Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I'm actually pleased with the mini-budget

241 replies

yubgummy · 29/09/2022 14:35

(Cue hysterical shrieking ;) )

Macroeconomics is complex. It surprises me that within a week, there's such a strong consensus that everything about the mini-budget is literally the work of the devil. Echo chamber...

The UK basically has never recovered from the GFC and has just been stagnant and struggling for a decade. The clear theme in this budget is encouraging people to actually get out and DO something ("supply-side reform"). Tax incentives for businesses to invest in plant & machinery, reducing red tape for infrastructure investment (more North Sea licences, more onshore wind), tax cuts to base rate & NI to encourage people into work...

I would like to see more action on interest rates from the BoE, and I would like to see more detail on the Planning & Infrastructure Bill, but I want to give them a chance instead of calling for yet another change in government. Supply-side reform is a perfectly sane strategy and the UK economy does need to get moving, by which I mean, producing new and useful goods and services not just keeping the whole country on life support.

OP posts:
ilovesooty · 29/09/2022 15:51

Quitelikeit · 29/09/2022 15:16

Gosh some people on here are not capable of a sensible debate.

you can’t argue with stupid op so you are wasting your time

So everyone critical of this mini budget is stupid?

noblegiraffe · 29/09/2022 15:49

Tadpoll · 29/09/2022 15:43

I think that’s the point. OP is looking at a bigger picture, while everyone else is looking at their own personal circumstances.

I’m assuming that the OP is capable of looking at the ‘bigger picture’ because they’re not worried that they might lose their house.

Shame on those fixating on personal circumstances like that, eh?

BloobryMuffin · 29/09/2022 15:48

yubgummy · 29/09/2022 14:52

@Igmum how would you have structured the tax incentives?

Which of Kwasi's tax announcements would you have changed?

I would’ve left rates and increased thresholds so that those on minimum wage (full time) pay no income tax or NICs, moved up the 40% banding start to c£80k to encourage spending by the “ squeezed middle “.

The majority of £150k+ earners accumulate cash, reducing 45% band will encourage them to accumulate - not spend - more.

I’d have kept all his business tax changes though (other than employer NIC reduction).

My budget would’ve been more expensive than Kwasi’s, I imagine, but it would have done better to encourage the desired behaviours.

Tadpoll · 29/09/2022 15:43

noblegiraffe · 29/09/2022 15:30

OP do you have a fixed rate for your mortgage that’s up for renewal soon? Or a pension that you’re about to start to collect?

If not, would you still be happy with the mini budget if you did?

I think that’s the point. OP is looking at a bigger picture, while everyone else is looking at their own personal circumstances.

Tadpoll · 29/09/2022 15:41

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

This is so offensive.

andymary · 29/09/2022 15:39

100% agree with you OP.

I honestly have no idea why everyone is saying it's bad... unless you're on benefits - because then you're not getting any increases.

But for working class people, they're getting more money in their pockets from their wages in November with the National Insurance cut, and then even more in April from the Tax cut - how is this not a good thing?
Do you know what this then leads to? People spending more money at shops, meaning employment goes up, businesses are making more money, businesses can afford to pay their staff more, the government makes more in tax/VAT, the economy goes up. It's a big circle.

Plus, a much better deal on stamp duty, which is only going to promote the buying and selling of more houses, making the fees lower for those who need to upgrade, and potentially continuing the rise in house prices due to the constant buying demand. It also means a lower LTV for everyone whom already has a mortgage, potentially reducing their interest % when remortgaging.

Everyone saying "OMG look what the budget did to the GBP" - the £ has been dropping steadily for the last 12 months, check the graphs. It had already dropped approx 22% in the last 12 months. 18% of which was BEFORE the mini budget. So really, the GBP only dropped 4% following the mini budget.

Couldyounot · 29/09/2022 15:30

Trying to dodge OBR scrutiny seems to have been a big problem here. Makes you look like you've not done the sums and are trying to blag it.

noblegiraffe · 29/09/2022 15:30

OP do you have a fixed rate for your mortgage that’s up for renewal soon? Or a pension that you’re about to start to collect?

If not, would you still be happy with the mini budget if you did?

Havanananana · 29/09/2022 15:29

As far as I can make out, Truss believes that:

To encourage the already rich, you have to pay them more.
To encourage the already poor, you have to threaten to make them poorer.

As for cutting taxes to promote investment, here is what Badenoch told American investors yesterday:

The Trade Secretary was set to show Britain's attractiveness to US investors by stressing that corporation tax would be kept at the lowest in the G20, at 19 per cent.
She was emphasising that level is "not cutting … keeping".

So she's admitting that even though the UK already has the lowest rate of Corporation Tax in the G20, this has not been sufficient to attract internal or international investment. Why would that be? Because the UK has put up barriers to trade with the largest, wealthiest and most standardised market on the planet - located just 22 miles away? Because UK infrastructure is crumbling after 50 years of neglect? Because the overseas investors can't see how the UK is any more attractive than so many other places, as it is lacking skilled labour, affordable housing, a health service that is on the point of collapse. Not forgetting a government that does not keep it's promises or even abide by international agreements, with a justice secretary, a qualified lawyer, who believes that it is alright to break international law in a specific and limited way?

ArcticSkewer · 29/09/2022 15:29

Don't remember being asked at a ballot box if I was up for gambling away my money to make some overseas asset strippers rich (er).

I'm pretty sure I would have declined the 'opportunity'

CPL593H · 29/09/2022 15:26

www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/blog/kwasi-kwartengs-new-era-economic-policy-major-gamble

This bunch think it's a big gamble at best. We should never forget whose money they're gambling with.

Rottenapples · 29/09/2022 15:26

It’s really shit to respond to OPs attempt at reasoned debate with comments like ‘are you off your meds’ and that Jesus crap.

For what it’s worth, there are sound economic arguments for policies such as these. However, it is a very big risk and the budget being in costed is a problem.

And before anyone shouts me down, my politics are left wing, I never have and never will vote Tory. However, I am a qualified economist (PhD) and have been working in government as an economist for the last 10 years.

Discodreams · 29/09/2022 15:24

I think it could be good if the current economic climate wasn’t so difficult already. If inflation was stagnating, interest rates were low and we weren’t booming then sure, encouraging the wealthy to invest more could be a not terrible policy. So maybe, say, 5 years ago this may work.
But now? whilst inflation is out of control and interest rates are rising quicker then expected, the cost of fuel and therefore food etc is rising with unprecedented speed - erm terrible policy!! No one is going to invest right now, it’s all about buckle up, hold on to your hats and brace yourself for a bumpy ride. Keep hold of every penny you can because the future is suddenly very uncertain.

I think the fact that every expert has had to come out and criticise the plan just goes to show how truely awful it is. I just hope those that back Truss instead of Sunak are content with this on their conscience

PacificState · 29/09/2022 15:21

It's so bloody cathartic to see Truss's supporters railing against the media/the IMF/the heft of the financial markets/the imperfectly-informed perspective of ordinary voters. Given that these were exactly the same factors that they gleefully used to turf out Gordon Brown and justify austerity using a bunch of extremely contentious economic arguments.

I never actually expected this day to come but boy, am I enjoying it. Live by the sword, die by the sword.

neverbeenskiing · 29/09/2022 15:20

I agree that OP's take on this makes no sense but can we please stop with all the "time for your meds", "proof the drugs don't work" type comments? As someone who lives with an actual Mental Illness it's not great seeing it used as a jokey insult. Also even those of us who are actually mentally ill and take meds can see that this mini budget was a total and utter disgrace so I'd rather not be lumped in with the OP, thanks! 😂

Hbh17 · 29/09/2022 15:20

Interest rates have been too low for a very long time, & we probably need a housing crash to bring prices down, so OP is not unreasonable.
Also, the economic situation was very similar in the early 1980s, & we went on to have a strong economy for most of the decade, so the current hysteria is probably a bit misplaced.
The reality is that everything will shake out eventually - history tells us that, at least.

Quitelikeit · 29/09/2022 15:16

Gosh some people on here are not capable of a sensible debate.

you can’t argue with stupid op so you are wasting your time

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 29/09/2022 15:15

😂

notdaddycool · 29/09/2022 15:13

Whilst I think there is a chance this could go better than expected, I'm not convinced and I wish we weren't doing this.

Igmum · 29/09/2022 15:12

Tax incentives for investment - particularly upskilling/reskilling and active changes to job design. A fair few others but that will do for now. HTH

the80sweregreat · 29/09/2022 15:07

Blaming the lockdowns is pretty crass.
Who signed off the lockdowns? Who came up with furlough ?
The government could have said no to any of it and not done what the other countries were doing. They made a choice , but they also threw money at their friends for test and trace and the ppe. A lot of people cashed in who should not have done. Why isn't this ever mentioned?
If the NHS had been properly funded years before maybe they might not have had to lockdown. Even Boris Johnson admitted this in March 2020. Or maybe not for as long.
He even ended up in hospital with it. What were they meant to do ? Honestly ?
I'm the first to criticize, but people saying about lockdown is a lost cause. It was a pandemic , a war footing and decisions had to be made to stop the health care system collapsing.

FluffySocksAndHotChocolate · 29/09/2022 15:07

Yes it's fantastic, it's the death of the selfish bastard tories ever being in power in our life times again.

Iwantmyoldnameback · 29/09/2022 15:04

I agree it's brilliant. It hastens the end of this corrupt, deceitful, useless, self serving, bunch of charlatans.

Abhannmor · 29/09/2022 15:01

yubgummy · 29/09/2022 14:35

(Cue hysterical shrieking ;) )

Macroeconomics is complex. It surprises me that within a week, there's such a strong consensus that everything about the mini-budget is literally the work of the devil. Echo chamber...

The UK basically has never recovered from the GFC and has just been stagnant and struggling for a decade. The clear theme in this budget is encouraging people to actually get out and DO something ("supply-side reform"). Tax incentives for businesses to invest in plant & machinery, reducing red tape for infrastructure investment (more North Sea licences, more onshore wind), tax cuts to base rate & NI to encourage people into work...

I would like to see more action on interest rates from the BoE, and I would like to see more detail on the Planning & Infrastructure Bill, but I want to give them a chance instead of calling for yet another change in government. Supply-side reform is a perfectly sane strategy and the UK economy does need to get moving, by which I mean, producing new and useful goods and services not just keeping the whole country on life support.

Hi Liz. It's an interesting budget. The markets hate it. Maybe your mate Kwasi is a secret Marxist.

Agree another change of government would be daft. This one has only been at the job for 12 years for heavens sake. Just a blink really. Give it another 10 I say!

DuncinToffee · 29/09/2022 14:57

You got the briefing then OP?

twitter.com/adampayne26/status/1575459881301278721?t=8ztZ_ab4c8OLJlV1KmPL1Q&s=19

Swipe left for the next trending thread