Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I'm actually pleased with the mini-budget

241 replies

yubgummy · 29/09/2022 14:35

(Cue hysterical shrieking ;) )

Macroeconomics is complex. It surprises me that within a week, there's such a strong consensus that everything about the mini-budget is literally the work of the devil. Echo chamber...

The UK basically has never recovered from the GFC and has just been stagnant and struggling for a decade. The clear theme in this budget is encouraging people to actually get out and DO something ("supply-side reform"). Tax incentives for businesses to invest in plant & machinery, reducing red tape for infrastructure investment (more North Sea licences, more onshore wind), tax cuts to base rate & NI to encourage people into work...

I would like to see more action on interest rates from the BoE, and I would like to see more detail on the Planning & Infrastructure Bill, but I want to give them a chance instead of calling for yet another change in government. Supply-side reform is a perfectly sane strategy and the UK economy does need to get moving, by which I mean, producing new and useful goods and services not just keeping the whole country on life support.

OP posts:
L1ttledrummergirl · 30/09/2022 06:37

If we closed the financial borders so money earned in the UK stayed in the UK, and capped the amount of money and assets each person earned to a maximum then trickle down economics might have a chance as people would be forced to spend.

Instead this government has picked the worst possible time to gamble, not with their own security, but that of the majority of the country. I'd like to know where they plan to house all the people who lose their homes due to mortgage rises, or those whose landlords increase the rent to unaffordable levels to cover theirs? How do they plan to feed a population that are living on the streets?

In short, they don't have the answers and will run from the responsibility.

They can fuck off.

Worriedaboutethics · 30/09/2022 06:31

@yubgummy

cant believe you posted this thread.
how ethically and economically embarrassing

LizTrusssPA · 30/09/2022 06:23

The very fact the markets reacted the way they did is enough to tell me it was a really stupid idea.

bozzabollix · 30/09/2022 06:21

So you’re right but the IMF and the Bank of England are wrong then?

Righto. Guess there’s got to always be one.

Tillsforthrills · 30/09/2022 06:10

Devilishpyjamas · 30/09/2022 06:04

Listen to them. They are saying out loud what they have always thought - they don’t care about people who lose everything because of their choices. They have a religious like belief in this ideology. People being left destitute doesn’t (in their minds) mean their approach has failed.

Once you realise that they don’t care what happens to the masses, that they see everyone as only being responsible to themselves (the ‘get on your bike’ ideology), they don’t care if people can’t feed their children then it all makes sense. What happens to individuals is irrelevant.

I agree, it’s disgusting.

YetiTeri · 30/09/2022 06:10

Blimpop · 29/09/2022 23:58

There is so much misinformation and self generated guff on this thread. I wish people would actually research what they nonsense they spout.

There's also bots. The point of challenging them is to stop other people blindly believing it. But I would put money on OP being a bot.

Devilishpyjamas · 30/09/2022 06:04

Tillsforthrills · 30/09/2022 05:54

No but they will sell it as a ‘victory’ anyway.

Listen to them. They are saying out loud what they have always thought - they don’t care about people who lose everything because of their choices. They have a religious like belief in this ideology. People being left destitute doesn’t (in their minds) mean their approach has failed.

Once you realise that they don’t care what happens to the masses, that they see everyone as only being responsible to themselves (the ‘get on your bike’ ideology), they don’t care if people can’t feed their children then it all makes sense. What happens to individuals is irrelevant.

Tillsforthrills · 30/09/2022 05:54

CurseOfBigness · 30/09/2022 00:22

I just read: “New research by the Tony Blair Institute for Global Change suggested new Budget will make economy just 0.4 per cent larger by 2027 than without tax cuts.”

Is sacrifice to the lives of the general public worth it?

No.

No but they will sell it as a ‘victory’ anyway.

Zebedee55 · 30/09/2022 04:40

Truss and Karteng are meeting the fiscal watchdog today, which is precedented - usually they do this before a budget, not afterwards.

They want to "curb" all benefits to save £5 billion, by linking them to wages and not the CPI. The poorest, including those working, claiming top-up benefits, are expected to pay for the tax cuts to the wealthiest.🙄

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/yougov-poll-labour-lead-conservatives-tories-n90lqlgf7

Meanwhile, in 5 days, Labour have shot into a 33% lead over the Tories:

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11264999/Liz-Truss-left-reeling-Labour-soaring-record-33-point-poll-lead.html

the80sweregreat · 30/09/2022 03:37

Fatmog,
Good post. The one making millions do not give a jot :(

FatMog · 30/09/2022 03:18

I don't know anything about economics but only my own situation.

My husband is a postal worker. He was offered 2% as a pay rise from Royal Mail, more if he gives away lots of agreements that the workers have accrued over the decades.

Royal Mail made over £700m in the last tax year in profit. It gave £400m to shareholders, and the CEO, CFO got a few million in bonuses.

Now they get a cut in corporation tax. Okay.

If "trickle down economics" works why are Royal Mail investing virtually nothing in the maintenance of their premises? Why are toilets constantly broken or blocked, and why are the delivery offices filthy? Why are the workers being told, even if they agree to the changes, they will only be given a 5.5% raise. Inflation is running at 10% plus, so why are they not getting a better deal? They just want to go to the loo without risking flooding the bathroom! They aren't being treated with dignity. The CEO isn't interested is passing on any profit or tax bounce to help his workers. He wants further cuts to his workforce! It doesn't translate that more profit, lower taxation leads to more jobs! They will just take that money and KEEP IT FOR THEMSELVES.

I know OP wants to make her point but money is so tight for us now because inflation is rampant, our mortgage has gone up, our fuel bill has gone up, estate charges on our flat have gone up, food is more expensive and we've had to massively reduce our outgoings to cope. We don't have a car but we still just make it in the black each month. This mini-budget has, and continues to be a disaster for most working families. Oh, so my NI is reduced. Whoopee-do. I already pay more than that on the leaky bill.

antelopevalley · 30/09/2022 01:50

Interesting OP that you think you know better than the Head of the Bank of England or the International Monetary Fund who have both condemned the mini-budget.

Roomytrouser · 30/09/2022 01:23

onthefencesitter · 29/09/2022 20:28

It would be perfect for the UK if the entire of the UK stopped at the north and south circular. Or even the M25. That isn't the case though which is why only London and the SE are net contributing regions. The work of 18 million people (9 million, 9 million SE) cannot support an entire country of 70 million people which is why the country's finances are in the state that they are in.

Larger countries are more expensive to run and generally the richer regions have to support the poorer regions, hence we must pay more tax.

When I worked in London, it was full of people who had been educated elsewhere and moved there - so the non-income producing earlier stages were funded by other parts of the country then drained away by London.

Novum · 30/09/2022 00:42

As the OP says, the mini budget is designed to incentivise people to work and businesses to set up here. That can only be a good thing.

Only if there is, at the very least, a very high chance of achieving that. The government simply hasn't put in place the necessary spadework and preliminary measures to make that happen. Plus that fails to take into account the fact that we are in a cost of living crisis which simply cannot just be ignored in the hope of jam tomorrow.

CurseOfBigness · 30/09/2022 00:22

Appleandoranges · 29/09/2022 23:28

The idea that these tax cuts will somehow increase people's incentives enough to generate 2.5 % sustainable growth is unbelievable! More likely it will be inflationary leading Bank of England to raise interest rates and increase likelihood of really high mortgage interest payments in the future

I just read: “New research by the Tony Blair Institute for Global Change suggested new Budget will make economy just 0.4 per cent larger by 2027 than without tax cuts.”

Is sacrifice to the lives of the general public worth it?

No.

Blimpop · 29/09/2022 23:58

There is so much misinformation and self generated guff on this thread. I wish people would actually research what they nonsense they spout.

SheilaWilde · 29/09/2022 23:53

Mark Carney doesn't agree with you. I don't know either of you but I'm going to go with him and the IMF.
I'm guessing you're not working 40 plus hours in a minimum wage job just to try and stand still (and not managing the inevitable slide backwards into debt/hunger/being cold).

Appleandoranges · 29/09/2022 23:28

The idea that these tax cuts will somehow increase people's incentives enough to generate 2.5 % sustainable growth is unbelievable! More likely it will be inflationary leading Bank of England to raise interest rates and increase likelihood of really high mortgage interest payments in the future

Notonthestairs · 29/09/2022 23:26

"The budget makes sense if it is backed by big infrastructure spending and business investment."

"Speculation swirling Chancellor might cut planned state capital spending (rather than day-to-day spending) to try to reassure markets.

State investment set to rise to around £70bn a year - big increase.

If taken back to 2010-19 average of £40bn would yield around £30bn...👇

important to note that most economists would argue that this - infrastructure spending etc - is precisely the wrong spending to cut if goal is to boost UK supply side & future productivity growth."

twitter.com/benchu_/status/1575469526157762564?s=46&t=5EvLXTupsKhHlp1BTOabDg

TeaKlaxon · 29/09/2022 23:26

A woman on Question Time just now had been offered a first time mortgage at a rate of 4.5% After Friday, that was withdrawn and the best she can now get is 10.4%.

For context, on a £250k mortgage that would take her monthly repayments from £1400 to £2400. Now she will almost certainly not be able to buy a home.

Appleandoranges · 29/09/2022 23:18

A cut in additional rate for the highest income earners means Bank of England will have to raise interest rates higher to clamp down on inflation. This will affect all homeowners who pay a mortgage, and also mean Govt will have to pay more interest on its own debt. Collapse in UK gilt market that followed (prob because markets believed that debt was unsustainable) led to near collapse of pension funds which required Bank of England intervention again funded by the tax payer. Also to make debt sustainable there will be cuts in public services, possibly less public sector investment and a possible reduction in universal credits for the poorest at a time of cost of living crisis. So additional cut in taxes for higher income earners is to be possibly somewhat funded by benefit cuts for the poorest and lower public investment. Hard to belive that's going to lead to higher incentives and 2.5 per cent economic growth. The markets don't believe it. The £ tanked. Why should we? On a more positive note subsidising energy prices for everyone was a necessary policy which they got that right!

CurseOfBigness · 29/09/2022 23:15

ChillyFloss · 29/09/2022 23:08

Maybe supply side reform will squeeze out zombie companies which have been such a drag on the UK economy for so long (China recently did something similar I think). Truss is pretty focused on improving the UKs (shockingly low) productivity. Worrying that the markets and the IMF are so concerned about the latest policy announcements though😕

You’re giving Truss a lot of credit to assume she knows what she’s doing. Her economic policy comes from her ideology and beliefs more than anything else.

I agree with improving productivity… but I’m not convinced that Truss knows how to achieve that.

Trickle down economics is a lazy way to be the next Thatcher. The policy has never worked before. Why would it work with Truss?

ChillyFloss · 29/09/2022 23:08

Maybe supply side reform will squeeze out zombie companies which have been such a drag on the UK economy for so long (China recently did something similar I think). Truss is pretty focused on improving the UKs (shockingly low) productivity. Worrying that the markets and the IMF are so concerned about the latest policy announcements though😕

CurseOfBigness · 29/09/2022 23:01

Skidaramink · 29/09/2022 22:10

Completely agree. I am a higher rate tax earner. Before the budget announcement, I was seriously considering going part-time because I only got half of what I actually earned after tax (and I work bloody hard in a difficult and stressful job). Now with the reduction to 40% and the reversal of the NIC increase, I will stick out full-time work a bit longer ~until Labour get in and whack it back up~.

I still pay a very large amount of tax so it pisses me off when people call it a “handout” to the rich. It’s not a handout, it’s being allowed to keep of a little bit more of the money I EARN.

As the OP says, the mini budget is designed to incentivise people to work and businesses to set up here. That can only be a good thing.

You’ve earned the privilege to work part time and still earn a good salary.

Other jobs (essential workers included) that are equally stressful and hard work don’t get the luxury of your position because the pay isn’t competitive enough.

It’s just a game really. You played it well to get into the higher tax bracket and have the luxury of choosing part time. Count yourself lucky…

CPL593H · 29/09/2022 22:51

Skidaramink · 29/09/2022 22:10

Completely agree. I am a higher rate tax earner. Before the budget announcement, I was seriously considering going part-time because I only got half of what I actually earned after tax (and I work bloody hard in a difficult and stressful job). Now with the reduction to 40% and the reversal of the NIC increase, I will stick out full-time work a bit longer ~until Labour get in and whack it back up~.

I still pay a very large amount of tax so it pisses me off when people call it a “handout” to the rich. It’s not a handout, it’s being allowed to keep of a little bit more of the money I EARN.

As the OP says, the mini budget is designed to incentivise people to work and businesses to set up here. That can only be a good thing.

Yes, because only higher rate tax payers work hard in difficult and stressful jobs, not firefighters/nurses/carers/paramedics and the rest of the endless list without whom society would collapse. Tax cuts will impact on that (already inadequate) funding for them.

These same people pay the same prices for petrol, food and heating their homes as the "higher bracket" taxpayer. They just have less money to do it with and certainly won't have the option of going part time if they want to survive.

This shouldn't even need saying.