Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ebay fraud

42 replies

Cantthinkofausername01 · 28/09/2022 23:27

Sorry guys, posting here for traffic

So last week i sold an item on ebay, nearly £700 worth. Buyer received and signed for the item.

Today I get an email stating the buyer has opened a dispute with their bank for an unrecognised transaction. Ebay asked me to upload evidence of it being delivered, which i did, i sent them the picture of the signature on royal mails website and its signed by 'Peter' which is the same name on the ebay account.

How likely is this person to win their claim? Ebay have the funds on hold until it's resolved, but I don't know how long that will take and I'm really worried. It was a mobile phone I sold and I have barred it now so they cant use it

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
mumofninetofive · 18/10/2022 23:16

Pleased for you OP that was lucky from my experience with eBay I refuse to use them now also.

I have been scammed twice, first time as a buyer , received a faulty item. Contacted the seller they bent over backwards to help or so I thought. It was a heavy item so they arranged to get it picked up for me (silly me thought they were being kind). Then refused to refund me as they said I failed to return it. I had no proof of tracking because they organised it and I could not prove I returned it. eBay ruled in their favour.

Second time, I sold an item. The buyer claimed it was faulty, eBay said I had to pay for a prepaid label to get it back. When I got it back parts were missing from it buy the buyer. eBay refused to listen, and refunded the buyer in full plus initial postage and I still got charged for return postage!

Cantthinkofausername01 · 18/10/2022 22:42

maeveiscurious · 18/10/2022 21:38

I'm in the middle so something at the moment, I have bought and sold in good faith and never had a problem until this week.

The seller is threatening me and it's put me off using these on line market places

Yeah I will never use Ebay again that's for sure!

I hope you get it sorted

OP posts:
maeveiscurious · 18/10/2022 21:38

I'm in the middle so something at the moment, I have bought and sold in good faith and never had a problem until this week.

The seller is threatening me and it's put me off using these on line market places

HunterHearstHelmsley · 30/09/2022 11:04

Cantthinkofausername01 · 29/09/2022 11:21

The thing is he isn't saying he didnt receive it, he saying he doesnt recognise the transaction on his bank account. Hes signed for it with royal mail in the same name that is on his ebay account 'peter'

Glad it's been resolved in your favour!

The name having signed for it doesn't necessarily mean anything. I had something delivered to my parents house in my name. The name that signed for it was "Hunter" but I wasn't even there and my dad signed for it.

JustHereWithMyPopcorn · 30/09/2022 10:54

I had this, they had even left me positive feedback and Ebay still withheld my money. It took about four months for me to get the money.

Laughingravy · 30/09/2022 10:50

deedledeedledum
How did eBay side with the seller? What was the reasoning? It can't be as you describe no way. You had evidence
Unfortunately eBay explain nothing in these cases. I bought an item and it never arrived. I had a tracking number which clearly showed it hadn't ever been put out for delivery and there was an issue with the my address not being correct. I had an online conversation with the couriers who acknowledged they hadn't tried to deliver it and had returned it to the vendor. The vendor confirmed they had got it back because the address wasn't clear. Did Ebay take my side? Nope. On the couriers website the item was listed as 'carded', a reference to an internal process but Ebay decided that in spite of the evidence that 'carded' meant a delivery had been attempted...
I got the item eventually thanks to the vendor and would have complained to Ebay but at the time there wasn't a process to complain and I wouldn't be surprised if there still isn't. They're a law unto themselves.

Cantthinkofausername01 · 30/09/2022 07:09

It's all been dealt with very quickly also! Case opened on the 28th and closed by the 30th! I was expecting this to go on for weeks

OP posts:
Lex345 · 30/09/2022 06:54

Thats great news OP! You have been quite lucky here, though. A favourite scam on ebay for phones is for the buyer to open "not as described" and return an empty box. They will win this type of case every time.

Glad its worked out for you :)

Cantthinkofausername01 · 30/09/2022 06:21

Just received an email from ebay stating that the dispute was found in my favour and no further action is needed! So relieved!!

OP posts:
Cantthinkofausername01 · 29/09/2022 18:22

CathyorClaire · 29/09/2022 16:06

I wouldn't be able to discuss it with the bank as it's his bank

You can dispute it with your own bank providing them with supporting documents.

Ebay have my money on hold so my bank wouldn't do anything, the money hasn't been in my bank account yet

OP posts:
jane1956 · 29/09/2022 16:46

sold an expensive teddy on e bay buyer in America claimed he received "an ugly doll" I had proof of postage and delivery etc too 6 months but I eventually got money (£120) back

CathyorClaire · 29/09/2022 16:06

I wouldn't be able to discuss it with the bank as it's his bank

You can dispute it with your own bank providing them with supporting documents.

Cantthinkofausername01 · 29/09/2022 15:55

Eylis · 29/09/2022 13:30

Have you actually entered the tracking into ebay or just sent a photo of the signature?

It's all moderated by computers. Humans won't look and make a human decision on the outcome so any photos you send won't be seen by anyone.

Also for £700 id send them a letter before action and if no response to that then go through a small claims court www.gov.uk/make-court-claim-for-money

Thankyou for this i will keep that in mind.

I spoke with Ebay earlier and they said if he had made a claim through Ebay it would be closed already because they can see he's at it basically but because it's through his bank i've got to wait on them making a decision. They said if the it doesn't go in my favour they will appeal it. I just can't be bothered with all this hassle!

OP posts:
Eylis · 29/09/2022 13:30

Have you actually entered the tracking into ebay or just sent a photo of the signature?

It's all moderated by computers. Humans won't look and make a human decision on the outcome so any photos you send won't be seen by anyone.

Also for £700 id send them a letter before action and if no response to that then go through a small claims court www.gov.uk/make-court-claim-for-money

AchatAVendre · 29/09/2022 13:05

I find ebay increasingly unreliable and a poor performer of late as a sales agent and tend to use other ways of selling/buying.

Its favoured sellers in its dispute resolution when I buy and genuinely didn't receive (by taking a photo of a completely different house and door as "proof" of delivery) and favoured buyers when I've sold. I stopped selling on it when I sold 3 pairs of Stella McCartney second hand running leggings in good condition for £25 and the seller then complained because one had a small loose thread and wanted me to refund her for that pair only. I refused, because they were second hand and I had ticked the "no returns" box on ebay, and they still sided with the buyer.

I find both ebay and Facebook very "American" in their terms and conditions and very poor at resolving the issues that should be resolved while cracking down too hard on perfectly innocent things.

Piffle11 · 29/09/2022 12:56

I would think that so long as your proof of postage matches his address, and this is the address that eBay provided you with, then you should be okay.

Winceybincey · 29/09/2022 12:38

Cantthinkofausername01 · 29/09/2022 11:21

The thing is he isn't saying he didnt receive it, he saying he doesnt recognise the transaction on his bank account. Hes signed for it with royal mail in the same name that is on his ebay account 'peter'

He could be pretending that a fraudster has used his bank details. In that case the bank will investigate and as there’s proof he bought and accepted the item it will get no where.

another scenario could be that a fraudster really has used his account to buy it, and set up an eBay account in his name, using a different address. If that’s the case it shouldn’t affect you, his own bank will refund him and you will keep your money.

Winceybincey · 29/09/2022 12:30

I’ll always advise to never sell anything of value on EBay. I know many who’ve been out of pocket because the buyer has pretended that something of low value had been put in the package instead of the item they ordered. One person I know stated they received a brick instead of a laptop. another person I know sold a phone and the buyer stated it didn’t work. She told him to send it back and she’ll refund. He did just that but had removed the parts that he wanted and sent her an empty shell. She had no choice but to refund him.

the problem is is there’s no proving it either way and so in those instances eBay will side with the buyer. some sellers do send items of low value instead of what the buyer paid for and that’s given fraudster buyers the idea.

no idea what he’s hoping to achieve with his bank though. I’ve not heard of that one.

ALoadOfCodswallop · 29/09/2022 12:17

Don't sell anything on eBay with a value of over about £50 you will probably be scammed and left out of pocket. All the stories I hear about eBay they seem to side with the scammer every time. You would have been better off going down to CEX or cash converters and taken £100 less than you could sell on eBay.

Cantthinkofausername01 · 29/09/2022 12:10

CathyorClaire · 29/09/2022 11:25

Ebay don't always side with the buyer.

I had a claim for an item not delivered. Tracking proved delivery but eBay left a hold on my account. I used the chat function and the hold was overturned that day and ebay chose to refund the buyer themselves.

What I didn't realise was the address was a collection address and I'd been opted in to offer it without ever being notified. I've now turned off that setting in my account because I had a second one within a few days that was a ballache to resolve.

It sounds like your buyer is using a bank chargeback, OP. You might be best off discussing it with the bank as well as ebay.

I wouldn't be able to discuss it with the bank as it's his bank. He paid the funds which are on hold in my ebay account until this is rectified😔

OP posts:
CathyorClaire · 29/09/2022 11:25

Ebay don't always side with the buyer.

I had a claim for an item not delivered. Tracking proved delivery but eBay left a hold on my account. I used the chat function and the hold was overturned that day and ebay chose to refund the buyer themselves.

What I didn't realise was the address was a collection address and I'd been opted in to offer it without ever being notified. I've now turned off that setting in my account because I had a second one within a few days that was a ballache to resolve.

It sounds like your buyer is using a bank chargeback, OP. You might be best off discussing it with the bank as well as ebay.

AgnesNaismith · 29/09/2022 11:25

Never sell phones on eBay! Similar happened to me, I sold a phone, packaged in the original iPhone box and saw photos of it arriving. The buyer claimed the box was empty and eBay sided with them. Actually broke my heart at the time as we really needed the money. Some buyers are ruthless cunts.

YouSirNeighMmmm · 29/09/2022 11:22

LuckyLil · 29/09/2022 10:52

Whatever happens just learn that if you sell high value goods on eBay make sure it's buyer collects only.

And cash on collection. If they pay another way first and refuse a refund and refuse to pay cash then cancel the transaction. Pay via paypal, collect, then claim the seller didn;t post... oldest trick in the book, and the seller can never prove they posted!

Cantthinkofausername01 · 29/09/2022 11:21

The thing is he isn't saying he didnt receive it, he saying he doesnt recognise the transaction on his bank account. Hes signed for it with royal mail in the same name that is on his ebay account 'peter'

OP posts:
Louloudaisy2020 · 29/09/2022 11:09

Hmmm I'm not sure.

I have NEVER won a claim as a seller before, ever.

I flat out refuse to sell on ebay these days as despite sending items 'signed for', the buyer raises a dispute for not receiving the item (the 'oh it's not at my address must have been incorrectly delivered' and then using a false name to accept it) or claiming it was damaged or not as described. I've never won. Because for damage, you cannot prove without a full macro inspected 360 that the damage wasn't there before...

It's ridiculous. Ebay and Paypay pretty much always favour the buyer. At best you can hope that as you have proof, that ebay will support both sides or request that the buyer seeks to get the money back from their bank rather than them.

This is why from now on, as much of a pain as it is, I only sell on facebook market place for cash on collection from a local supermarket car park (never my house).

Let us know how you get on, hope it all works out.

Swipe left for the next trending thread