Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to complaint to the police.

216 replies

NurseInTraining · 29/09/2022 20:53

So first of all I generally have always had a really good relationship with police officers that I come into contact with - they do an incredibly difficult job and don't need any extra hassle but...

For context I have mental health problems and sometimes self harm. A few weeks ago I contacted the local crisis team to say I was struggling and they contacted the police who came around. They asked me to come outside my house and then immediately handcuffed me behind my back (I had cut my wrist) and detained me under section 136 of the mental health act (you can't be detained under a 136 if you are in your home hence why he asked me to come outside).

I have no history of violence and I don't believe that handcuffing me behind my back was necessary. The officer's partner apologised for how it was handled afterwards and the next pair of officers that looked after me in hospital (police have to wait with you while you are waiting for an assessment) also said that he was heavy handed.

I don't think I should have been handcuffed but if they needed to for safety I think they could have handcuffed me with my hands in front of me rather than behind. Afterwards I had bruised wrists and I needed stitches as the wounds in my wrist were so bad. I don't think this was helped by the handcuffs.

It was very traumatic but I didn't think much of it afterwards as I was unwell however I have since found out that I have tendon damage in my wrist (not sure where or when from - could easily have come from elsewhere but might have come from this event).

I was mentioned this to a mental health support worker at my uni and he said that he thinks I should make a complaint to the police about this. It never occurred to me to do so before but I am also a student mental health nurse (ironic) and I believe that education about helpful way to work with people with mental health problems is really important and that nothing changes if problems aren't reported.

So should I complain?

OP posts:
Madwife123 · 30/09/2022 16:16

@NurseInTraining It’s only fair to forewarn you that there is almost no chance the NMC will approve your PIN once you qualify if you suffer such significant mental health issues.

Your uni will tell you whatever you want to hear generally as long as they keep getting your student fees funding their institution. Plus there is a HUGE difference with being fit to be a student nurse being fit to be a registered nurse?

Have your uni told you that after you qualify you will need to pass the NMC fitness to practice test? That a panal will decide on whether this role is suitable for you? That multiple people have been turned away from the profession at this point and denied a pin (for far more minor issues than you deadline here) despite spending 3 years qualifying as a nurse? I’m guessing not.

I seriously suggest looking into the NMC requirements before you waste more time.

EightChalk · 30/09/2022 15:47

I'm talking about the way commenters have been posting to and about the OP (and other people having mental health crises), not the incident. The tone of that post addressed to me is very different from the one about her wanting the drama above.

WeepingSomnambulist · 30/09/2022 15:26

EightChalk · 30/09/2022 14:59

I wonder if some of the people commenting here are so nasty about people needing treatment for physical health problems. "The fluffy treatment you think you deserve", "drain on resources", etc. It's not OP's fault that the emergency services' policies and processes are set up the way they are. People should not be blamed for having mental health crises. It's not a choice they've made.

She is not being blamed, but the police cannot help her. The hospital staff can.

She had used a blade to cause serious injury. Police should not be risking their lives when dealing with people like this. It is safer for everyone to handcuff and get her straight to a hospital where the help is. A couple officers stay with her and the others can get on with police work.

They got her the help she needed. Help they could not provide.

VoiceOfCommonSense · 30/09/2022 15:08

You shouldn’t complain. You should get proper help and stop wasting police time and resources.

Josette77 · 30/09/2022 15:05

I am unclear as to why OP didn't call a taxi and go to the hospital herself. It sounds like she didn't want all the help beyond stitches.

EightChalk · 30/09/2022 14:59

I wonder if some of the people commenting here are so nasty about people needing treatment for physical health problems. "The fluffy treatment you think you deserve", "drain on resources", etc. It's not OP's fault that the emergency services' policies and processes are set up the way they are. People should not be blamed for having mental health crises. It's not a choice they've made.

wombat1a · 30/09/2022 14:35

Ironically there is a post today asking "To all those wondering why police aren't investigating crime" and saying its because > 80% of calls to the police are mental health issue ones and not crime related.

It's no wonder you were treated like this - doing this to you gets you off the police hands faster allowing them to get on with what they are supposed to be doing. FOr anyone who says that dealing with people like you is their job - really is it - I would say its the job of the mental health units and we need to vote next time is such a way they they are properly funded so people like OP are seen too but proper health professionals and not two coppers who really probably hate what their job has become.

startfresh · 30/09/2022 14:32

YABU 46%

I use the app but sometimes I find the post on browser if I feel strong enough to vote about it.

http://www.mumsnet.com/Talk/amiibeingunreasonable/4644510-aibu-to-complaint-to-the-police

NameChangeNameChangeNameChangeName · 30/09/2022 14:27

I can't see the voting as that feature isn't on the app. I would be interested in knowing the results?

Another problem is that using police resources has a knock on effect on other services. For example, if the police had been available for me, I wouldn't have had to use the NHS, A and E and all the follow ups. In the end I didn't use the criminal justice system as I had no faith the men would be convicted as I know how fucked up the system is and I didn't feel strong enough for it. If the police had arrived earlier I think it's likelier they would have been convicted and justice could have been done (but that's a whole other thread I guess).

startfresh · 30/09/2022 14:21

NameChangeNameChangeNameChangeName · 30/09/2022 13:51

The main issue here is that the public services - police, ambulance, mental health support etc, have been decimated by lack of funding and the government are at fault for that and we need to hold them to account.

That being said we all also have a personal responsibility for our own actions.

The police weren't in time to stop me being raped as all available crews were on "other calls" and couldn't get there in time despite it being a priority call. Perhaps in your self reflection @NurseInTraining you could seek support in finding strategies to help you to self present at hospital and obtain your medications etc. Under my circumstances, reading your posts of how the police were "keeping you entertained for hours" and "going to the pharmacy" for your antibiotics, whilst remembering how desperate I was for help, doesn't make me think you are amazingly empathetic. Quite the opposite.

My heart hurts for you. I hope you're ok Flowers

Mollymalone123 · 30/09/2022 14:02

I think people who are voting that you are not unreasonable have not then gone and read all your posts.As others have pointed out you are either very defensive or don’t bit her replying to peoples posts if they are not on your side.I really hope you get the help you need so that in future people such as @NameChangeNameChangeNameChangeName get the help they desperately needed.

NameChangeNameChangeNameChangeName · 30/09/2022 14:00

I forgot I I mention this comment too @NurseInTraining. Not much reflective skill shown in this sentence "I have literally helped officers chose their next car before as I am stuck with them for hours". How do you think that makes people like me feel who were waiting for police that didn't arrive in time? Where's your empathy?

NameChangeNameChangeNameChangeName · 30/09/2022 13:54

Mind you @stillvicarinatutu it's also depressing as fuck reading a police officer saying "Stop being a self entitled attention seeking numpty" to someone experiencing mental health problems. That isn't very fucking empathetic either.

NameChangeNameChangeNameChangeName · 30/09/2022 13:51

The main issue here is that the public services - police, ambulance, mental health support etc, have been decimated by lack of funding and the government are at fault for that and we need to hold them to account.

That being said we all also have a personal responsibility for our own actions.

The police weren't in time to stop me being raped as all available crews were on "other calls" and couldn't get there in time despite it being a priority call. Perhaps in your self reflection @NurseInTraining you could seek support in finding strategies to help you to self present at hospital and obtain your medications etc. Under my circumstances, reading your posts of how the police were "keeping you entertained for hours" and "going to the pharmacy" for your antibiotics, whilst remembering how desperate I was for help, doesn't make me think you are amazingly empathetic. Quite the opposite.

stillvicarinatutu · 30/09/2022 13:22

Treecreature · 30/09/2022 13:15

You're only being unreasonable for thinking the police would help.

She didn't want the police . She wanted medical attention. Unfortunately when people are cutting their wrist it involves something pointy and stabby- ambulance don't have personal protective equipment so police would have been called by ambulance anyway . To deal with the pointy stabby thing . I really do not know what people expect. The sense of poor me I'm entitled is astounding.

If you are a danger to yourself then you could be a danger to anyone attending. The reason cuffs aren't used is because they don't know who they are dealing with and if they lose a danger . I've had self harmers secrete razor blades in their cheeks - in cuffs you can't carry in trying to hurt yourself or anyone else . The officers (4 wasn't it ? That's half a shift ) turned up and don't know what they are confronting. Would you walk into a house and ask nicely for the razor blade ? Or would you protect yourself and others first ?

Suzi888 · 30/09/2022 13:18

The responses - basically be thankful no one knelt on your neck and killed you.

🙄 Only on MN.

Treecreature · 30/09/2022 13:15

You're only being unreasonable for thinking the police would help.

startfresh · 30/09/2022 13:13

Brefugee · 30/09/2022 12:43

I started writing, had a call then came back and the thread had moved on. eek.
You weren't ignored, you weren't beaten, you didn't have someone kneeling on your neck whilst you begged you couldn't breathe until you died.This is a very low bloody bar though. None of this should ever happen, i don't care how stressed and stretched the police are. (i mean - i do care deeply that they are stressed and stretched, but that these actions shouldn't be the result of that)You were swiftly detained, taken to hospital for care and accompanied until completion.That is true. Where i have questions is the OPs assertion that she was chucked in a van, and was rolling on the floor. Being "tricked out of the house" is neither here nor there, they have to act fast. But if OP feels that she was roughly cuffed, or whatever, it is worth making the complaint so that the police can look for themselves and assure themselves they acted correctly. (although i see from pp they apparently don't have time for this)

Yes, if you read the whole post:

You weren't ignored, you weren't beaten, you didn't have someone kneeling on your neck whilst you begged you couldn't breathe until you died.

You were swiftly detained, taken to hospital for care and accompanied until completion.

Sounds like you were lucky.

This is not the minimum level of standard, but how are the police or yourself to know if you would have went willingly. You weren't acting rationally.

startfresh · 30/09/2022 13:11

Brefugee · 30/09/2022 12:43

I started writing, had a call then came back and the thread had moved on. eek.
You weren't ignored, you weren't beaten, you didn't have someone kneeling on your neck whilst you begged you couldn't breathe until you died.This is a very low bloody bar though. None of this should ever happen, i don't care how stressed and stretched the police are. (i mean - i do care deeply that they are stressed and stretched, but that these actions shouldn't be the result of that)You were swiftly detained, taken to hospital for care and accompanied until completion.That is true. Where i have questions is the OPs assertion that she was chucked in a van, and was rolling on the floor. Being "tricked out of the house" is neither here nor there, they have to act fast. But if OP feels that she was roughly cuffed, or whatever, it is worth making the complaint so that the police can look for themselves and assure themselves they acted correctly. (although i see from pp they apparently don't have time for this)

This is a very low bloody bar though.

Did my whole post not go on to say how that isn't the level for standard or similar? I'm sure I made that point, if not it was supposed to be my very next sentence.

stillvicarinatutu · 30/09/2022 12:57

Just a an aside today we had an email from our chief constable stating only 17% of what we are going to is for crime ! 83% is mental health issues or other non crime related incidents.

Ladybug9 · 30/09/2022 12:52

Officers aren't permitted to transport anyone in the front handcuff position unless its from one safe place to another, such as a custody cell to a different custody cell. I won't link it but there's a video on YouTube of what happened to a female officer who gave someone benefit of the doubt and stayed with them in front cuffs( very violent ). Its really hard to know without being aware of the particular officers experiences, skill set and definitely information he had why he made the choice to respond how he did but it could be worth asking if you could be informed of these details as only you can then decide whether or not it was too much or not. All use of force should be recorded on a form with a really thorough justification and submitted so it isn't just a case of what someone feels like doing, it has to be considered and justified. Do you know who reported it from the crisis team? What had they told the police about you or what it was they were attending? Also might be worth finding out why you were taken in a van as opposed to a car. Hopefully this helps!

Brefugee · 30/09/2022 12:43

I started writing, had a call then came back and the thread had moved on. eek.
You weren't ignored, you weren't beaten, you didn't have someone kneeling on your neck whilst you begged you couldn't breathe until you died.This is a very low bloody bar though. None of this should ever happen, i don't care how stressed and stretched the police are. (i mean - i do care deeply that they are stressed and stretched, but that these actions shouldn't be the result of that)You were swiftly detained, taken to hospital for care and accompanied until completion.That is true. Where i have questions is the OPs assertion that she was chucked in a van, and was rolling on the floor. Being "tricked out of the house" is neither here nor there, they have to act fast. But if OP feels that she was roughly cuffed, or whatever, it is worth making the complaint so that the police can look for themselves and assure themselves they acted correctly. (although i see from pp they apparently don't have time for this)

Brefugee · 30/09/2022 12:31

The police can't win. Under funded and understaffed and a massive amount of resources taken up my mental health issues. Police officers stretched beyond what is safe.

meh. I used to have a lot of time for the police but the more i read things like this, the worse they seem. 1 out of several police acted like a bit of a twat (how about putting her carefully on the bench? in any case are we to understand the police drive around with people just bouncing around the back of a van? WTF?) etc etc. Sure they're stretched, we all are. Acting like a dick is optional.

OP, in your shoes i would make a factual complaint but not expect anything at all to happen or to change. But at least you will have done it.

Mangogogogo · 30/09/2022 12:16

I’d be wary asking on here op. These people are not experts and a lot of the comments I’ve read have no idea what they’re talking about, mostly spouting rubbish you read on social media written by other people who don’t know what they’re talking about. Also forces are all different.

speak to your support and advocacy team, they know what they’re talking about. Is there a victim care service?

the way complaints are handled here in our force are very ‘you’-focussed so they will advise whether you have grounds and speak to you about it with no judgement. They also have places they can refer you to for support with the complaint. I’d like to think they’re all the same.

Suzi888 · 30/09/2022 11:20

I can’t believe 48% think handcuffing you was an appropriate response.
Unless you were wielding a knife and acting in an aggressive or threatening manner, which it doesn’t appear you were.

I think it’s absolutely shocking and would 100% complain. That’s an inappropriate response to someone who has harmed themselves and is unarmed and requesting help.

(The police didn’t seem so heavy handed with the individual who stamped on a hotel receptionists head and body and punched a female police officer in the face and then licked the blood off his boot!)
The mental health response in this country is absolutely dire, well documented to be utterly shit, people just don’t understand it- which you can see from the shockingly uneducated responses on this thread.

I hope you get to practice again OP and I sincerely hope that you are able to access the help you need. Good luck for your future 💐I hope it’s a bright one.