Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD16 walking home from school

84 replies

Isthisbatcountry · 29/09/2022 20:17

So DD 15 (1 month away from being 16) has to attend mandatory revision class after school every evening. This means she will be leaving school at 16.10 every night. I've asked her if she wants a bus pass. She's adamant she wants to walk. It's about 1. 5 miles. No one else can pick her up. It's bus or walk. She really doesn't want to bus, says she wants the exercise and enjoys the walk. It also takes longer to get home on the bus. We don't live in an amazing area but the walk is along main busy roads and is well lit. I've reluctantly allowed her to do so thinking she's almost an adult and she should be able to decide for herself what she wants to do.
Today a teacher calls me saying she's concerned, it's a safe guarding issue and can someone pick her up or can we convince her to get the bus. Especially during the winter months. I'm doubting my parenting decisions now.
Don't want to harp on about "back in my day" but I was out after dark most nights when I was a teenager and I was fine.
AIBU to allow her to walk home or should I put my foot down and force her to get the bus.

OP posts:
NewbietoSE3 · 29/09/2022 22:01

Ignore my previous post - just saw your update.

NewbietoSE3 · 29/09/2022 21:59

A lot of this depends on your area doesn't it? Are you in the deep dark countryside? Why does the teacher think it's an issue?

UrslaB · 29/09/2022 21:57

Don't stress OP. You have made a considered decision alongside your daughter. Don't let yourself be undermined.

Was walking home two miles every day from I was 14. 1/4 mile was along a road with no footpath. In winter weather I would take a folding bike to school to cycle home to speed the journey.

Am surprised the teacher even knew how your DC was getting home. When I hold revision classes after school the kids have to fill in permission slips signed by themselves and their parent/guardians to say they understand they are responsible with getting their own way home. I never ask how. Bus, walk, bike, lift...it's not my concern. It is assumed the parents/guardians have made an informed decision with the kid. I assume the teacher is young or this is their first time organizing revision classes? Maybe overly cautious/nervous?

MurderAtTheBeautyPageant · 29/09/2022 21:55

safeguarding issue my ass.

that teacher is a tit.

Kite22 · 29/09/2022 21:54

How very bizarre.
My dds both walked home from school, and coincidently, their school was 1.5miles away.
Aside from her very different risk assessment of the situation from mine, how does she even know how a Year11 gets home ? Confused

Like others, I would probably e-mail back and ask if there was some other information that she was aware of that we weren't, as it seemed like such a strange thing for her to be contacting you about.

Kumri · 29/09/2022 21:53

Depends on the area. In the vast majority of places it is probably fine, but there are also plenty of places I won’t walk alone as a female because of fear of mugging/rape, presumably your DD’s teacher is worried that the area is unsafe. Lots of adult women like walking alone home. It doesn’t always end well.

I walked home from school from age 12. By the time I was 16 I’d been groped twice, seperately followed twice by two different gangs of men (managed to lose them both times), had a knife pulled on me, had rocks thrown at me (they hurt!) and been pushed over into the road by a random girl from my school, I still have the scars on my knees.

(Plus all the usual wolf whistles and ‘give us a smile love’ harassment from creepy men.)

All in the daytime, in a wealthy ‘nice’ part of London.

Teenagers don’t understand the abuse headed their way because they haven’t experienced it yet.

I’ll be giving my children lifts as long as I can and explaining why walking alone is usually a bad idea, no matter how freeing it feels.

XmasTreeOh · 29/09/2022 21:51

I track my teen on their phone and will do until they leave school then they choose if I keep it on. She’s 16, could be out at work if they hadn’t changed the rules!

heartbroken22 · 29/09/2022 21:44

I'd be worried with all the cases of women walking alone getting battered to death. It's 1.5 miles too. Can she take the bus and you pick her up? I wouldn't ever take that risk with my child. Don't care how old she is.

OriginalUsername2 · 29/09/2022 21:43

A lit busy road is the safest place to walk - eyes everywhere. Walking is healthy exercise. Even the sun going down doesn’t mean danger suddenly lurks.

A phone call mentioning a safe-gaurding issue would set my anxiety right off! I wonder if the teacher checked it was okay to do this.

Noteverybodylives · 29/09/2022 21:40

Is she walking on paths or on the actual road?

If the route is unsafe then I get why the teacher would be concerned.

Is it an area with a lot of attacks on girls?
And will lots of other school children also be walking that way?

I think it’s absolutely fine and have many students who walk much further than that but the route is safe and it’s in a safe, busy area.

The only time I’ve had to contact a parent over a child walking home was when the child was classed as vulnerable.

WithIcePlease · 29/09/2022 21:31

Both DD's walked 2 miles back from their school (not together due to different ages) and sch didn't finish until 4 and some days later with plays, orchestra etc
At that age too they were out and about to/from friends all weekend and sorting themselves out

Nyancat · 29/09/2022 21:25

My 7 and 10 year old do it regularly about a mile there and back, at 16 its ott by the teacher

bellac11 · 29/09/2022 21:20

At 16 I had retail jobs that involved leaving Tescos in one town and getting the very late and slow bus home at 11.15 (last bus) and then walking home from the bus stop, it was nearly an hours journey although the bus used to fly at that time of night

What on earth is wrong with people.

mrsm43s · 29/09/2022 21:17

My two walked (separately) 1.5 miles home from school at 4 from from year 7. And 1.5 miles to school in the morning as well. It's a fairly normal thing to do once they've reached secondary age, so I really can't understand what the teacher's issue is. Perhaps talk to the school? Perhaps there's something about what your daughter is doing specifically that is raising alarm bells? It's got to be something more than simply walking home at 4pm at age 16...

KleineDracheKokosnuss · 29/09/2022 21:12

Ummm. My nine year old walks a mile home at 4:15 on her own. Most of the kids round here do the same…

I am only planning to go fetch her when it’s actually dark (part of the way is unlit).

latetothefisting · 29/09/2022 21:12

really weird and overprotective of the teacher.
Apart from anything else, how would you be able to physically make a 16 y/o get the bus?
I presume that even if she doesn't get a bus pass she can still just get on a bus and pay an adhoc fare if she wants to get it occasionally if it's raining etc.?

NotJustAnybody · 29/09/2022 21:11

It's quite nice that school have shown concern. There's another thread where the school put a 11 yr old on the wrong bus and said it was his fault.
I'd contact them and ask if there's any reason for them flagging this up.
Your DD might not be so keen to walk when it's darker but if she's happy then I don't see the problem.

LondonQueen · 29/09/2022 21:10

Not sure how it's a safeguarding issue unless you live in a really really bad area, if she sticks to well lit main roads and keeps her wits about her, she is probably safer then taking the bus.

WonderingMum2 · 29/09/2022 21:08

I’m very sorry for the people on this thread who have suffered assault. It’s a horrendous experience. But I firmly believe we can’t limit all womens behaviour because of horrible men. Assaults happen sadly, in and out of the home.

Solidarityisbetterthanchsrity · 29/09/2022 21:06

The only safeguarding issue I see here is a teacher who is so utterly clueless about how to handle a teenager's natural development towards adulthood

BloodAndFire · 29/09/2022 21:05

I thought I must have misread this
My daughter is in Year 7 (in London) and walks home later than this, as did I at the same age.
By 16 I'd moved out of home. This isn't a real post, is it?

PaperPalace · 29/09/2022 21:04

I walked that distance home from school in a "not great" area from when I was 11.

TheBoxOfWhat · 29/09/2022 21:03

It might be that there is a safeguarding issue you are unaware of. I was sexually assaulted in broad daylight around 5pm walking back to my car from work in a town centre. I was also about 6 months pregnant. Not sure if they realised that or if they cared. I was a grown woman in my late 20s.

My local shopping mall type place is well known for grooming teenage girls, I know this from safeguarding training however lots of parents let their young teens go there as they feel it is safe. One large building with lots of shops, cinema, food court etc. It is safe if you know the dangers, know how they operate and what to look for, what to question. It may be the same for your DD, she might be walking a route that is fine when lots of other school children are walking it, not so great if they have had single walkers targeted somehow.

I would speak to the school and ask if there is anything specific that makes your DD walking home a risk at that time.

WonderingMum2 · 29/09/2022 21:03

If she was training for a 10k she’d be running longer and later. Good on her

VampiresWife · 29/09/2022 21:02

This is bonkers!

DD walked the 1.5 miles to school and the same home every day from the age of 11. Even in the snowy, dark winter evenings when choir finished at 4.30pm or later. There was no direct bus route and we don't drive so there wasn't any choice.

At 16 you can get married or join the armed forces for heaven's sake! Is this teacher known for being dramatic?