Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I'm actually pleased with the mini-budget

241 replies

yubgummy · 29/09/2022 14:35

(Cue hysterical shrieking ;) )

Macroeconomics is complex. It surprises me that within a week, there's such a strong consensus that everything about the mini-budget is literally the work of the devil. Echo chamber...

The UK basically has never recovered from the GFC and has just been stagnant and struggling for a decade. The clear theme in this budget is encouraging people to actually get out and DO something ("supply-side reform"). Tax incentives for businesses to invest in plant & machinery, reducing red tape for infrastructure investment (more North Sea licences, more onshore wind), tax cuts to base rate & NI to encourage people into work...

I would like to see more action on interest rates from the BoE, and I would like to see more detail on the Planning & Infrastructure Bill, but I want to give them a chance instead of calling for yet another change in government. Supply-side reform is a perfectly sane strategy and the UK economy does need to get moving, by which I mean, producing new and useful goods and services not just keeping the whole country on life support.

OP posts:
Bzzz · 29/09/2022 18:08

@yubgummy i assume you are not an economist?

SleeplessInEngland · 29/09/2022 18:07

ClareBlue · 29/09/2022 18:05

The argument that 'the experts' have criticised this so it must be wrong forgets that it is the experts that got us here in the first place. Check the record of predictions by the IMF and not there reactionary statements in hindsight, and see how expert they really are.

Who cares about the IMF? I'd be more concerned that the BoE had to intervene to save pension funds from its own government.

Inghean · 29/09/2022 18:06

@Tiani4 I really hope enough poor people will turnout to vote them out, and the non-poor will have a heart at the polls. We (disabled people) literally cannot take any more of this.

ClareBlue · 29/09/2022 18:05

The argument that 'the experts' have criticised this so it must be wrong forgets that it is the experts that got us here in the first place. Check the record of predictions by the IMF and not there reactionary statements in hindsight, and see how expert they really are.

TeaKlaxon · 29/09/2022 18:04

Let's imagine that the Tory wet dream was correct, and that tax cuts for the wealthy would actually stimulate growth and investment that would benefit everyone.

This would still have been a dreadful budget.

The single biggest crisis facing the country before this was inflation. It remains the single biggest crisis. Interest rates were already going to have to rise - some as a result of global conditions and some as a result of Brexit (higher costs of trading, staff shortages fuelling inflation).

But the budget on Friday means inflation would be even higher because of the money it would pump into the economy, meaning interest rates need to be highest than otherwise just to make up for that. And then, because the markets had no confidence in the plan, the £ plummeted, which will push inflation still further (necessitating higher interest rates), and finally, the cost of Government borrowing has soared because markets do not trust this Government.

All of this will push up interest rates far more than they would have been if they had just been responding to inflation caused by global conditions. Those interest rates will wipe out the benefit of any tax cuts for many, many people.

Tiani4 · 29/09/2022 18:02

I predict people will die as a result of this mini budget

And it won't help those poorest, it helps those richer

Bl@@dy tories 🥺🥺😰😰 absolute selfish b//£tards

Alll truss is doing is causing pain before she and tories get ousted

Labour will have a landslide and she is making it blipping certain

CPL593H · 29/09/2022 18:01

Tadpoll · 29/09/2022 17:00

Why have people taken on mortgages so large in relation to their earnings that they can only pay them on historically very low interest rates?

Because that's what they need to raise to buy a house and the alternative is spending equally ludicrous amounts on rent? They may be overcommitting but the vast majority are doing it to get a roof over their heads and some stability, not because they fancy a 10 bed mansion.

Tadpoll · 29/09/2022 18:01

Firstly, those who are 30 and under will not know anything different than low interest rates because we entered adulthood with low interest rates. And funnily enough we don't get taught economics and the history of UK politics/economics in school so how would we know they're artificially low.

This is a very odd way of looking at it.

Tiani4 · 29/09/2022 17:58

Sorry my phone auto incorrected some of my text

But I'm so unbelievably mad and upset about this

Tadpoll · 29/09/2022 17:58

Roomytrouser · 29/09/2022 17:32

So, when you concentrate on your own personal circumstances you’ll be fine?

All these people concentrating on their own personal circumstances, what is the world coming to?

You’re missing my point!

Tiani4 · 29/09/2022 17:57

I hate this budget
It isn't about those on breaking and struggling it takes odd higher take rate for higher earners to increase national debt

And itv other rescue packages welfare ie nhs and social card budgets will be slashed

You do know that adult social care and nhs was slammed dyeing covid and have a huge backlog? And it'll be two years before we even clear that and people are already shouting at us? No zero tolerance for us ? Me and my colleagues are abused at least 3x a week..,it's become our norm 😱 in an unacceptable way

Hey wonder what it'll be like when we can't keep people alive let alone safe?

No I am not happy but heyho richer people get more money instead of tax . 🎉Yeay them! 🎉🥳

Liebig · 29/09/2022 17:55

Hbh17 · 29/09/2022 15:20

Interest rates have been too low for a very long time, & we probably need a housing crash to bring prices down, so OP is not unreasonable.
Also, the economic situation was very similar in the early 1980s, & we went on to have a strong economy for most of the decade, so the current hysteria is probably a bit misplaced.
The reality is that everything will shake out eventually - history tells us that, at least.

The present situation is nothing at all like the ‘80s.

Daisybuttercup12345 · 29/09/2022 17:53

Millions don't agree with you.

Marchmount · 29/09/2022 17:53

AloysiusBear · 29/09/2022 17:24

How can house prices crash when there is a shortage of supply and everyone needs somewhere to live.

People can’t get mortgages as big as previously due to the increased cost of servicing them with increasing interest rates and/ or people don’t want to buy as they think prices will crash therefore becoming a self-fulfilling prophecy. More people will stay put if they can to save moving costs and mitigate risk. If buyers can’t or won’t pay the price then prices will drop.

Thisismynamenow · 29/09/2022 17:52

Tadpoll · 29/09/2022 17:00

Why have people taken on mortgages so large in relation to their earnings that they can only pay them on historically very low interest rates?

@noblegiraffe this annoys me so much and shows the whole "I'm alright Jack" mentality.

Firstly, those who are 30 and under will not know anything different than low interest rates because we entered adulthood with low interest rates. And funnily enough we don't get taught economics and the history of UK politics/economics in school so how would we know they're artificially low.

Secondly, house prices are much more expensive than they were pre 2008, so even if people wanted to go lower they couldnt. They have to push themselves to buy a 3 bed semi, their not buying 5 bed detached mini mansions...

Finally, I don't think you can say they're temporary/artificially low after 12 years, at that point they're just low.

noblegiraffe · 29/09/2022 17:49

Why are ordinary working folk expected to look past their (dire) personal circumstances to see the benefit to the country and yet bankers couldn't possibly be expected to put up with bonuses less than double their annual salary otherwise they'd flee the country?

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 29/09/2022 17:48

Trying to dodge OBR scrutiny seems to have been a big problem here. Makes you look like you've not done the sums and are trying to blag it.

Quite. Which is why all the markets panicked and sterling plummetted. Which means it costs a fuck ton more for the government to borrow money to pay for those tax cuts for the rich. And LT won't back down so is planning to cut services to pay for those promised tax cuts. Plus everything we import will go up in price including energy. I'm struggling to actually see how they could have made worse decisions really.

Inghean · 29/09/2022 17:45

Are you claiming PIP and getting LCWRA element? If you are then you’re better off than those on benefit who don’t have these top ups. If you don’t get these top ups and still run a house then you really do have it tough. I don’t know how single people on basic benefits cope, it must be awful.

UC acknowledge I'm too ill to work, but I've been on the basic rate £334 for a year.

I am choosing between using fuel and eating, and every fortnight I have to sit for days without electricity because it runs out and I cannot top up my meter until UC comes in. So I cannot use my freezer and I've lost weight. Foodbank food is making my health even worse.

People have no idea. There are very very long waits for the disability payments and lots of wrongful declines (70% I think).

Also people forget about the 5 week wait for payment, you then need to take out a loan to pay rent and live, which then reduces your payments to even below the basic level for a whole year whilst it's clawed back.

CurseOfBigness · 29/09/2022 17:44

Tadpoll · 29/09/2022 17:01

This. People can’t see past their own (admittedly dire) circumstances. And then they accuse the government of short-termism…

What about the short-termism of shorting the pound to make a quick buck?

There are claims of Insider Trading that needs investigation because that’s a criminal offence.

TheVanguardSix · 29/09/2022 17:43

“Supply-side reform is a perfectly sane strategy and the UK economy does need to get moving, by which I mean producing new and useful goods and services”

Like manufacturing weapons and not much else to feed the beast that is the runaway train military-industrial complex? We’re in WW3. Let’s not pretend otherwise. And every penny will feed the war machine of US Imperialism, of which we are the conjoined twin, and Russia’s own capitalistic/imperialistic agenda.

I just can’t imagine this government subsidising education or training that will be needed to get people back into jobs that don’t even seem capable of existing in the UK we currently live in.

I don’t trust the politicians implementing this mini-budget.
And what comes with this glorious vision of a Tory mini-budget? Unbridled deregulation (the Brexiteers wet dream is about to become even more real). Oh for the salad days of worrying about chlorinated chicken.
In theory, it’s all so gilded and hopeful (in the eyes of the insane putting forth this ‘sane’ mini-budget).
In practice, well, pick a bus, any bus to get thrown under.
I might be wrong. I feel like I won’t be. Just look at the mugs running the asylum!
I’m sorry to have a go, OP. I do kind of see what you mean. But honestly, how things play out in reality is often so very different than the theories that give birth to those ‘things’ and ideas that fill the heads of those with decision-making power.

noblegiraffe · 29/09/2022 17:40

Gosh, add the electorate, including many, many previous Tory voters to the list of people who are WRONG about this budget.

Roomytrouser · 29/09/2022 17:34

Very equal countries are very hard to govern because the needs of the people are so different. Scandinavian countries tend to have a much stronger social pack because they believe the state will support them if the need arises therefore they should support the state.

SleeplessInEngland · 29/09/2022 17:33

New YouGov poll, the (insane) numbers speak for themselves:

Henry Zeffman
BREAKING
Labour have a 33 POINT LEAD with YouGov/Times
Yes, 33. THIRTY-THREE POINTS

Lab: 54 (+9)
Con: 21 (-7)
Lib: 7 (-2)
Green: 6 (-1)
Ref: 4 (+1)

Fieldwork: Today and yesterday

ForeverFailing · 29/09/2022 17:33

Inghean · 29/09/2022 17:20

Nobody seems to care about people who cannot work Sad Sad .
We just get left.

The £650 grant won't even nearly cover the rises in my electric and gas, and that's from a letter from my supplier after the cap was lowered (lowish users don't really benefit from that). My gas and elec is going up from £1000 to £2000.

Food prices are rising and rising and yet I bet they won't rise UC in line with inflation in April. They'll just tell us again to 'work more' - what if we cannot?? Eating foodbank food is exacerbating my health condition badly.

Punishing 'assessment' system.

This is after a decade of benefit cuts and freezes 2010-2020.

I really don't know what to do. I'm considering things I shouldn't ever have to consider, just to get by. I wish I was able to work and improve my circumstances, I really miss it.

But as long as the 'I'm alright jacks' can assuage their conscience by chucking an extra few tins in the foodbank box, then I guess it's ok eh?! Or like a poster on this thread - as long as it 'only' affects those on benefits who can work more apparently..

Please, please, do what you can to make them listen that they need to raise UC at least in line with inflation.

Are you claiming PIP and getting LCWRA element? If you are then you’re better off than those on benefit who don’t have these top ups. If you don’t get these top ups and still run a house then you really do have it tough. I don’t know how single people on basic benefits cope, it must be awful.

Roomytrouser · 29/09/2022 17:32

Tadpoll · 29/09/2022 17:06

All of those things have happened to me in the last few years, but I still haven’t taken on more than I can pay even with significant rises. It will be hard, but I won’t lose my house.

I don’t have tonnes of sympathy for the ‘squeezed middle’ who’ve taken on huge mortgages and now can’t pay them tbh.

So, when you concentrate on your own personal circumstances you’ll be fine?

All these people concentrating on their own personal circumstances, what is the world coming to?