in my wrist (not sure where or when from - could easily have come from elsewhere but might have come from this event).

I was mentioned this to a mental health support worker at my uni and he said that he thinks I should make a complaint to the police about this. It never occurred to me to do so before but I am also a student mental health nurse (ironic) and I believe that education about helpful way to work with people with mental health problems is really important and that nothing changes if problems aren't reported.

So should I complain?

OP posts:
MakeMineALarge1 · 30/09/2022 10:50

I'm not surprised he cuffed you.
If you had half as much attitude with him as you have on this thread, then I don't blame you.
I also don't understand why a great deal of mental health nurses have issues themselves, surely being surrounded by people in crisis isn't good for you, it's normalising abnormal behaviour.
But that's another thread.

Floomobal · 30/09/2022 09:29

Although reading your replies to people and seeing your argumentative tone, I don’t blame the police officer for ensuring their own safety.

I won’t comment on a person with your health troubles becoming a mental health nurse, as I think we all have our own opinion on the appropriateness, and that’s not the point of the thread

startfresh · 30/09/2022 09:28

OP - would you have rather had an ambulance?

Floomobal · 30/09/2022 09:18

I would complain. They sound like they were too heavy handed with someone who needed medical attention.

However, if you self harm to the point that you need stitches, you are more likely to have caused your tendon damage etc than the police are.

NurseInTraining · 30/09/2022 09:15

NormalNans · 30/09/2022 09:11

Aah I misunderstood your comment about doing theory right now and going on placement later and thought you were on one of the courses which has had to change the pattern of the curriculum because of issues with placements.

Another piece of feedback if you want it is that the tone of your communication on here (unsure if it reflects real life) is going to get people’s backs up. You have been quite confrontational with people and dismissive of different perspectives, which I know is hard not to do when you feel like you’re being attacked or criticised but as you know this is going to happen in your line of work. If you dig in to defend your perspective you won’t be able to engage with people and your work will be less effective.

Hi fair point. I am less confrontational in real life. I have been quite defensive (I'm not in real life at all) but it is difficult when some people seem to be making me out to be some kind of monster.

OP posts:
Nolongera · 30/09/2022 09:14

It's normal for detainees to be handcuffed.

Had the OP secreted a blade and continued to harm in transit, the same second guessing chairborne experts would be slagging the police off.

Dammed if they do, dammed if they don't.

Experts who have never done anything like it yet somehow know all about it.

bathbombaholic · 30/09/2022 09:13

The officers should have had body worn cameras on so if you complain that will be reviewed as part of the complaint.

I would say to complain- not so much for the handcuffing as like others have said this would be for your and their safety. Tho they have to use a reasonable amount of force so depending on your behaviour at the time, they would need to justify that.

But tricking you outside so they can 136 you is bad practise and not allowed. There are other ways to deal if someone is in there own home.

NormalNans · 30/09/2022 09:11

Aah I misunderstood your comment about doing theory right now and going on placement later and thought you were on one of the courses which has had to change the pattern of the curriculum because of issues with placements.

Another piece of feedback if you want it is that the tone of your communication on here (unsure if it reflects real life) is going to get people’s backs up. You have been quite confrontational with people and dismissive of different perspectives, which I know is hard not to do when you feel like you’re being attacked or criticised but as you know this is going to happen in your line of work. If you dig in to defend your perspective you won’t be able to engage with people and your work will be less effective.

NurseInTraining · 30/09/2022 08:58

NormalNans · 30/09/2022 08:50

Some of the best nurses I know have their own mental health issues, so this absolutely shouldn’t preclude you from training. However, some advice from an old fart who’s been in the business for over thirty years, you admit that you’ve only done the theory so far and you talk about the importance of reflection. Perhaps a good reflection for you is the difference between theory and reality and reflecting on what you can learn from understanding other perspectives.

A curse of trainee nurses can be the assumption that your knowledge is superior to other peoples, it’s not, it’s different and if you want to be a good nurse you need to be open to all perspectives. If you aren’t you won’t provide effective support for your patients or colleagues (in all different sectors).

Hi, I haven't done only theory. I have done four placements and every year we spend 50 of our time on clinical placement as per NMC regulations but I really appreciate the feedback. I personally feel that I learn the most from other practitioners.

OP posts:
LiftyLift · 30/09/2022 08:58

You have no grounds for complaint here. You’re upset because you didn’t get the fluffy treatment you’ve come to think you deserve.

The police are trained to fight crime, they don’t want to be the first line in someone having a MH crisis unless they’re at immediately risk of suicide. It doesn’t sound like the officer was unprofessional in any way, just that he wasn’t as empathetic as you want. The other officers might have been nicer, but that’s not any slight on the other one.

S136 is one of the only tools they have to quickly deal with you. I’m sure the public wouldn’t want police spending hours trying to convince you to seek help when they can detain you and get you to hospital there and then. Supervision would agree with this too. There are calls going uncovered due to a lack of resources, incredibly dangerous situations all the time.

A compliant won’t lead to a “reflective essay” as you might suggest. Police live in the real world and change comes from major incidents, not MH detainees who don’t like being handcuffed writing a complaint.

NurseInTraining · 30/09/2022 08:55

Quitelikeit · 30/09/2022 08:46

Op

youve hard a hard time on here but you will get a variety of perspectives.

I am sorry that you are struggling.

unfortunately some people are resentful of the police resources being used in the way you describe

I have to agree with others on one thing though - please do be careful - you could easily be declared unfit to practice if your self harming persists to the dangerous extent you have described. If you can’t help yourself how can you help others?

maybe you will he diverted onto a different course in your last year. They obviously haven’t made a decision yet but that day will come and they have a responsibility to the profession to make sure those who are admitted into it are safe to practice.

good luck

I think you make a good point but honestly (and I hate to sound like I am bragging because that makes me so uncomfortable) but I am really good at what I do and I have had only positive feedback on placement. I was recently on placement on a mental health assessment ward where I was a patient a long time ago and I believe I can understand patients in a way that some people can't. Patients seem to trust me.
I am currently jumping through hoops to be declared fit to practice and I understand why that is but I passionately believe that my mental health difficulties make me a better nurse.

OP posts:
NormalNans · 30/09/2022 08:50

Some of the best nurses I know have their own mental health issues, so this absolutely shouldn’t preclude you from training. However, some advice from an old fart who’s been in the business for over thirty years, you admit that you’ve only done the theory so far and you talk about the importance of reflection. Perhaps a good reflection for you is the difference between theory and reality and reflecting on what you can learn from understanding other perspectives.

A curse of trainee nurses can be the assumption that your knowledge is superior to other peoples, it’s not, it’s different and if you want to be a good nurse you need to be open to all perspectives. If you aren’t you won’t provide effective support for your patients or colleagues (in all different sectors).

Quitelikeit · 30/09/2022 08:46

Op

youve hard a hard time on here but you will get a variety of perspectives.

I am sorry that you are struggling.

unfortunately some people are resentful of the police resources being used in the way you describe

I have to agree with others on one thing though - please do be careful - you could easily be declared unfit to practice if your self harming persists to the dangerous extent you have described. If you can’t help yourself how can you help others?

maybe you will he diverted onto a different course in your last year. They obviously haven’t made a decision yet but that day will come and they have a responsibility to the profession to make sure those who are admitted into it are safe to practice.

good luck

cheeeeeeeese · 30/09/2022 08:25

And no sorry, you shouldn't complain

cheeeeeeeese · 30/09/2022 08:24

Crisis team called an ambulance as you had cut your wrists......obviously bad enough to require an ambulance if you needed stitches and had tendon damage. De-escalation techniques can help with calming you down, causing further harm to yourself but they can't help with your injuries as a result of that harm.

BadNomad · 30/09/2022 08:23

You were having a mental health crisis. An emergency. They needed to get you to safety asap. Neutralised. Not to have a friendly chat on the doorstep, frisk you down, then invite you into the car for a lift to the hospital.

NurseInTraining · 30/09/2022 08:18

ThinkingForEveryone · 30/09/2022 08:10

Hi, sorry to need to spell this out but people that self harm can still feel pain. I don't self harm regularly now but I am still vulnerable to significant acute trauma that can trigger a crisis.
I didn't say anywhere that you could not feel pain OP.
My point is, the officer dealing with you was scared of feeling significant pain if you stabbed him with the sharp object you had been cutting yourself with.
By your own admission you received help very quickly, fair enough, he didn't spend forever talking you round (time is precious OP, as are resources right now). He dealt with you quickly, effectively and safely for all involved.
A slightly bruised wrist is not something I would be complaining about in this situation but we are all different.

Totally get his concerns about his safety and these are 100% valid but at no point did he search me. If he had any concerns that I might have had a weapon surely he would have searched me?

OP posts:
NurseInTraining · 30/09/2022 08:16

TheOrigRights · 30/09/2022 08:05

Does your MH support worker not have a duty of care towards you which would mean they should complain about your treatment by the police if they believe the police ill-treated you?

I ask because when I was under the care of the MH team, when I discussed something that she thought was a safeguarding issue, it was taken right out of my hands. It was all pretty grim actually, as it affected someone else but when she became aware of it she said she had to take it further.

Does your MH worker realise the can of worms they opened mentioned it to you?

He does have a duty of care and has reported concerns to the NHS crisis team but with little result. This is just something he mentioned in passing during my appointment yesterday and made me think. I didn't expect it to turn into such a big deal raising it on here to be honest - my fault.
Equally I have capacity (despite what some on here may think) to make my own decisions and this doesn't put me immediately at risk so it would be up to me to complain.

OP posts:
ThinkingForEveryone · 30/09/2022 08:10

Hi, sorry to need to spell this out but people that self harm can still feel pain. I don't self harm regularly now but I am still vulnerable to significant acute trauma that can trigger a crisis.
I didn't say anywhere that you could not feel pain OP.
My point is, the officer dealing with you was scared of feeling significant pain if you stabbed him with the sharp object you had been cutting yourself with.
By your own admission you received help very quickly, fair enough, he didn't spend forever talking you round (time is precious OP, as are resources right now). He dealt with you quickly, effectively and safely for all involved.
A slightly bruised wrist is not something I would be complaining about in this situation but we are all different.

TheOrigRights · 30/09/2022 08:05

Does your MH support worker not have a duty of care towards you which would mean they should complain about your treatment by the police if they believe the police ill-treated you?

I ask because when I was under the care of the MH team, when I discussed something that she thought was a safeguarding issue, it was taken right out of my hands. It was all pretty grim actually, as it affected someone else but when she became aware of it she said she had to take it further.

Does your MH worker realise the can of worms they opened mentioned it to you?

SpringIntoChaos · 30/09/2022 08:01

OP...with all due respect, you really do need to stop complaining about the speed at which you got the actual hospital treatment you needed, and start thinking about getting help for your mental health.

Without the efficient (but to you, heavy handed 🤷‍♀️) way this officer got you to hospital and stitched up (for what sounds like not the first time either!) you might have been bleeding out for hours...as you said yourself, it can take 12 hours for an ambulance to arrive, and this officer, with his 'method' got you there in 15 minutes 👍

He's seen this many times before, and knows how difficult the situation can get in terms of help arriving and potentially escalation in the crisis of the patient. Expeditiously dealing with it is often the best way to get the help needed.

Misty999 · 30/09/2022 07:47

YABU do not complain, the officer acted appropriately.

Redqueenheart · 30/09/2022 07:42

Yes make a complaint.

There is still a lack of knowledge about mental health issues and how to deal with people in crisis in the police force.

So a complaint might actually lead to more training for these officers so that they won't do that to other people who face the same issues as you, which would be a positive outcome.

Handcuffing someone who has just cut her wrists sounds ludicrous to me.

Unless you were being violent and preventing them from taking you to hospital and they had to try to restrain you for your own safety their behaviour was unacceptable and in fact made your situation worse.

Hope you are feeling OK now.

NurseInTraining · 30/09/2022 07:33

ThinkingForEveryone · 30/09/2022 07:30

So you are cutting yourself to the point you regularly need hospital treatment but are complaining about sore wrists from being handcuffed to keep yourself and the people responding to you safe?
You are being so unreasonable and the fact you are a student mental health nurse is a scary thought.

Hi, sorry to need to spell this out but people that self harm can still feel pain. I don't self harm regularly now but I am still vulnerable to significant acute trauma that can trigger a crisis.

OP posts:
startfresh · 30/09/2022 07:33

startfresh · 30/09/2022 07:30

You weren't ignored, you weren't beaten, you didn't have someone kneeling on your neck whilst you begged you couldn't breathe until you died.

You were swiftly detained, taken to hospital for care and accompanied until completion.

Sounds like you were lucky.

This is not the minimum level of standard, but how are the police or yourself to know if you would have went willingly. You weren't acting rationally.

You are still here. Possibly because of that police office. We will never know, but they may have saved your life, your next step might have been fatal.

You are possibly alive because of the actions those police officers took. And you want to complain. Please think about that.

And I add, SOMEONE ELSE is alive because the police took the place of an ambulance.

Someone could have died if an ambulance was being held up at this situation where the police were able to detain you and get you to hospital.

Or would you have preferred the ambulance?**
Please answer that.