Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My DC missing for 4 hours after school.!!

409 replies

Highfivemum · 29/09/2022 18:45

had no intention of putting this up for discussion but after call today I am livid and would like some opinions
so my DC summer born started high school beginning of the month. Just 11 so young in year. He catches the coach from our village and has done this since he started. All fine up until yesterday when he was not on the coach when I waited for it after school. Tried his phone and it was turned off. Frantic drive to school with other DC and he was no where to be found. School did not have a clue where he was. Caretaker and head teacher called back into school ( they had both left premises when I got there) they both insisted he got the coach etc as all year 7 were taken to the coach stop at rear of school and escorted on the coach. For info it is a small high school. And only runs 3 coaches to surrounding villages.
Cutting a long story short that seemed like days for me my DC was discovered to be on another coach and was in another village, sitting by the coach stop. We eventually were reunited over 4 hours later.
my DC was distraught. He said his teacher let them out of lessons late and took three Dc to the back of the school and put them all on the same coach. This was the only coach left at school as the others had left. He said no time to collect their phones from the office. This was the wrong coach. When the coach arrived at its final destination my DC who was to upset to say anything got of the coach ,And there he sat till the error was discovered and we collected him.
the school today have said my son was at fault and he should have spoke to the driver and not got off the coach.,,, yes I get that but they have not admitted any mistake with the staff at all.
I am livid. Am I being unreasonable. What would anyone else think/ do. My DH took our DC to school today as they didn’t want to go.

OP posts:
MolliciousIntent · 30/09/2022 18:12

Tessabelle74 · 30/09/2022 18:08

Wow! How is this in ANY way your child's fault? He's barely 11! I'd be starting a formal complaint asap, it's a massive safeguarding issue!

The school have acknowledged their error, apologised and taken steps to ensure it doesn't happen again.

However, OP's son does bear some responsibility for how this turned out. Getting off the bus in the middle of nowhere and sitting by himself for 3 hours rather than asking the bus driver to call his mum was really very stupid. My 3yr old knows to ask a grown-up to call mummy if she gets lost!

Tessabelle74 · 30/09/2022 18:08

Wow! How is this in ANY way your child's fault? He's barely 11! I'd be starting a formal complaint asap, it's a massive safeguarding issue!

TheMadGardener · 30/09/2022 15:38

NinetyNineRedBalloonsGoBy · 30/09/2022 13:31

I'm absolutely shocked at the difference between all these kids on this thread who are clueless - and m
the London kids I know who navigate their own way across London every day from 11 years old on tubes / buses / trains without any problems..

Yes, expectations in different areas are vastly different!

I taught primary in London for years and currently work in a small rural West Country town.

In London hardly any kids, even in Y6, walked home without adults. Down here, loads of kids from Y3 upwards have permission to go home alone/with friends. In one way the kids here are much more independent BUT my colleagues here are aghast when I tell them that in London virtually all our school trips were on the Tube (free school travel) and that when kids went to Y7 they navigated the Tube/London buses solo. They just can't get their heads round taking a Ks1 class on the Tube. So it's different expectations everywhere. (I'm at home with Covid BTW in case anyone wonders why I'm Mumsnetting at this hour!)

Glad the school in OP's case seem to have accepted responsibility but still think OP's son should have had the nous to speak to the bus driver.

cantkeepawayforever · 30/09/2022 15:37

Porridge, I absolutely agree that ideally everyone would prepare, and model for, children every skill that they might need.

However, I can quite understand if some parents don’t or can’t equip their children with the skills that are rarely used in their current environment.

It is no more ‘shocking’ that an 11 year old rural child can’t navigate their way round a public transport system as confidently as a London child as it is that an 11 year old Londoner nay not be able to navigate their way through a field of cattle as confidently as a child who crosses that field every day on their way to school. Both are understandable products of their environment.

DD - 19 - can’t drive, not yet had lessons as not been her priority since lockdown. In an environment where she needs it, she’ll get it organised.

PorridgewithQuark · 30/09/2022 15:20

My kids are rural - nearest shop is 5 miles away, nearest small village primary school 3 miles away (the village shop there closed permanently during the pandemic), secondary school is 10 miles. There is one bus a day to our village in each direction and one an hour to the village where the primary school is.

They can navigate public transport and have been responsible for getting on the right school bus since the age of 6 (no escort from school). At 16 my eldest started college 30 miles away in the nearest city and travels there independently.

Yes, you do have to prepare and model for children of course! Its important for rural and urban children to have all the independence skills they're capable of mastering.

Don't drive and can't drive aren't the same any more than don't use public transport and can't use public transport are and it's a useful skill to have - most people don't stay living in one place these days.

cantkeepawayforever · 30/09/2022 13:54

Dd’s peers from our old village are horrified that she doesn’t drive. Amazed. Shocked. Every 17 year old there takes their test at the earliest possible opportunity. Dd can negotiate urban public transport systems in some of the world’s major cities. It depends what you need / have modelled for you.

cantkeepawayforever · 30/09/2022 13:50

NinetyNineRedBalloonsGoBy · 30/09/2022 13:31

I'm absolutely shocked at the difference between all these kids on this thread who are clueless - and m
the London kids I know who navigate their own way across London every day from 11 years old on tubes / buses / trains without any problems..

I think that we very much get what we model. A London child will navigate public transport with adults from a very early age. For a rural child to get ANY experience of non-car transport will often require parents to seek out a very specific opportunity as a ‘teaching experience’.

My old village has had no public transport for over 7 years, so a child starting secondary from there would have to have been explicitly taken by a parent to somewhere with buses to go on a bus at all (except for school trips, which are obviously under the control of teachers). Yes, many parents WILL do this as part of giving their child life skills, but many will not.

Equally, a rural child might negotiate a field of cattle on a footpath where an urban child might not, or might be used to cycling miles as a form of transport where an urban child might not, so again a parent may have to explicitly teach those skills before they are needed.

’Urban’ skills are not ‘better’ than rural skills. They are just different.

Paq · 30/09/2022 13:32

Better response from the school OP. Well done.

NinetyNineRedBalloonsGoBy · 30/09/2022 13:31

I'm absolutely shocked at the difference between all these kids on this thread who are clueless - and m
the London kids I know who navigate their own way across London every day from 11 years old on tubes / buses / trains without any problems..

Meatshake · 30/09/2022 13:16

You might not want to hold him accountable but I would certainly consider debriefing with him what he could and should have done to keep himself safe.

In all honesty I think I would personally begin to hold my child accountable for his actions at that age. Children learn through failure and mistakes so I'd talk it through/problem solving, role play a few scenarios, teach him how to check that he's on the right bus. Job done. Taking him out for pizza and tell him how well he did while getting on at the school is probably great for his ego but utter crap for his life skills! "I knew you'd find me eventually" isn't resourcefulness, it's learned helplessness.

If he's too shy to seek help and would rather sit by himself for 4 hours at a bus stop than to talk to a passing stranger and ask them to call you, is there not more going on here? It just seems utterly bizarre to be so helpless at his age. I'd be looking at myself as much as I looked at the school and thinking about ways to encourage his independence.

Dixiechickonhols · 30/09/2022 11:50

Glad school are taking it more seriously.
To all those saying you should have gone through all scenarios first time mine went to city on train alone there was someone mentally ill saying they had a bomb - police boarded train at some sidings and made them all climb off and hide in bushes. She had her phone and called me but I couldn’t get through as the police had closed the roads in case a bomb exploded. We laugh now. I’d gone through scenarios like check screen on platform make sure it’s correct train, keep your phone and purse safe from pickpockets but bomb one I hadn’t thought of.
Hope your son is ok today.

MolliciousIntent · 30/09/2022 11:44

Highfivemum · 30/09/2022 11:38

thank you for all your thoughts on this. To the few who have said. My DC does know my mobile number off by heart, and before he started we went through all poss issues that could happen. I don’t hold my DC in any way responsible for any of this. He is just 11 and shy. That’s his personality. No amount of coaching will change the way he is.
My DH went into school today and spoke to Deputy head. The teacher who was responsibly for sending the children out late and putting them on the coach has been spoken to and admitted he was at fault. He is new to school and said he wasn’t aware that there was more than one coach 🤨at school. The deputy was very upset about the whole incident and has called an emergency staff meeting this lunch. He has arranged a meeting with my husband again on Monday.
the deputy apologised for the email I had yesterday and said it should not have been suggested my DC was at fault.
he is speaking to my DC this afternoon.

That's a really positive response from the school,I'm glad to hear it.

However I really think you need to have a word with your son. He put himself at a huge unnecessary risk and you need to very firmly speak to him about the decisions he made and what he should have done instead. He needs to learn from this.

Highfivemum · 30/09/2022 11:38

thank you for all your thoughts on this. To the few who have said. My DC does know my mobile number off by heart, and before he started we went through all poss issues that could happen. I don’t hold my DC in any way responsible for any of this. He is just 11 and shy. That’s his personality. No amount of coaching will change the way he is.
My DH went into school today and spoke to Deputy head. The teacher who was responsibly for sending the children out late and putting them on the coach has been spoken to and admitted he was at fault. He is new to school and said he wasn’t aware that there was more than one coach 🤨at school. The deputy was very upset about the whole incident and has called an emergency staff meeting this lunch. He has arranged a meeting with my husband again on Monday.
the deputy apologised for the email I had yesterday and said it should not have been suggested my DC was at fault.
he is speaking to my DC this afternoon.

OP posts:
cantkeepawayforever · 30/09/2022 11:34

Sorry - another factor is that this cohort has really struggled to re-establish ‘school / learning behaviour norms’, through a combination if online learning with its opportunities for breaks etc, class bubbles leading to lack of opportunity to follow the model set by older peers and allowances being made - often by parents - along the lines of ‘poor things, they have missed out in so much, we have to be extra nice to them / make allowances’.

This means that receiving secondary schools have often gone in quite hard in terms of behaviour expectations after transition, hoping that by doing so as part of the ‘new start in secondary’, there will be a reset in terms of behaviour at the cohort level.

This may well mean that quieter, less confident children feel that secondary school adults are strict and unapproachable if a problem arises early in Y7.

cantkeepawayforever · 30/09/2022 11:18

Parents are more protective, just as part if general international anxiety, and groups like Scoits/ Guides / Boys’ or Girls’ Brigade plus the host of other sports and hobby organisations that might organise short trips / residentials that require independence have all been restricted in what they can do. It’s really noticeable.

cantkeepawayforever · 30/09/2022 11:09

Thanks that is an interesting perspective and surprises me

I have taught upper KS2 for many years, and looking at recent Y6s compared with those from 5 years ago is quite revealing.

In some ways, many seem more ‘adult’ - physically larger, much more use of sexualised and bad language, exposed to much more through social media etc - but in terms of real life skills and experiences, and in terms of independence and managed rusk taking, much much younger.

Dixiechickonhols · 30/09/2022 11:06

antelopevalley · 30/09/2022 11:00

Thanks that is an interesting perspective and surprises me.
My children are 14 and 16 years old so I thought I knew what was the norm for 11 year olds, but looks like I was wrong.

I’ve got a 16 yr old but spend time with 11-12 age now (Guides) and there’s a definite difference.

antelopevalley · 30/09/2022 11:01

LoisLane66 · 30/09/2022 10:57

@Blackheath95
Oh...I can think of a million kids who don't or won't speak up about things where an adult is concerned and I'm perfectly sure that if YOU read the news and watch TV, you will also know that this happens. Children worried about speaking out in case they get a curt answer from an adult. It's not only children.

Children need to be taught life skills though as being too afraid to talk to an adult in case they get a curt answer makes them very vulnerable.

antelopevalley · 30/09/2022 11:00

cantkeepawayforever · 30/09/2022 10:46

I think the current cohort of Y6/7/8 is also extremely ‘young’ in a way that it is hard for those who have children older than this to fully appreciate. Because it is a whole cohort issue, due to Covid, it is also very hard for parents to understand how far outside the ‘long term norms’ their child’s overall independence and experience of the world is. Everyone has lived more restricted lives in the period from March 2020, with not only fewer direct experiences, but also fewer opportunities for them and their parents to observe the children a bit older and go ‘that’s what the next step looks like’.

This is even more the case in relatively rural places, where those ‘developmental steps’ have to be so much more actively sought and where the peer group is so much smaller that the ‘current restricted / protected norms’ are pretty much universal.

So I would have been really surprised by the total passivity of this child 5 years ago, but would see it as well within the norm today.

Thanks that is an interesting perspective and surprises me.
My children are 14 and 16 years old so I thought I knew what was the norm for 11 year olds, but looks like I was wrong.

LoisLane66 · 30/09/2022 10:57

@Blackheath95
Oh...I can think of a million kids who don't or won't speak up about things where an adult is concerned and I'm perfectly sure that if YOU read the news and watch TV, you will also know that this happens. Children worried about speaking out in case they get a curt answer from an adult. It's not only children.

cantkeepawayforever · 30/09/2022 10:46

I think the current cohort of Y6/7/8 is also extremely ‘young’ in a way that it is hard for those who have children older than this to fully appreciate. Because it is a whole cohort issue, due to Covid, it is also very hard for parents to understand how far outside the ‘long term norms’ their child’s overall independence and experience of the world is. Everyone has lived more restricted lives in the period from March 2020, with not only fewer direct experiences, but also fewer opportunities for them and their parents to observe the children a bit older and go ‘that’s what the next step looks like’.

This is even more the case in relatively rural places, where those ‘developmental steps’ have to be so much more actively sought and where the peer group is so much smaller that the ‘current restricted / protected norms’ are pretty much universal.

So I would have been really surprised by the total passivity of this child 5 years ago, but would see it as well within the norm today.

Nocaloriesinchocolate · 30/09/2022 10:40

Another one appalled at the school. No wonder you were tearful for so long, OP> Reading this I want to rush off and give my DS a big hug but that’s not practical because he’s 37 and at work!

Dixiechickonhols · 30/09/2022 10:34

Blackheath95 · 30/09/2022 10:27

I am also a little concerned about the seemingly large number of meek and obedient children on this thread. If they are unable to speak up about being on the wrong bus, what else will they be unable to speak up about?

I definitely think some of it has origins in covid. All the rules, you must comply. Hearing on news about fines. Plus lots of schools are zero tolerance - no chance to say why late just automatic detention. Some especially go hard core first few weeks to set the tone - assemblies laying down the law, penalty points for forgetting a book when they are new.

scrufffy · 30/09/2022 10:32

Lolacat1234 · 30/09/2022 07:49

Surely something simple like a register that the bus driver holds each day would have solved this! Like they should wait until they have all kids at the school that day who were present for lessons in the morning and not leave until they are all accounted for? It's not like missing the normal bus where there will be another one it's the only bus, all kids that need to catch it should be accounted for! I would be so disappointed with the schools response and I can literally feel your fear in the pit of my stomach. I had it once where there was a simple mistake and my mum picked my kid up from school once and he wasn't there for me to collect and it was fixed within 20 mins but that fear where you don't know where they are and can't get hold of them is awful you must have been beside yourself for 4 hours!!

To be fair that wouldn't work because the bus driver is on a schedule and can't be held up. Plus. What about kids who are away to the dentist or going home with a friend ?

ancientgran · 30/09/2022 10:29

Dixiechickonhols · 30/09/2022 10:16

The bus carried on with the younger kids on with the driver having been given directions. If sixth form lad hadn’t spoken up then yes driver would have just stopped and told them to get off over a mile from school. Ok if you know where you are, you can walk, not if you are 11 and don’t know town (25% of places go to none catchment and it’s a huge catchment mostly rural)

Sorry, when you said you had no idea what happened to the younger ones I didn't realise you knew the bus carried on to the school.

Swipe left for the next trending thread