Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ending relationship because he is too tight?

291 replies

Lucasmamax · 29/09/2022 18:03

I’ve been dating someone for a few months and we get on well. However he is extremely tight! He is a property landlord and owns just over 80 properties.

he is constantly going on about the cost of living and gas and electric it’s exhausting. Won’t take me to a nice hotel or nothing he will not pay over £70 for a hotel!

he continually takes me to crappy cheap Chinese restaurants.

His house is beautiful but full of crappy old furniture but then he has super flash cars.

I’m over it! Usually when I start dating someone it’s fun. Weekends away nice meals out you know the honey moon period. But this is miserable and everything we do consists around the price.

Now how do I call this off without sounding like some kind of goldigger?

OP posts:
AchatAVendre · 30/09/2022 10:23

If someone is earning way more than the other person do you not think they should pay for majority of things?

A few months in? No. Not unless they offer. Before DH, I dated a very rich man, and I honestly felt really embarrassed when he insisted on paying for everything. Even then, he didn't go on spa days with me. I could go to the spa in the hotel on my own of course, and he might join in for 45 minutes on the lounger, but expecting a man to actually go on a spa weekend with you, mmmn, thats not really something I'd be looking for in a man anyway. And you wouldn't have liked my rich boyfriend either, as he was more into small local restaurants that were actually rather good rather than expensive and flashy, and mid range hotels where you could go hiking from!

He had no presents from anyone on his birthday I went out and brought him loads.

Bet you only did that in the expectation of getting more spent on you though OP.

You don't even like this man, goodness knows why you agreed to date him at all. It sounds like he just wants a younger woman on his arm and isn't bothered about impressing you too much, so he probably doesn't like you that much either. Its transactional, but he sounds like nobody's fool.

AchatAVendre · 30/09/2022 10:18

Goldbar · 30/09/2022 10:14

However rich someone was, I'm afraid if they suggested a camping holiday to me they'd go on the 'bin' list. As far as I'm concerned, there is absolutely no material wealth that can compensate for being expected to go camping on a regular basis!!!

Judging by the photos, they had a great time! I don't think they go camping regularly, but perhaps going camping if you are a multi-millionaire at the outset of a relationship is a good way of testing compatibility under less than idea conditions!

And I guess you don't protect all that inherited wealth by spending it on new girlfriends exotic luxury holidays Grin

Tigertigertigertiger · 30/09/2022 10:17

are there really men out there who want to go on spa days ?

Goldbar · 30/09/2022 10:14

AchatAVendre · 30/09/2022 10:07

He seems to suggesting dates which are quite normal for most people - whats wrong with Chinese restaurants or going to the pub exactly? Or hotels costing less than £70? I mean most people just go round to each other's houses after a certain time and have one or two meals out or weekend hotel stays as a special thing, not a regular thing.

And if the guy's interest is in managing his own money, then yes its probably a trait that he will talk about how much things cost. A lot of wealthy people do this. No-one likes to be fleeced and he's probably learned to get good value.

I do think you come across as a golddigger. Do you invite him round to your home and cook? Its quite odd to so demanding about expensive hotels and restaurants.

I would guess he is quite wary of women like you just wanting to use him for his money, and I don't blame him. You have quite a "chunky" demanding way of writing, so perhaps it doesn't come across this way in real life. Did you agree to date this man because he was rich or because you liked him? Because tbh if you are a golddigger and you are assuming that rich men won't see through you, you are going to fail miserably at getting a rich husband. The richest man I know (acres of land, estates in Surrey and Scotland) took his now wife camping on a Scottish island for their first holiday!

However rich someone was, I'm afraid if they suggested a camping holiday to me they'd go on the 'bin' list. As far as I'm concerned, there is absolutely no material wealth that can compensate for being expected to go camping on a regular basis!!!

NippyWoowoo · 30/09/2022 10:13

Lucasmamax · 30/09/2022 06:54

He spent 45k on a private plate last week! Forgot to add. He will spend a fortune on cars and private plates but then will moan about the little things. Makes no sense!

however I have told him now but he wants to meet today to speak.

Ignore the others on here, I'm sure they're the same ones who run to posts saying their husbands earn 6 figure salaries. Bet they wouldn't put up with that either!

Honestly, stinginess is an unattractive quality. You're better off without.

Autumnleavesandmoods · 30/09/2022 10:11
  1. you dont sound like a gold digger at all, so no worries OP
  2. he sounds such a great joy to be with ha! No way please leave him today and enjoy life with your son instead :)

Keep us posted! x

daisyjgrey · 30/09/2022 10:11

I'd be binning him off purely because he thinks it's ok to hoard over 80 properties...

Goldbar · 30/09/2022 10:11

You have a different philosophy towards life, that's all. You want to enjoy the money that you do have by having fun experiences and you want someone to share them with. He is only willing to spend money on the things that are 'worth it' to him regardless of what you value. That's the reason I'd dump him, really... he doesn't sound like the type that would put himself out or go out of his comfort zone to make someone he supposedly loves happy. In reality, relationships have to have some give or take.... I've been to see films I haven't enjoyed, on holidays which weren't my preference and to restaurants I don't particularly like because my DH wanted to go to those. Similarly, he's done the same for me.

It sounds like it's not so much that he's tight with money but that he thinks his preferences are the only ones that matter. Successful relationships depend on compromise and reciprocity.

lking679 · 30/09/2022 10:11

Not sure about the wanting him to pay for things in general but overall tightness is not a good look and if you're not getting on because of it then yeah leave him. My husband is quite tight but I'm the higher earner so if I want something I pay for it. I pay for our holidays because his salary just covers half the mortgage, bills, food and childcare. But it's annoying if he's out without me, I have to remind him to offer to pay for a round with his mates. And he will still expect his parents to pay for a meal out if he's out with them. He bucks up when it's pointed out though. If it was any worse or if he was the higher earner... it'd be exhausting.

redgirl1 · 30/09/2022 10:09

I would just say you enjoy different things. You want to go out be sociable, have new experiences and see new places and he does not. Just say you think you want different things in life and after thinking about it you just don’t see that is going to work between you. It doesn’t have to be framed in the context of money.

AchatAVendre · 30/09/2022 10:07

He seems to suggesting dates which are quite normal for most people - whats wrong with Chinese restaurants or going to the pub exactly? Or hotels costing less than £70? I mean most people just go round to each other's houses after a certain time and have one or two meals out or weekend hotel stays as a special thing, not a regular thing.

And if the guy's interest is in managing his own money, then yes its probably a trait that he will talk about how much things cost. A lot of wealthy people do this. No-one likes to be fleeced and he's probably learned to get good value.

I do think you come across as a golddigger. Do you invite him round to your home and cook? Its quite odd to so demanding about expensive hotels and restaurants.

I would guess he is quite wary of women like you just wanting to use him for his money, and I don't blame him. You have quite a "chunky" demanding way of writing, so perhaps it doesn't come across this way in real life. Did you agree to date this man because he was rich or because you liked him? Because tbh if you are a golddigger and you are assuming that rich men won't see through you, you are going to fail miserably at getting a rich husband. The richest man I know (acres of land, estates in Surrey and Scotland) took his now wife camping on a Scottish island for their first holiday!

WendyWagon · 30/09/2022 10:01

A poor guy who would give you his last penny is a better bet than a rich miser.
If he owns 80 BTLs he is never going to be poor.
I went out with some very wealthy blokes back in the day. All shits, all now divorced in their 50/60s.
My husband bought me champagne on our first date and brought flowers for my mother when he came to lunch. He was a ordinary working Jo. He actually told our son he must buy a lady her first dinner (23, they all go halves these days).
So I would tell him you are off out with some friends to somewhere nice and don't have time.
£45k for a numberplate (bloody idiot).

Mxyzptlk · 30/09/2022 09:53

It's not because of the money itself, it's because he doesn't want to do things with you that you want to do.
Nothing is preventing him, as he could afford them, he just doesn't want to .
You aren't suited.

Naunet · 30/09/2022 09:51

candycaneframe · 29/09/2022 18:53

That's the definition of a gold digger

You don't seem to get that

Someone paying for themselves is a gold digger?! 😂

Rewis · 30/09/2022 09:51

I don't think this is about being a millionaire or gold digger. Or necessarily being tight. It's compatibility.

He spends £45k towards his car cause it is something he wants and it is worth it for him. A Chinese buffet brings him more/same amount of joy as does a £££ Michelin star meal. Going to the pub is an equal outing to him as is Spa weekend getaway. So he dienst want to spend the money for something he doesn't appreciate. Should he do it occasionally to make his partner happy? Yes. Especially if he has the means. But if op is the one always looking for the next weekend away and expecting him to pay his share of something he doesn't really want to do then that is a lot to ask.Whining about money all the time (wether you're rich or broke) is a turnoff.

Cleothecat75 · 30/09/2022 09:47

I’d ditch him. And tell him why. Maybe in the future he will be a bit more generous (and I don’t mean that he should be paying for everything, but he should be paying for some things).

I think this is also a really good example of why the government’s ‘trickle down’ economy won’t work. The rich don’t always spend their money! He’s moaning about rice going up by 9p when he’s a millionaire. I completely understand him wanting to protect his money from gold diggers, but you sound like you are willing to go half’s, the problem is that he isn’t willing to go half’s for his share.

There is no long term in this relationship. Can you imagine living with him or having a child with him. I’ve seen friends struggle because there partner limits their spending and it was awful (worst example- very young baby and toddler, washing machine broke and despite him being able to afford to replace it, she hand washed the whole families clothes for weeks). Don’t let yourself be in that position. Life is to short.

JacquelineCarlyle · 30/09/2022 09:44

hattie43 · 30/09/2022 06:54

Meanness and tightness are not nice traits . I'm with OP and would quit this relationship. Tight people are not popular and listening to someone always winging about money and prices is exhausting.

Completely agree - even when they're struggling this can be quite hard to listen to, but when they're much better off than you, then it's particularly galling.

Get rid Op - your outlook on spending money and living life in general aren't compatible and it'll be nothing but misery for you if you stick with him.

Crazykatie · 30/09/2022 09:42

Hi my DIL is married, husband is rich and as tight as a ducks arse, she had to live with him for 7 yrs before he married her, by then she was 6 months gone with the second baby. Now she is a SAHM with 4 children, 5 horses 3 dogs and he is still tight, her lifestyle is very good, she just takes what she needs out of the account and he does not say a word.

If your man is rich and treats you well stick with him and make yourself valuable, get involved in the business if you can, you will have a very good life that many will envy. So if you love him stick to him.

WeAreTheHeroes · 30/09/2022 09:31

ManateeFair · 30/09/2022 09:06

Why would you expect him to ‘go halves’ on something he doesn’t want to do? Go on a spa day on your own if you want one.

Isn't this indicative of their incompatibility though? If he's never done it before he can be open minded and try it, or if he doesn't fancy it he can suggest something else which isn't a Chinese buffet restaurant.

rainbowstardrops · 30/09/2022 09:27

I don't think you sound like a money grabber because otherwise, surely you'd stay with him if he's a millionaire!!!
It sounds like you value life and want to do nice things and him moaning about microwave rice going up by 9p, isn't compatible to that!

Haffiana · 30/09/2022 09:24

It is so worrying the number of posters on this thread who would go down the route of 'proving' to a miserly man that they are not gold diggers. That way lies financial abuse. That way lies abuse in general.

It is SO easy to get sucked into it - into showing a man that you will be a 'good partner' and not be taking 'advantage' of him and all that silly fantasy shit.

The starting point for any relationship is to be yourself, as you are, with your own boundaries and your own values. Knowing your own self worth, and not framing yourself in his terms. Not to be creating new eggshells to tiptoe on.

And ffs, not advising other women to be 'good girls for your man' either.

hadtochangetothisone · 30/09/2022 09:23

You didn't answer the question OP.

Would you be attracted to him without his trappings of wealth. If he didn't even have a car let alone a flash one. ? Lived in a 2 bed terrace and worked in a respectable profession earning about the same as you. ?

Do you fancy him. ?
Does your heart skip a beat at the idea of seeing him. ? Not because you are going out for dinner or 'doing something' - just staying in, cooking together and spending a quiet night at home together. Does that make you excited to see him or bored witless at the thought of it ?

Don't really understand the comment "£25k isn't my whole income". When you literally said you earned £25k ?

katepilar · 30/09/2022 09:18

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Autumninnewyork · 30/09/2022 09:17

Don’t let him talk you around, OP! Your values are incompatible (you sound fun and he sounds exhaustingly tight!) and he won’t change

katepilar · 30/09/2022 09:16

I find your expectations way too high. Not sure why you expect to go out for meals and spa days and such.
Plus I do understand why he is worrying about money re his properties.

You need to date someone else, someone who meets your expectations and has the money to spend.

Perhaps this is a reverse thread? I find the post a bit weird.