Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that chest binders are harmful to children and shouldn't be encouraged?

183 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 29/09/2022 00:29

Trans charity accused of offering chest binders without parental consent

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/37b9fc6e-3d8b-11ed-b24d-96120f17513d?shareToken=b62ae7a914c919bf911bb69f54455fe8

How did we get to this point that people are saying this is brave and cheering it on?

AIBU - to think it's insanity
YABU - it's "lifesaving" and rainbow unicorns

OP posts:
Mummyoflittledragon · 02/10/2022 07:32

takeme0uttonight · 02/10/2022 05:55

These threads always make me laugh, because they do nothing except serve the image of tiny minded Mumsnetty-ness. I may no longer be with him, but my ex partner was more of a man than 99% of your tiny dicked, shiftless, horrible husbands.

My partner never wanted to go into the woman's changing rooms to perv on women, all he wanted was to be accepted in the men's room.

He went through almost 7 years of brutal, invasive treatment, and his knowledge that he'd been born in the wrong body never wavered. It wasn't a fashion statement, it wasn't a fad, it was who he was.

He was on a nationwide tv show (a dating show, no less) and nobody knew the difference between him and a "cis male"

What do you mean in your second paragraph about your ex going into women’s changing rooms? Has anyone on this thread said this happens?

WhereTheFuckIsMyFuckingCoat · 02/10/2022 07:26

With all due respect, @takeme0uttonight - unless your ex was one of the very few (statistically) members of the population who were born with an intersex condition (or Disorders of Sex Development "DSDs" as they are otherwise known), then they weren't born in the wrong body, as there's no such thing.

If however they were born with DSD, and were (possibly as I suspect, owing to the language you use) "categorised" wrongly - I.e., indistinguishable genitalia which was categorised and purposely developed to be female, when it was later discovered that they had male chromosomes and/or male internal reproductive organs, then yes, they would/could be stated to be living in the "wrong sex" body. However if that is the case then your argument is disingenuous, because they wouldn't be classed as what we know as trans - they were born with a medical/genetic abnormality, which was being medically corrected.

If what you are claiming, they were simply born female and transitioned to identifying as male, then no amount of transitional surgery/hormones or otherwise will change their skeletal form, which would, despite what you say, be detected at autopsy or examination by a forensic pathologist as an adult human female, and that is if it was only the skeleton remaining and they didn't also have internal organs to go by.

Doesn't matter how many people can't tell that they weren't born male by looking at them in person, or on a tv show, doesn't change that they are biologically female and always will be. And it's not wrong, or nasty or small minded to say so.

Also, and I apologise for the length of my post, but from the NHS website, no hormonal or medical treatment will be undertaken on a child before they are at the very earliest approaching puberty, far less at age 7/8 (psychological and psychiatric input will however be provided):

Hormone therapy in children and young people
Some young people with lasting signs of gender dysphoria who meet strict criteria may be referred to a hormone specialist (consultant endocrinologist) to see if they can take hormone blockers as they reach puberty. This is in addition to psychological support.

And yes, it is degrading and insulting to call other people's male partners derogatory names, in spite of the number of people moaning about their "feckless men" on this site. The minute you start calling people's partners "small dicked", or whatever it was, you've lost the argument by highlighting your immaturity.

There's really no relevance to why your partner is now your ex, it adds nothing to this discussion, so I don't think my gas is going to be at a peep any time soon.

sashh · 02/10/2022 07:04

He is, as far as I'm aware, happy. However, you're wrong when you say if he was dug up that he'd be "categorised" as female - from age 7/8, he went through treatment. Every single part of his body changed. Beyond appearing on the tv, multiple articles/studies have been done about him, because he was one of the first individuals to go through the extent of treatment he did on the NHS. I'll happily DM you the links to the articles. By the end of the treatment (and as his partner at the time, witnessed the extent of it) you'd never know the "difference".

Sorry but all those changes are cosmetic. There is a guy that has used extensive procedures to look like a cat, he is still a man.

Differences between men and women include:

Different lung capacity
Different genitalia
Different types of muscle
Different reproductive organs
Different bone structure
Different chromosomes

takeme0uttonight · 02/10/2022 06:41

@WhereTheFuckIsMyFuckingCoat

Interesting points you raise. However, you're wrong on several points.

He didn't "think" or indeed "feel" he was born in the wrong body. He WAS born in the wrong body. He knew from the age of 7/8 he wasn't "categorised" right. The NHS treated him from age 7/8.

He is, as far as I'm aware, happy. However, you're wrong when you say if he was dug up that he'd be "categorised" as female - from age 7/8, he went through treatment. Every single part of his body changed. Beyond appearing on the tv, multiple articles/studies have been done about him, because he was one of the first individuals to go through the extent of treatment he did on the NHS. I'll happily DM you the links to the articles. By the end of the treatment (and as his partner at the time, witnessed the extent of it) you'd never know the "difference".

As for what you say about "demeaning" other peoples "male" partners, I disagree. This site is full of posts day upon day about useless, shiftless men. My partner at the time stepped up to every single male "stereotype", because he knew what was expected of a woman. He knew what box society placed us in, and he fulfilled it and more.

If you knew why he was my ex partner, your gas would be at a peep.

WhereTheFuckIsMyFuckingCoat · 02/10/2022 06:05

takeme0uttonight · 02/10/2022 05:55

These threads always make me laugh, because they do nothing except serve the image of tiny minded Mumsnetty-ness. I may no longer be with him, but my ex partner was more of a man than 99% of your tiny dicked, shiftless, horrible husbands.

My partner never wanted to go into the woman's changing rooms to perv on women, all he wanted was to be accepted in the men's room.

He went through almost 7 years of brutal, invasive treatment, and his knowledge that he'd been born in the wrong body never wavered. It wasn't a fashion statement, it wasn't a fad, it was who he was.

He was on a nationwide tv show (a dating show, no less) and nobody knew the difference between him and a "cis male"

Your ex partner thought/felt they were born in the wrong body. But they weren't, because genetically and biologically it's not possible.

I'm glad they are now happy, and "pass", as ultimately, everyone deserves to be happy. But it doesn't take away from the fact that they are biologically female, have been since they were born, and will be until they die.

If they want to live as a male, and go through the required hormones, counselling, surgeries etc etc to allow them to do that (live presenting as male) comfortably, then that is indeed their prerogative, but what they can't do is change reality.

If they were buried somewhere and dug up by forensic archaeologists in years to come, when their skeletal remains were examined, it would be determined (due to bone length, density, pelvic shape, skull and dental formation amongst other things), that they were an adult human female.

There's nothing small minded or nasty or discriminatory about saying that, it's just fact.

Demeaning other peoples male partners as derogatory names, on the other hand, stinks of meanness and small mindedness.

It's ok to be fully supportive of your ex's feelings and experiences, while it's also ok to state true biological fact. No hate or nastiness required.

takeme0uttonight · 02/10/2022 05:59

stillvicarinatutu · 02/10/2022 05:58

This is assault . Child abuse . Who is sanctioning this absolute traversty?

The NHS?

stillvicarinatutu · 02/10/2022 05:58

This is assault . Child abuse . Who is sanctioning this absolute traversty?

takeme0uttonight · 02/10/2022 05:55

These threads always make me laugh, because they do nothing except serve the image of tiny minded Mumsnetty-ness. I may no longer be with him, but my ex partner was more of a man than 99% of your tiny dicked, shiftless, horrible husbands.

My partner never wanted to go into the woman's changing rooms to perv on women, all he wanted was to be accepted in the men's room.

He went through almost 7 years of brutal, invasive treatment, and his knowledge that he'd been born in the wrong body never wavered. It wasn't a fashion statement, it wasn't a fad, it was who he was.

He was on a nationwide tv show (a dating show, no less) and nobody knew the difference between him and a "cis male"

takeme0uttonight · 02/10/2022 05:47

@Rainbowshit yaaaaawn

takeme0uttonight · 02/10/2022 05:47

MorningPlatypus · 02/10/2022 05:43

YANBU.

I'd like to add that there is no such thing as being born in the wrong body. We should be working with people to help them accept their own healthy bodies, instead of encouraging them to hurt themselves in pursuit of an unattainable ideal

There is absolutely such a thing as being born in the wrong body.

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 02/10/2022 05:46

BeeRogue · 29/09/2022 13:03

The point made is that she doesn't know the difference...

It literally is the same as wearing a tight non-wired bra. Many women do wear breast binders instead of bras. In fact, many breast binders are bras that have been re-marketed (i.e. the same exact product in different packaging).

Are you a man? You seem not to know about bras..........................................

Rainbowshit · 02/10/2022 05:44

ChagSameachDoreen · 02/10/2022 05:27

1) 7 years ago, I got a breast reduction. My breasts, the things that apparently make me 'interently female' were making me ill. Does that make me less of a woman?

No. But that doesn't change the fact that teenage girls having their breasts removed is a travesty.

2) There are safe ways to bind, which I was taught by, god forbid, the NHS, following my reduction, to keep all the requisite bits in place

There are not safe ways to bind young growing breast tissue. Post-surgery wound healing is not the issue here.

3) My ex partner was trans. HE wasn't a pervert, or a deviant, or someone who wanted to look at women in changing rooms. He was someone born in the wrong body. He went through all the surgeries, and subsequently appeared on a popular tv show. People thought he'd been male all his life, because weirdly, with enough treatment, you CAN reassign your gender. DM if you want proof of his existence, because it's readily available on YouTube

Your ex-partner exists. Nobody is doubting that. But she is female - was born female and will die female. Her sex will never changed no matter how much surgery she has.

4) As a cis woman myself, I find the idea of being a woman intolerable. Womanhood is mired with harassment, rape, degradation, solitude. Who would want womanhood if they didn't truly feel they were born that way?

Males with fetishes who get off on the degradation.

This. ^

I was going to reply to @takeme0uttonight 's ludicrous post but you have said everything I would have said but better.

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 02/10/2022 05:44

SwordToFlamethrower · 29/09/2022 13:39

My teenage daughter is using binders without my consent, but with the consent of her dad.

I can do nothing about it. It has broken my heart into a million pieces.

Why cant you do anything?

MorningPlatypus · 02/10/2022 05:43

YANBU.

I'd like to add that there is no such thing as being born in the wrong body. We should be working with people to help them accept their own healthy bodies, instead of encouraging them to hurt themselves in pursuit of an unattainable ideal

takeme0uttonight · 02/10/2022 05:33

ChagSameachDoreen · 02/10/2022 05:27

1) 7 years ago, I got a breast reduction. My breasts, the things that apparently make me 'interently female' were making me ill. Does that make me less of a woman?

No. But that doesn't change the fact that teenage girls having their breasts removed is a travesty.

2) There are safe ways to bind, which I was taught by, god forbid, the NHS, following my reduction, to keep all the requisite bits in place

There are not safe ways to bind young growing breast tissue. Post-surgery wound healing is not the issue here.

3) My ex partner was trans. HE wasn't a pervert, or a deviant, or someone who wanted to look at women in changing rooms. He was someone born in the wrong body. He went through all the surgeries, and subsequently appeared on a popular tv show. People thought he'd been male all his life, because weirdly, with enough treatment, you CAN reassign your gender. DM if you want proof of his existence, because it's readily available on YouTube

Your ex-partner exists. Nobody is doubting that. But she is female - was born female and will die female. Her sex will never changed no matter how much surgery she has.

4) As a cis woman myself, I find the idea of being a woman intolerable. Womanhood is mired with harassment, rape, degradation, solitude. Who would want womanhood if they didn't truly feel they were born that way?

Males with fetishes who get off on the degradation.

What a small minded individual you are. Interestingly, your username tells me all I need to know. Have a good evening.

Ahf22 · 02/10/2022 05:31

FrancescaContini · 29/09/2022 13:22

Seriously concerned by the number of posters here minimising the harm done by these things.

I think those posters coming on here and minimising it “nothing to see here” and ludicrously comparing it to sports bras etc are very telling and only serves to them inadvertently highlighting how scandalous this actually is and how brainwashed they’ve become

it’s child abuse plain and simple and those advocating for it are complicit.

ChagSameachDoreen · 02/10/2022 05:27

1) 7 years ago, I got a breast reduction. My breasts, the things that apparently make me 'interently female' were making me ill. Does that make me less of a woman?

No. But that doesn't change the fact that teenage girls having their breasts removed is a travesty.

2) There are safe ways to bind, which I was taught by, god forbid, the NHS, following my reduction, to keep all the requisite bits in place

There are not safe ways to bind young growing breast tissue. Post-surgery wound healing is not the issue here.

3) My ex partner was trans. HE wasn't a pervert, or a deviant, or someone who wanted to look at women in changing rooms. He was someone born in the wrong body. He went through all the surgeries, and subsequently appeared on a popular tv show. People thought he'd been male all his life, because weirdly, with enough treatment, you CAN reassign your gender. DM if you want proof of his existence, because it's readily available on YouTube

Your ex-partner exists. Nobody is doubting that. But she is female - was born female and will die female. Her sex will never changed no matter how much surgery she has.

4) As a cis woman myself, I find the idea of being a woman intolerable. Womanhood is mired with harassment, rape, degradation, solitude. Who would want womanhood if they didn't truly feel they were born that way?

Males with fetishes who get off on the degradation.

sashh · 02/10/2022 04:58

BeeRogue · 29/09/2022 12:53

Just to be clear chest binding and chest ironing aren't the same thing.

One is mutilating someone else's chest with heavy or hot objects, damaging the breast tissue permanently. The other is wrapping your own chest with soft material to reduce the appearance of the breasts. It causes no more physical harm than wearing sports bras - in fact, it causes less harm by distributing the weight more evenly across the back.

Breast ironing is: “the process during which young pubescent girls’ breasts are ironed, massaged, flattened and/or pounded down over a period of time (sometimes years) in order for the breasts to disappear or delay the development of the breasts entirely...large stones, a hammer or spatula that have been heated over scorching coals can be used to compress the breast tissue."

Chest binding is: "the flattening of breasts with constrictive materials such as cloth strips, purpose-built undergarments, often using spandex or other synthetic fiber, and shirts layered from tight to loose...Binders may also be used as alternatives to bras or for reasons of propriety."

Children and trans issues are an entirely separate discussion point but being outraged by your own confusion doesn't help real issues by discussed. Trans people are not engaging in chest ironing.

You are wrong.

But this post will probably be deleted because MNHQ don't like me saying things like that.

takeme0uttonight · 02/10/2022 04:31

ISaySteadyOn · 29/09/2022 06:46

Utterly wrong. There is no safe way to bind. And I find it very sad that some girls find the prospect of womanhood so awful that they feel a need to do this.

Assuming you are a woman, I have a number of points:

  1. 7 years ago, I got a breast reduction. My breasts, the things that apparently make me 'interently female' were making me ill. Does that make me less of a woman?

  2. There are safe ways to bind, which I was taught by, god forbid, the NHS, following my reduction, to keep all the requisite bits in place

  3. My ex partner was trans. HE wasn't a pervert, or a deviant, or someone who wanted to look at women in changing rooms. He was someone born in the wrong body. He went through all the surgeries, and subsequently appeared on a popular tv show. People thought he'd been male all his life, because weirdly, with enough treatment, you CAN reassign your gender. DM if you want proof of his existence, because it's readily available on YouTube

  4. As a cis woman myself, I find the idea of being a woman intolerable. Womanhood is mired with harassment, rape, degradation, solitude. Who would want womanhood if they didn't truly feel they were born that way?

Rainbowshit · 02/10/2022 04:22

I see some idiot has said they are just like sports bras. NO

Sports bras are recommended to alleviate discomfort and breast tissue damage during high impact activities.

Binders are designed to compress Brest tissue to masculinise the chest.and the safety warnings say they are NOT meant to be worn while exercising because they restrict breathing. Side effect is permanent damage to the breast tissue.

They are absolutely NOT the same thing.

FrancescaContini · 02/10/2022 03:15

WandaWomblesaurus · 01/10/2022 12:56

Great article - I love Janice. And I agree with your comment. Why, indeed?

catandcoffee · 01/10/2022 12:59

FeralWitch · 29/09/2022 07:56

It’s like an anorexia-support group sending out laxatives. I’m gobsmacked.

💯 % correct.
when you look at it like this it's so unbelievable wrong.

WandaWomblesaurus · 01/10/2022 12:56

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/time-to-change-the-world-not-girls-bodies-m03n269xf

Why can't we just leave girls bodies alone?

OP posts:
WandaWomblesaurus · 29/09/2022 17:39

BeeRogue · 29/09/2022 12:53

Just to be clear chest binding and chest ironing aren't the same thing.

One is mutilating someone else's chest with heavy or hot objects, damaging the breast tissue permanently. The other is wrapping your own chest with soft material to reduce the appearance of the breasts. It causes no more physical harm than wearing sports bras - in fact, it causes less harm by distributing the weight more evenly across the back.

Breast ironing is: “the process during which young pubescent girls’ breasts are ironed, massaged, flattened and/or pounded down over a period of time (sometimes years) in order for the breasts to disappear or delay the development of the breasts entirely...large stones, a hammer or spatula that have been heated over scorching coals can be used to compress the breast tissue."

Chest binding is: "the flattening of breasts with constrictive materials such as cloth strips, purpose-built undergarments, often using spandex or other synthetic fiber, and shirts layered from tight to loose...Binders may also be used as alternatives to bras or for reasons of propriety."

Children and trans issues are an entirely separate discussion point but being outraged by your own confusion doesn't help real issues by discussed. Trans people are not engaging in chest ironing.

Look at the Met Police definitions above.

Of course there is an end goal. The end goal that gets pushed eventually along with the breast binding you are attempting to minimise.

They are engaging in encouraging double mastectomies and rebranding it as "top surgery"

Big cheer! Rainbows! Magic!

OP posts:
FirstandLastBorn · 29/09/2022 14:41

YANBU

Adults and organisations encouraging this are despicable.