Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ending relationship because he is too tight?

291 replies

Lucasmamax · 29/09/2022 18:03

I’ve been dating someone for a few months and we get on well. However he is extremely tight! He is a property landlord and owns just over 80 properties.

he is constantly going on about the cost of living and gas and electric it’s exhausting. Won’t take me to a nice hotel or nothing he will not pay over £70 for a hotel!

he continually takes me to crappy cheap Chinese restaurants.

His house is beautiful but full of crappy old furniture but then he has super flash cars.

I’m over it! Usually when I start dating someone it’s fun. Weekends away nice meals out you know the honey moon period. But this is miserable and everything we do consists around the price.

Now how do I call this off without sounding like some kind of goldigger?

OP posts:
eldora · 30/09/2022 11:40

Forfukzsake · 30/09/2022 11:38

If he is a landlord with 80 properties he is morally repugnant. Would he become nice if he paid for your spa days?

The Royal Family are raking in £2.8m pa in rent money, I hope this moral repugnance extends to them too.

Forfukzsake · 30/09/2022 11:38

If he is a landlord with 80 properties he is morally repugnant. Would he become nice if he paid for your spa days?

Sandra1984 · 30/09/2022 11:37

Bollindger · 30/09/2022 11:27

Right now you have nothing to lose.
Tell him your not after his money, and you know he will spend out on his cars, but the way he is with normal life is killing the romance for you.
Tell him your on much less money than him but your willing to pay out for things and that his way is giving you the ick.
Ask him why his previous relationships have ended?
Ask him if he really thinks being so tight is getting him anywhere?
Say all you want is to not have to penny pinch or compromise on things.
Ask if maybe he could set a budget for doing things, maybe £1k a month for a trial and see if he can see an improvement.

😫

Sounds like he needs to do an A level to date her. Relationships should be easy and fun, specially at the beginning. These people are not on the same page. He'll die alone rich with 5 cars in the garage and she would have moved on to someone who loves and cherishes her. Two people looking for different things in life. Is not going to work.

Bollindger · 30/09/2022 11:27

Right now you have nothing to lose.
Tell him your not after his money, and you know he will spend out on his cars, but the way he is with normal life is killing the romance for you.
Tell him your on much less money than him but your willing to pay out for things and that his way is giving you the ick.
Ask him why his previous relationships have ended?
Ask him if he really thinks being so tight is getting him anywhere?
Say all you want is to not have to penny pinch or compromise on things.
Ask if maybe he could set a budget for doing things, maybe £1k a month for a trial and see if he can see an improvement.

Spanielsarepainless · 30/09/2022 11:26

You don't need to explain. Just say it's been interesting being with him but the relationship doesn't work for you.

fluffi · 30/09/2022 11:25

He's not tight, you have different priorities. He likes cars and spending his money on them and you like experiences like eating out and holidays. The cost of living is affecting everyone right now, regardless of income we are have less disposable income (or no disposable income at all now), so of course he's going to talk about it.

I wouldn't bother to meet though. Stick to you aren't compatible and want different lifestyles.

Ihearticecream · 30/09/2022 11:16

I wouldn’t bother meeting him. He’s not going to change. It’s just more time of yours wasted if you do.

Livinginanotherworld · 30/09/2022 11:12

Run a mile…..there is nothing worse than a miser. They are embarrassing to be out socially with. He won’t change.

AchatAVendre · 30/09/2022 11:03

Goldbar · 30/09/2022 10:55

And I think that's a fair point. But it doesn't make someone a gold digger (which some people seem to be inferring) just because they like nice restaurants, breaks away and expensive holidays (as opposed to cheap buffets and camping) and would like their partner to share these experiences with them. That would only be the case if they expected the other person to pay for it all.

On 26k with a child, the OP is hardly going to be living that kind of lifestyle if she is funding it for herself or even paying half. I don't believe her. She wants him to pay for her.

I have a group of friends who are mostly comprised of women who have moved here for marriage. I love my friends, they bring a perspective to my life that I otherwise lack, but oh goodness, they do talk about their husbands in terms of money all the time. Their spending habits are examined in minute detail in conversation about matters which would normally be kept private, how much the home their husband already owned is mentioned all the time, and their future finances commented upon in quite a forensic way which seems quite alien to me. Then again, their husbands made the choice to marry women from outside their local area in fact outside Europe, whom they really didn't know very well and they all seem to be quite happy marriages.

I sometimes think maybe I should have adopted that attitude and pursued a ring on my finger with the multi-millionaire, but I was more into the outdoors and doing stuff for free and enjoying life rather than counting pennies. And DH and I haven't ended up that badly off anyway!

HotWashCycle · 30/09/2022 11:01

Few things are worse in a man than meanness, and he won't miraculously change into a free-wheeling, generous spirit. So give him a miss and save yourself years of no fun. There are plenty of other fish in the sea. Just tell him that his approach to life is too money-oriented for you - that should deal with any suggestion of gold digging!

Midlifemusings · 30/09/2022 11:00

Goldbar · 30/09/2022 10:55

And I think that's a fair point. But it doesn't make someone a gold digger (which some people seem to be inferring) just because they like nice restaurants, breaks away and expensive holidays (as opposed to cheap buffets and camping) and would like their partner to share these experiences with them. That would only be the case if they expected the other person to pay for it all.

It is perfectly fine to like expensive restaurants and holidays if you can afford it. It is being a gold digger to like them on someone else's dime.

stealthninjamum · 30/09/2022 10:57

Op you don’t have to see him if you don’t want to.

i wouldn’t focus on the money or the fact he’s tight but the fact he doesn’t seem to want to enjoy life or compromise to do the things you enjoy doing

Goldbar · 30/09/2022 10:55

sheepdogdelight · 30/09/2022 10:49

My point was that I wouldn't be with someone who fundamentally wanted different things to me. Which I think is true of most people?

And I think that's a fair point. But it doesn't make someone a gold digger (which some people seem to be inferring) just because they like nice restaurants, breaks away and expensive holidays (as opposed to cheap buffets and camping) and would like their partner to share these experiences with them. That would only be the case if they expected the other person to pay for it all.

BadNomad · 30/09/2022 10:53

How on your salary with a child can you possibly being paying your half for all these lavish and expensive vacations you want.

Maybe the child's father is also a millionaire.

MoCaine · 30/09/2022 10:53

Lucasmamax · 29/09/2022 18:03

I’ve been dating someone for a few months and we get on well. However he is extremely tight! He is a property landlord and owns just over 80 properties.

he is constantly going on about the cost of living and gas and electric it’s exhausting. Won’t take me to a nice hotel or nothing he will not pay over £70 for a hotel!

he continually takes me to crappy cheap Chinese restaurants.

His house is beautiful but full of crappy old furniture but then he has super flash cars.

I’m over it! Usually when I start dating someone it’s fun. Weekends away nice meals out you know the honey moon period. But this is miserable and everything we do consists around the price.

Now how do I call this off without sounding like some kind of goldigger?

i'm a fella who made an account for advice on a particular issue i had, a lovely woman took the time to reply and helped me with said issue, i lurked around the rest of the forum and read some of the other threads, like the lady who has a newish boyfriend and he wants to invite a female friend to his place for a holiday {get rid ASAP} the young mum who's toddler had to get his leg amputated { my best wishes for you and you son, you are special people}.....then i read your thread, you'd put me off dating someone new that i didn't know.

Ending relationship because he is too tight?
oohfuckinghell · 30/09/2022 10:53

NippyWoowoo · 29/09/2022 18:45

Ew I find that very off-putting. Unpopular opinion but I shouldn't have to go halves with someone who probably has triple my income Hmm

Why? They may have triple your outgoings too.

Just because someone has more money than you it doesn't mean you're entitled to not pay your way. That's a typical gold digger.

sheepdogdelight · 30/09/2022 10:49

Goldbar · 30/09/2022 10:33

And how would you feel if the other person disregarded your preferences the whole time and insisted on spa weekends and expensive holidays and never did what you wanted to do?

My point was that I wouldn't be with someone who fundamentally wanted different things to me. Which I think is true of most people?

Midlifemusings · 30/09/2022 10:48

How on your salary with a child can you possibly being paying your half for all these lavish and expensive vacations you want. You thought you found a sugar daddy, he didn't fall for it. You don't like him for who he is but for what you thought he could give you. That isn't happening. Move on.

Next time find someone who you like as a person versus how many houses they own and how much money they have in the bank.

Sandra1984 · 30/09/2022 10:40

You guys have very different values, money is a "means to an end" for you, something you earn in order to enjoy life (spa, nice restaurant etc...) while for him money is an "ends", he sacrifices his life just so he can have lots of money in the bank. At the end of life you will die happy having had a lot of fun and he will die the richest person in the cemetery having been a miser.Love is a very important (the most) part of life, he should be wanting to keep and pamper you as his partner, but he doesn't value love either, only values $$$. He'll only keep you if you turn into a miser like him. He will die alone and rich. What a miserable life.

Doesn't sound like this relationship is going to work for you mainly because of the different in values.

Rosehugger · 30/09/2022 10:33

YANBU. Tightness is very unattractive.

Goldbar · 30/09/2022 10:33

sheepdogdelight · 30/09/2022 10:30

Is he really tight? Or just he chooses to spend his money in different ways to you?

I'd rather go to a cheap Chinese buffet than a spa weekend, and would rather go camping than to an expensive hotel I prefer simple pleasures to spending lots of money (even if I can afford it). At this stage in your relationship, I'd want more emphasis on quality of time spent, than what we did.

And how would you feel if the other person disregarded your preferences the whole time and insisted on spa weekends and expensive holidays and never did what you wanted to do?

sheepdogdelight · 30/09/2022 10:30

Is he really tight? Or just he chooses to spend his money in different ways to you?

I'd rather go to a cheap Chinese buffet than a spa weekend, and would rather go camping than to an expensive hotel I prefer simple pleasures to spending lots of money (even if I can afford it). At this stage in your relationship, I'd want more emphasis on quality of time spent, than what we did.

Goldbar · 30/09/2022 10:29

Tigertigertigertiger · 30/09/2022 10:17

are there really men out there who want to go on spa days ?

My DH went on a few with me under sufferance before we had DC, because I wanted to. Tbh, it wouldn't be my first choice of activity these days and I'd prefer to go alone, but given the sports events I've attended with him and the shit movies I've sat though, him saying that he didn't want to come really wouldn't have impressed me much.

If one of you likes Chinese buffets and the other likes Michelin-starred restaurants, surely the answer (if you want the relationship to work) is to do a mix of both.

poetryandwine · 30/09/2022 10:28

OP,

I don’t think you sound like a gold digger but I think you and this guy sound wrong for each other. TBH he sounds sort of sad and lonely. He probably has been hurt in the past, but so what? That’s life.

You are young and full of life. You will find someone else. He may not, but that isn’t your problem.

Myotherdogsaballboy · 30/09/2022 10:25

I find tightness incredibly un attractive in people who are loaded. I’ve got a few in my life. Someone who bought their newborn GC a crappy used cardigan from a charity shop as a welcome to the world gift. She could have bought the entire contents of the shop and the building itself. I’ve a friend who is well meaning but will literally save every last penny, recycle Babyliss and Harding stuff she does like to close family for birthday/Christmas. Her house is worth at least half a million and she has a massive amount of savings but she wouldn’t dream of buying anyone anything nice or treat them just because she can. She will save every last penny when she does a supermarket shop and buy the most basic stuff. So many people have no choice other than to save every last penny and have to justify every single purchase. When people who are multi millionaires do it and seem to think it’s a great trait, it really irks me. I’d get out because this is an ingrained attitude and unlikely to change .