Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My DC missing for 4 hours after school.!!

409 replies

Highfivemum · 29/09/2022 18:45

had no intention of putting this up for discussion but after call today I am livid and would like some opinions
so my DC summer born started high school beginning of the month. Just 11 so young in year. He catches the coach from our village and has done this since he started. All fine up until yesterday when he was not on the coach when I waited for it after school. Tried his phone and it was turned off. Frantic drive to school with other DC and he was no where to be found. School did not have a clue where he was. Caretaker and head teacher called back into school ( they had both left premises when I got there) they both insisted he got the coach etc as all year 7 were taken to the coach stop at rear of school and escorted on the coach. For info it is a small high school. And only runs 3 coaches to surrounding villages.
Cutting a long story short that seemed like days for me my DC was discovered to be on another coach and was in another village, sitting by the coach stop. We eventually were reunited over 4 hours later.
my DC was distraught. He said his teacher let them out of lessons late and took three Dc to the back of the school and put them all on the same coach. This was the only coach left at school as the others had left. He said no time to collect their phones from the office. This was the wrong coach. When the coach arrived at its final destination my DC who was to upset to say anything got of the coach ,And there he sat till the error was discovered and we collected him.
the school today have said my son was at fault and he should have spoke to the driver and not got off the coach.,,, yes I get that but they have not admitted any mistake with the staff at all.
I am livid. Am I being unreasonable. What would anyone else think/ do. My DH took our DC to school today as they didn’t want to go.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
antelopevalley · 04/10/2022 10:57

The teacher escorted the children across the car park as part of their safeguarding after a child was knocked down.
I am sure they are not officially putting the children on the bus. If they were taking on that responsibility they would have registers for each bus.

Gemcat1 · 04/10/2022 10:52

@antelopevalley If the teachers are not responsible for the children getting on the bus why did this one take the late children and put them all on the last and wrong bus especially without checking it was the right one ? Why did he fail to give the children their mobile phones? Could it be that he knew he was in the wrong and just wanted to get rid of the last children so he could go home? The teachers would have an obligation to ensure that the children finish school in sufficient time to catch their coach/bus as it is the only one running to take them home. And, before you say it, not all 11 year olds would question a teacher doing so nor would they speak up for themselves with the driver. Maybe he did and the driver didn't listen. We are missing part of the story here but, from the information provided, the teacher was in the wrong, pure and simple. I would add that, in Year 7, my children rode their bikes to the train station and took a train to school and they were allowed to keep their mobile phones as long as they were switched off otherwise they lost it to the teacher in class. But that was a bigger school with someone in the school office where they could ask for help. In this case it sounds like the staff went home asap.

Highfivemum · 04/10/2022 07:13

Thank you.

OP posts:
lannistunut · 03/10/2022 22:54

I am really pleased the school are making changes - that is all you can ask really and is a sign they are listening. I hope your son soon forgets!

Dixiechickonhols · 03/10/2022 22:30

Thanks for taking the time to
update. Sounds like school took seriously and hope your DS quickly puts it behind him and enjoys yr7.

Highfivemum · 03/10/2022 21:11

Quick update.

deputy at school had meeting with DH today and two of the governors and the teacher. Very apologetic and advised him of various changes in school policy to ensure this doesn’t happen again. My DC has been getting the school coach for two weeks. Out of the two weeks he has used it a total of five occasions due to after school. No one from our village gets the coach so in answer to people saying he woudl know who was on it. He wouldn’t.
we are happy that the school has and is implementing good measures and took it serious.
My DC got the coach today and used it coming home. He seems to have forgotten the dramas of last week which is good.
i think the level of response on this post has divided a few as to my Dc. As a mum some of the comments were rather rude and insulting to me and my DC. Which when one would like support is rather unkind.
thank you to all the helpful and kind comments and mums netters who accept that all children are different and act in ways we cannot predict when under stressful circumstance.

OP posts:
MolliciousIntent · 03/10/2022 19:14

thestaffy · 03/10/2022 18:57

What would have happened if the correct bus had left without him and he was left behind, standing outside the school, as against getting on the wrong bus? (Demand an answer, there must be a policy. Remember he was late because of the actions of a teacher, not his fault, if he is to be believed)

Are there public transport options, or is the bus the only way home?

As a former teacher who had to do "supervising the charter buses taking kids home" duty, I can tell you there was a senior teacher in overall supervisory charge. They dropped the ball, they know it, you know it, and the school governors need to know it.

Hopefully he would have had the common sense to walk back into the school, retrieve his phone from the office and call his mum.

thestaffy · 03/10/2022 18:57

What would have happened if the correct bus had left without him and he was left behind, standing outside the school, as against getting on the wrong bus? (Demand an answer, there must be a policy. Remember he was late because of the actions of a teacher, not his fault, if he is to be believed)

Are there public transport options, or is the bus the only way home?

As a former teacher who had to do "supervising the charter buses taking kids home" duty, I can tell you there was a senior teacher in overall supervisory charge. They dropped the ball, they know it, you know it, and the school governors need to know it.

Novum · 03/10/2022 15:25

antelopevalley · 03/10/2022 15:14

@Gemcat1 Teachers are not responsible for ensuring children aged 11 get on the right bus to go home. At secondary they do not do registers of kids getting in coaches. A coach is provided and children get on or they do not get on.

The point is that this teacher did choose to make herself responsible. If she hadn't told OP's son that this was the right bus he would presumably have followed his usual routine and discovered it wasn't.

Mojoj · 03/10/2022 15:21

PorridgewithQuark · 29/09/2022 19:00

I'm really sorry you and your child had a scary experience, and happy to hear it turned out okay.

However unless this is a special needs school (which you haven't mentioned) I'm absolutely astounded that year 7s are escorted to the coach and not trained in all the realistic "what you do if xyz" s.

My children have been catching school buses from age 6 and then from age 10 public transport and it's always been on the children to get on the right bus. We taught and rehersed from the start what to do if you miss the bus, get on the wrong bus or get off at the wrong stop, and between the three of them they'd unintentionally tried out all the contingency plans successfully at some point.

My youngest is 11 and the idea anyone would need to put him on the right bus is quite alien - he's very much responsible for getting on the right bus and has been from his first day at secondary (when he was 10 and a half as we're non UK - different school system). The public buses he catches stop at a row of stops in front of a different secondary school 500 meters from his - that school has over a thousand pupils aged 10-18 as does his school (so over 2000 total) and at least 20 buses leave from the bus stops within the 10-15 minutes after school finishes.

tldr: I think children need to be equipped with the skills and contingency plans to deal with these types of situation by age 11.

Couldn't agree more. I am sorry you all got a fright but honestly an 11 year old should be able to get on a bus without a teacher's help! And, as for just sitting on it, when he knew it was the wrong bus! Why didn't he borrow one of the other kids' phones to let you know if he couldn't tell the driver? This is what helicopter parenting results in. When mine were 11 they were already using public transport to get around, even although I could have driven them. He needs to learn how to look after himself!

antelopevalley · 03/10/2022 15:14

@Gemcat1 Teachers are not responsible for ensuring children aged 11 get on the right bus to go home. At secondary they do not do registers of kids getting in coaches. A coach is provided and children get on or they do not get on.

Gemcat1 · 03/10/2022 15:11

The teacher failed to check that the coach was the correct coach for the children. He was obligated to ensure that the children got onto the correct coach. The children should also have been given their phones back before they were shunted onto the coach. The school acts in loco parentis ie as their parent until they are given back to their parents. I cannot imagine any parent shoving a child onto a bus just to get rid of them so that they could go home. I'm assuming that this is the UK in which case I would suggest getting legal advice if the school refuses to apologise, investigate and draw up guidelines to prevent it happening again. I would also involve the Head Governor who you can contact through the school office. The Governors are also legally responsible for the welfare of your child, and they ought to help with this.

Coyoacan · 03/10/2022 13:11

I honestly think the op needs to look at how she has parented this boy, the expectation is that children this age have at least a glimmer of common sense

Maybe it is the parenting or maybe it is natural, but this little boy does not have very good problem solving skills.

ancientgran · 03/10/2022 08:29

The teacher messed up keeping them late, the 11 year old must have known he was getting on the bus with kids who didn't catch his bus. No one told him to sit in the middle of nowhere for 4 hrs.

The teachers actions started it but some of us feel the 11 year old should have spoken at some point even if that was when he saw he was being dropped off somewhere he didn't know.

GnomeDePlume · 03/10/2022 07:44

Some posters on this thread seem determined to make this incident the fault of the 11 year old.

So far as I can see the only thing he was 'guilty' of was doing as he was told!

No doubt OP will have told her DS 'Call me if there is a problem'. Except that wasn't easily possible because the phone was still locked up back at school.

So what was he supposed to do given the situation? He was on a main road, no visible houses, in an unfamiliar area. He stayed put which was the sensible thing.

Yes, he should have said something to the driver but that is only in hindsight. That convenient position of knowing what was the right decision.

No doubt this has been a 'learning experience' for everyone involved. For OP's DS it is okay to speak up. But the biggest learnings are for the school. They should be looking at their own procedures especially around communication amongst staff, between students and staff and between home and school.

EspressoPatronumm · 03/10/2022 06:09

@fUNNYfACE36 op said on Saturday that the deputy head apologised and admitted fault..

fUNNYfACE36 · 03/10/2022 05:15

GnomeDePlume · 02/10/2022 07:45

@fUNNYfACE36 give over, you've not bothered to read the OP's posts.

The buses weren't marked. The teacher was unfamiliar with the bus system so just hustled the students onto the bus which was the last one still there as all the others had already left.

The lad is 11, in his first few weeks of secondary school. It is likely he isn't yet familiar with all the students who take 'his' bus. Not all students will take the bus every day.

The school has admitted it was at fault: the lesson finished too late, the teacher wasn't aware of how the bus system worked, the buses weren't marked. The school is taking steps to rectify all this.

Where does the op say the school has admitted they are at fault? She doesn't!!

He has been taking the same bus e v ery day for over 3 weeks !The kid must know by now which kids in his own class take the same bus as him, so why on earth didn't he speak up, why didn't he tell the driver at the end if the route, why didn't he ask his classmates for help, why didn't he seek help in the village? I honestly think the op needs to look at how she has parented this boy, the expectation is that children this age have at least a glimmer of common sense.
It seems as though the op hasn't prepared this boy at all for hw to cope when things don't go to plan.

Devora13 · 02/10/2022 21:22

Thank goodness he was okay. But-God forbid-anything had happened to him, I wonder if an investigation would have accepted the school's contention that they were blameless? I think not.

Pigsinmuck · 02/10/2022 15:14

If the bus was his friends bus but not his then surely he noticed straight away it wasn’t his bus as he wouldn’t usually get on with his friends.

I can only assume that he thought the wrong bus would still go near to where he needed. Lesson learned now, only the correct bus will get you home.

antelopevalley · 02/10/2022 14:07

GnomeDePlume · 02/10/2022 13:31

"Unknown boy knocked at my door claiming to be lost. I live on the outskirts of a small village and have never seen him before. WIBU to refuse to open the door?"

Sound like a familiar AIBU thread? Lots of posters would have said YANBU citing scam or distraction burglary.

The school's response has been entirely proportionate. This could have ended so much worse. The school's processes were not robust. They are now addressing this.

Most people do not behave like mumsnet.

user29 · 02/10/2022 13:49

I live in a small rural village with a similar set up
The kid would know after a few days , let alone 3 weeks which children from his own class catch the same bus as him!,
He must have known something was wrong when he was shepherded on the same bus as them!
And then, having been daft enough to get on the wrong bus, not alert the driver, not asking the other students for help, sutely he ould have aked his classmatesd to go their house to use the telephone
This is the problem with babying children so much , and not giving them the skillset to cope with anything.

GnomeDePlume · 02/10/2022 13:31

"Unknown boy knocked at my door claiming to be lost. I live on the outskirts of a small village and have never seen him before. WIBU to refuse to open the door?"

Sound like a familiar AIBU thread? Lots of posters would have said YANBU citing scam or distraction burglary.

The school's response has been entirely proportionate. This could have ended so much worse. The school's processes were not robust. They are now addressing this.

antelopevalley · 02/10/2022 12:54

GnomeDePlume · 02/10/2022 07:12

Nearby but not necessarily visible eg screened by trees (grown to screen noise from the main road. Over the years many villages have been bypassed. The village centre can easily be half a mile away. The bus stop is on the main road but is the stop for Little Codswallop, Upper Codswallop, Codswallop Major and Codswallop Minor, known collectively as The Codswallops.

Bus pulls up and the kids for The Codswallops all get off. In the time it takes for OP's lad to get his bearings and realise he is totally lost all the other kids have disappeared.

I live in Northamptonshire which is littered with such places. It is only when you are very familiar with a particular area that you know that it is, contrarily, Codswallop Minor which is the thriving metropolis blessed with a corner shop and a pub.

It's not the parents who drum in not to speak to the driver.

Most buses/coaches have signs up saying 'do not speak to the driver' or similar. Teachers on primary school trips also tell children the same. Some drivers are also quite aggressive in enforcing this rule.

I grew up in a rural area, I know how it works. But there will be houses nearby you can easily find.
And the signs about not talking to the driver is about not disturbing him or her when they are driving. This is why it is important to explain the reason for rules. I knew as a child not to talk to the driver while they were driving as it could distract them, I also knew it was fine to talk to the driver when getting on and off at a stop.
I was travelling alone at this age on two public buses and knew what to do if things go wrong.
I know someone upthread says just in the last few years this cohort act way younger than just a few years ago because of the pandemic. So I accept this may be normal for this cohort. But I think whenever children are going to be away from their parents, they do need to be taught what to do if things go wrong.

ancientgran · 02/10/2022 09:32

GnomeDePlume · 02/10/2022 07:12

Nearby but not necessarily visible eg screened by trees (grown to screen noise from the main road. Over the years many villages have been bypassed. The village centre can easily be half a mile away. The bus stop is on the main road but is the stop for Little Codswallop, Upper Codswallop, Codswallop Major and Codswallop Minor, known collectively as The Codswallops.

Bus pulls up and the kids for The Codswallops all get off. In the time it takes for OP's lad to get his bearings and realise he is totally lost all the other kids have disappeared.

I live in Northamptonshire which is littered with such places. It is only when you are very familiar with a particular area that you know that it is, contrarily, Codswallop Minor which is the thriving metropolis blessed with a corner shop and a pub.

It's not the parents who drum in not to speak to the driver.

Most buses/coaches have signs up saying 'do not speak to the driver' or similar. Teachers on primary school trips also tell children the same. Some drivers are also quite aggressive in enforcing this rule.

If an 11 year old can't say "I don't know where I am" at the terminus of a school bus journey I don't think he should be travelling unaccompanied.

Doesn't mean the teacher should have kept them in late but the child also has some responsibility here.

I think the "emergency meeting" is overkill. Just send a reminder round to teachers that last lesson of the day must end at x time.

Twentyfirstcenturymumma · 02/10/2022 09:11

It's on the school, appalling lack of safeguarding. Go through right channels re the complaint. Teacher needs to learn none of this is OK. YANB, total sympathy for you and your DC.