Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Mumsnet only tolerates a tiny age bracket for women to have children

164 replies

Crumpetandbutter · 29/09/2022 17:59

Teens - Forget it.

Twenties - No. You should be partying, travelling and living the high life, preferably in London.

Early thirties (30-32) you should be building your career.

32-35 - probably acceptable. Many feel 32/33 on the young side.

35-38 - just tolerated. Many feel 37/38 is on the old side.

38+ no. You will die, have a child with disabilities and really how selfish. (If you can have one at all, that is.)

Disclaimer, I think the above is bollocks.

Have a baby when you want to have one.

OP posts:
JunebuginDecember · 30/09/2022 20:19

LuciferRising · 30/09/2022 18:14

*The healthier and fitter part is probably not true.

Many 40 y.o believe they're healthier and fitter because they look good.*

Give over. Have you see how fit and healthy our society is? If you are bringing health and fitness into, so many people would fail. I'd hazardous a guess that age related issues are less of a concern than lifestyle related issues which can leave parents unable to retain energy at a younger age.

Fully agree with this. These days rubbish lifestyles tend to cause problems more than age...

Jayne35 · 30/09/2022 20:03

My parents worked full time until they were in their mid 60s. They wouldn’t have been able to do any school runs!

My dad retired at 65 and he had my DCs every afternoon while I worked (DM was still working ft as she is a lot younger). I think 60-70 year old GPS are fine with little ones but had I waited, my Dad would have not met them as he died at 70, sadly. For me 20s was the best time but I didn’t have a career as such to consider.

I don’t judge anyone for their age having children (I have quite a few friends who were 16/17). The only thing that does stand out for me is a friend I had in junior school, she was never allowed allowed friends in as her 75 dad couldn’t cope with it, which I thought was sad.

LuciferRising · 30/09/2022 18:14

*The healthier and fitter part is probably not true.

Many 40 y.o believe they're healthier and fitter because they look good.*

Give over. Have you see how fit and healthy our society is? If you are bringing health and fitness into, so many people would fail. I'd hazardous a guess that age related issues are less of a concern than lifestyle related issues which can leave parents unable to retain energy at a younger age.

OceanbreezeSun · 30/09/2022 16:18

I had my dd at 33 and ds no2 is due when I will have not long turned 37.

I’ve never had any comments, good or bad, about age irl.
It’s only on MN that I read comments about mothers ‘being way too old’ or ‘far too young’

Everybody has their own experiences and opinions. I personally never even considered having kids before the age of 30. I wasn’t ready, even at 30, despite being in a happy , stable long term relationship (with my now dh)

The majority of my friends through uni/work started having their first around 32/33 too, with a 2nd dc 2/3 years later, so it just seems ‘normal’ to me.

I think a pp poster summed it up well
‘Your individual readiness to enter motherhood matters more than age’

Crumpetandbutter · 30/09/2022 16:15

Fimofriend · 30/09/2022 15:33

I find it to be incredibly sexist to claim that Mumsnet is a hive mind. As if women cannot have individual opinions but rather need someone to tell them what their opinions are.

Dear OP, you need to deal with your internalized misogyny because we get enough of that crap from men.

There are general consensus’ on here. That’s not internalised misogyny, any more than it’s internalised racism to say the British are good at queueing or whatever.

Start a thread about dressing a baby boy in blue or a girl in pink and you’ll be told you’re BU. Brave / stupid enough to say trans women are women and you’ll get your arse handed to you. (BTW I don’t believe TWAW - sorry.) Start a thread in the doghouse about what breed of dog to get and half the responses will tell you you’re not worthy to have a dog at all and the other half will tell you to get a retired greyhound.

Of course all the above will have exceptions but threads do tend to go a particular way and it is a bit stupid to say that’s internalised misogyny!

OP posts:
SemperIdem · 30/09/2022 16:08

I think having children in your 20’s is becoming less usual and having them in your late 30’s/40’s more usual depending on demographic.

I had my daughter at 26 and am very much now a “younger parent” at pick up.

The demographic on Mumsnet was at one point skewed towards older, professionals but I think it less so in recent years.

MintJulia · 30/09/2022 15:34

Yanbu the ageism on here is laughable.

out of the seven females in our family who have children at the moment, 1 was 19 and the others were all 38 or older when they gave birth to 11 babies between us.

Not a problem with any of them. No-one is traumatised, or seen a parent die. No issues with bullying or embarrassment at having an 'older' mum. It's just a total non-issue.
No physical issues with the mums either beyond feeling a bit tired.

Fimofriend · 30/09/2022 15:33

I find it to be incredibly sexist to claim that Mumsnet is a hive mind. As if women cannot have individual opinions but rather need someone to tell them what their opinions are.

Dear OP, you need to deal with your internalized misogyny because we get enough of that crap from men.

FromageRouge · 30/09/2022 15:32

dinosaurcookie · 30/09/2022 15:26

Thanks @FromageRouge. I'm in shock at the moment, has convinced myself I couldn't get pregnant! Turns out I was wrong😅

Wow. Have you just found out today?

Crumpetandbutter · 30/09/2022 15:31

Congratulations!

OP posts:
wannabeamemmysobad · 30/09/2022 15:29

@EmeraldShamrock1 that's your experience. In mine however I had DD at 35 . My DM is 55 and works FT, DMIL is in her 70s and retired. It's DMIL that is the most active on the floor with DD.

DM had me young and has no energy because raising kids as a single mum is tiring. DMIL is very MC, had kids in her 40s after getting to the top of her game and meeting DFIL.

dinosaurcookie · 30/09/2022 15:26

Thanks @FromageRouge. I'm in shock at the moment, has convinced myself I couldn't get pregnant! Turns out I was wrong😅

FromageRouge · 30/09/2022 15:23

Congratulations @dinosaurcookie !

dinosaurcookie · 30/09/2022 15:21

Blimey. Well to really stir the pot I've just found out I'm pregnant at 40 with my first...

TheHoover · 30/09/2022 15:16

Sorry should qualify that I am sad for anyone who has people judging and pointing their fingers at their choices.

FlorettaB · 30/09/2022 15:15

’Despite what people might believe there's very few 80's helping with the school run or kicking a ball with DGC.’

My parents worked full time until they were in their mid 60s. They wouldn’t have been able to do any school runs!

TheHoover · 30/09/2022 15:14

So there should be a fitness test for parenting?

I’m guessing a fuck ton of judgement is also piled on to disabled parents. I know this does happen but it makes me very sad.

Mamai90 · 30/09/2022 15:13

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 29/09/2022 23:43

Yeah, this. The problem is whilst many people feel like a perfectly healthy, sprightly 40 to 42 year old with the energy and gusto of a 20 year old, (so I can jolly well have a baby cause I'm full of energy, and bouncy like a little Labrador puppy,) they forget one salient piece of information...

The fact that in about 10 to 12 years time they will very likely be absolutely fucked energy wise, they will be menopausal, and are going to probably start to develop physical health problems. I'm sorry, but although some people say they are as healthy as a 17 year old in their mid to late 50s, (and older,) the fact is that most people will start to develop certain physical health problems when they pass the age of 50.

Who the bloody hell wants to be dealing with primary school aged children when they are in their mid to late 50s? And with teenagers when they're in their 60s?! And all the school politics, and general 'having young/school age children' bullshit.... Lots of expense, running them around everywhere, having to deal with bullying, tolerating and supporting all their hobbies and interests, never putting yourself first, and putting your own life - and what YOU want to do - on hold for another 2 decades.

Most people surely want to get to early 50s, and start having time to themselves and going travelling, or socialising a lot more, or just having lots of 'me time' or 'couple' time. You will also potentially have elderly parents to care for. Who wants to be looking after school age children, on top of elderly parents to care for when you're knocking the door of SIXTY? Nah fuck that.

Some people don't have the choice though. I suffered infertility all through my 30s, failed ivf etc. Then just as I was turning 39 I found myself pregnant. Ideally I would have been younger, I'd love to have had my daughter in my early 30s but I couldn't. These threads make women like me feel like shit. Though my mother was 37 when I was born and she's 77 and goes jogging and teaches yoga but I do worry she's the exception. Im hoping though I at least have good genes on my side. My grandmother was 40 when she had my dad and lived til 90 without any major health issues.

I definitely don't feel like a lab puppy, I'm fucking knackered.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 30/09/2022 15:07

Friend really wanted another child, she and her Dh are fit and healthy They have a good income and she looked way younger than half the mums at the school gate and was probably healthier and fitter than nearly all of them.
The healthier and fitter part is probably not true.

Many 40 y.o believe they're healthier and fitter because they look good.

My friends were aghast when I disagreed 40 is the new 30.

Leaving it late is also ruling out DGP relationships for the DC and when they're adults if they also choose to wait until 40 they're DC will miss out on the relationship too.

Despite what people might believe there's very few 80's helping with the school run or kicking a ball with DGC.

whatthejuice · 30/09/2022 15:07

I got pregnant at 31 and 34 because it was right for me! Why compare yourself to other people?
And in any case, I know so many people who have had fertility issues, I felt very blessed to have two healthy children.

hellosunshineagainxxx · 30/09/2022 15:06

I was first out if my friends and was 28. 32 with my second and most friends have had kids now. Never felt too young to have kids by anyone on here

Mamai90 · 30/09/2022 15:03

LemonDrop22 · 29/09/2022 18:44

This.

Ive mostly lived on the border between NI and ROI and until this generation - religious influences meant very large numbers of women had kids until they couldn't any more - early 40s for most, mid 40s for some.

I'm Irish and my grandmother had her first at 23 and last at 45. 10 children in all. She was 40 when she had my dad and lived til she was 90. So many women had babies later in life, certainly here anyway, MIL was the last of 8 and her mother was 41 when she was born and she's 94 and still with us.

Crunchingleaf · 30/09/2022 15:03

LuciaPopp · 30/09/2022 13:57

I definitely think MN is down on older mums. Every time someone posts to ask whether they should TTC at 40+, there are endless comments about how cruel it is to impose an old mum on your child, as if it's so dreadful to have an older mum that it's literally better not to have been born. Also a load of ageist and ableist stuff which, taken to it's logical conclusion, would suggest that noone with any sort of health condition or disability should be having kids either 🙄

I think it’s reasonable to consider the future as well as the present when deciding to have a child.
Your fertility declines with age, your chances of having a child with disabilities increases (it can happen at any age but still more likely the older you are), more likely to have pregnancy complications with age. It’s up to an individual or a couple to decide what is right for them.
You mention being ableist, which reminds me of a friend I had as a teenager who had a few siblings close in age. The mother had a serious degenerative condition and the parents went on to have another baby. The pregnancy worsened the mothers condition. My friend was furious at her parents for deciding to have another baby. The teenagers became the ones who were expected to go to school, come home take over with the baby, housework, dinner and then their own homework. My friend and the older siblings all moved far away for university because it was only way of having their own independent lives. I can definitely see my friends perspective here and I don’t think she was being ableist. None of us can predict the future, life certainly throws us curveballs. We make decisions and hope it works out for the best.These decisions aren’t always easy and sometimes we don’t meet someone until we are older.

Crumpetandbutter · 30/09/2022 14:56

Perhaps for some people. I have friends from many different backgrounds.

OP posts:
FlorettaB · 30/09/2022 14:52

’so really it can be summed up with People Do Things I Personally Would Not - at both ends of the age extreme’

Yes! More than that though it’s about how we tend to surround ourselves with/be surrounded by people who reaffirm those views by making the same choices.

Swipe left for the next trending thread