Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can't sleep thinking about neighbour's cat...

67 replies

chages · 29/09/2022 00:02

DP thinks I'm being ridiculous.

This cat never seems to be in during the day, but she's super affectionate and loving (never seen a friendlier cat). She desperately runs to me every time I open the door for cuddles.
I know that she never seems to be let in during the day/evening as she is always in sight in our garden! Even during heavy rain showers when the owners are home, she's there.
I've found it a bit questionable that a cat who is so loving and affectionate is out constantly anyway.

She's been trying more and more to get into our house so she's certainly not not wanting to be indoors.

Anyway, I just had to open the front door quickly (11.30pm) and she sprinted into our house - drenched and freezing from rain and wind, even though we know they're home.
I gave her a cuddle but had to put her back outside and now I can't sleep because I just feel horrendous about it. She doesn't seem to find shelter in the rain/wind either as she's constantly waiting so close to our front door. Just can't stop thinking about her being wet and freezing out there.

DP said I'm being ridiculous about it and overly concerned. Maybe I'm being soft.

Is it acceptable for an owner to leave a cat out through all terrain when it seems desperate to be inside? I don't even know what protocol is with cats really as a dog owner.

OP posts:
cherrysthename · 29/09/2022 08:58

You might think this is my cat as it's always in my garden 😂 it's not mine. It 'lives' 3 doors down but chooses to mostly stay in one of his favourite spots all of which seem to be in my back yard. Cats do what they want.

LaForza101 · 29/09/2022 08:55

Do you know that you neighbours definitely do not have a cat flap installed? We have a cat flap at the back of the house and an ex stray who is happy to go out and get soaked at all hours. We have had neighbours concerned about the cat's welfare and look very sheepish when we show them the cat flap and special warm towel she gets dried in.

It's nice that they are looking out for her but it is upsetting to be accused of animal abuse when she can come into the warmth at any point

ChaToilLeam · 29/09/2022 08:54

Is she neglected though? Our neighbours have a cat who likes to visit other houses, she goes out of the cat flap as she pleases and has popped over to see us every evening this week as a brief respite from the weather. She comes in, gets fussed over, dries off and warms up, then she is off again. She might just be a roving kitty.

TaylorsSecond · 29/09/2022 08:53

We recently had 2 4 week kittens in our garden and I felt terrible leaving them outside and even worse when it rained but every rescue was full 😩 we did get it sorted out in the end but I felt so bad for the poor little things

ittakes2 · 29/09/2022 08:51

Cats are nocturnal - I have two cats and the male cat wants to be out all night. He gets stress cystitis which is very dangerous for male cats as due to the bone any urine build up can explode his kidneys. He’ll pee on the floor rather than in the litter tray when he is stuck in doors. We don’t want to stress him so we have our cat flap open 24hrs a day.
I have seen him stay out even in the snow.

Sally090807 · 29/09/2022 08:26

I have a cat and he goes missing for days and then strolls back when he wants feeding. He’s super affectionate and loves cuddles but after 5 minutes inside he is off out again. He came back this morning and has been gone for 8 days. I have no idea where he goes, maybe you’re my neighbour 😃.
Is he a black and white cat?

WonderingWanda · 29/09/2022 08:03

My cat has a cat flap and will go out for hours on end, he has a routine of people he goes to visit. People probably think we don't let him in or feed him but that really isn't the case. If you have fed the cat or shown it some attention it has decided you would be a good person to visit. Why don't you find out if it has a cat flap.

mountainsunsets · 29/09/2022 07:45

No this is not acceptable. Cats do choose to be outside in the cold, wind etc but it’s very unlikely a cat would choose to stay out in the pouring rain.

Loads of cats choose to do precisely this, though, as is evidenced by stories on this thread.

SallyWD · 29/09/2022 07:39

Please chat to your neighbours. I think it's very cruel to keep a cat shut outside when it's cold and raining.

fruitstick · 29/09/2022 07:24

I should also point out that my FIL STOLE someone's cat by feeding it and giving it treats. First in the garden, then in his house.

The cat now lives there and he says it's his cat.

He doesn't have a cat flap so the cat is frequently now locked in his house when he goes out.

I'd be furious and heartbroken if that was my cat. Don't be that person.

dudsville · 29/09/2022 07:24

Is she making a choice? You know, maybe she isn't pining to get inside at her own home?

Rainbowcat99 · 29/09/2022 07:21

My cats will cry constantly at the door to get out, then when I let them (or when the door's open to let a person in or out) they bolt out, run round to another door and immediately start scratching and crying pitifully to be let in. My neighbour is constantly taken in by this and keeps ringing my doorbell demanding to know how long the poor little things have been out there for.
I think perhaps you are my neighbour 😆

Azandme · 29/09/2022 07:20

I wouldn't leap to any conclusions - cats can be contrary buggers!

Mine has a cat flap in the back door, and is free to come and go as she chooses. She usually comes trotting down the street when I pull up in the car, and then comes in the front door.

Yesterday she didn't come in, so I shut it. Within minutes I could hear plaintive miaowing from the side of the house (bear in mind - cat flap). I shouted her, she did not appear, so I went out of the front door, and looked down the drive - she was sat under the kitchen window, yelling to come in. Through a window she has never come in via...

Many stupidly early mornings she'll parkour around the garden fences, garage, and pergola to get onto the roof under my bedroom window - where she will loudly yell to be let in. Even in the pissing down rain. Again - CAT FLAP. I end up going downstairs and opening the door for milady... Five minutes later she goes back out. Through the sodding cat flap.

My neighbour's very well looked after, cat flap owning, cat often comes into my house to eat my cat's food, and have s stroll about. She acts like she's never been fed. I know she is because I talk to my neighbours - who tell me my cat visits them for treats, and marches around their house like she owns the place.

My point is, cats are dramatic, wily, contrary little sods who will plead neglect to anyone who will listen. Even when they are pampered at home.

The only way to find out if the visitor is one of these or not, is to speak to the owner.

Hobbesmanc · 29/09/2022 07:20

We have three very individual cats. Two have never stayed out. In fact one rarely moves away from the decking when he goes out. They both come in and out of the cat flap

The third has a mind of his own. He can be affectionate but then attack, won't use the cat flap but will wowl for the door to be opened and often sleeps out all night in his favourite bush

Someone did start to feed him and keep him in and we were worried sick as he was gone for three days. Only found him through Facebook. Feeding other peoples cats and keeping them is tantamount to theft.

Sidisawetlettuce · 29/09/2022 07:18

Our neighbour's cat was the same. It was in our garden in all weathers and used to peer through the cat flap trying to get in.My DH made a house for him and he'd go in there. When it snowed heavily, we decided to let him in. When the neighbours moved, they asked if we wanted to keep him and we didn't hesitate.

fruitstick · 29/09/2022 07:12

We have a cat like that. He's a complete dick if I'm honest.

He's always been very nervous and won't let you near him a lot of the time.

We got a dog last year and he hates him. So he won't come in if the dog is in the house, and waits until I'm out with him.

We don't have a cat flap so I'm not sure what to do now that it's too cold tk keep the back doors open.

I'm not a neglectful owner though - we love him, feed him and try our best.

Twiglets1 · 29/09/2022 07:11

I would let her into my house and see if I could get the cat and dog to accept one another. If not, have a word with the neighbours. If that doesn't work, buy a shelter and put it in your garden and introduce the cat to the shelter which could at least have a blanket inside and be protected from the rain.

Icequeen01 · 29/09/2022 07:06

We had this with a neighbours' cat and it broke our hearts watching her outside in all weathers. Our own two cats were petrified of her as she was quite feisty with other cats having often been in fights when she strayed onto another cats' territory.

We couldn't bear it one winter when it was freezing cold and she was peering through the catflap at us so we started letting her in and feeding her. The little chirrup noises she used to make when she was snuggled up in the warm on my DS's bed made us determined to take her in permanently. We wrote a letter and spoke to the neighbours who initially were reluctant to sign her over (even though they never bothered about her). Eventually they agreed and she's been with us for about 4 years now. She has an uneasy truce with my two other cats and they try to avoid her when they can (although one desperately wants to be her friend but she's not having it!) and she has her own "places" in the house. All our surrounding neighbours were delighted when they heard we had taken her in as they had been concerned about her too.

Definitely speak to your neighbours first if you feel you are able to take her in. Situations like this break my heart.

Hesleepswiththefishes · 29/09/2022 07:05

My cat sleeps all day and prowls all night, she 10 and I do worry about other cats/foxes as she gets older

however as others have said cats are dicks and she will wail sitting on the window ledge at the front of house for all to see in the rain when she can come and go through catflap at anytime

she also lies flat out on the pavement and looks dead which gives people a fright

BuzzBeeEmoticon · 29/09/2022 06:54

No this is not acceptable. Cats do choose to be outside in the cold, wind etc but it’s very unlikely a cat would choose to stay out in the pouring rain.

One of our neighbours cats is left like this. I’ve watched them shut the door in its face multiple times when its tried to get in (they don’t have a cat flap, I don’t understand this either). We put a kennel outside with a self heating mat in it so it has somewhere to go if its cold or it’s raining. Could this be an option? It was about £60 from Etsy but for my peace of mind it was worth it!

Cotswoldmama · 29/09/2022 06:51

It sounds a bit like my cat. As far as I know she doesn't go into anyone's house but if anyone calls her she will come running! She lives attention. I can see her sleeping in our neighbours garden sometimes too. She has a cat flap but is getting a bit old and forgetful so sometimes sits by the back door miaowing!
My neighbours very happy, very well fed cat (we called her fatty catty) used to appear on our dining room table on winter mornings when we came down stairs!

mountainsunsets · 29/09/2022 06:44

People who leave animals out to the elements are vile.

I don't disagree, but on the flip side, lots of cats do choose to stay outside in bad weather and often choose not to go to their own homes, but someone else's instead.** They can be furry little arseholes.

My own cat has chosen to sit in the garden in the pissing rain instead of coming inside - if I went to pick him up to bring him in, she'd scrabble over my shoulder and run back out.

If this was a dog being chained up with no choice I'd agree it's vile but cats are stubborn and will do go where they please.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 29/09/2022 01:51

My cat often goes in next doors. He can get in here whenever he chooses but often decides to stay out. He came in half an hour ago and plonked his wet self down on my head

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 29/09/2022 01:39

Ohh just let her in! Take her upstairs for the night, away from your dog. At least let the poor thing have one night being warm & dry

Fraaahnces · 29/09/2022 01:31

Do you think your dog would hurt the cat? I’d just gradually let it move to your place