Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what rules you have for your 14 year old

113 replies

VictimYuY · 28/09/2022 19:08

im struggling with DD to know if I’m being too strict or not strict enough. What are your rules regarding phone use, monitoring social media, going out, what they’re allowed to do ect.

OP posts:
hopeishere · 30/09/2022 08:10

No phone restrictions but I can access his phone. Ditto laptop.

We have Life360 on his phone so we k do where he is.

He can go into town with friends for lunch / cinema.

JessesMum777888 · 30/09/2022 07:53

Darbs76 · 28/09/2022 19:29

My DD is 14 - she’s my youngest, DS’s are 28 and 18. I’ve always had few actual rules. No phone limits re time allowed on phone, no enforcing of homework before leisure etc, no banning on social media. DD has only chosen to have Instagram in the last 6 months, she doesn’t like any other social media and doesn’t really engage with Instagram much either. She does like gaming, but again I don’t enforce any rules around times allowed on them, or track any devices. My mum used to invade my privacy so much and I know checking phones does protecting children (and perhaps I would if I was worried or suspicious) but I’ve always wanted to allow my children that privacy around their private life / growing up.

DD doesn’t go out to hang around like I did as a child, none of her friends do, maybe different where I grew up in North Wales to South London. If she does go out I don’t track her, I would impose a time to be home.

I’ve never had to have any rules with any of my kids, I do think that my being laid back they’ve never felt any need to rebel or push boundaries. But if things changed (and they could) I would review but I’d never be a strict parent as I genuinely believe it backfires and leads to poor relationships long term. One day those kids become adults and they can choose whether or not to have good adult relationships or not.

Same as this , and for my 12 year old. Prepared to be shot down in flames 🤦‍♀️

JaninaDuszejko · 30/09/2022 07:48

All phones downstairs overnight. She's pretty sensible though and has nice friends. She had a tricky time with a different group of friends back in Y8 and all the bullying happened over Whatsapp, I don't think banning specific apps stop any problems, it's about making sure they know you have their back and will support them when they need it. As long as you maintain a conversation that's the most important thing.

Cillery · 30/09/2022 07:42

lovelilies · 29/09/2022 02:24

I do find it odd how some parents are so intrusive into their teens worlds. I can't imagine making them hand over phones and not see friends after school, unless there are some serious issues?

No wonder a lot go crazy with their first tastes of freedom.

You need to be able to trust them, and surely they deserve that? Why would they seek to harm themselves or you?

Mistakes will be made surely! But my job is to be there in the wings to support and guide as required, not dictate and control.

Just that there is a case at the moment in the current coroner’s court of a kid of 14 who committed suicide after being on Instagram and viewing a lot of harmful material. I was also listening to the case of a young girl (middle class home) who fell in with a load of sex traffickers because the parents were always out at work and she was a latchkey kid . Frankly every parent should know exactly what their child is up to even as a teen. This opting out and ‘trusting them’ process is just a copout. We should know where our kids are and what they are doing. There are too many harmful things around. I don’t mean smothering them but for goodness sake we should know where they are and what they are doing and what they are watching. We used to have their friends round a lot to our house because at least we knew what they were doing then!

lljkk · 30/09/2022 07:35

I don't monitor what's on their phone or their messages.
... As long as they get up in morning for work/school: which they do.

Going out: none of mine have ever been terrible for mystery outings or staying out late. They volunteer where they are going and who they are seeing, which can be after dark. We moan if they might be late for a meal.

I don't really interact with cleanliness of their rooms. They tend to moan about how slovenly I am: they are tidier, cleaner than me.

Beezknees · 30/09/2022 07:33

9pm curfew on school nights, so home by then. DC has all social media accounts but I do have the passwords, I don't tend to check them though. I don't ban phones after a certain time at night but DC likes their sleep and is usually asleep before 11 anyway.

I think too many "rules" isn't always a good thing, I prefer to give mine freedom and trust, if they ever break my trust then I'd set some rules in but so far they haven't. It's about mutual respect.

crosbystillsandmash · 30/09/2022 07:04

FrangipaniBlue · 28/09/2022 20:27

WhatsApp, Tik Tok and Insta but I follow him on both and can see what he posts.

Phone account linked to mine, he can't download any apps without my authorisation.

Phone goes into night mode at 9pm until 7am, nothing other than phone calls and WhatsApp works.

Left outside bedroom overnight.

Can go out with his mates "until the street lights come on" as long as I know where he is and who with.

You do realise that most teens have 2 insta accounts?
Their real one and the one to keep their parents happy!

crosbystillsandmash · 30/09/2022 07:01

lovelilies · 28/09/2022 19:35

Same as @Darbs76 .
She's 17 now and in the RAF.
Never had any rules at home other than don't be a dick!
She self regulated with her phone. I expected and showed respect and it worked.
If she went out she would run it by me, she told me where and who with and was contactable. We were open about internet safety.
She was allowed to do whatever she liked. She never smoked or took drugs. She got all 9s in her GCSES. Boyfriend stayed over here and they were in a sexual relationship from 15, but I was ok with it, it's what teens do and they were safe and respectful of each other.

We're good friends now

Same.

I focused on building an open, trusting and supportive relationship. I used to cringe inside listening to other parents talking about their multiple rules and hated hearing about phones being checked - just so awful.

Dd is now an adult, she is a well rounded, successful and happy young women and we have a wonderful relationship.
As a young teen she talked openly to me about drugs, sex etc
She has many examples of friends who couldn't talk to (or trust) their parents who went completely off the rails.

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 30/09/2022 06:52

lovelilies · 29/09/2022 02:24

I do find it odd how some parents are so intrusive into their teens worlds. I can't imagine making them hand over phones and not see friends after school, unless there are some serious issues?

No wonder a lot go crazy with their first tastes of freedom.

You need to be able to trust them, and surely they deserve that? Why would they seek to harm themselves or you?

Mistakes will be made surely! But my job is to be there in the wings to support and guide as required, not dictate and control.

They're still children, just older children, but still children.

I find it hard to regulate my phone usage at times so it would be unfair to expect a younger teen to be able to manage it.

Plus I learnt the hard way that I needed to monitor my dds phone, she downloaded the app YUBO when she was 13yo and it led to her receiving a lot of very inappropriate messages.

I became a lot stricter after that and I think my dd was relieved tbh, they want to know you're looking after them and keeping them safe.

Wheelerdeeler · 29/09/2022 09:31

Has snapchat no tiktok.

Devices downstairs only. Shuts off at 930pm weeknights.

Have family link installed.

Ds14 knows the rules and will negotiate sometimes. We always listen and discuss and sometimes we go with his request.

underneaththeash · 29/09/2022 09:28

lovelilies · 29/09/2022 02:24

I do find it odd how some parents are so intrusive into their teens worlds. I can't imagine making them hand over phones and not see friends after school, unless there are some serious issues?

No wonder a lot go crazy with their first tastes of freedom.

You need to be able to trust them, and surely they deserve that? Why would they seek to harm themselves or you?

Mistakes will be made surely! But my job is to be there in the wings to support and guide as required, not dictate and control.

You do still need to parent teens, a think a lot of people forget that. I think most children do better within set boundaries. But, if does depend on the child. Phones in bedrooms are never a good idea.

We have no electronics up stairs rule (for adults too), mine prefer gaming and chatting to friends rather than going out, but it needs to be off by 11pm at the latest. Sitting in front of a screen for hours isn't good for anyone ( their mental health, eyes) and DS1 especially is significantly happier if he doesn't.

lovelilies · 29/09/2022 09:23

Surely often staying up all night a couple of times he would see that it's not a great idea?

MissyB1 · 29/09/2022 09:02

lovelilies · 29/09/2022 02:24

I do find it odd how some parents are so intrusive into their teens worlds. I can't imagine making them hand over phones and not see friends after school, unless there are some serious issues?

No wonder a lot go crazy with their first tastes of freedom.

You need to be able to trust them, and surely they deserve that? Why would they seek to harm themselves or you?

Mistakes will be made surely! But my job is to be there in the wings to support and guide as required, not dictate and control.

You can’t imagine why a teen wouldn’t be allowed to be on their phone all night? Really? Maybe it’s because they actually need some sleep before a day at school? That’s why my ds has to hand his phone over at 9:30pm. Because I would quite like him to be able to focus at school.

I can trust him with certain thugs, but it’s worth remembering they aren’t adults and don’t necessarily make decisions that are in their own best interests. That’s why we need to still parent them!

lovelilies · 29/09/2022 02:24

I do find it odd how some parents are so intrusive into their teens worlds. I can't imagine making them hand over phones and not see friends after school, unless there are some serious issues?

No wonder a lot go crazy with their first tastes of freedom.

You need to be able to trust them, and surely they deserve that? Why would they seek to harm themselves or you?

Mistakes will be made surely! But my job is to be there in the wings to support and guide as required, not dictate and control.

FrangipaniBlue · 28/09/2022 20:28

No Xbox on a school night.

FrangipaniBlue · 28/09/2022 20:27

WhatsApp, Tik Tok and Insta but I follow him on both and can see what he posts.

Phone account linked to mine, he can't download any apps without my authorisation.

Phone goes into night mode at 9pm until 7am, nothing other than phone calls and WhatsApp works.

Left outside bedroom overnight.

Can go out with his mates "until the street lights come on" as long as I know where he is and who with.

Darbs76 · 28/09/2022 20:13

lovelilies · 28/09/2022 19:35

Same as @Darbs76 .
She's 17 now and in the RAF.
Never had any rules at home other than don't be a dick!
She self regulated with her phone. I expected and showed respect and it worked.
If she went out she would run it by me, she told me where and who with and was contactable. We were open about internet safety.
She was allowed to do whatever she liked. She never smoked or took drugs. She got all 9s in her GCSES. Boyfriend stayed over here and they were in a sexual relationship from 15, but I was ok with it, it's what teens do and they were safe and respectful of each other.

We're good friends now

DS got all 9’s in his GCSE’s too. He chose himself to not play PS4 during GCSE and A levels, holidays only. Now he’s just started at Uni he’s in much better stead than those who are used to mum dictating when they need to study / when can have down time. He’s always been self disciplined and my DD is just starting GCSE’s and buying lots of materials to start already with making revision cards etc.

MissyB1 · 28/09/2022 20:09

Ds. No Snapchat/ Instagram/ TikTok, only WhatsApp. No phone upstairs overnight. I have access to his phone to check it when I want - and I do.

Socialising tends to be weekends afternoons/ early evening. I can track him on his phone. He’s not allowed to hang around in town.

Stickortwister · 28/09/2022 20:04

Dont be a dick sums it up nicely.

Ds15 not dd. Obviously no swearing or aggression and try and help out and tidy up after yourself. Not really a "rule" per se more just expectations for the whole household.
Plays online but mainly in a public part of the house so know what he gets up to. If he doesnt do his homework or stays up all night he deals with the consequences. ( and it's happened and hes learnt from it) . He knows we could check his phone but havent for a while. And when we have in the past it's been very boring! With regards to "going out" we live rurally so provide all lifts and it's done on a case by case basis... although so far never had to say no as mostly hanging out with a small group of friends during weekend or going to afternoon football matches

Ds13 is the same but without the phone issues as he doesnt have a mobile . Had a cheap one but lost it. Hes not allowed one at school anyway and plays sport outside of school and doesnt feel the need for one.

Have a ds 19 who's turned out to be a lovely young man and were still all close.

justmaybenot · 28/09/2022 20:01

I’m similar to Star Witness, more or less same rules, phone disabled 9 pm - 8 am. DD is expected to help out in the house when asked - which she does - and tidy her room when asked. I guess the main thing we might have words about is to make sure she’s being inclusive in school and that she texts her grandparents fairly frequently. That’s about it, all great so far but presume it might get trickier in time.

Duvetdweller · 28/09/2022 19:58

I don’t really have any. Nights out are pretty self regulated (no one wants them too late), I normally pick her up or sort a taxi. Her best mates live very close. She never really puts a foot wrong!

StarWitness · 28/09/2022 19:54

I’m fairly relaxed as long as she gives me no reason to go hardcore.

Shes allowed social media and WhatsApp. I don’t look at her phone often, but do have the password if I want to. She hands her phone in at 9.30pm on school days, 10.30pm on weekends, and I charge it in my bedroom overnight and hand it back to her before school. If I feel like she’s on her screen too much, I take her phone away for a few hours. She knows the score there.

During the week she has to come straight home from school. She has activities 3 evenings a week which I or her Dad take her to. Not allowed to hang about with friends after school in the park etc.

Weekends I’m relaxed about daytime outings with friends as long as I have an idea of where she is, she keeps in touch etc. Only allowed sleepovers now and then, and only when I know the parents. Not allowed out after dark currently.

It’s all negotiable and changeable as she gets older and shows she can be responsible. She’s a good kid so far, achieving academically and involved in sports, so I try to reward her for that. But teens can be dick heads, so I’m always cautious.

ReformedWaywardTeen · 28/09/2022 19:46

DS is 14:
No Snapchat.
No WhatsApp for the year group (it's a bloody pit of bullying and being abusive about the staff, he's quite happy to have no part in it)
No net after 9pm
No gaming until homework done (I have access to Google classes so can check).
Passwords for gaming must be kept remembered on the computer and lost password email must be mine (tbf, this is down to him having Asperger's and he forgets/gets locked out all the time)
I check his phone once a fortnight. I don't mind swearing on WhatsApp (they all do it) but none is to be spoken around adults.

This has been the status quo since he got his first mobile at 11 for secondary and was the same for DD. Neither have ever argued or questioned it.

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 28/09/2022 19:42

Literally none.
Not allowed to quit a hobby on a bad day
Praise effort not attainment.
Erm thats it.

ImHavingAnOldFriendForDinner · 28/09/2022 19:41

Pretty much the same as @Darbs76 except I have a 14 year old boy. He's a good kid and I've never felt the need for strict rules. He has his Xbox in his bedroom which he can use whenever he wants, I don't ask if he has done homework because I know he's going to do it and he knows I'll find out if he doesn't and then he'll lose the Xbox or his phone. No restrictions on his phone and I don't check it because he's entirely to privacy, we are pretty open and close and he has always come to me with any problems. What he does know is that if I ask him to hand over his phone then I'll except it to be given without any arguments. He uses WhatsApp, Snapchat and instagram but I'm friends with him on all of them and I don't expect homework to be done before he plays football or uses the Xbox I just expect it to be done when it needs to.

I have an 8 year old dd and I think things might not be so easy with her!!