Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I'm actually pleased with the mini-budget

241 replies

yubgummy · 29/09/2022 14:35

(Cue hysterical shrieking ;) )

Macroeconomics is complex. It surprises me that within a week, there's such a strong consensus that everything about the mini-budget is literally the work of the devil. Echo chamber...

The UK basically has never recovered from the GFC and has just been stagnant and struggling for a decade. The clear theme in this budget is encouraging people to actually get out and DO something ("supply-side reform"). Tax incentives for businesses to invest in plant & machinery, reducing red tape for infrastructure investment (more North Sea licences, more onshore wind), tax cuts to base rate & NI to encourage people into work...

I would like to see more action on interest rates from the BoE, and I would like to see more detail on the Planning & Infrastructure Bill, but I want to give them a chance instead of calling for yet another change in government. Supply-side reform is a perfectly sane strategy and the UK economy does need to get moving, by which I mean, producing new and useful goods and services not just keeping the whole country on life support.

OP posts:
Devilishpyjamas · 29/09/2022 17:28

If you’re a headbanger right winger who doesn’t care about inequality or millions of people being unable to afford to heat or eat then yes it’s fabulous.

GladysGladioli · 29/09/2022 17:26

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Pathetic.

SleeplessInEngland · 29/09/2022 17:25

fluffinsalad · 29/09/2022 17:23

I agree. Its going to be painful for some but in the long term we will be better off. Ive had to put off buying a house as I feel a crash is coming but as it is at the moment they are massively over inflated and not worth the money people are paying

A housing crash doesn't solve a housing crisis. It's just another crisis.

Good to see disaster capitalists like the budget though, that's a real confidence boost.

AloysiusBear · 29/09/2022 17:24

How can house prices crash when there is a shortage of supply and everyone needs somewhere to live.

AloysiusBear · 29/09/2022 17:23

Supply side reform doesn't work, especially not in an inflationary context where much of the inflation is imported, beyond our control and of inelastic goods.

Trickle down economics: also doesn't work .

A big pie split unevenly leaves more people hungry than a smaller pie shared out evenly.

fluffinsalad · 29/09/2022 17:23

Hbh17 · 29/09/2022 15:20

Interest rates have been too low for a very long time, & we probably need a housing crash to bring prices down, so OP is not unreasonable.
Also, the economic situation was very similar in the early 1980s, & we went on to have a strong economy for most of the decade, so the current hysteria is probably a bit misplaced.
The reality is that everything will shake out eventually - history tells us that, at least.

I agree. Its going to be painful for some but in the long term we will be better off. Ive had to put off buying a house as I feel a crash is coming but as it is at the moment they are massively over inflated and not worth the money people are paying

onthefencesitter · 29/09/2022 17:20

Tadpoll · 29/09/2022 17:06

All of those things have happened to me in the last few years, but I still haven’t taken on more than I can pay even with significant rises. It will be hard, but I won’t lose my house.

I don’t have tonnes of sympathy for the ‘squeezed middle’ who’ve taken on huge mortgages and now can’t pay them tbh.

I can pay my mortgage even if it doubled and the interest rate hits 8%. This is because I am 30, no DC yet and live in a small 2 bed flat in London... So 'starter home', no car, only 'big' expense is the mortgage. So have been able to overpay £1k into the mortgage every month.

However this was not viewed as the 'smart' thing to buy in 2019 when I bought. It is a small 1930s purpose built flat with a communal garden and most people would not consider it a good long term home for a young married couple looking to start a family. DH was insistent on us staying in London as he wanted to keep costs as low as possible . The 'smart' thing to do in 2019 with a 400k to 500k budget was to move outside London to a nice home counties town, buy a 3 bed house for that amount and spend £8000 per annum on commuter fares. Because that is 'future proof' and saves you moving in the future.and due to low interest rates, a lot of young couples did this and they stretched to the maximum in order to jump several rungs of the property ladder. For me staying in London meant that I couldn't get anything bigger than a 2 bed flat anyway for my price range so I just got the cheapest flat that I possibly could in my area. If I had moved out of London, I would probably have been tempted to 'stretch' cos spending a little more would have gotten me so much more!

But it doesn't take much math to figure out that you would have fewer savings from that approach compared to a couple like us who buy a small flat in zone 3 and use public transport/cycle. Esp now that hybrid working is the norm and many people are expected in the office three times a week. Yes we would probably have to move in the future, I am looking at bigger flats now, but I would buy that with the new interest rates in force and hence the price of the new place would be adjusted accordingly.

Inghean · 29/09/2022 17:20

Nobody seems to care about people who cannot work Sad Sad .
We just get left.

The £650 grant won't even nearly cover the rises in my electric and gas, and that's from a letter from my supplier after the cap was lowered (lowish users don't really benefit from that). My gas and elec is going up from £1000 to £2000.

Food prices are rising and rising and yet I bet they won't rise UC in line with inflation in April. They'll just tell us again to 'work more' - what if we cannot?? Eating foodbank food is exacerbating my health condition badly.

Punishing 'assessment' system.

This is after a decade of benefit cuts and freezes 2010-2020.

I really don't know what to do. I'm considering things I shouldn't ever have to consider, just to get by. I wish I was able to work and improve my circumstances, I really miss it.

But as long as the 'I'm alright jacks' can assuage their conscience by chucking an extra few tins in the foodbank box, then I guess it's ok eh?! Or like a poster on this thread - as long as it 'only' affects those on benefits who can work more apparently..

Please, please, do what you can to make them listen that they need to raise UC at least in line with inflation.

noblegiraffe · 29/09/2022 17:17

Tadpoll · 29/09/2022 17:00

Why have people taken on mortgages so large in relation to their earnings that they can only pay them on historically very low interest rates?

They could probably pay them on higher interest rates, but there are people who will struggle to pay them on higher interest rates at the same time as having to pay higher energy costs, petrol money and food bills.

It's the cost of everything else going up at the same time while wages in no way keep up that's really causing problems.

SleeplessInEngland · 29/09/2022 17:13

The trouble with a budget is you can't divorce it from politics. "Take your medicine, you fools!" won't work when everyone remembers the ineffectiveness of austerity.

Tadpoll · 29/09/2022 17:07

Hoppinggreen · 29/09/2022 17:06

Which is why I’m not arguing with OP

Ah, the old MN favourite: anyone who has a different opinion to me is stupid.

Love it!

Farawayfromhere · 29/09/2022 17:07

Hi Liz

Tadpoll · 29/09/2022 17:06

midgetastic · 29/09/2022 17:03

Tadpoll

I guess they ha be little choice if they need to live within a sensible commute time to work , or end up losing a job or getting I'll r divorced

Yes sone will have been stupid but many are just trapped by circumstances

All of those things have happened to me in the last few years, but I still haven’t taken on more than I can pay even with significant rises. It will be hard, but I won’t lose my house.

I don’t have tonnes of sympathy for the ‘squeezed middle’ who’ve taken on huge mortgages and now can’t pay them tbh.

Hoppinggreen · 29/09/2022 17:06

Quitelikeit · 29/09/2022 15:16

Gosh some people on here are not capable of a sensible debate.

you can’t argue with stupid op so you are wasting your time

Which is why I’m not arguing with OP

ForeverFailing · 29/09/2022 17:05

@yubgummy I don’t understand economics let alone macro ones. Can you put it in very simple terms, for very simple people like myself? Perhaps if we understood it better we wouldn’t be panicking so much. I can understand why people are so worried because the higher cost of living is just not sustainable for your average Jo Bloggs 😕

SleeplessInEngland · 29/09/2022 17:04

Tadpoll · 29/09/2022 17:01

This. People can’t see past their own (admittedly dire) circumstances. And then they accuse the government of short-termism…

Somehow I don't see the tories putting this sentiment on their next general election leaflets.

midgetastic · 29/09/2022 17:03

Tadpoll

I guess they ha be little choice if they need to live within a sensible commute time to work , or end up losing a job or getting I'll r divorced

Yes sone will have been stupid but many are just trapped by circumstances

Tadpoll · 29/09/2022 17:01

JimTheShit · 29/09/2022 16:29

I'm almost scared to admit in this echo chamber, but I think you're quite right.
But people generally focus on microeconomics rather than the macro picture.

This. People can’t see past their own (admittedly dire) circumstances. And then they accuse the government of short-termism…

SleeplessInEngland · 29/09/2022 17:01

The 45p thing is only ~£2bn, vs ~£60bn for energy support.

It's not the raw cost so much as the direction of travel it symbolises. No one thinks it'll help cost of living and that's what markets care about right now.

Tadpoll · 29/09/2022 17:00

noblegiraffe · 29/09/2022 15:49

I’m assuming that the OP is capable of looking at the ‘bigger picture’ because they’re not worried that they might lose their house.

Shame on those fixating on personal circumstances like that, eh?

Why have people taken on mortgages so large in relation to their earnings that they can only pay them on historically very low interest rates?

Havanananana · 29/09/2022 16:55

They still have to get abroad, using British airports, whether or not they use a British airplane company

Almost all airlines flying from the UK are foreign owned. TUI, BA, Ryanair, Wizz etc. Most Easyjet flights are operated by their EU subsidiary. Admittedly the travellers are flying from the UK and paying UK car parking fees etc. but out of a £10,000 holiday, how much of that is spent in the UK and how much goes to the foreign airline, the hotels and the restaurants etc. abroad?

There's fees and charges to import cars into the UK. Also if it's a less common car in the UK, services and parts fees are higher in our garages. Hence, they're paying out more to our own car maintenance businesses, to keep their car running.

The UK has free trade agreements with the EU and Japan, so imported cars from these countries are not subject to fees and charges. Even brands like Hyundai, Jeep and Kia are built in the EU for the UK market. Parts fees? These are paid to the foreign manufacturer, so the UK garage doesn't profit more than if the part came from the UK. The origin of the car is irrelevant to the car maintenance business - other than to say that if UK potholes and roads get worse, there will be more work for the workshops. Perhaps that's the plan?

Barely anything is made in the UK anymore, but the retailer selling the goods is, who are also employing British citizens, keeping them in jobs and having the ability to increase their wages.

Why do you assume that the retailer is British? On line companies such as Amazon pay very little tax in the UK, even on huge amounts of UK turnover. Boots pay their tax in Switzerland. All of which again means money flowing out of the UK, reducing the amount in circulation. And selling things to each other does not grow the economy any more than cutting each other's hair does. Truss wants to cut wages and remove workers' rights - her whole theory is based on productivity increasing when "idle" British workers are forced to take any job, at any wage, in order to make ends meet.

Rosesandstars · 29/09/2022 16:55

I'm guessing you earn a high income then OP?

yubgummy · 29/09/2022 16:53

What exactly is in this budget which is so shocking, aside from the comms around it and the evident lack of coordination with the BoE?

The single biggest cost in it is the energy price cap - which was already announced. Next biggest is getting rid of the NI increase which Rishi only just put in, and which everyone moaned was a regressive tax which only a Tory could have come up with. Both of these had already been announced, Liz was hardly hiding her plans...

The 45p thing is only ~£2bn, vs ~£60bn for energy support. Bringing that back isn't going to save the NHS.

OP posts:
SleeplessInEngland · 29/09/2022 16:32

Even if you think it's a good budget (it isn't), the comms surrounding it have been so dire that it doesn't matter. No believes these people can pull it off because the can't/won't even say how these decisions will lead to growth in a cost of living crisis.

If I were a libertarian I'd be furious my philosophy had such poor ambassadors in Truss and Kwarteng.

SirCharlesRainier · 29/09/2022 16:30

CurseOfBigness · 29/09/2022 14:51

@yubgummy “Macroeconomics is complex. It surprises me that within a week, there's such a strong consensus that everything about the mini-budget is literally the work of the devil.”

You brought the devil into discussion; it is more likely the work of the devil to be fair…

Truss claims to have Christian values. No. her economic is not in line with the teachings of her spiritual teacher, Jesus.

Tax cuts for the wealthy and trickle-down economics? Jesus had plenty to say about that…

James O’Brien: Kwasi Kwarteng’s tax cuts are “against Christ’s teachings”

Work of the Devil is a credible claim. “Don't make a deal with the devil, if you do you will lose something important that you once had.”

@CurseOfBigness It depends which Jesus you listen to.

imgur.io/gallery/bCqRp

Swipe left for the next trending thread