Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what rules you have for your 14 year old

113 replies

VictimYuY · 28/09/2022 19:08

im struggling with DD to know if I’m being too strict or not strict enough. What are your rules regarding phone use, monitoring social media, going out, what they’re allowed to do ect.

OP posts:
AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 02/10/2022 11:46

TreeLine6 · 02/10/2022 11:14

I guess i am strict in some ways but relaxed in others. Education comes first in my house- so DC have to earn all their screen time by completing an age appropriate amount of study.

So for example, DS2 in year 9 has to do 2 hours of homework and revision on school nights and 3 hours each weekend. This allows him to earn a certain amount of screen time to cover all of his phone, gaming and TV time.

Anything above this has to be earned through extra study- so for example, DS knew he wanted to watch a film on Friday so did an extra hour of French revision on Thursday.

However, when it comes to using their screen time, I am very hands off. DC are free to do whatever they want within reason. I find it astonishing actually the degree of surveillance that some parents seem to undertake. It would be grossly inappropriate to start monitoring a private diary, so parents shouldn’t be looking at private WhatsApp messages etc imo unless there are serious causes for concern.

Woah, that is some severe stuff.

Just reading it I feel sorry for the poor lad. How is he going to learn independence and decison making under such a regime

It sounds oppressive and stifling of any spontaneity, you don't really make him decide what Tv wants to watch at a future date and earn it with extra homeworrk

I'm a bit lost for words, or have a fallen for a wind up, I really can't tell

PugInTheHouse · 02/10/2022 11:45

No rules for 14 yo DS, he is good at self regulating tech and bed time. Always does home work, gets himself up for school. Also does various clubs outside of school also. If he didn't do those things then we would do things differently.

Violashift · 02/10/2022 11:42

So for example, DS2 in year 9 has to do 2 hours of homework and revision on school nights and 3 hours each weekend. This allows him to earn a certain amount of screen time to cover all of his phone, gaming and TV time

As a teacher just wow. Year 9😳😳😳🙄

mountainsunsets · 02/10/2022 11:38

Lullabies2Paralyze · 02/10/2022 10:24

How come everyone says no social media except WhatsApp? You do realise random people can message you on WhatsApp? Not sure how or where they get number from, but I am an adult and occasionally get random messages, some explicit, from unknown people. I just block and report spam but some kids might not.

But random people can send you texts or call you too.

WhatsApp is just texting/calling over WiFi instead of the normal phone network. It's not like other forms of social media in that respect.

PinkiOcelot · 02/10/2022 11:25

I never put any rules in place with regards to their phones. Never encountered any problems at all.

when they went out I did like to know where they were going and who with and what time expected back etc. again, never encountered any problems.

I showed trust in them and that is what I got back.

Downtown123 · 02/10/2022 11:23

Only rules I have for my 14 year old dd is be in for 8.30/9pm and show respect. She has to learn how to self regulate her life as in a few years time she is a adult

Middledazedted · 02/10/2022 11:18

I don’t have any rules but we chat about the issues. I say I will monitor if I feel it’s needed and know his passcode. I don’t- I have forgotten it actually. He is a sensible sort and not phone obsessed. His brother was a conniving little risk taker - rules were still used less than talk as can always be got round in an environment where there are so many phones available. He sorted out himself fairly quickly. Mine didn’t get phones though until about year 8. That makes them pretty late to the party round here.

Violashift · 02/10/2022 11:16

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 28/09/2022 19:42

Literally none.
Not allowed to quit a hobby on a bad day
Praise effort not attainment.
Erm thats it.

Snap

TreeLine6 · 02/10/2022 11:14

I guess i am strict in some ways but relaxed in others. Education comes first in my house- so DC have to earn all their screen time by completing an age appropriate amount of study.

So for example, DS2 in year 9 has to do 2 hours of homework and revision on school nights and 3 hours each weekend. This allows him to earn a certain amount of screen time to cover all of his phone, gaming and TV time.

Anything above this has to be earned through extra study- so for example, DS knew he wanted to watch a film on Friday so did an extra hour of French revision on Thursday.

However, when it comes to using their screen time, I am very hands off. DC are free to do whatever they want within reason. I find it astonishing actually the degree of surveillance that some parents seem to undertake. It would be grossly inappropriate to start monitoring a private diary, so parents shouldn’t be looking at private WhatsApp messages etc imo unless there are serious causes for concern.

BungleandGeorge · 02/10/2022 11:12

Tbh a lot of nice kids get sucked into inappropriate and damaging things on the internet and parents are totally unaware. Just look at the numbers of kids who have watched porn or been involved with cyber bullying. Many of them are generally good kids with involved parents who have been a bit naive. They’re not adults and don’t have the brain function of an adult. I’d personally rather restrict sites accessed and time on the net than look through their phone as they do need some privacy to message friends

Namechanger1002 · 02/10/2022 11:03

Our number one rule in the house is Don’t Be A Knob - love that others have similar.
I don’t have hard and fast rules - my 4 children (23yrs down to 8yrs) are all very different and need different guidance.
I encourage self regulation, independence and an understanding that our family is a team and we all have to get stuck in. Natural consequences all the way here. Seems to be working so far. If it stopped working on any of my children then I would reevaluate my approach.

coffeetofunction · 02/10/2022 11:03

DD15 has own phone and laptop. I have the passwords/codes for both but don't check them. I trust her and know she's not stupid. We talk openly about even the uncomfortable topics and I know she would talk to an adult if she was in a vulnerable position. She goes out with her friends in to town or on the train for a day out. She goes to her boyfriends house and although I know they haven't had sex yet, it is going to happen and we've already discussed this. I often check her location on Snapchat but for my own peace of mind. She's doing well at school, has a little job, babysits for others. Helps with younger sister. Helps round the house. And is respectful of others

Butterfly44 · 02/10/2022 10:41

As you see from responses. Very mixed bag. It will TOTALLY depend on your child and family dynamics so you have to decide for yourself. There is a balance between restrictions, trust and respect.

The only restrictions we really did at that age was limiting internet time rather than restrictions on any particular app. Home before dark etc. I've always wanted my children to feel they can come to me and that they didn't need to hide anything. They have freedoms and are relatively sensible. And if their are issues we come to a compromise on what we think is fair/sensible or we trial something and reassess few days later.

pogostickplastique · 02/10/2022 10:28

Reading these has me amazed looking back at myself at 14.

Lullabies2Paralyze · 02/10/2022 10:24

How come everyone says no social media except WhatsApp? You do realise random people can message you on WhatsApp? Not sure how or where they get number from, but I am an adult and occasionally get random messages, some explicit, from unknown people. I just block and report spam but some kids might not.

WhatWouldTheDoctorDo · 02/10/2022 10:23

Not too many rules tbh. Has some chores - setting table, loading dishwasher, changes own sheets etc.

In terms of tech - has WhatsApp, discord, Instagram. I have the password for the phone, but can't remember the last time I checked it, I only would if I was really worried about something. Isn't prone to staying up late and pretty good at self-regulating tech use so don't feel the need to remove phone at a specific time etc. Has iPad and gaming PC in bedroom.

We've had lots of conversations about appropriate use, tech being a privilege and knows that it would be removed immediately if any issues.

LimpBiskit · 02/10/2022 10:19

lovelilies · 28/09/2022 19:35

Same as @Darbs76 .
She's 17 now and in the RAF.
Never had any rules at home other than don't be a dick!
She self regulated with her phone. I expected and showed respect and it worked.
If she went out she would run it by me, she told me where and who with and was contactable. We were open about internet safety.
She was allowed to do whatever she liked. She never smoked or took drugs. She got all 9s in her GCSES. Boyfriend stayed over here and they were in a sexual relationship from 15, but I was ok with it, it's what teens do and they were safe and respectful of each other.

We're good friends now

Same here. Main rule-don't be a dick. Everything flows from that.

Goawayangryman · 02/10/2022 10:13

It's tempting to conclude that parents who take a different (seemingly more lenient) approach to you are opting out of parenting or trying to be their children's best friend. But it could just be they do things differently from you, after making a careful assessment of risks and benefits and coming to a different conclusion, and that's alright.

Goawayangryman · 02/10/2022 10:08

I don't think there are many rules in our house in the sense of rules that apply only to the teens/ tweens. One set works pretty ok for all of us.

Don't be a dick is a good one.
Apologise if you've upset someone and mean it.
Be responsible for your own work, leisure, chores, personal hygiene etc.
Don't leave half the household crockery in your room growing mould.
And keep in touch if you're out so we all have an idea where we all are.

Don't have phone rules and scrutiny as such but they do have to go off at 11.

Cillery · 02/10/2022 09:54

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 30/09/2022 13:57

I think some of it does depend on the child, I grew up in a very liberal family environment, my parents didn't have many rules. I was always well behaved as I'm a people pleaser. However I know I ended up in some situations where I'd have much rather my parents had told me I couldn't go (parties with lots of underage drinking for example.)

With my own dd I tried to get the balance between keeping her safe but allowing her some freedom. The phone issue to me is basic safeguarding and however much I trust my dd I do not trust the internet at all!

I have a good relationship with my dd, she is now 16yo and doing everything a 16 year old should be doing (college, pt job, seeing friends, going out etc.) She knows she can trust me and that I will always be there for her. She tells me now she's glad I had rules around the phone when she was younger as some of the stuff her friends were doing was very scary.

A few basic rules around phone safety do not automatically result in a shit mum - child relationship 🤷‍♀️

Some parents need to realise they are parents are not friends of their children. Sometimes their kids need to be told, ‘No you can’t,’ for their own good. My kids appreciate it now years later even though they didn’t always at the time

AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 01/10/2022 12:41

MissyB1 · 30/09/2022 12:52

No rules at all? Hmmmm really…

So it’s treat others however you want? Go where you like anytime? Don’t bother telling anyone where you are? stay out all night if you like? Whack your sibling if you feel like it? Don’t bother with homework, get in as much trouble at school as you like?

I strongly suspect you would have rules around those things. Parents who say they have “no rules” usually do, they just call them something else.

Rules arent for things where's there's no option but to do the right thing or there's no choice like homework or hittinglpeople

If you need to actually spell those out as being options you've faled at an earlier stage. Deciding that phones need to be switched off at 9pm is a different kind of issue as there's no universally accepted right answer. Those are rules in my book and no, I don't have any like that.

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 30/09/2022 13:57

I think some of it does depend on the child, I grew up in a very liberal family environment, my parents didn't have many rules. I was always well behaved as I'm a people pleaser. However I know I ended up in some situations where I'd have much rather my parents had told me I couldn't go (parties with lots of underage drinking for example.)

With my own dd I tried to get the balance between keeping her safe but allowing her some freedom. The phone issue to me is basic safeguarding and however much I trust my dd I do not trust the internet at all!

I have a good relationship with my dd, she is now 16yo and doing everything a 16 year old should be doing (college, pt job, seeing friends, going out etc.) She knows she can trust me and that I will always be there for her. She tells me now she's glad I had rules around the phone when she was younger as some of the stuff her friends were doing was very scary.

A few basic rules around phone safety do not automatically result in a shit mum - child relationship 🤷‍♀️

Dacadactyl · 30/09/2022 12:57

I removed tiktok and Snapchat from my daughters phone at 14. Said if i find them on there again i will cancel phone contract. She is nearly 16 now and i check her phone periodically.

She goes on phone or watches telly for about 2 hours a day.

No screens in bedroom, 9pm bedtime and phone on charge downstairs. She has lots of hobbies.

We get on really well, no MH issues or self esteem problems, top grades etc.

I am happy with this approach and She responds well to strict parenting

I think my son will be a different kettle of fish but he is only 10 and has no phone ATM.

MissyB1 · 30/09/2022 12:52

AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 30/09/2022 08:19

I dont have a 14 year old atm but when I did it was exactly the same. I don't agree with the concept of rules in families, I'm not running an army camp

Why does it have to be so regimented? It appears I'mn a minority but nothing bad has happened.

No rules at all? Hmmmm really…

So it’s treat others however you want? Go where you like anytime? Don’t bother telling anyone where you are? stay out all night if you like? Whack your sibling if you feel like it? Don’t bother with homework, get in as much trouble at school as you like?

I strongly suspect you would have rules around those things. Parents who say they have “no rules” usually do, they just call them something else.

AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 30/09/2022 08:19

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 28/09/2022 19:42

Literally none.
Not allowed to quit a hobby on a bad day
Praise effort not attainment.
Erm thats it.

I dont have a 14 year old atm but when I did it was exactly the same. I don't agree with the concept of rules in families, I'm not running an army camp

Why does it have to be so regimented? It appears I'mn a minority but nothing bad has happened.

Swipe left for the next trending thread