Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Mumsnet only tolerates a tiny age bracket for women to have children

164 replies

Crumpetandbutter · 29/09/2022 17:59

Teens - Forget it.

Twenties - No. You should be partying, travelling and living the high life, preferably in London.

Early thirties (30-32) you should be building your career.

32-35 - probably acceptable. Many feel 32/33 on the young side.

35-38 - just tolerated. Many feel 37/38 is on the old side.

38+ no. You will die, have a child with disabilities and really how selfish. (If you can have one at all, that is.)

Disclaimer, I think the above is bollocks.

Have a baby when you want to have one.

OP posts:
Crumpetandbutter · 30/09/2022 14:43

@FlorettaB so really it can be summed up with People Do Things I Personally Would Not - at both ends of the age extremes!

Personally I wouldn’t have wanted a baby at 18. I would have been lonely and isolated and miserable. I also wouldn’t want a 24 year old now I’m 42. I’m enjoying having a small child around the place.

But (and this isn’t aimed at you personally) it’s unbelievably pompous and irritating to be lectured about why you’ve lived your life all wrong by someone who isn’t living it.

OP posts:
Jayne35 · 30/09/2022 14:39

As I was peri menopausal by age 32 I am glad I had my children in my early 20s.

FlorettaB · 30/09/2022 14:37

I don’t doubt that 18 year olds can be great parents and go on to have successful careers. It’s that they’re taking on the responsibility of being parents when they’re so young. Yes, their children will be grown before they hit 40 but you’re only young once.

Crumpetandbutter · 30/09/2022 14:33

FlorettaB · 30/09/2022 14:29

Not at 23 but at 18?

It is a shame @Ylvamoon but I’d rather have my son and know him and experience motherhood than not. And I think he’d rather be alive than not born at all. I hope, anyway.

@FlorettaB i don’t think eighteen year olds having babies are insane. I suspect the majority aren’t planned but I know a fair few who have done just fine, and life ends up looking different but not necessarily worse. I know on here your late teens and twenties are supposed to be all about parties and travel, but mine certainly weren’t. I look at photos from some of my friends and their eighteenth and twenty firsts were celebrated with family and friends and lots of laughing and fun. I can’t say the same for mine, baby or no baby. Life’s what you make it and all that.

OP posts:
Ylvamoon · 30/09/2022 14:30

Have your family when it's right for you.

I am only a little bit judgmental for people who have their first at 40+... but this is because my dad was nearly 50 when I was born... he never met his grandchildren and I think it's sad because he would have made a gret grandad.

FlorettaB · 30/09/2022 14:29

Not at 23 but at 18?

Kennykenkencat · 30/09/2022 14:28

EmeraldShamrock1 · 30/09/2022 14:11

Friend’s dc was only just starting reception when she was 50.
For a planned pregnancy through choice no infertility issues that is madness no matter how much money you have.

Why?

Planned pregnancy, no infertility issues

Friend really wanted another child, she and her Dh are fit and healthy They have a good income and she looked way younger than half the mums at the school gate and was probably healthier and fitter than nearly all of them.

I also know someone who had years of ivf and at 49 decided to stop. Went on a long holiday to come to terms with the fact that they were never going to be parents and a few weeks later found out she was pregnant. Perfectly healthy baby at 50

RedWingBoots · 30/09/2022 14:28

JunebuginDecember · 30/09/2022 14:19

I honestly think age matters very little when you consider all the other aspects of choosing the correct time to get pregnant.

For example I think a 40 year old in good health, a stable and loving relationship and who has a good career is probably better suited to becoming a mum than a 28 year old with a rubbish financial situation and an 'on again off again' relationship status....

Your individual readiness to enter motherhood matters more than age.

Even then you can't judge.

Some people on paper look like they would be a good parent but reality shows otherwise.

Crumpetandbutter · 30/09/2022 14:25

@FlorettaB , I had my first and thus far only child at 40. I don’t think anyone who had theirs at say 23 is ‘insane’, funnily enough.I think … they had a baby at 23. That is about the beginning and the end of my thoughts on the matter.

I might have judged once, but I’ve grown up since school days and I know many awful mothers of all ages and many fantastic ones of all ages, too. And there tend to be reasons as to why people have their first child at the age they did which stretch further than class, although education levels come into it I suppose.

OP posts:
RedWingBoots · 30/09/2022 14:25

WhatNoRaisins · 30/09/2022 14:23

For me a peak MN moment was a thread about the struggles of holiday childcare where it was said that you shouldn't even TTC until you've researched holiday club availability in your local area.

😂😂

Like childcare providers don't close and open every year.

WhatNoRaisins · 30/09/2022 14:23

For me a peak MN moment was a thread about the struggles of holiday childcare where it was said that you shouldn't even TTC until you've researched holiday club availability in your local area.

Crumpetandbutter · 30/09/2022 14:23

@Noviembre , a girl I went to school with (a few years younger) had an unplanned pregnancy at 16, had the baby at 17. She always was quite an old head on young shoulders and she and her partner married at 18 and decided to have their family as young parents, so started TTC and she had twins at 19! He worked, she stayed at home until they were all at school and then she went to university. She trained as a midwife actually Grin

She was a great mum, very loving and kind, had lots of support from their wider families who were all still young and I think it worked really well for them. It’s funny as she’s now in her late 30s with young adult children and she must have enjoyed it as she’s pregnant again! She’s still with her husband, too.

OP posts:
FlorettaB · 30/09/2022 14:22

MN isn’t homogenous. There’s more than one group. In part it’s a class thing.

I know girls who became pregnant as teenagers but I don’t know any who chose to continue their pregnancy. The norm in my group of friends and acquaintances is to have children from around 30+. Having children at 40-45 seems totally reasonable to me.

For those who, along with the rest of the people they know, have children in their teens or early 20s, 40+ must seem old to be having babies. They may well be grandmothers at 40-45 years old.

So if you post about having a baby at 18 or at 40 you’ll get people from each group thinking, ‘That’s insane!’

Kennykenkencat · 30/09/2022 14:21

Also I pretty much sailed through menopause with regard to hot flashes.

i am vegetarian/vegan and eat a lot of soya so not everyone has problems with temperature

I also don’t have elderly parents and dh’s parents were active right up to their late 80s when fil died of cancer and mil mid 90s when she died this year. In her 80s after fil passed mil was playing bridge and going on cruises with her younger man friend (late 70s)

Just because you get old doesn’t mean you automatically get ill. The food you eat, what you drink, exercise and less stress all count towards helping you stay fit.

JunebuginDecember · 30/09/2022 14:19

I honestly think age matters very little when you consider all the other aspects of choosing the correct time to get pregnant.

For example I think a 40 year old in good health, a stable and loving relationship and who has a good career is probably better suited to becoming a mum than a 28 year old with a rubbish financial situation and an 'on again off again' relationship status....

Your individual readiness to enter motherhood matters more than age.

TheHoover · 30/09/2022 14:16

Haven’t seen much solid reasoning against being an older mum on here. Just a load of judgement, which MN is full of. Reasons for having your kids older can include:

  • Finding the right partner later in life (much better than having kids in a shit relationship that then breaks up)
  • financial security
  • being very well adjusted mentally (might be a personal thing but I was a bit of a fuck-head until I reached late-30s)
  • no resentment at missing out on travel, culture, partying etc
  • really wanting to have a child and committing fully to everything that requires
I’m basically really happy with everything and am a WAY better parent than I would have been when I was 10yrs younger. I’m not saying this is better for everyone at all and I have no judgement for whenever you have your baby. Just sticking my middle finger up to anyone who thinks what I am doing is wrong (unless you work in obstetrics).
Noviembre · 30/09/2022 14:15

By starting work at 16 and by remaining in work throughout uni, I was in a great career and in a new house by 25. Great time to have kids. SAHM then was back in work by 35. Being a younger parent means having more energy and I seem to enjoy parenthood more than it is fashionable to admit. I don't know why others whinge about it so much.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 30/09/2022 14:11

Friend’s dc was only just starting reception when she was 50.
For a planned pregnancy through choice no infertility issues that is madness no matter how much money you have.

Kennykenkencat · 30/09/2022 14:08

Cuppasoupmonster · 29/09/2022 21:37

But 37 is quite old to be having a baby, biologically. And the majority of women wouldn’t be able to have 3 babies in their 40s.

I find the false hope given on here to be quite cruel at times. You get a 45 year old asking if they’re mad to ttc and posters are all ‘go for it, my nan had a baby at 49, it definitely can happen’ etc. Meanwhile I’m reading it shaking my head knowing the likelihood of conceiving and having a healthy baby at 45 is probably close to zero.

I know a few people who had perfectly healthy babies at 45+

Of course it is possible if you are physically and mentally fit and all your bits are in working order. Why not go for it.

If nothing happens then at least you tried.

The parents I know who had children with additional needs were all in their 20s/early 30s

Crumpetandbutter · 30/09/2022 14:05

Lol at 50 being old.

OP posts:
Kennykenkencat · 30/09/2022 14:02

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 29/09/2022 23:43

Yeah, this. The problem is whilst many people feel like a perfectly healthy, sprightly 40 to 42 year old with the energy and gusto of a 20 year old, (so I can jolly well have a baby cause I'm full of energy, and bouncy like a little Labrador puppy,) they forget one salient piece of information...

The fact that in about 10 to 12 years time they will very likely be absolutely fucked energy wise, they will be menopausal, and are going to probably start to develop physical health problems. I'm sorry, but although some people say they are as healthy as a 17 year old in their mid to late 50s, (and older,) the fact is that most people will start to develop certain physical health problems when they pass the age of 50.

Who the bloody hell wants to be dealing with primary school aged children when they are in their mid to late 50s? And with teenagers when they're in their 60s?! And all the school politics, and general 'having young/school age children' bullshit.... Lots of expense, running them around everywhere, having to deal with bullying, tolerating and supporting all their hobbies and interests, never putting yourself first, and putting your own life - and what YOU want to do - on hold for another 2 decades.

Most people surely want to get to early 50s, and start having time to themselves and going travelling, or socialising a lot more, or just having lots of 'me time' or 'couple' time. You will also potentially have elderly parents to care for. Who wants to be looking after school age children, on top of elderly parents to care for when you're knocking the door of SIXTY? Nah fuck that.

You forget that for a lot of people who didn’t have children till there late 30s/40s have spent the previous 2 decades climbing the career ladder, travelling and generally having no responsibility so don’t come at parenting in their late 30s/40s with a jaded attitude.
I had one at primary school and 1 who had just started senior school at the age of 50.
I am in my 60s now and am physically as fit or fitter that some people who are younger than me. I do a very physically demanding job, I drive a big van. (I have a HGV licence) Today I loaded a load of rubble from the floor screed I took up into my car and took it down the tip and managed to do 2 trips before being stopped for the day.
I am removing a false ceiling this afternoon and will be plastering a wall going into the evening time.

How many 20/30/40/50 year olds will be doing that.

Just because you are knackered doesn’t mean others are the same.

Friend’s dc was only just starting reception when she was 50.

She is a marathon runner.

Life would get very boring if everyone had to start winding down at 50.
You could have another 50 years to go. There is only so much winding down you can do. Especially if you are pinging off the walls and your mind is active.

LuciaPopp · 30/09/2022 13:57

I definitely think MN is down on older mums. Every time someone posts to ask whether they should TTC at 40+, there are endless comments about how cruel it is to impose an old mum on your child, as if it's so dreadful to have an older mum that it's literally better not to have been born. Also a load of ageist and ableist stuff which, taken to it's logical conclusion, would suggest that noone with any sort of health condition or disability should be having kids either 🙄

JOFFCV · 30/09/2022 13:52

ErrolTheDragon · 30/09/2022 13:47

You're not going to be one of those people who get old before their time are you?

seems like you're one of those people who doesn't understand sarcasm.Grin

Oh sorry 😂.

I have the most sarcastic Husband ever, so don't know how I missed that.

ErrolTheDragon · 30/09/2022 13:50

(Mind you, cardis at 50ish is a real thing because one thing the menopause can do is muck up your temperature regulation a bit. Has very little to do with one's ability to parent youngsters though, apart from teenage DD sometimes nicking mine)

EmeraldShamrock1 · 30/09/2022 13:47

It's a class thing. 😅

Swipe left for the next trending thread