Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that chest binders are harmful to children and shouldn't be encouraged?

183 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 29/09/2022 00:29

Trans charity accused of offering chest binders without parental consent

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/37b9fc6e-3d8b-11ed-b24d-96120f17513d?shareToken=b62ae7a914c919bf911bb69f54455fe8

How did we get to this point that people are saying this is brave and cheering it on?

AIBU - to think it's insanity
YABU - it's "lifesaving" and rainbow unicorns

OP posts:
ISaySteadyOn · 29/09/2022 06:46

Utterly wrong. There is no safe way to bind. And I find it very sad that some girls find the prospect of womanhood so awful that they feel a need to do this.

Ravensclawdropout · 29/09/2022 02:32

It's complete child abuse. Those under 18 just have no concept of the long term affects this will have. Hard to believe this is happening in the 21st century in western nations! Anyone promoting this to children should be arrested and charged with GBH.

NitroNine · 29/09/2022 02:06

YANBU.

Last year a small study was published in the journal Pediatrics - & the findings of “Time to First Onset of Chest Binding–Related Symptoms in Transgender Youth” make it abundantly clear it is a harmful practice. The study did not seek to determine which methods were used to bind - there is, however, a (sadly not open-access) 2015 paper titled Health impact of chest binding among transgender adults: a community-engaged, cross-sectional study which has looked at a whole range of methods used, including binders, & it found they cause harm.

Wearing a binder, even “correctly” could literally kill a girl with asthma. The BLF mortality stats are now a decade old, but they point out that while 1,200 deaths/year from asthma might sound low; with the treatments now available for asthma, it should be close to 0. Almost 2/3 of those who die each year are female. In 2018, 7% of girls aged 0 - 15 in England had asthma (levels similar across UK but I don’t have stats) - 12% of 10-12yos & 8% of 13-15yos, so it is hardly unlikely for Mermaids to have sent a binder to a child who has asthma. If you’ve never had an asthma attack, try putting a swimming clip on your nose, then running up several flights of stairs carrying a 10kg or so rucksack, breathing through a straw.

They have no way to safely provide the binders because - as demonstrated by the article - they don’t know to whom they’re actually going. They don’t know the child begging for one in secret has managed to measure herself correctly. They are providing this item with apparently no thought as to how it will be kept clean (just because we can accidentally create novel bacterial & fungal infections doesn’t mean we should) nor recognition, crucially, of the fact that you can send the binder with a wee bit of paper about The Rules and make girls [pinky-]promise to keep them before you agree to send them a binder, but that means nothing at all. It’s a flimsy bit of flim-flam trying to convince everyone it’s a safeguarding measure.

Cheekymaw · 29/09/2022 01:13

It's horrific. Jail the b*stards.

HerRoyalNotness · 29/09/2022 01:03

Sickening

Redbushteaforme · 29/09/2022 00:54

Teenage girls questioning their gender are being told this is a valid option for them. It is horrendous.

BoreOfWhabylon · 29/09/2022 00:40

YANBU

WandaWomblesaurus · 29/09/2022 00:39

www.met.police.uk/advice/advice-and-information/caa/child-abuse/breast-ironing-flattening/

The metropolitan police say that:

"Breast ironing (also called breast flattening) is when young girls' breasts are damaged over time to flatten them and delay their development. Sometimes, an elastic belt, or binder, is used to stop them from growing.

Breast ironing usually starts with the first signs of puberty and is most often done by female relatives. In most cases, the abuser incorrectly thinks they're behaving in the best interests of the child. They believe flattening the breasts will make the child less 'womanly'. They hope this will protect the girl from harassment, rape, abduction and early forced marriage, and help them stay in education.
Breast ironing can cause serious physical issues such as:
• abscesses (a painful collection of pus that develops under the skin)
• cysts (fluid-filled lumps under the skin that can develop into abscesses)
• itching
• tissue damage
• infection
• discharge of milk
• breasts becoming significantly different shapes or sizes
• severe fever
• the complete disappearance of one or both breasts"

So how is Mermaids charity, Lush and other getting away with giving these to children in secret?

OP posts: