Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Mumsnet only tolerates a tiny age bracket for women to have children

164 replies

Crumpetandbutter · 29/09/2022 17:59

Teens - Forget it.

Twenties - No. You should be partying, travelling and living the high life, preferably in London.

Early thirties (30-32) you should be building your career.

32-35 - probably acceptable. Many feel 32/33 on the young side.

35-38 - just tolerated. Many feel 37/38 is on the old side.

38+ no. You will die, have a child with disabilities and really how selfish. (If you can have one at all, that is.)

Disclaimer, I think the above is bollocks.

Have a baby when you want to have one.

OP posts:
madasawethen · 30/09/2022 12:42

Not really.
There are women of all ages on here obviously. It's mumsnet!

IRL I've known from age 16 to mid 40s who have given birth.

I had mine fairly young and happy I did.

MarmeeMarch4 · 30/09/2022 12:40

I think you're wrong that most people think this way, but I definitely think these are stereotypes that exist out there for sure.

Also number of children:

0 - what the fuck are you thinking? You'll regret it forever. Where will you spend Christmas when you're old and alone? Your poor parents won't have grandkids. It is selfish.

1- you are selfish, and your kid will be selfish becaus they never learned to share.

2 - well done you. Though having any children is a drain on the planet's resources, so you probably shouldn't have done it.

3 - okay, so long as you only had two girls or two boys before. But a bit self-indulgent. Don't have any more.

4 + - any problems you have in life you brought on yourself by having too many children. You are not allowed to be tired/broke/struggling. If your kids are unhappy, it's because you put your own need for a baby before their needs as individuals. And also you are ruining the planet. You are selfish.

Glitteringapples · 30/09/2022 12:37

There definitely seems to be a contingent who are vocal about how awful it is to consider motherhood beyond your early 40’s. Im 50 with a two year old and couldn’t be happier! My bright, beautiful DD wants for nothing and is completely adored by both her ‘aged’ parents but according to some MNers we have ruined her life by having her so late!

Crunchingleaf · 30/09/2022 12:36

Some women are validating their own life choices in threads like these.
The truth is that there is no perfect or right time to have kids. You will always find a reason not to have kids at every stage.
My eldest was an unplanned pregnancy, I was early 20’s, bad relationship, career was entry level and no money. It was tough at the time, but other moms have kids at same age and it’s isn’t a tough for them as they are in different circumstances.
I am currently expecting number 3 in my late 30’s and had number 2 last year. My circumstances are drastically different money, partner, career. I would of preferred to have them younger but wasn’t in the position to. We all have different life experiences and make our decisions about when to have children accordingly.

SirenSays · 30/09/2022 12:29

I see this often. If you start a thread about pregnant teenager DD, most replies will be saying to abort.

EdgeOfACoin · 30/09/2022 12:22

Gosh, it's come to something when 40-year-olds are described as 'sprightly'. Blimey.

I'll get my Zimmer frame and cardi ready for when I'm 50!

TheBirdintheCave · 29/09/2022 23:52

@kitcat15 Some of us don't have a choice though. I met my husband at 29, married at 32 and then we had fertility problems. Our son wasn't born until I was 34 and now we've been trying for number two for nearly a year and are facing the same issues. In an ideal world I'd have two children and be done by now but that's just not how my life worked out. I still have plenty of energy at 36 by the way 🤷🏻‍♀️

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 29/09/2022 23:43

kitcat15 · 29/09/2022 23:06

I wouldn’t say ‘should’ but if you have a baby at 35 , you are going to be in well your 50s when before they are adults…… that wouldn’t bother some….I wouldn’t have liked it tho …..I preferred to do all my child rearing when I had the energy….I was 47 when my 3rd turned 18…..but that’s just my preference

Yeah, this. The problem is whilst many people feel like a perfectly healthy, sprightly 40 to 42 year old with the energy and gusto of a 20 year old, (so I can jolly well have a baby cause I'm full of energy, and bouncy like a little Labrador puppy,) they forget one salient piece of information...

The fact that in about 10 to 12 years time they will very likely be absolutely fucked energy wise, they will be menopausal, and are going to probably start to develop physical health problems. I'm sorry, but although some people say they are as healthy as a 17 year old in their mid to late 50s, (and older,) the fact is that most people will start to develop certain physical health problems when they pass the age of 50.

Who the bloody hell wants to be dealing with primary school aged children when they are in their mid to late 50s? And with teenagers when they're in their 60s?! And all the school politics, and general 'having young/school age children' bullshit.... Lots of expense, running them around everywhere, having to deal with bullying, tolerating and supporting all their hobbies and interests, never putting yourself first, and putting your own life - and what YOU want to do - on hold for another 2 decades.

Most people surely want to get to early 50s, and start having time to themselves and going travelling, or socialising a lot more, or just having lots of 'me time' or 'couple' time. You will also potentially have elderly parents to care for. Who wants to be looking after school age children, on top of elderly parents to care for when you're knocking the door of SIXTY? Nah fuck that.

RainingRubies · 29/09/2022 23:41

These threads crack me up. The average age of a first time mother in the UK nowis 31. So by objective definition, anybody around that age by a few years either way is pretty close to average. 36 would be slightly above average, 26 slightly below average (5 years either side). 41 would be quite a lot above average and 21 would be quite a lit below average. 16 would be a very young age and out of the ordinary, as would 46. For a first baby. Those are the objective facts on the stats, although it's obvious it will vary by region, circumstances, economic group etc as all things do.

But why does it matter? Why do you care when other people decide to have a family or think that they care when you do, or even if they do, why do you pay it any attention? Weird.

Moonshine5 · 29/09/2022 23:29

IME Mumsnet is an amazingly informed, supportive community - end of.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 29/09/2022 23:26

MattDamon · 29/09/2022 21:30

Agree, OP. There is an 'Am I too old to have a baby' thread every other week and when you open it, the OP is 37. 😑

I'm in London media type circles and almost every woman I know in her forties either recently had a baby (covid boom!) or is pregnant. One woman at work had three in her forties.

Shock I couldn't think of anything worse. 3 teenagers in your 60s! No thanks very much! Must be a sucker for punishment!

kitcat15 · 29/09/2022 23:06

EdgeOfACoin · 29/09/2022 19:17

Why should women stop having babies between 35 and 37?

I wouldn’t say ‘should’ but if you have a baby at 35 , you are going to be in well your 50s when before they are adults…… that wouldn’t bother some….I wouldn’t have liked it tho …..I preferred to do all my child rearing when I had the energy….I was 47 when my 3rd turned 18…..but that’s just my preference

ZenNudist · 29/09/2022 22:48

Don't talk rubbish, I'd say 18 through 44 about acceptable on here.

Patapouf · 29/09/2022 22:47

Hardly, I think Mumsnet is skewed to first time mum age of over 30 tbh.

Cuppasoupmonster · 29/09/2022 21:41

I don’t think there is a perfect age to have a baby as such, obviously the extremes of too young or too old come with the most significant risks. I think my only ‘please really think this through’ is people who have an only child in their 40s - I’ve not seen this play out well many times.

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 29/09/2022 21:39

I think 28-32 is an acceptable range for no 1 and 38 for subsequent blessings. Anything else is deviant.

Cuppasoupmonster · 29/09/2022 21:37

MattDamon · 29/09/2022 21:30

Agree, OP. There is an 'Am I too old to have a baby' thread every other week and when you open it, the OP is 37. 😑

I'm in London media type circles and almost every woman I know in her forties either recently had a baby (covid boom!) or is pregnant. One woman at work had three in her forties.

But 37 is quite old to be having a baby, biologically. And the majority of women wouldn’t be able to have 3 babies in their 40s.

I find the false hope given on here to be quite cruel at times. You get a 45 year old asking if they’re mad to ttc and posters are all ‘go for it, my nan had a baby at 49, it definitely can happen’ etc. Meanwhile I’m reading it shaking my head knowing the likelihood of conceiving and having a healthy baby at 45 is probably close to zero.

StarWitness · 29/09/2022 21:33

But why are women asking ‘am I too old?’. It’s weird. It’s just inviting a whole load of strangers to troll you from behind their screens. If you want to have a baby at 40, just fucking do it. Yes, you’re an older mother. It’s just a fact.

MattDamon · 29/09/2022 21:30

Agree, OP. There is an 'Am I too old to have a baby' thread every other week and when you open it, the OP is 37. 😑

I'm in London media type circles and almost every woman I know in her forties either recently had a baby (covid boom!) or is pregnant. One woman at work had three in her forties.

Cuppasoupmonster · 29/09/2022 20:41

YANBU.

Mid to late 30s is seen as the ‘acceptable age’ on here. Lots of slagging off of young mums, but say anything about older mums and you’re a nasty goady bully.

What I don’t get is when people say ‘Oh I would’ve HATED to have kids in my 20s, why would I want to be changing nappies and cleaning up sick when I could’ve been partying and building my amazing career?’

Well if having kids is that awful, why did you then give up the partying and amazing career to do it Confused

roarfeckingroarr · 29/09/2022 20:36

Although I'm amused that I'm at the height of the respectable age to procreate, having my babies at 32 and 34!

roarfeckingroarr · 29/09/2022 20:35

I think you're exaggerating.

Does anyone think a child in your teens is a great idea?

Often posters are worrying about conceiving in their 20s and they're often advised to not worry or rush. That's different to think it's not acceptable!

Older mothers aren't criticised IME.

chatterbug22 · 29/09/2022 19:49

YANBU.

Personally I think dependent on circumstances 20-40 is fine. Many wouldn’t choose either 20 or 40, but for those who do it can also work out quite nicely.

I think people should do what they want, advantages and disadvantages to both. You could be 30 with your ducks in a row and anything can change at any given moment, you don’t know what’s round the corner.

candycaneframe · 29/09/2022 19:45

Nah there is definitely a sweet spot

28-35 seems to be accepted

Meili04 · 29/09/2022 19:40

I had DD when I was 20 😂😂 Mumsnet cardinal sin we now have a household income of 150k. So definitely did not fuck my life up.