Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jokes - are they a thing of the past?

219 replies

WhenDanMetHelen · 29/09/2022 00:48

Growing up in the 1960’s … humour was all around but nowadays it’s difficult because it’s based on different parameters that can’t touch on stereotypes etc …

Modern day examples sound funny but apart from the World’s Funniest Joke (as told by Monty Python) it was so funny that everyone who read it, allegedly died laughing, a lot of comedy we’re told is funny - just isn’t -

I read a joke online last week;
If you go into a bathroom as an American and Come out of the bathroom as an American … What are you while you’re in the bathroom?

ANSWER:
European!

What kind of jokes (these days) make you laugh?

OP posts:
Lunabun · 29/09/2022 13:33

Agrudge · 29/09/2022 12:50

MORE BOB MONKHOUSE:

"The last time I was in Spain I got through six Jeffrey Archer novels. I must remember to take enough toilet paper next time." "Personally, I don't think there's intelligent life on other planets. Why should other planets be any different from this one?" "I can still enjoy sex at 74 - I live at 75, so it's no distance." "People always say: 'You're a comedian, tell us a joke.' They don't say: 'You're an MP, tell us a lie.' “What do gardeners do when they retire?"

maybe these are funny when they are being told by a comedian. They dont sound funny when being read

Also none of these examples would get a comedian "cancelled". It's hardly controversial humour, is it?

Jibbajabba1 · 29/09/2022 13:21

Is it being suggested that some posters are irked that racist jokes aren’t as socially acceptable as they used to be?

Jibbajabba1 · 29/09/2022 13:17

@ChelseaRobertsofMalibu
We were talking about friends and father ted.

YouSirNeighMmmm · 29/09/2022 13:11

I've been watching Love Thy Neighbour for the first time recently.

I have reservations about the extent to which it was probably watched by people who were laughing along at the white racists "hilarious" racist jokes. But a lot of the humour comes from laughing at the stupidity of the racists. eg the main (white) character ending up arrested for dancing naked around a tree in the middle of the night because he's been tricked into thinking that he put a voodoo curse on his black neighbour and that's the only way to reverse it. Even back then a lot of the racist comedy was not really racist.

For what it's worth I have been watching it along with a black american man who does a lot of reactions to old british TV (rising damp, in sickness and in health, steptoe and son etc). Obviously you can;t go round being racist and saying it's ok because you found one black person who agrees with you... but there's a real risk that white people get over-sensitive and fail to listen to the opinion of minorities when it comes to what is acceptable or not.

YouSirNeighMmmm · 29/09/2022 13:04

bicyclesaredeathtraps · 29/09/2022 12:55

Um yeah, if I make a joke about my own disability, it's okay to laugh. Usually I'm making fun of "certain attitudes".

Serious question. You are out with a group of friends and some of their friends you don't know. You make a joke about your disability, and someone in the group you don't know says that they have a hidden disability and that they found your joke incredibly offensive. Or what if someone else is offended because it reminds them of the jokes mocking their sibling when they were a teenager?

To what extent does your disability give you a free pass, and to what extent do other people have a right to silence you because it offends them?

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 29/09/2022 13:01

Jibbajabba1 · 29/09/2022 12:03

urm - I’m confused. All the shows you’re claiming wouldn’t get made today, are still available to watch. Even Roy chubby brown is still touring - if that’s your cup of tea. So what is it that you apparently can’t say anymore?

All the racist jokes have been removed from Only Fools & Horses. I can think of one which has been permanently edited out of one episode which I can’t even quote on here because it's that bad

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 29/09/2022 12:58

KILM · 29/09/2022 09:04

Ah yes, the classic 'you cant joke about anything any more'
There is a thriving comedy circuit in the UK full of acts making audiences laugh every single night without being offensive.
Glad that Tim Vine has already been mentioned - a great example of someone who writes very clever, funny material without needing to punch down or rely on outdated stereotypes.
There is a whole wide world out there, and people find joy and humour everywhere - if you need to resort to punching down, or using outdated stereotypes, then you just arent that good of a comedian.
And dont come at me about the old greats as obviously we had some very funny people who mixed in with some great material had some horrible stuff.
I mean today, right now, comedians on the circuit know full well making misogynistic jokes isnt okay, as its 2022. So making jokes about that instead of one of the billions of other topics available is just laziness or lack of ability.

THIS!!!!!

bicyclesaredeathtraps · 29/09/2022 12:55

Agrudge · 29/09/2022 12:46

It's ok to laugh when they make jokes then ? Is it still promoting certain attitudes?

I laugh about white people, and Britain's historical atrocities. Oh sorry I forgot white people are fair game for everyone my mistake.

P.s I never said racists joke were fine

Um yeah, if I make a joke about my own disability, it's okay to laugh. Usually I'm making fun of "certain attitudes".

Agrudge · 29/09/2022 12:50

MORE BOB MONKHOUSE:

"The last time I was in Spain I got through six Jeffrey Archer novels. I must remember to take enough toilet paper next time." "Personally, I don't think there's intelligent life on other planets. Why should other planets be any different from this one?" "I can still enjoy sex at 74 - I live at 75, so it's no distance." "People always say: 'You're a comedian, tell us a joke.' They don't say: 'You're an MP, tell us a lie.' “What do gardeners do when they retire?"

maybe these are funny when they are being told by a comedian. They dont sound funny when being read

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 29/09/2022 12:50

AirFryerNinja · 29/09/2022 04:16

@Confusion101 I agree.
I find people under the age of Forty to be humourless and dour.
They look for offence in absolutely everything.
Can't say this, can't joke about that. Oh fuck off!
Drives me mad.

I disagree with under 40! I'd say under 30. I was born in 84' and grew up watching Only Fools & Horses, One Foot in the Grave, Porridge & Roseanne etc! I'm more than familiar with a good laugh 😂

Agrudge · 29/09/2022 12:46

bicyclesaredeathtraps · 29/09/2022 11:50

Good to know you're spouting an opinion on something you've never experienced then.
The thing is, it's not "just jokes". Ableist jokes promote ableist attitudes, racist jokes promote racist attitudes, sexist jokes promote sexist attitudes, and so on. They show people that it's "okay" to demean people because they're different. This leads to marginalised groups being shut out of society, very literally.

Come back when you've been sworn at in public for using a wheelchair.
Or when you've been beaten up for daring to wear makeup as a gay man.
Or when you've listened as family members have been told you have no free will or agency, because you can't speak.

All things that have happened, recently, to me and my friends and family.

Then tell me that it's okay to make fun of people for being different.

It's ok to laugh when they make jokes then ? Is it still promoting certain attitudes?

I laugh about white people, and Britain's historical atrocities. Oh sorry I forgot white people are fair game for everyone my mistake.

P.s I never said racists joke were fine

Jibbajabba1 · 29/09/2022 12:34

@pfs
so you actual issue is that some people don’t like friends and complain about it online? Just like you’re complaining about types of humour that aren’t to your taste online?

bicyclesaredeathtraps · 29/09/2022 12:31

YouSirNeighMmmm · 29/09/2022 12:09

But a joke is not automatically racist because it involves race. How do we determine whether a joke is offensive or not?

What if a groupd of black people are telling each other 1970s racist jokes as a way of mocking the stupidity of old school racists - they are laughing at the idea that the joke could be funny, laughing at their incredible superiority to the sort of mindset that thinks the joke funny. Is that racist?

Jokes work or fail dependent on the comedian, their persona, the situation in which the joke is made (eg the same joke may be 100% fine in a lesbian comedy club but at the Royal Variety performance it would be a bigoted car crash), the audience and their expectations.

Some subjects, like disability, are best to avoided unless you are disabled or you are an INCREDIBLY talented comedian who has REALLY thought the joke through.

I think of a list of subjects unsuitable for comedy as a list of things that I shouldn't make jokes about... but are probably the subjects of some of the best jokes when done incredibly well by incredible comedians in the right context.

Sometimes a joke can be deeply offensive when told by one person to an audience who laugh along, but hilarious if told by another who laugh at the idea that anyone could be so backward thinking that they would make such a joke in 2022.

Frankie Boyle style shock value has a place, though Boyle's particular schtik is getting pretty fucking tired now, and some things he says and doe are terrible (but then again, the odd terrible joke from a comedian is a proce worth paying for good comedy, most adult comedians take risks, and if you take risks you will make mistakes, and whilst I love some truly harmless comedy - tim vine one liners may be a good example - a bit of an edge is preferable as a rule.

If I tell a really dark joke about cancer as a way of coping with a relative's passing am I a bad person?

I said in a different post that a member of a marginalised group making a joke about their own group is very different to someone outside that group making the same joke, so I agree with you there.
I make jokes about my disability all the time, because it's my own experience and if you didn't laugh you'd cry. Doesn't mean I want non-disabled comedians to make disabled people the butt of their jokes!

Lunabun · 29/09/2022 12:30

I think old people just find punching down funny, whereas most people today don't 🤷‍♀️

Sometimessometime · 29/09/2022 12:20

My parents made the same complaints in the 80s (because they were working class and enjoyed the likes of Alf Garnett). It was ever thus. I didn't find their idea of comedy funny, they thought Ben Elton and his chums (which I adored) was unfunny filth.

WhenDanMetHelen · 29/09/2022 12:20

I started this thread to give people an opportunity to have a laugh - I rather feel as though we’re drifting down the usual “analyse every single word in case it’s ‘woke’ or a further opportunity for ‘cancel culturalists’ - to stop this open discussion in case we laugh about something we shouldn’t be laughing at!!!

Lighten Up everyone - it’s great to be alive!!!

MORE BOB MONKHOUSE:

"The last time I was in Spain I got through six Jeffrey Archer novels. I must remember to take enough toilet paper next time." "Personally, I don't think there's intelligent life on other planets. Why should other planets be any different from this one?" "I can still enjoy sex at 74 - I live at 75, so it's no distance." "People always say: 'You're a comedian, tell us a joke.' They don't say: 'You're an MP, tell us a lie.' “What do gardeners do when they retire?"

source: www.jokes4us.com/peoplejokes/comedianjokes/bobmonkhousejokes.html

OP posts:
KTKismet · 29/09/2022 12:20

Best comedian is hands down Billy Connolly!! The way he tells a story!!

Honourable mentions to Rhod Gilbert and Reginald D Hunter that I saw many moons ago at the Fringe and were hilarious!

Friends is funny... Yes the jokes land differently now because people seem to look to be offended these days!! Me on the other hand... I'm fine, I'm totally fine! 😂😂 Love friends!

pfs · 29/09/2022 12:12

urm - I’m confused. All the shows you’re claiming wouldn’t get made today, are still available to watch

they are available to watch because their peak days are gone, look at the new shows on mainstream today-do they make the same style of jokes? No because in today's pc culture they can't. Most of the non pc jokes now are reserved for less mainstream stuff like southpark, family guy etc.

I've seen umpteen articles on friends aging badly and being offensive this last decade, I've seen it on mn and across other media.

YouSirNeighMmmm · 29/09/2022 12:09

bicyclesaredeathtraps · 29/09/2022 11:50

Good to know you're spouting an opinion on something you've never experienced then.
The thing is, it's not "just jokes". Ableist jokes promote ableist attitudes, racist jokes promote racist attitudes, sexist jokes promote sexist attitudes, and so on. They show people that it's "okay" to demean people because they're different. This leads to marginalised groups being shut out of society, very literally.

Come back when you've been sworn at in public for using a wheelchair.
Or when you've been beaten up for daring to wear makeup as a gay man.
Or when you've listened as family members have been told you have no free will or agency, because you can't speak.

All things that have happened, recently, to me and my friends and family.

Then tell me that it's okay to make fun of people for being different.

But a joke is not automatically racist because it involves race. How do we determine whether a joke is offensive or not?

What if a groupd of black people are telling each other 1970s racist jokes as a way of mocking the stupidity of old school racists - they are laughing at the idea that the joke could be funny, laughing at their incredible superiority to the sort of mindset that thinks the joke funny. Is that racist?

Jokes work or fail dependent on the comedian, their persona, the situation in which the joke is made (eg the same joke may be 100% fine in a lesbian comedy club but at the Royal Variety performance it would be a bigoted car crash), the audience and their expectations.

Some subjects, like disability, are best to avoided unless you are disabled or you are an INCREDIBLY talented comedian who has REALLY thought the joke through.

I think of a list of subjects unsuitable for comedy as a list of things that I shouldn't make jokes about... but are probably the subjects of some of the best jokes when done incredibly well by incredible comedians in the right context.

Sometimes a joke can be deeply offensive when told by one person to an audience who laugh along, but hilarious if told by another who laugh at the idea that anyone could be so backward thinking that they would make such a joke in 2022.

Frankie Boyle style shock value has a place, though Boyle's particular schtik is getting pretty fucking tired now, and some things he says and doe are terrible (but then again, the odd terrible joke from a comedian is a proce worth paying for good comedy, most adult comedians take risks, and if you take risks you will make mistakes, and whilst I love some truly harmless comedy - tim vine one liners may be a good example - a bit of an edge is preferable as a rule.

If I tell a really dark joke about cancer as a way of coping with a relative's passing am I a bad person?

Jibbajabba1 · 29/09/2022 12:03

urm - I’m confused. All the shows you’re claiming wouldn’t get made today, are still available to watch. Even Roy chubby brown is still touring - if that’s your cup of tea. So what is it that you apparently can’t say anymore?

InPraiseOfBacchus · 29/09/2022 11:58

I'd accuse OP of dog-whistle rhetoric, but this is just... a regular whistle.

'member the past?
'member when you could be racist?
Weren't it marvellous?

Brefugee · 29/09/2022 11:58

Please can I ask how many of those marginalised groups you're a part of yourself?
zero.

@Agrudge lucky you. I have been in marginalised groups and the but of relentless horrible "jokes" and "banter". Rape jokes galore. Oh how we laughed. Not. Often not in a position (lowly private, sergeants and above making the "jokes") to complain or do anything other than suffer along until it stopped.

And so on.

So lucky you. And lucky us that we are now able to say "STFU" to rape jokes, racist jokes, homophobic jokes etc etc. (apparently not jokes against middle aged women but i have hope)

Brefugee · 29/09/2022 11:56

Ok on friends there were lots of gay jokes-think chandler's dad, chandler and the jokes about ross's ex wife. They'd not go down well today. Also there were loads of fat jokes about younger monica and then people would see characters like Joey or Sam from Cheers as being jock type studs/womanizers as being misogynistic and promoting it to women.

ok @pfs all of these things have been repeatedly mentioned here and elsewhere, since about the time they were aired, as being a) not hugely funny and b) problematic because of subject matter.
Monica is hilarious because she used to be fat and therefore hideous and now she's thin she's gorgeous -but she is still a judgy controling person. Hilarious. My ribs hurt

etc etc

And yet: there are still jokes, tropes and memes making fun of fat people. Now more than ever, i'd argue. they are still not funny. And now we recognise the damage constant bullying of this kind causes.

So in effect all the people saying: "wah wah we can't tell jokes any more wah wah" are saying that they're sad they can't bully, say, fat people into an eating disorder. slow handclap

these are the kind of thing Bob Monkhouse used to tell. Or even Des O'Connor. (speaking of whom: he was the butt of plenty of Morcombe and Wise jokes. The payoff being, they came off as being a little bit mean, he laughed and usually had the upper hand in the end. Bantz that he went along with. Nothing wrong with any of that)

inews.co.uk/light-relief/jokes/tim-vine-best-jokes-and-one-liners-88044?ico=in-line_link

pfs · 29/09/2022 11:51

And yet Friends is still very frequently repeated on TV. So clearly it's not true at all that you can't say anything anymore as a show that was full of sexist, homophobic and ableist references is still showing on TV today and high street shops still sell Friends merchandise

ofcourse they are and so are the shows I mentioned but they get a free pass as they are classics now much like many older films/shows, if they were to be done in new mainstream shows these days they'd be pulled up on it. Friends constantly gets criticized online by new generations for its lack of pc culture.

Even the new James Bond films James has to be more respectful to the women but it doesn't stopped the old films being played on tv. The old films do get criticised though for it over the media.

bicyclesaredeathtraps · 29/09/2022 11:50

Agrudge · 29/09/2022 11:39

Please can I ask how many of those marginalised groups you're a part of yourself?

zero.

I dont believe:

Only black comedians can make black jokes
Only disabled people can make disability jokes
Only gay comedians can make gay jokes
And so on

No one should be bubble wrapped incase they get hurt feelings . They are just jokes and not meant to be taken seriously

Good to know you're spouting an opinion on something you've never experienced then.
The thing is, it's not "just jokes". Ableist jokes promote ableist attitudes, racist jokes promote racist attitudes, sexist jokes promote sexist attitudes, and so on. They show people that it's "okay" to demean people because they're different. This leads to marginalised groups being shut out of society, very literally.

Come back when you've been sworn at in public for using a wheelchair.
Or when you've been beaten up for daring to wear makeup as a gay man.
Or when you've listened as family members have been told you have no free will or agency, because you can't speak.

All things that have happened, recently, to me and my friends and family.

Then tell me that it's okay to make fun of people for being different.

Swipe left for the next trending thread