Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how we managed our mortgage when interest rates were 13.6%

331 replies

BlueBloodedBlue · 28/09/2022 18:52

We bought our flat in 1990 with a mortgage rate of 13.6%

I know house prices were much lower but so were wages.

I'm obviously not minimising the current nightmare situation so many people are facing, I just don't really understand the economics so would be grateful if anyone is able to explain in simple terms please?

OP posts:
commanderprimate · 29/09/2022 10:47

Just had a look at repossession stats for the last 60 years. On average, there were 59160 repossessions a year between 1990 and 1994. Doesn't come down much until 1998. For comparison it was 6734 on average for the five years up to 2019. So it looks like many didn't cope.

AngelsWithSilverWings · 29/09/2022 10:41

Bought my first flat in 1990 with a boyfriend. New build one bedroom and it was £39k. We both earned £10k a year back then. No idea how we were allowed to borrow so much! We took out a 95% mortgage and used our savings to carpet and furnish it and buy kitchen white goods.

We were young and foolish ( age 20) It was horrendous. I've never been so poor in my life. Had to stop meeting friends for lunch and even a takeaway coffee was out of the question. Couldn't buy new clothes or shoes for a year. We could afford to eat and pay the essential bills and mortgage payment but had zero left. Couldn't afford to run a car. It was a miserable existence.

The best thing that ever happen to me was my boyfriend cheated on me and was so desperate to move his new girlfriend in that he allowed me to remove myself from the mortgage which was by then in negative equity. Luckily by the time we sorted the legal stuff out he had got a new and much better paid job and could service the mortgage with the help of the new girlfriend.

I was so happy to walk away from that situation.

So many people at that time had rushed to buy property and ended up handing the keys back.

When I married my husband in 1996 we were so cautious about buying our first house together - we could have stretched much more than we did but my experience in 1990 had put me off.

Interest rates had reduced to around 8% by then and property prices had reduced so much that we were able to buy a nice three bed semi for £59k - it was so much easier then.

boxybox · 29/09/2022 10:40

I realise we could not have foreseen what is happening now but it was obvious that interest rates would have to rise sometime.

The trouble is they have been so low for so long thstvwhen they would indeed rise & by how much wasn't obvious at all.

boxybox · 29/09/2022 10:33

You are stress tested or at least were however I don't think many predicted the current energy bills

ginghamstarfish · 29/09/2022 10:22

I don't currently have a mortgage as we are renting. I am wondering though why when someone applies for a mortgage when rates are low - as they have been for a long time now - surely both they and the mortgage broker account for the possibility of rises, and lend/borrow according to that future prospect? I realise we could not have foreseen what is happening now but it was obvious that interest rates would have to rise sometime.

Blossomtoes · 29/09/2022 10:13

Not enough housing has been built = not enough supply = increased prices

How does that work when there will still be the same amount of houses next year and the housing market will deflate by 10 to 15%? If prices go down builders will stop building because their costs will go up because we have rising inflation and their profits will go down.

CapMarvel · 29/09/2022 10:11

Funkyblues101 · 29/09/2022 09:53

People didn't spend their money on as much stuff back then. They rarely went out for meals, buying takeaway coffee barely existed. A few people had sky but otherwise everyone just paid the licence fee. Only well off people had computers. There weren't nearly as many fashion shops, or the range of beauty products. Nowadays no internet or mobile phone is unthinkable, but those simply didn't exist the last time this happened.

I'm sorry, but of course people did.

Different stuff, but shops and consumerism were in fact a thing in the 90s.

CapMarvel · 29/09/2022 10:10

Blossomtoes · 29/09/2022 10:01

The issue here is the size of people's mortgages due to the ridiculously high property prices far more than interest rates

There wouldn’t have been ridiculously high property prices if interest rates hadn’t been kept artificially low for over a decade. Now look what’s happening - interest rates are predicted to go up to 6% by the spring and house prices will go down by 10 to 15%. The supply will be the same.

Obviously the difference in the value of your house is immaterial until you sell it. But people who have bought recently will likely be in negative equity, how will it feel to see your hard earned deposit wiped out? Because that’s what’s going to happen.

Yes there would. House prices were on the way up before the interest rates hit the lows we've seen over the last few years.

Not enough housing has been built = not enough supply = increased prices.

boxybox · 29/09/2022 10:05

There wouldn’t have been ridiculously high property prices if interest rates hadn’t been kept artificially low for over a decade.

I agree but why were they kept so low & for so long?

boxybox · 29/09/2022 10:04

People have always had a choice. Nobody had a gun held to their head to make them pay inflated house prices. Look at the housing market just a few months ago - bidding wars, houses going for £50k above asking, it was lunacy

what real choice though? We moved recently and payed 20k over asking, still far cheaper than the equivalent rental.

Blossomtoes · 29/09/2022 10:01

The issue here is the size of people's mortgages due to the ridiculously high property prices far more than interest rates

There wouldn’t have been ridiculously high property prices if interest rates hadn’t been kept artificially low for over a decade. Now look what’s happening - interest rates are predicted to go up to 6% by the spring and house prices will go down by 10 to 15%. The supply will be the same.

Obviously the difference in the value of your house is immaterial until you sell it. But people who have bought recently will likely be in negative equity, how will it feel to see your hard earned deposit wiped out? Because that’s what’s going to happen.

Funkyblues101 · 29/09/2022 09:53

People didn't spend their money on as much stuff back then. They rarely went out for meals, buying takeaway coffee barely existed. A few people had sky but otherwise everyone just paid the licence fee. Only well off people had computers. There weren't nearly as many fashion shops, or the range of beauty products. Nowadays no internet or mobile phone is unthinkable, but those simply didn't exist the last time this happened.

lovelypidgeon · 29/09/2022 09:40

The fact is that anyone, like OP, who bought in the early 90s when interest rates were high would have factored that in when deciding what they could afford to borrow. Just like nowadays, the huge rise in interest rates was not predicted a few years before so there were plenty of people who bought a few years earlier who ended up struggling to afford to pay their mortgages. I knew several people who bought new build properties in the mid/late 80s who found that they were struggling to pay their mortgage but had negative equity (due to the combination of inflated new build prices and drop in demand) so selling up and moving somewhere cheaper was not a viable option.

However, as well as the fact that house prices now are a much higher multiple of average income, I think some of the key differences between then and now are:

  • We've had really high house prices for decades now, so even people mid-way through their mortgage are likely to be finding the interest rate hike a problem. Whereas in the 90s, people 10 years through their mortgage would have had very low borrowings.
  • Rents now are insanely high. In the 90s there was more social housing available and rents were generally much more affordable. So the choice people have now is risk taking on a mortgage that might become less affordable or pay rent that's already unaffordable.
  • Due to high house prices, many families nowadays are already stretching their finances- both parents working, taking on as many hours as possible, limiting outgoings. In the early 90s I knew lots of people who took on a second part time job/stopped going out etc to fund their mortgage payments but (despite what Truss and co say) many of the people who will be impacted worst by this are already doing that.
CapMarvel · 29/09/2022 09:39

Blossomtoes · 29/09/2022 09:33

It isn’t as simple as that. If interest rates had been raised sensibly in the last ten years the cost of borrowing would have kept the rise at sensible levels.

People have always had a choice. Nobody had a gun held to their head to make them pay inflated house prices. Look at the housing market just a few months ago - bidding wars, houses going for £50k above asking, it was lunacy. We’ve had a decade of personal spending like drunken sailors on shore leave and it had to end some time.

So what's the choice? Rent at equally inflated prices along with all the insecurity that brings? Not have somewhere to live at all?

If there are 10 people trying to buy 1 house of course house prices are going to get overinflated. If successive governments had actually built enough houses to meet demand then we absolutely not would have this problem.

The issue here is the size of people's mortgages due to the ridiculously high property prices far more than interest rates, which is not the same as 30 years ago.

Kabalagala · 29/09/2022 09:39

Blossomtoes · 29/09/2022 09:33

It isn’t as simple as that. If interest rates had been raised sensibly in the last ten years the cost of borrowing would have kept the rise at sensible levels.

People have always had a choice. Nobody had a gun held to their head to make them pay inflated house prices. Look at the housing market just a few months ago - bidding wars, houses going for £50k above asking, it was lunacy. We’ve had a decade of personal spending like drunken sailors on shore leave and it had to end some time.

We bought recently at £25k over asking. We have a 35 year mortgage. Lunacy, yes. But the alternative was to keep renting at £700 per month more than our current mortgage repayments. It's not really a choice is it?

Blossomtoes · 29/09/2022 09:33

CapMarvel · 29/09/2022 09:27

House prices have gone up because for decades we haven't built enough houses for demand. It's a simple as that.

People have had to take on huge mortgages because house price increases have massively outstripped wage increases. In the vast majority of cases it's got nothing to do with being reckless; people simply have had no choice.

It isn’t as simple as that. If interest rates had been raised sensibly in the last ten years the cost of borrowing would have kept the rise at sensible levels.

People have always had a choice. Nobody had a gun held to their head to make them pay inflated house prices. Look at the housing market just a few months ago - bidding wars, houses going for £50k above asking, it was lunacy. We’ve had a decade of personal spending like drunken sailors on shore leave and it had to end some time.

ForestDad · 29/09/2022 09:30

Bought our first house in 2009. 5% interest. It was painful not seeing the amount owed coming down much. Rates fell so quickly it was worth paying £2k early repayment charge to get out early. Current mortgage 1.54% for another 3+ years. Finally some luck in the timing.
But back then paying £1k/month for a house half the value of current one was painful.

CapMarvel · 29/09/2022 09:27

jimmyjammy001 · 29/09/2022 08:55

People have vastly over paid for property over the past decade as a result of zero interest rates, just in the past 2 years near me people paying an extra £100k / 35% increase for a 3 bed semi! And taken on huge mortgages as a result! That is nobody else's fault apart from their own, there would of been other people who would have walked away as they knew when interest rates go up they wouldn't be able to afford the mortgage, then there are those that have been reckless and are now about to suffer as a result, it's not fair on the sensible people out there to bail these people out.

House prices have gone up because for decades we haven't built enough houses for demand. It's a simple as that.

People have had to take on huge mortgages because house price increases have massively outstripped wage increases. In the vast majority of cases it's got nothing to do with being reckless; people simply have had no choice.

onmywayamarillo · 29/09/2022 09:23

By 1995 the interest rate on my mortgage was 16%!!

But it soon lowered to roughly 7/8%

Lots and lots of people had their homes repossessed.
No such thing as a fixed rate back then.
Or even repayment. All interest only and you had to take out a separate endowment or pension linked plan to pay it off. Lots of people were caught out by that too!

boxybox · 29/09/2022 09:10

my parents however maxed themselves on an interest only mortgage for their 2nd home & then in later years borrowed against that debt. Were they sensible?

boxybox · 29/09/2022 09:07

And taken on huge mortgages as a result! That is nobody else's fault apart from their own, there would of been other people who would have walked away as they knew when interest rates go up they wouldn't be able to afford the mortgage, then there are those that have been reckless and are now about to suffer as a result, it's not fair on the sensible people out there to bail these people out.

Why blame people? Was I more sensible because I didn't max myself or because I had a lower LTV?

AwkwardPaws27 · 29/09/2022 09:02

TiddyTidTwo · 29/09/2022 06:33

"My mortgage repayment is half my income. I can't afford an interest rate increase. I have no room for manoeuvre. What use is"stress testing". It was the cheapest house I could find. And rent would have been even more."

Stress testing has its place but is basically useless when all the other factors have come into play like inflation, cost of living crisis, energy crisis, tanking pound, no wage increase, etc etc.

^ this.

We stress-tested when we bought. Life changes.

DH has had pay rises but everything has gone up. The baby we planned and budgeted for has finally arrived after a couple of years and several miscarriages, & I'm honestly not sure how we'll pay for childcare now if the mortgage goes up to 6%. When he was conceived that same budget looked comfortable.

If I look at working opposite hours to DH to save on childcare when I go back to work, I'd be taking a paycut but also hobbling my career progression in the longterm. It's a tough choice.

Blossomtoes · 29/09/2022 08:57

in 1992 we borrowed £32,000 on a combined wage of around £10,000 to buy our first house. The interest rate was 7%

I don’t know how you managed to get 7% when the base rate was 9%. My mortgage was more like 12% in 1992.

MeanderingGently · 29/09/2022 08:57

Our first mortgage was at 15%, I'm talking 1980s here. It was a tiny box of a place, we didn't even have the money for fees, which I had to borrow, it came to £900!! We got a 100% mortgage because we didn't have any savings, we were fresh out of university, been working about 2 years and were renting, no family money or help behind us. It was a risk, but it paid off.

House prices were rising fast even then, we sold that flat within a year (put it on the market after about 9 months and completed 3 months later) and by then had managed to gain £7000 equity which was our 'deposit' for a little house on a housing estate; we weren't in that long before we traded up to a 3-bed as we'd started a family. By then building societies were lending on 4 x joint salaries.

We weren't in high paying jobs and did it from nothing. But other costs weren't as expensive, by the time we were in the 3-bed, the mortgage was at least 50% of our income. Things were tight but we still ate, clothed the kids (toddlers) and I stayed at home, so no childcare costs.
There were no mobiles, no internet charges, fuel bills weren't excessive, we didn't worry about petrol costs.

It was a different world though, our first flat seemed excessively expensive (as we lived down south at the time) at £23,500. When we finally sold our 3-bed and moved to a different part of the country we thought we'd won the jackpot, as it sold for £150,000!!

PigsInBlanketyBlankets · 29/09/2022 08:55

Quite @Notlosinganyweight

Sorry, I got dragged into the derailment. It's utterly shit