Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I'm actually pleased with the mini-budget

241 replies

yubgummy · 29/09/2022 14:35

(Cue hysterical shrieking ;) )

Macroeconomics is complex. It surprises me that within a week, there's such a strong consensus that everything about the mini-budget is literally the work of the devil. Echo chamber...

The UK basically has never recovered from the GFC and has just been stagnant and struggling for a decade. The clear theme in this budget is encouraging people to actually get out and DO something ("supply-side reform"). Tax incentives for businesses to invest in plant & machinery, reducing red tape for infrastructure investment (more North Sea licences, more onshore wind), tax cuts to base rate & NI to encourage people into work...

I would like to see more action on interest rates from the BoE, and I would like to see more detail on the Planning & Infrastructure Bill, but I want to give them a chance instead of calling for yet another change in government. Supply-side reform is a perfectly sane strategy and the UK economy does need to get moving, by which I mean, producing new and useful goods and services not just keeping the whole country on life support.

OP posts:
CherryGenoa · 29/09/2022 20:31

Hello Kwasi @yubgummy Haven’t read the whole thread as I can’t really be bothered to engage with conservative central office, unless it’s to watch their expulsion from number 10. The budget won’t achieve improved productivity or investment. Business owners are making plans to move their businesses out as they don’t trust the tories, who have already facilitated a ton of Brexit related problems and they don’t want to raise their children in a fracked Freeport UK.

onthefencesitter · 29/09/2022 20:28

Kissingfrogs25 · 29/09/2022 19:11

London is the financial capital of the world, and powers much of the U.K. in terms of revenue.
I think the low tax, low reg policy is perfect for the U.K. we are uniquely placed to take advantage of the benefits. I strongly believe this is precisely what we need to do - we have many assets as a country in science, law, tech, AI and research as well as finance.

It would be perfect for the UK if the entire of the UK stopped at the north and south circular. Or even the M25. That isn't the case though which is why only London and the SE are net contributing regions. The work of 18 million people (9 million, 9 million SE) cannot support an entire country of 70 million people which is why the country's finances are in the state that they are in.

Larger countries are more expensive to run and generally the richer regions have to support the poorer regions, hence we must pay more tax.

Havanananana · 29/09/2022 20:09

The government are trying to help unshackle the country of pointless regulation to attract more business, to ensure the very best legal minds, bankers, surgeons and entrepreneurs STAY in the U.K. by reducing their tax burden. In an increasingly competitive global market we need to be a low tax country that stands out from all the rest. Business friendly and attractive. That way we stimulate growth and investment.

The best legal minds have to stay in the UK - thanks to Brexit their qualifications are no longer recognised outside of the UK. Surgeons likewise - although after Hunt decided that junior doctors could not have a pay rise or better conditions, many of them left for Canada, Australia and New Zealand. As for entrepreneurs - the most vocal pro-Brexit, pro "small state" entrepreneurs have likewise left the UK. Ineos (billionaire Brexit-supporter Jim Ratcliffe) and Dyson both chose to invest in their factories abroad rather than in post-Brexit UK.

In an increasingly competitive global market, the current government (as spelled out in Britannia Unchained) wants an unregulated, low-tax economy which is totally at odds with the interests of the population. It equates to sweatshop Britain, as already seen in the textile factories of the East Midlands and in the fields of East Anglia. And if the British won't work under these conditions, then the government has plans to import cheap labour from Nepal and elsewhere in Asia. The role of government is not just to be "business friendly" - the government is elected by the voters and is supposed to act at all times for the benefit of the entire population, not just for the interests of "business".

RafaistheKingofClay · 29/09/2022 19:55

Kissingfrogs25 · 29/09/2022 19:11

London is the financial capital of the world, and powers much of the U.K. in terms of revenue.
I think the low tax, low reg policy is perfect for the U.K. we are uniquely placed to take advantage of the benefits. I strongly believe this is precisely what we need to do - we have many assets as a country in science, law, tech, AI and research as well as finance.

We fucked science over when we left the EU. I’ve got a feeling the finance industry has been moving money out of the U.K. at speed.

I’d be surprised if lowering taxes further was the driver to huge amounts of investment given that they were already relatively low. It doesn’t make up for the U.K. being a high risk basket case where absolutely anything can happen. Much better and safer opportunities elsewhere.

Havanananana · 29/09/2022 19:54

@Kissingfrogs25 "You haven’t mentioned what countries in Europe tax over 45%"

Germany - top rate of income tax is 45% plus a 5.5% solidarity surcharge.
Austria - rate over €60,000 is 48%, increasing to 55% for top earners.
Denmark - top rate is capped at 52%
Netherlands - rate over €69,398 is 49.5%

A simple google will find the rest but it is clear that many countries with a far higher standard of living than the UK also have a higher tax rate.

The UK actually has one of the lowest rates of income tax in Europe, and one of the poorest levels of investment. Which country does Bloomberg think is the most competitive to invest in? - Denmark, which by no measure is a low-tax, low regulation economy. www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-06-15/danes-overtake-the-swiss-as-world-s-most-competitive-nation

Namenic · 29/09/2022 19:53

The timing of the tax cuts at a time of high inflation, energy crisis, high national debt levels is terrible. Then not spelling out your plans (despite market turmoil) makes it look like you have no plan and are making it up as you go along. We hear now on bbc that kwarteng is asking govt depts now where they can make cuts. To me this makes it seem like he first wanted to cut tax (and thinks about the consequences afterwards). I expect a chancellor to first assess impacts of cuts before making them - and be able to justify in a detailed way.

I don’t think the strategy is totally without reason - I guess they may want to attract multi national companies to open more offices in U.K., bringing in more jobs etc - so we may get more higher rate tax payers in total? The weak pound may make it more attractive. But the market instability, political instability (multiple pms) and increased difficulty doing business with Europe might count against it? also frequent strikes, under funded public services. Plus, it will take time for investment to happen - so no need to do big rapid changes like LT and KK have done.

MadameMaxGoesler · 29/09/2022 19:43

@Havanananana Germany's inflation rate is 10%.
EU inflation by country.

ForeverFailing · 29/09/2022 19:42

Inghean · 29/09/2022 17:45

Are you claiming PIP and getting LCWRA element? If you are then you’re better off than those on benefit who don’t have these top ups. If you don’t get these top ups and still run a house then you really do have it tough. I don’t know how single people on basic benefits cope, it must be awful.

UC acknowledge I'm too ill to work, but I've been on the basic rate £334 for a year.

I am choosing between using fuel and eating, and every fortnight I have to sit for days without electricity because it runs out and I cannot top up my meter until UC comes in. So I cannot use my freezer and I've lost weight. Foodbank food is making my health even worse.

People have no idea. There are very very long waits for the disability payments and lots of wrongful declines (70% I think).

Also people forget about the 5 week wait for payment, you then need to take out a loan to pay rent and live, which then reduces your payments to even below the basic level for a whole year whilst it's clawed back.

I have a very good understanding and can totally understand your struggle if you’re still waiting for assessment. I hope you don’t have to wait much longer. Don’t be ashamed of relying on food banks, lots of people use them and people tend to give to food banks because they genuinely want to help. In an ideal world you’d have had your assessment and have your top ups, unfortunately the world is far from ideal

yubgummy · 29/09/2022 19:40

@balalake

The concept of not running up massive debts just to give money to the richest 1% is simple however.

How do you feel about the concept of running up a £60bn+ debt to give energy bill relief to households and businesses, £15bn to give tax relief to ALL households by rolling back NI, and adding £2bn to give money to the richest 1% as part of a wider growth plan?

OP posts:
lljkk · 29/09/2022 19:34

How hard do you work, OP? Because according to Truss & KK, you're a lazy toerag. Almost all the Brits are. These tax changes are meant to turn us into lean mean producing machines.

What are YOU going to do different in your life to stop being one of the idle?

Lottsbiffandsmudge · 29/09/2022 19:32

I'm a higher rate tax payer. I was and am happy to pay 45%. I don't need a tax cut.
I don't disagree with the energy cap- but the producers who have earned unplanned and huge extra profits should have been taxed on those extra profits to pay for some of it. I do not buy the 'if we tax them more they won't invest' argument. All these companies will have short, med and long term investment plans based on their forecasts of profit prior to the energy crisis. These plans should not be affected by a windfall tax.

I don't agree with the tax cuts (except NI reversal) It puts fiscal policy totally at odds with monetary policy. Surely the best way to grow the economy in as little an inflationary way as possible is with infrastructure spending preferably in areas of most deprivation. If they had to cut taxes how about VAT on fuel? Immeidate and tangible benefit to all.

And today I heard a tory explain that they will be doubling down on costs. Not going a penny over the budgets agreed in the last round. Which with the costs of energy, the collapse of sterling and high inflation will see real cuts and that's before they announce more actual budget cuts in Nov.

There is no point having an income tax cut if there is no health care, education or a fire and police force etc etc.

TheHateIsNotGood · 29/09/2022 19:23

My best advice to most people is to re-evaluate their talents and their work in a productive light. Too much of our Economy is based on Financial Services and the 'serf services' to keep this sector happy and 'buoyant'.

Being able to make useful things, provide useful services and keep our society as healthy as possible (through public sector services) is the best use of any money.

The Financial Sector are mainly gamblers playing with Monoploy money
and aren't really that useful and certainly don't deserve to hoard money in various global coffers without expecting the serfs to take it back at some point.

And only the most brainwashed would think that keeping these Snake Oil Sellers in charge of Global Economies is a good thing.

YetiTeri · 29/09/2022 19:20

Kissingfrogs25 · 29/09/2022 19:17

Er yes! Given it is my salary!

Ok. So yes, I like most people who earn less than the 45% threshold would be very happy to pay 45% on the income earned over that threshold. In just the same way as I'm happy to pay tax on the income which is above the tax free allowance. Because that's fair. HTH.

balalake · 29/09/2022 19:19

Macroeconomics is complex. Some supply side reforms would be welcome no doubt.

The concept of not running up massive debts just to give money to the richest 1% is simple however.

Kissingfrogs25 · 29/09/2022 19:17

YetiTeri · 29/09/2022 19:14

You know it's not 45% tax on all your income right...?

Er yes! Given it is my salary!

Kissingfrogs25 · 29/09/2022 19:16

SleeplessInEngland · 29/09/2022 18:51

These people would never agree to 45% tax!!! Never, but they expect other people to pay it I definitely - they are welded to the socialist dream of redistribution because they have no assets, money, talent or ambition to earn their own. It’s known as theft elsewhere.

Going by this logic and today’s polling 79% of the electorate are socialists now. Think you may need a more refined definition.

Polling changes every week!!

YetiTeri · 29/09/2022 19:14

Kissingfrogs25 · 29/09/2022 19:12

I hope you will be happy to pay 45% tax in that case?

You know it's not 45% tax on all your income right...?

YouCantTourniquetTheTaint · 29/09/2022 19:14

The rich are getting richer, the poor will get punished and poorer. Let them eat cake, huh.

Liz Truss on local BBC radio stations was absolutely and utterly humiliated by local radio hosts, especially on BBC Bristol. She just repeated the same lines, didn't answer questions, and it made her look utterly stupid.

People are angry because KamiKwasi's old Hedge fund buddies bet against the £ the Friday before he announced his mini budget, and they made 145% returns.

People are angry because it looks like the rich are getting richer, getting tax cuts and whatnot.

Whilst the poor are getting poorer, are being threatened to have their benefits slashed no matter the situation I.e disability, no suitable work, 0 hour contracts, and many other situations.

Food, fuel, energy, and water prices going up, I'm going to have to probably leave the job I'm doing now, the job that fits my disability fits around my studies where I'm trying to better myself, because I can't afford to live on £10 an hour. It's bullshit.

Trickle down economics is a fallacy, it doesn't work.

When bankers and trade unions agree on something you know something is really wrong.

We're going to have a winter of discontent, strikes, Demonstrations, and civil unrest. Cold hungry people aren't happy people, I think the UK is going to grow a pair and tell the government exactly what they think of them.

Kissingfrogs25 · 29/09/2022 19:12

Tillsforthrills · 29/09/2022 19:09

Excellent point.

I hope you will be happy to pay 45% tax in that case?

Kissingfrogs25 · 29/09/2022 19:11

onthefencesitter · 29/09/2022 19:04

My home country Singapore is pretty big on supply side economic policies,( low tax, low regulation) but it's also a city state. If you study a level economics in my home country, a huge part of the syllabus is devoted to supply side economics and how great it is, how Singapore is successful because of it etc

It's a completely different country. It's like as if inner London was a country as it's literally half the size of London. It also has no deficit and the government owns 95% of land and controls large swathes of the economy through its state owned company. One of the biggest sovereign wealth funds. As the state owns so much land, they can build subsidized housing that it sells to its citizens and even in past recessions, the value of the government housing did not go down as much as private housing as the prices are controlled by the government (given that the government has full control of the supply).

Deregulated/low tax policies tend to work in city states with a well educated population and a growing financial sector. The vast majority of the population can work in the financial sector/other well paid tertiary sectors and the government can afford to help the small number of people who don't.

London is the financial capital of the world, and powers much of the U.K. in terms of revenue.
I think the low tax, low reg policy is perfect for the U.K. we are uniquely placed to take advantage of the benefits. I strongly believe this is precisely what we need to do - we have many assets as a country in science, law, tech, AI and research as well as finance.

YetiTeri · 29/09/2022 19:10

I honestly don't know where to start.

  1. Productivity is down due to lack of 'resource' because
a) a significant number of over 50s have been left with health problems over Covid and have left the workforce. b) a significant number of women have left the workforce due to a lack of affordable childcare. c) Brexit has cut off a significant source of labour.
  1. The stamp duty cut will ultimately push house prices up.
  1. More oil and gas?! Are you INSANE? Where are we getting this oil and gas from? The UK doesn't own our own gas we have to buy it on the open market. We are way past the point of burning any new fossil fuels being acceptable.
Tillsforthrills · 29/09/2022 19:09

noblegiraffe · 29/09/2022 17:49

Why are ordinary working folk expected to look past their (dire) personal circumstances to see the benefit to the country and yet bankers couldn't possibly be expected to put up with bonuses less than double their annual salary otherwise they'd flee the country?

Excellent point.

Kissingfrogs25 · 29/09/2022 19:05

Havanananana · 29/09/2022 18:57

Congratulations for trying to open up a nuanced discussion and I agree with you op, there is every chance that these policies will stimulate growth and will stave off a deep recession.

@Kissingfrogs25 But it isn't a nuanced discussion. Supporters of the budget have not explained how they think it will improve the UK's economy, nor have they explained why trickle down has failed every time that it has been attempted. Nor have they explained why every economist (with the possible exception of Minford, who has been wrong on all of his other theories) has explained why they think it won't work.

"I agree that there is every chance that these policies will work" is an opinion, not a nuanced argument. Many of the posters here have attempted to explain why we hold an opposing view, only to be met with insults ("momentum thugs").

These people would never agree to 45% tax!!! They are welded to the socialist dream of redistribution because they have no assets, money, talent or ambition to earn their own. It’s known as theft elsewhere.

And yet in many other European countries, taxation rates are higher than in the UK, growth over the last 40 years has been greater than in the UK and people are far from being "socialists". What they do realise is that a fairer distribution of wealth, opportunity, education, infrastructure, housing and healthcare is key to the success of any modern economy, and they are willing to pay for it because they can see the benefits that accrue to everyone.

You haven’t mentioned what countries in Europe tax over 45%

Secondly this isn’t trickle down! It never was. The government are trying to help unshackle the country of pointless regulation to attract more business, to ensure the very best legal minds, bankers, surgeons and entrepreneurs STAY in the U.K. by reducing their tax burden. In an increasingly competitive global market we need to be a low tax country that stands out from all the rest. Business friendly and attractive. That way we stimulate growth and investment.

Truss is taking the hard decisions no other PM has had the balls to follow through before now.

The alternative was a deep depression with a tanking economy and huge debts. She had no choice in my view

onthefencesitter · 29/09/2022 19:04

ThirtyThreeTrees · 29/09/2022 18:52

OP, can you provide an example of any country at all stage that adopted this policy and had a successful outcome directly associated with this approach?

All I'm looking for is the country and the time period? If you have evidence to support it that would be great but just looking for the example really.

My home country Singapore is pretty big on supply side economic policies,( low tax, low regulation) but it's also a city state. If you study a level economics in my home country, a huge part of the syllabus is devoted to supply side economics and how great it is, how Singapore is successful because of it etc

It's a completely different country. It's like as if inner London was a country as it's literally half the size of London. It also has no deficit and the government owns 95% of land and controls large swathes of the economy through its state owned company. One of the biggest sovereign wealth funds. As the state owns so much land, they can build subsidized housing that it sells to its citizens and even in past recessions, the value of the government housing did not go down as much as private housing as the prices are controlled by the government (given that the government has full control of the supply).

Deregulated/low tax policies tend to work in city states with a well educated population and a growing financial sector. The vast majority of the population can work in the financial sector/other well paid tertiary sectors and the government can afford to help the small number of people who don't.

noblegiraffe · 29/09/2022 19:00

KK will in the coming days make a reassuring statement.

He was supposed to make a reassuring statement at the weekend and instead said 'hey, there will be even more tax cuts next year' which did the opposite of reassuring.

The markets have already settled…

Because the BoE have spent billions of taxpayers' money trying to settle them.