Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that chest binders are harmful to children and shouldn't be encouraged?

183 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 29/09/2022 00:29

Trans charity accused of offering chest binders without parental consent

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/37b9fc6e-3d8b-11ed-b24d-96120f17513d?shareToken=b62ae7a914c919bf911bb69f54455fe8

How did we get to this point that people are saying this is brave and cheering it on?

AIBU - to think it's insanity
YABU - it's "lifesaving" and rainbow unicorns

OP posts:
takeme0uttonight · 02/10/2022 08:14

@LaughingPriest

All of them, of course 😂

He was very strongly of the opinion that he needed his body to match how he felt - societal views of the masculine body gave him something to aim for.

I've sadly no answer to your second question - I've not spoken to him for a very long time, but I imagine he'd be as open to the idea of gender as a non-exclusive construct as he was about everything else.

LaughingPriest · 02/10/2022 08:09

takeme0uttonight · 02/10/2022 08:04

@LaughingPriest this is the first remotely sensible thing I've seen all night

Which post (all of them, obviously Grin)

Genuinely am curious though about my first question - Presumably (do correct if I'm wrong) he was very strongly of the opinion that men have male bodies and women have female bodies? (I.e. men are flat-chested, etc)

What does he make of the current view that you can be either gender regardless of your body - that physical sex is separate from gender, gender is a feeling, therefore women can be (and can be indistinguishable from) male-bodied people?

takeme0uttonight · 02/10/2022 08:08

@Rapidtango even female born individuals can have sexual feelings towards another women. Heaven FORBID you were in the same changing room as a lesbian, imagine if they peeked around the curtain.

He's my ex boyfriend because I got cancer and neither of us coped with it well. Does that work for you?

Also, 93% of trans men start with sports bras, because binders are 60% more expensive.

Knittingmonster · 02/10/2022 08:06

@takeme0uttonight so she’s in a relationship with a straight bloke taking advantage of a vulnerable girl with obvious mental health issues. Again, the poor poor girl. She can’t be in a same sex relationship with a male. She’s female.

Knittingmonster · 02/10/2022 08:04

So rather than encouraging and helping your ex to accept her body, and the fact she did not like the things ‘girls are meant to like’, her parents subjected her to years of medical procedures and drugs which have been proven to have harmful effects on children. The poor poor girl.

Rapidtango · 02/10/2022 08:04

'My partner never wanted to go into the woman's changing rooms to perv on women, all he wanted was to be accepted in the men's room.'

Women don't generally go into female changing rooms to oerv on people. This probably goes some way to explaining your ex partner' stance. And most women do have issues with male bodied people being in women's changing rooms. They just don't feel, in today's climate, they can say so.

For those saying binders are no different to sports bras, why don't the girls and young women involved just wear a sports bra - no secrecy or underhand behaviour from so called 'charities' required at all.

takeme0uttonight · 02/10/2022 08:04

@LaughingPriest this is the first remotely sensible thing I've seen all night

takeme0uttonight · 02/10/2022 08:03

@Knittingmonster no, he's in a gay relationship. 2x penises = gay relationship. And I can assure you, from experience, his penis functions the same way your miserable husband/boyfriend/partners does, with the blessed relief I'd never have an unwanted pregnancy

LaughingPriest · 02/10/2022 08:03

I don't think there's anything wrong, per se, in wanting to be the opposite sex because of how they are treated in society. Just be honest and say that's what it is rather than invoking gendered souls and higher beings and types of bodies having to match types of personality.

The rejection of the notion that either sex can be masculine or feminine as they like seems very Victorian to me.

takeme0uttonight · 02/10/2022 08:00

@Strictlyfanoftenyears yes he probably did suffer from body dysmorphia - and he did receive help through the NHS, who spent a very long time correcting it.

Knittingmonster · 02/10/2022 07:59

So your ex is in a another lesbian relationship? That’s fab she’s accepted her sexuality And no, a fake penis cannot do everything a male penis can, if you think that then that says a lot about your sexual experience and or intelligence

LaughingPriest · 02/10/2022 07:59

I don't believe in souls or a higher being making a mistake when they dish out personalities to bodies, so when I hear "born in the wrong body" surely it more accurately means they are unhappy with their body? My disabled sister is unhappy with her body but never claims she was born in the wrong one or anything. It borders on Glen Hoddle esque superstition to me.

It would make far more sense to get to the bottom of why someone is unhappy with their body than to agree and say "you're right, your body is wrong, because only certain types of personality have bodies like yours, so let's get those breasts removed, eh?"

takeme0uttonight · 02/10/2022 07:57

Knittingmonster · 02/10/2022 07:53

Why do you say boyfriend for someone you know is female? Were you in a lesbian relationship but your internalised homophobia prevented you from acknowledging this? You may call them your ‘boyfriend’. But isn’t that like a six year old calling someone their ‘wife’ when they pretend to be married?
You say your partner took on all the male stereotypes? What are those? Isn’t this just further proof that trans ideology is sexist and imposes regressive stereotypes on people?

I say boyfriend because I never knew him as female.

Your point about six year olds is funny, good job

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 02/10/2022 07:57

takeme0uttonight · 02/10/2022 06:41

@WhereTheFuckIsMyFuckingCoat

Interesting points you raise. However, you're wrong on several points.

He didn't "think" or indeed "feel" he was born in the wrong body. He WAS born in the wrong body. He knew from the age of 7/8 he wasn't "categorised" right. The NHS treated him from age 7/8.

He is, as far as I'm aware, happy. However, you're wrong when you say if he was dug up that he'd be "categorised" as female - from age 7/8, he went through treatment. Every single part of his body changed. Beyond appearing on the tv, multiple articles/studies have been done about him, because he was one of the first individuals to go through the extent of treatment he did on the NHS. I'll happily DM you the links to the articles. By the end of the treatment (and as his partner at the time, witnessed the extent of it) you'd never know the "difference".

As for what you say about "demeaning" other peoples "male" partners, I disagree. This site is full of posts day upon day about useless, shiftless men. My partner at the time stepped up to every single male "stereotype", because he knew what was expected of a woman. He knew what box society placed us in, and he fulfilled it and more.

If you knew why he was my ex partner, your gas would be at a peep.

I am assuming that your partner suffered from body dysmorphia which of course is not the same as "born in the wrong body". Did they receive help?

WhereTheFuckIsMyFuckingCoat · 02/10/2022 07:56

**Knittingmonster
@takeme0uttonight you do know sex is binary and immutable right? No human being has ever changed sex? No amount of hormones and mutilating surgery will ever make someone become the opposite sex. You seem very invested in trying to convince us your ex girlfriend was a man? Why?

Yes I'm quite aware how biology works, thank you. He wasn't my ex girlfriend though, he was my ex boyfriend.**

Right, so we have established that this person is an adult human female, living their life in a(n altered to be) male (appearing) body.

As @Knittingmonster says, sex in binary and immutable, therefore it is physiologically impossible to be born into the "wrong" body.

takeme0uttonight · 02/10/2022 07:54

PaterPower · 02/10/2022 07:42

My partner never wanted to go into the woman's changing rooms to perv on women

Of course your exP didn’t - those are (generally) offences committed by the pervier end of the male population. People who’ve gone through male puberty and follow statistically male dominated offending patterns.

Even assuming that, somehow 12+ years ago in this country, your ex got hold of blockers and then took testosterone through puberty, her body still didn’t go through the same processes as a teenage boy’s.

And however well you think she ‘passes’ with clothes on, when undressed (or as skeletal remains in the future), her sex will be detectable.

As for being accepted in male changing rooms - most men wouldn’t have a problem with a trans ‘man’ changing alongside them, other than possibly a little embarrassment. We don’t feel physically threatened, and don’t for a minute imagine that trans men would be remotely interested in surreptitiously filming us.

What my ex did was effectively go through puberty for a second time. His voice broke, he grew hair in places previously unseen.

He didn't "get hold" of blockers, he was prescribed them. He then went through a series of horrendous surgeries, to realign his gender.

I don't "think" he passes well, I know he exists as a man. For the 820th time, he was on a mainstream dating show on tv. The person he was on a date with had no idea he had "previously been female". He has subsequently been in a same sex relationship with said person for 5 years, because (bizarrely and intrusively) all of the functions of his penis do the same thing a cis males does.

As to your point about changing rooms - if it were that simple, then why don't the majority of women have no problem with trans females changing in the ladies room? As you say, it's only an offence committed by "the pervier end of the population"

The whole trans thing on Mumsnet is hysteria whipped up by people with no lived experience, and I hope if your children ever go through this, you'll be far more accepting than you are online.

Knittingmonster · 02/10/2022 07:53

Why do you say boyfriend for someone you know is female? Were you in a lesbian relationship but your internalised homophobia prevented you from acknowledging this? You may call them your ‘boyfriend’. But isn’t that like a six year old calling someone their ‘wife’ when they pretend to be married?
You say your partner took on all the male stereotypes? What are those? Isn’t this just further proof that trans ideology is sexist and imposes regressive stereotypes on people?

MorningPlatypus · 02/10/2022 07:51

@takeme0uttonight

It wouldn't let me reply.

The idea that people can be born in the wrong body is nonsense on stilts. Your ex was (is?) a woman with gender dysphoria, like my niece.

Sex is determined at birth and can't be changed. Gender is as imaginary as unicorns or mermaids.

LaughingPriest · 02/10/2022 07:49

@takeme0uttonight interesting to hear about your ex. Presumably (do correct if I'm wrong) he was very strongly of the opinion that men have male bodies and women have female bodies? (I.e. men are flat-chested, etc)

What does he make of the current view that you can be either gender regardless of your body - that physical sex is separate from gender, gender is a feeling, therefore women can be (and can be indistinguishable from) male-bodied people?

MorningPlatypus · 02/10/2022 07:49

Utter guff.

takeme0uttonight · 02/10/2022 07:45

Knittingmonster · 02/10/2022 07:41

@takeme0uttonight you do know sex is binary and immutable right? No human being has ever changed sex? No amount of hormones and mutilating surgery will ever make someone become the opposite sex. You seem very invested in trying to convince us your ex girlfriend was a man? Why?

Yes I'm quite aware how biology works, thank you. He wasn't my ex girlfriend though, he was my ex boyfriend.

takeme0uttonight · 02/10/2022 07:44

@Mummyoflittledragon no - but it's the usual hysteria on threads like this "omg someone who isn't like us is only doing this so they can look at women in changing rooms" - do a wee search under "changing rooms" if you're unsure what I'm talking about

PaterPower · 02/10/2022 07:42

My partner never wanted to go into the woman's changing rooms to perv on women

Of course your exP didn’t - those are (generally) offences committed by the pervier end of the male population. People who’ve gone through male puberty and follow statistically male dominated offending patterns.

Even assuming that, somehow 12+ years ago in this country, your ex got hold of blockers and then took testosterone through puberty, her body still didn’t go through the same processes as a teenage boy’s.

And however well you think she ‘passes’ with clothes on, when undressed (or as skeletal remains in the future), her sex will be detectable.

As for being accepted in male changing rooms - most men wouldn’t have a problem with a trans ‘man’ changing alongside them, other than possibly a little embarrassment. We don’t feel physically threatened, and don’t for a minute imagine that trans men would be remotely interested in surreptitiously filming us.

Knittingmonster · 02/10/2022 07:41

@takeme0uttonight you do know sex is binary and immutable right? No human being has ever changed sex? No amount of hormones and mutilating surgery will ever make someone become the opposite sex. You seem very invested in trying to convince us your ex girlfriend was a man? Why?

grey12 · 02/10/2022 07:40

It makes me so sad 😔

I have big breasts and started developing very early. By 10 I had a decent pair to rival many older women 🤦🏻‍♀️ it was awful..... kids made fun of me in school, I hated jumping/running in PE, older men made nasty comments and ogled in the street....... maybe I would have considered binding ro hide them if I had been more uneducated and/or pressured.....