Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ending relationship because he is too tight?

291 replies

Lucasmamax · 29/09/2022 18:03

I’ve been dating someone for a few months and we get on well. However he is extremely tight! He is a property landlord and owns just over 80 properties.

he is constantly going on about the cost of living and gas and electric it’s exhausting. Won’t take me to a nice hotel or nothing he will not pay over £70 for a hotel!

he continually takes me to crappy cheap Chinese restaurants.

His house is beautiful but full of crappy old furniture but then he has super flash cars.

I’m over it! Usually when I start dating someone it’s fun. Weekends away nice meals out you know the honey moon period. But this is miserable and everything we do consists around the price.

Now how do I call this off without sounding like some kind of goldigger?

OP posts:
KettrickenSmiled · 30/09/2022 08:27

ImpartialMongoose · 29/09/2022 18:36

If OP was a gold digger she would be hanging on for dear life and going along with everything to bag herself a millionaire.

No she wouldn't.
Gold diggers stop digging when they find they are working a dead seam.

red4321 · 30/09/2022 08:27

Lucasmamax · 30/09/2022 06:54

He spent 45k on a private plate last week! Forgot to add. He will spend a fortune on cars and private plates but then will moan about the little things. Makes no sense!

however I have told him now but he wants to meet today to speak.

I fear that's how our spending habits would come across. We have a large house with a pool, nice cars (second hand) and spend quite a lot on holidays.

On the other hand, I take food for the kids when we go to the cinema, I'd always order the smallest drink at Starbucks, my husband likes buying clothes from the charity shop and I sit in a coat in a cold-ish house in winter because it seems indulgent to put the heating on. We also don't usually give each other gifts for birthdays and Christmas.

I guess you spend money on things that bring you pleasure but, even though we're lucky enough to be well-off, I don't like wasting money on other things either. Maybe he's the same although he does sound quite extreme with it.

Redorblues · 30/09/2022 08:27

Don't do it OP. The fact he won't take no for an answer says he has no respect for you (which was already evident) and will be controlling if you let this continue. He likes to feel powerful, and you to feel small. You certainly aren't his equal in his eyes, and he's probably a misogynist. Don't let him squash your fun, lovely self!

Meanness is the worst trait in a person. Don't give him a chance to temporarily change his behaviour, or make more empty promises. The longer this goes on the harder it will be to get rid of him.

Itsacafe · 30/09/2022 08:24

Anamechangeisasgoodasarest - Thankyou. I had read "plate" as "plane!" Oh dear. Time to get to Specsavers for me.

AisforApplePie · 30/09/2022 08:24

A private plate for £45k???? Surely this is a wind up. No one would pay that much money for a number plate for a car. Private number plates are the worst anyway, but what did it say for £45k???

LuaDipa · 30/09/2022 08:23

Yanbu and he may want to meet but he isn’t going to change. Personally I think you’ve done the right thing. Life is too short to love a joyless existence if you have the funds to do otherwise. Enjoy your days out and holidays with friends and sack this man off.

GCAcademic · 30/09/2022 08:22

I would dump him for having a private plate, tbh.

Those things as sad as fuck.

oviraptor21 · 30/09/2022 08:20

Don't even need to give him a reason but if you do, yes, different spending priorities.

Anamechangeisasgoodasarest · 30/09/2022 08:11

£45k for a private plane? This type of thing annoys me as there is no need. Was he sharing the cost of the plane with friends? DH is sometimes in this position and they get carried away, but personally, I think it's a) unnecessary b) obscene c) an environmental disaster d) a load of bollocks.

@Itsacafe

I think it was a typo and OP meant "plate" (as in number plate)

Inertia · 30/09/2022 08:10

In terms of the conversation, I would just say that your priorities are too different. You’re happy to pay your way, but as meals out / weekends away are your only treats to yourself you want to make them enjoyable. His priorities are flash cars and number plates, which is his choice but isn’t an investment in your relationship.

If you’re paying your fair share then you’re not a gold digger. If he were paying for all the hotels and meals and you were complaining about them not being swanky enough then that’d be gold digging.

sheepdogdelight · 30/09/2022 08:07

If you're happy to pay halves, do you think he's actually being considerate by not insisting on going to expensive places because he knows you won't be able to afford it.

I'm not sure how as a single mother with a child on 26K how you are affording spa days, holidays away, hotels more than £70, nice restaurants etc. The answer sounds like you aren't - so you expect him to pay.

Your post is all about how much money he has but him not spending it - would you be happy to go to "crappy cheap Chinese restaurants" with him, if you knew that was all he could afford?

chilliesandspices · 30/09/2022 08:06

I had an ex who was similar and that's why he's my ex. I earned half what he did and managed to live within my means while still enjoying life. He really sucked the fun out of everything with his penny pinching. I wanted something who would share experiences with me. The final straw was when my friends invited us to go canoeing on a sunny weekend. It cost £30 each for 6 hour hire and we were bringing picnic food. Parking was £10 and when I said I'd pay that myself he was horrified that I'd let them rip me off like that ("them" being the council). I ended up going alone, he started sulking like a teenager and was in a foul mood when I saw him later. I dumped him that night.

Babyroobs · 30/09/2022 07:57

Why would you want to be with someone who is so morally bankrupt as to be owning 80 houses?

dingbat56 · 30/09/2022 07:56

Just tell him the truth OP .. you like experiences and he likes flash cars … I’m not sure you even have difference perspectives .. you will both flash the cash but just on different things . Perhaps he feels able to afford the cars and number plate because he doesn’t allow himself other things .You only live once flippant but true

Honeylover333 · 30/09/2022 07:55

User112 · 30/09/2022 07:04

You want a life style you cannot afford and want him to fund it for you.

he is not tight, he is sensible with his money. the reason he has money is because he doesn’t wAste it !!

How is stressing over trivia (like his microwave rice going up by 9p!) “sensible”? He’s sucking the joy out of his own life, let alone OP’s.

OP, I went out for a while with a man who earned lots more than me, but was the most miserable skinflint. He was interesting and attractive, but I gave up after discovering he carefully reused his dental floss!

Jengnr · 30/09/2022 07:54

She doesn’t though, does she? It’s literally in the post that you quoted that she’s happy to pay for herself.

She doesn’t want to be whisked away to do stuff at no cost, she wants to do nice things and go to nice places and is happy to pay her way. She’s not willing to foot the bill for someone with a shitload of money just because they’re too tight.

MrsClarkandPercy · 30/09/2022 07:50

You have such different perspectives. What even is the compatibility between you? This will never work. It's not a question of judging him or you. It's his money, his prerogative to mind it. Similarly your choice what you do. But what won't work is one person having expectations of the other and getting annoyed when they aren't met.

Personally yes I think he sounds too tight, and I very much doubt he'll change.

Just simply say so sorry but it's not working out.

I'd avoid going into why. Pointless waste of energy and may leave you upset.

Noteverybodylives · 30/09/2022 07:45

You two just aren’t compatible.

You have given it a go, even though you weren’t really into him and it didn’t work.

Just tell him it’s not working out as you see him more of a friend and that it’s over.

JanesBond · 30/09/2022 07:44

Just say this the meanness and penny pinching on everything that’s sucking the fun out of things.

Rainbowqueeen · 30/09/2022 07:38

Yuck I’d ditch him too OP. He has shown you what life would be like with him. He has no interest in your feelings or building a mutually respectful and enjoyable relationship.

Don’t listen to what he has to say. He has shown you who he is. Believe that.

donttellmehesalive · 30/09/2022 07:35

If you know it's over, why meet? It'll just be an awkward conversation in which you're forced to pull punches out of politeness and he tries to persuade you to change your mind.

Are you hoping he will say that he'll be more generous from now on? Would that be enough to change your mind?

CatchersAndDreams · 30/09/2022 07:30

My grandparents were friends with a stingy millionaire. The husband would moan at his wife for buying herself a coffee and she'd never buy a cake. They had 10plus year old meat they had bought on special buys in the freezer. Wouldn't wash dishes in hot water to save money - but would buy a new car every two years and go on cruises. He was one of those men who would pay for things to impress ( new car, cruise every year to brag to his friends) but wouldn't let his wife buy a cake when having a coffee with my nan. Fuck having a miserable life like that.

Itsacafe · 30/09/2022 07:29

Hmm, when you say he's a 'millionaire,' do you mean in terms of property assets? This doesn't mean he has multi-millions in cash, just sat there. Maybe he has property worth millions, but also mortgages on some / all of those - ie. a situation where he makes a small profit on each property after the mortgages and other costs are considered? I don't know, just wondering. On paper, my DH owns similar, but there are obviously high costs and risks.

Also, it's quite common for some men to see the point in things like cars, but then have crap furniture. This is just how they are. Again, my DH is like this. If I didn't buy the furniture and that type of thing, the house would look crap.

£45k for a private plane? This type of thing annoys me as there is no need. Was he sharing the cost of the plane with friends? DH is sometimes in this position and they get carried away, but personally, I think it's a) unnecessary b) obscene c) an environmental disaster d) a load of bollocks.

However.... regardless of how much actual disposable income he may or may not have, he should WANT to be treating you on dates. What is wrong with him? Call me old fashioned (but he sounds more my age to be fair) he should be paying for most things - not because he has more money, but because he a man and it's the gentlemanly thing to do on dates. You say he's been chasing you for a while - well, all the more so! I couldn't be doing with these wet men.

If he's like this now, imagine what he'll be like in ten years. It could be he is non- NT and gets obsessive about certain petty details snd needs help, but all in all, it sounds like you have the measure of him OP. Go with your gut instinct.

liveforsummer · 30/09/2022 07:22

SleeplessInEngland · 30/09/2022 07:16

He's just spent 45k on a number plate ffs.

Yes, it’s almost unbelievable, wouldn’t you say?

Not to me, I've known people like this myself. Not unbelievable in the slightest.

BadNomad · 30/09/2022 07:22

He doesn't want to spend money on things he doesn't enjoy. There's nothing wrong with that. Money spent on things you don't like is a waste. The same way you probably think him spending 45k on a car is a waste. But it's not to him. Your likes and dislikes are just not compatible.