Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what rules you have for your 14 year old

113 replies

VictimYuY · 28/09/2022 19:08

im struggling with DD to know if I’m being too strict or not strict enough. What are your rules regarding phone use, monitoring social media, going out, what they’re allowed to do ect.

OP posts:
MegBusset · 02/10/2022 19:33

DSes are 13 and 15. Our rules are:

Screens off at 9.30 on a school night
Phones downstairs overnight
No screens at the dinner table
Homework before screens on a school night

That's about it I think! Neither are interested in going out yet, all their socialising is online.

AbreathofFrenchair · 02/10/2022 19:29

PugInTheHouse · 02/10/2022 15:51

ABreathofFrenchAir - I think that sounds much more normal for most schools, my DCs are at a private school which has good results but they aren't super selective or pushy, they cover most of the learning in lessons and then a small amount of homework. Even in Y11 they covered majority of revision during lessons once the syllabus had finished then obv studied outside as and when required for exams. The only low mark DS got was the school messing up a practical submission. He could have maybe got the odd few marks with more studying as he was 1-3 marks off grade boundaries in most papers but to be honest to get on in life you need more than 9s across the board.

I don't even know what could be studied for 2 hrs a night in Y9, I'd be disappointed that the school were missing the mark so much that it was required TBH.

I'd heard things like homework is to either finish off what hasnt been completed in class or used as a way of checking children are understanding what has been taught.

Certainly the emphasis has shifted off homework. In secondary, it's submitted on line if its something the Teacher needs to grade, however more often than not, they mark each others work in the class.

I'm still shocked by 2 hours studying a night. I obviously need to get out more 🤣

MissyB1 · 02/10/2022 19:26

TreeLine6 · 02/10/2022 19:01

@AbreathofFrenchair

DS is at a stage grammar. The impression from his school and also local friends (including those with DC at non-grammars) is that 2 hours a night is normal and reasonable for year 9.

Tbh I’m not surprised that so many schools have such poor outcomes with lots of DC not meeting their potential if 2 hours of work a night is seen as so unreasonable!

DH is from overseas and in his home country, 2 hours of work a night for a 14 year old would be seen as nowhere near enough. Clearly we don’t want to emulate that culture fully here, but hard work should be encouraged and expected.

Ds is in a small successful private school. Their results are excellent. He is year 9 and has one hour homework each night, same for the weekend.

AbreathofFrenchair · 02/10/2022 19:24

TreeLine6 · 02/10/2022 19:01

@AbreathofFrenchair

DS is at a stage grammar. The impression from his school and also local friends (including those with DC at non-grammars) is that 2 hours a night is normal and reasonable for year 9.

Tbh I’m not surprised that so many schools have such poor outcomes with lots of DC not meeting their potential if 2 hours of work a night is seen as so unreasonable!

DH is from overseas and in his home country, 2 hours of work a night for a 14 year old would be seen as nowhere near enough. Clearly we don’t want to emulate that culture fully here, but hard work should be encouraged and expected.

Our school doesn't have poor outcomes though, it's outstanding and has achieved the highest grades for GCSE and Alevels for many years now. The last 4 years including adjusted covid grades, they have achieved higher grades than the grammar school.

TreeLine6 · 02/10/2022 19:01

@AbreathofFrenchair

DS is at a stage grammar. The impression from his school and also local friends (including those with DC at non-grammars) is that 2 hours a night is normal and reasonable for year 9.

Tbh I’m not surprised that so many schools have such poor outcomes with lots of DC not meeting their potential if 2 hours of work a night is seen as so unreasonable!

DH is from overseas and in his home country, 2 hours of work a night for a 14 year old would be seen as nowhere near enough. Clearly we don’t want to emulate that culture fully here, but hard work should be encouraged and expected.

PugInTheHouse · 02/10/2022 15:51

ABreathofFrenchAir - I think that sounds much more normal for most schools, my DCs are at a private school which has good results but they aren't super selective or pushy, they cover most of the learning in lessons and then a small amount of homework. Even in Y11 they covered majority of revision during lessons once the syllabus had finished then obv studied outside as and when required for exams. The only low mark DS got was the school messing up a practical submission. He could have maybe got the odd few marks with more studying as he was 1-3 marks off grade boundaries in most papers but to be honest to get on in life you need more than 9s across the board.

I don't even know what could be studied for 2 hrs a night in Y9, I'd be disappointed that the school were missing the mark so much that it was required TBH.

Violashift · 02/10/2022 13:58

I wouldn't even know what to tell him to do to gain an extra 11 hours of study each week! All school work is completed and homework tasks completed and he isnt exceptionally clever either

Agree! GCSE isn't even that difficult let alone year 9. A level then more understandable.

AbreathofFrenchair · 02/10/2022 13:55

TreeLine6 · 02/10/2022 11:14

I guess i am strict in some ways but relaxed in others. Education comes first in my house- so DC have to earn all their screen time by completing an age appropriate amount of study.

So for example, DS2 in year 9 has to do 2 hours of homework and revision on school nights and 3 hours each weekend. This allows him to earn a certain amount of screen time to cover all of his phone, gaming and TV time.

Anything above this has to be earned through extra study- so for example, DS knew he wanted to watch a film on Friday so did an extra hour of French revision on Thursday.

However, when it comes to using their screen time, I am very hands off. DC are free to do whatever they want within reason. I find it astonishing actually the degree of surveillance that some parents seem to undertake. It would be grossly inappropriate to start monitoring a private diary, so parents shouldn’t be looking at private WhatsApp messages etc imo unless there are serious causes for concern.

Why so much study? Is it a private or grammar school? And 13 hours of study a week?! (Assuming you mean 2 hours a night on the week and 3 hours at the weekend)

My child does their homework, which is 2 hours per Sunday each week and is in year 10. Predicted grades between 8 and 9. Throughout the entire school time, theyve never expected hours of study each week.

They have a 2 week rolling time table so week 1 is lessons all week, homework set is due in a week later, but the school rarely set homework. They have high grade results for exams too and it's a bog standard secondary.

I wouldn't even know what to tell him to do to gain an extra 11 hours of study each week! All school work is completed and homework tasks completed and he isnt exceptionally clever either

AbreathofFrenchair · 02/10/2022 13:48

VictimYuY · 28/09/2022 19:08

im struggling with DD to know if I’m being too strict or not strict enough. What are your rules regarding phone use, monitoring social media, going out, what they’re allowed to do ect.

Has a phone. What's app and Instagram on there, but phone is checked frequently and randomly. Phone on a timer so they can't go on it between 9pm and 7am. Charge it on their room. Laptop checked randomly and frequently too. Kept on room. PS5 on room but only goes on it Saturday and Sunday days.

Goes out with friends to play sport and can go with them whenever they want and come back before dark. They sometimes stay out after school to play sport on the way home but has to text to let us know.

They make their beds, put the first washing load on after school on a Friday and will empty the dishwasher daily. Will make their own breakfast in the week and will hover upstairs on a Sunday.

They are also very busy with sports clubs, volunteering and Explorers

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 02/10/2022 13:39

She only has WhatsApp on her phone in terms of social media.

She’s allowed to go most places that you’d imagine a 14 yo would go (location wise - shops or whatever) if I know where she’s going, and we’ve agree a time to be back, but she’s not the type to just bugger off really far afield.

Normal rules about behaving kindly / politely with others, family members of course.

She naturally goes to bed reasonably early so I don’t have a fixed rule for that.

Our slight rubbing point is she thinks I make too many plans for the family to do things together etc, wants more time when it’s just free/ flexible, but she equally would like it if I sprung things on her (last minute plans etc) so there’s a bit of give and take to he had here!

lljkk · 02/10/2022 13:02

TreeLine6 · 02/10/2022 12:23

I’m very surprised that people think 2 hours of study time is too much for a year 9! That is the expectation from the school and I know many other parents at the school actually expect significantly more.

If a DC gets home at say 3.30, they still have over 4 hours to do what they want even with 2 hours of studying.

Personally I think surveilling DC’s private messages and social media is far more concerning than expecting them to work hard at school!

DS is up at 5:45am, paper round, cycles to work 8-830. Cycles home 3:30-4pm. In bed by 9-930. Has cadets 2 nights/week & some school events he attends... plus competes in some sports. DoE silver activity starts soon. Fair enough that PP's offspring would find it easy to fit in 2 hours of study time in their day (and evidently needs 2 hrs study/day to achieve their potential), but I find DS's day is already pretty full.... and he is achieving his potential.

Hankunamatata · 02/10/2022 12:47

Ds14 has adhd so we have to be a bit more careful as not great with self regulation. We have time limits on his phone and xbox just so he doesnt play into the night on weekdays.

He only had what's app but he hasnt asked for any other social media. He doesnt really go out with friends except to play football so we havnt had to discuss weekend curfew

Echobelly · 02/10/2022 12:44

Laptop and phone are on timers so go off at a certain hour. I follow them and who they follow on social media but I don't look at their phone. I approve what apps they put on but probably don't need to do that anymore - I have only once refused an app when it was one of those 'anonymous question' ones; they wanted to use it for something specific, but when I explained how toxic those apps could be they totally understood why not.

They can go to late events with friends (c9-10ish) as long as we know where they're going, and can go into central London on their own or with friends during the day (we live in suburbs); we are willing to let them travel intercity to places they are familiar with with a friend. The walk from the tube to our house is short and always quite busy at any of the times they'd be coming home.

mountainsunsets · 02/10/2022 12:42

TreeLine6 · 02/10/2022 12:23

I’m very surprised that people think 2 hours of study time is too much for a year 9! That is the expectation from the school and I know many other parents at the school actually expect significantly more.

If a DC gets home at say 3.30, they still have over 4 hours to do what they want even with 2 hours of studying.

Personally I think surveilling DC’s private messages and social media is far more concerning than expecting them to work hard at school!

It's way too much. I didn't even do that much work for my A-levels!

Ten hours/week after school plus even more at weekends for a 13/14 year old is just insanity to me. Why does he need to do so much work?

PugInTheHouse · 02/10/2022 12:37

My DCs work very hard at school so its not that no emphasisis put on that, 2 hrs a night is way OTT for a 13/14 yo and completely unnecessary. Most DCs don't get home at 330, mine don't finish till 345 and its a 45 min walk home for a start then have various activities after, a rounded education is better than just studying for exams for several years surely. DS1 got mostly 7-9s in his exams whilst working also (he works in the music industry so works many hours during school time) and never studied for 2 hrs a night even in Y11.

We dont monitor their phones content or usage either though as that's not right but limiting usage if a child can't be trusted/struggles to get up every morning is a non issue.

TreeLine6 · 02/10/2022 12:23

I’m very surprised that people think 2 hours of study time is too much for a year 9! That is the expectation from the school and I know many other parents at the school actually expect significantly more.

If a DC gets home at say 3.30, they still have over 4 hours to do what they want even with 2 hours of studying.

Personally I think surveilling DC’s private messages and social media is far more concerning than expecting them to work hard at school!

treetoptina · 02/10/2022 12:10

No 'rules' around phone but DD self regulates well so I'm never needed them.

In terms of social life- she can go into town/meet up with friends after school but has to be home by 6. Weekends are hers to do as she pleases mostly but she has a couple of hobbies and sports that keep her busy. If she's going out I ask what time she needs picking up- once she said midnight and I said "er no, see you at half ten" but that's the extent of it.

She's naturally academic and hard working so have never had to intervene to ensure homework done etc.

MintJulia · 02/10/2022 12:09

My ds is totally uninterested in phones/social media so we don't have an issue there. And he's a home bod so far.

Rules are around doing homework, tidying room, putting his dirty laundry in his wash basket, being in bed by 9.30 (or he is really grumpy), and turning off appliances and lights.

So far I've been lucky. I realise it will probably get worse so I'm enjoying the calm before the storm. 😀

Kissingfrogs25 · 02/10/2022 12:07

We also prioritise homework over all else, until it’s finished and checked they don’t chat to friends or go on phones. To be fair we started this a long time ago before phones, so it didn’t need enforcement when phones arrived as it’s a fixed routine.

Hoolihan · 02/10/2022 12:07

Cannot imagine having to 'earn' the right to watch a film 😱 Jesus.

My 14yo doesn't have many rules - phone goes off overnight from 11.30pm - 6.30am, expected to do homework (although the school is very strict on this anyway), clear up after himself, be generally good company. Allowed out whenever he wants, can have friends round without asking inc sleepovers, can hang around town to his hearts content!

Kissingfrogs25 · 02/10/2022 12:03

I have a sensible 14 yr old dd and she speaks to all of her friends on social media, they make plans and play games etc. I do feel sorry for the teens that aren’t allowed, as they get left out of everything, and you can really see it affects their friendships. They don’t really have any/many friends. So before you ban everything be aware they may either be ostracised or get a burner phone (lots of dds friends have them of those with super strict parents) and they just do it behind their parents backs.

We wanted a totally transparent and open connection with our teens, it promotes trust, they talk to us about everything. We don’t ‘lay down the law’ and be authoritative - we have a more relaxed style, we talk things through. Come to an agreement together and let our expectations be known. We haven’t been let down yet. It’s worked really well for us.

Phones etc downstairs at 9pm on school nights, 9.45pm at the weekend.
Dc then usually read until they ready to sleep.

Teens need to learn how to manage SM etc and be able to independently limit their screen time and prioritise sleep. It’s a life skill, so better not to make SM a forbidden fruit but to have some exposure gradually and explaining as you go to keep them safe.

ArtixLynx · 02/10/2022 11:53

no tablets/consoles on or in room between 9pm and 6am.

All accounts must be accessible by me if i want to see what she's up to (i dont check often, but have the ability if i think something is up)

She's not allowed tiktok, discord, or snapchat, but i do allow youtube, facebook/insta.

Her phone only does calls/texts so when she's out she can still contact me, but i have to know where she is going, who she is with, and she must answer my texts if i send one, and she must be back on time.

PugInTheHouse · 02/10/2022 11:52

I agree, forcing that sort of regime on a teen teaches them nothing for later in life. Same as over the top regulation of other aspects such as phones, bed times etc. I didn't have too many rules for my oldest DS and he is really motivated and was able to manage studying for GCSEs, work and now college. It works for us.

mountainsunsets · 02/10/2022 11:51

TreeLine6 · 02/10/2022 11:14

I guess i am strict in some ways but relaxed in others. Education comes first in my house- so DC have to earn all their screen time by completing an age appropriate amount of study.

So for example, DS2 in year 9 has to do 2 hours of homework and revision on school nights and 3 hours each weekend. This allows him to earn a certain amount of screen time to cover all of his phone, gaming and TV time.

Anything above this has to be earned through extra study- so for example, DS knew he wanted to watch a film on Friday so did an extra hour of French revision on Thursday.

However, when it comes to using their screen time, I am very hands off. DC are free to do whatever they want within reason. I find it astonishing actually the degree of surveillance that some parents seem to undertake. It would be grossly inappropriate to start monitoring a private diary, so parents shouldn’t be looking at private WhatsApp messages etc imo unless there are serious causes for concern.

Jesus Christ 😬

PugInTheHouse · 02/10/2022 11:48

TreeLine6 · 02/10/2022 11:14

I guess i am strict in some ways but relaxed in others. Education comes first in my house- so DC have to earn all their screen time by completing an age appropriate amount of study.

So for example, DS2 in year 9 has to do 2 hours of homework and revision on school nights and 3 hours each weekend. This allows him to earn a certain amount of screen time to cover all of his phone, gaming and TV time.

Anything above this has to be earned through extra study- so for example, DS knew he wanted to watch a film on Friday so did an extra hour of French revision on Thursday.

However, when it comes to using their screen time, I am very hands off. DC are free to do whatever they want within reason. I find it astonishing actually the degree of surveillance that some parents seem to undertake. It would be grossly inappropriate to start monitoring a private diary, so parents shouldn’t be looking at private WhatsApp messages etc imo unless there are serious causes for concern.

Personally I find this level of hot housing of a Y9 child (or any child) is worse than regulating their phones. That is seriously OTT for any child.

Swipe left for the next trending thread