Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is everyone worried about mortgages but no one worried about pensions?

165 replies

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 28/09/2022 15:33

There's numerous threads with people wanting to pay thousands to get out of their mortgages, but noone seems concerned that pension funds are (or were, before urgent intervention from the BoE) on the brink of collapse as result of the mini-budget.

Anyone urgently cashing in on their pensions?

OP posts:
BambinaJAS · 29/09/2022 02:45

PassMeASpork · 29/09/2022 02:34

This. Plus - anyone approaching retirement would (or should) have been moving funds into "cash" funds to mitigate for potentially unexpected scenarios like this.

I'm a couple of years away from pension drawdown, but converted 80% of my funds to cash 12 months ago. The value won't go up or down, but at least I know exactly what I have to live on. The other 20% could go either way.

The real value of that cash is dropping at about 10% every year now.

PassMeASpork · 29/09/2022 02:34

DoodlePug · 28/09/2022 16:57

Your private pension, if genuinely a pension not just money you are investing for your retirement, should also be secure. In that it can't go bust.

Obvs if invested it can lose value but lots (most?) should be invested in whole world funds, ie not overly exposed to the UK market so will move based on what's happening round the world not just here.

My investments have dropped a fair amount. Its not nice but it should come back.

This. Plus - anyone approaching retirement would (or should) have been moving funds into "cash" funds to mitigate for potentially unexpected scenarios like this.

I'm a couple of years away from pension drawdown, but converted 80% of my funds to cash 12 months ago. The value won't go up or down, but at least I know exactly what I have to live on. The other 20% could go either way.

Nat6999 · 29/09/2022 02:12

£1,000,000,000,000 has been lost on pensions since the financial statement last Friday.

Iliveonahill · 28/09/2022 23:15

bellac11 · 28/09/2022 19:41

Is there no chance of you starting something at the moment?

Id be terrified if I were you. Im older than you and worried enough about the fact that I dont have a great pension anyway, started too late, no lump sum despite it being local government pension, my OH also have a local government pension with no lump sum.

At your age you'll be retiring when you're about 69, and state pension at current prices is about 8k I think, its pennies, you wont be able to survive on that.

Since 2008 there have been no lump sums in local govt pensions. Any lump sum is as a result of membership prior to 2008.

TheRubyRedshoes · 28/09/2022 23:08

There's always an on going debate, pay off mortgage or invest it instead.

I personally think this sort of crisis with the fear of rates rising, it really pays to pay down the house/ as well/at least.

@user6497219 @user1487194234

Sorry couldn't remember which one said they have 20ngrand used as draw down.

What does this mean?

saltinesandcoffeecups · 28/09/2022 22:44

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 28/09/2022 16:40

Yes, the obvious answer is now vs future. But it's worrying isn't it, that people don't prioritise their pensions generally? We may be concerned now about our immediate finance because they are most pressing, and pensions seems far away, but with an aging population, and dilution of state pension, I do wonder what's going to happen in years to come.

Personally, I am dismayed by the news. I have prioritised my pension the last couple of years (despite being fairly young) to ensure I am not left high and dry in my late 60s, and it's worrying that all the investment could disappear.

If you are not collecting or plan to collect in the near future, this is actually sort of a good thing. If you are able now is the time to increase contributions… if your investments are diversified and intended for long term holding, then periods like this are the equivalent of a stock up sale.

Now, those collecting are screwed and it may mean a deferral of retirement plans or financial ruin for those on a fixed income. And yes everyone should be running what-if scenarios in your head when you are in this situation, because I can almost guarantee that everyone will face a recession in their retirement. So hopefully it will get some thinking about planning for retirement.

AuntSalli · 28/09/2022 22:29

My plan is to take the 25% to improve my home, upgrade appliances etc as soon as I’m able to and then spend 10 years drawing down the rest by which point I’m more than happy to throw myself on the mercy of the government. I won’t need much at that stage just sweets for the grandchildren.

entropynow · 28/09/2022 21:53

BigWoollyJumpers · 28/09/2022 16:25

Have you seen annunities are back in the news though. Best rates for years.

Annuities are still utter crap Don't go for them.

BorgQueen · 28/09/2022 21:44

My Sister has a small annuity of £120 a month and before she became disabled enough for PiP, Housing benefit and pension credit, she was £70 a week worse off than someone without a pension ( other than State).

rwalker · 28/09/2022 21:39

no
i look at my mum she has a small pension and is marginal better off than state pension and pension credit
tbh there things she’d get if she was on pension credit so all those years of saving were for nothing

BorgQueen · 28/09/2022 21:38

My advice for those with 10+ years to retirement is to just not look, save for seeing what funds you are invested in. A low fee, global passive fund is suitable for most people and if the global economy implodes and never recovers we are all fucked anyway.
Don’t just stay on an employers default lifestyle option, they are only suitable if you plan to buy an annuity - if you don’t then you’ll still need at least 60-75% equities to carry you through maybe 30 years of retirement.

edwinbear · 28/09/2022 21:35

And I take the same view a you @Hayliebells I have a DC scheme, the value has fallen (mainly the equities), but I’m 20yrs away from retirement so it has time to recover. My mortgage on the other hand - far more immediate issue!

tillytoodles1 · 28/09/2022 21:34

I was a SAHM mum until my youngest went to junior school. I get £200 a month on top of my state pension and have to pay for everything. It really pisses me off that if I got less and had pension credit all the stuff I have to pay for would be free. I pay my rates, dental fees and everything.

edwinbear · 28/09/2022 21:33

DC schemes have lost money because they will also invest in equities (and some corporate bonds/gilts/cash) and the equity part has fallen. As well as the price of the bonds/gilts. It’s worth noting there is an inverse relationship between bond/gilt prices I.e the cash price to buy them and the yield (return) you make on them. The lower the price, the higher the yield and vice versa.

Hayliebells · 28/09/2022 21:29

I am starting to understand it, thanks! But why are some PPs complaining they've lost money on their pensions this week? I'm not worried about my (admittedly small) private pension as it hasn't lost much at all. To answer the OPs question, this whole crisis hasn't got me spooked about my pension and investments at all as they're holding up well, and I've no reason to believe they won't continue to do so. My mortgage on the other hand is a different kettle of fish. I'm really quite worried about that, as it looks like I'll be paying much much more for it in a couple of years.

BorgQueen · 28/09/2022 21:24

Nobody with a DB pension has lost anything. It’s basically a promise to pay an income of X amount at age 65 or whenever - there is no pot of money with that kind of pension.

DC pensions fluctuate daily and the only time it matters is when you have to sell funds for income or to buy an annuity. Only those buying annuity sell all assets.

That’s why, on the run up to retirement, you build up cash reserves, usually inside a pension, that will act as a buffer and give you income during rough times. You can also have income from dividends, if you have income funds.
Say you have £100k in your pension and will take an income of £4000 a year from it, ideally you will have £12- £20k in cash as your buffer if you have no other savings.

edwinbear · 28/09/2022 21:23

@Hayliebells you’re absolutely right. People in DB schemes will still get their pensions in line with their terms. The issue is that final salary schemes are essentially untenable these days, hence them being closed to most new entrants. The cost to maintain them is why they have to leverage them - i.e buy gilts, then use those same gilts as security to buy more gilts. Pretty risky strategy, but to make the returns they need to meet their contractual requirements, they have to take more risk than with a DC scheme.

The BoE have artificially supported gilts to protect DB schemes, but if they incur a loss in doing so, the Government (tax payers) will pick up the bill.

Hayliebells · 28/09/2022 21:11

edwinbear · 28/09/2022 20:57

www.itv.com/news/2022-09-28/why-the-mini-budget-threatened-to-bankrupt-pension-funds

This article describes the situation better - and it’s primarily the final salary schemes that were affected. The BoE stepped in precisely to avert the situation - as it should/would.

Thanks for that, it explains it very well. But it's left me even more confused in on respect, if this has mainly affected define benefit funds, of which the benefits are guaranteed anyway, why have the OP (and PP), lost money on their pensions? The funds haven't collapsed, the defined benefits will still be paid, so pensioners haven't lost anything, or am I missing something again?

user1487194234 · 28/09/2022 21:09

Have more or less resigned myself to working until I drop 🤷‍♀️

kitcat15 · 28/09/2022 21:03

200degrees · 28/09/2022 20:57

For me, my pension isn’t something I think about much as I’m in my 20s. Half consider opting out most months. Therefore mortgage changes are more pertinent. Short term hassle vs long term hassle

I was in my 20s like you….I blinked and was in my 50s….. I considered opting out of my NHS pension at one stage when times were hard with 3 little ones….if I had I wouldn’t have been able to take my pension at 55 with lump sum …l.think long and hard before opting out of a pension

BorgQueen · 28/09/2022 21:02

If you have a small pension, then it can be positively harmful in later life as the tiny bit of income can put you over the limit for benefits. Sometimes it’s better to not have one at all, my Sister would have been much better off without hers as her rent would have been paid and she’d have got extra benefits.

200degrees · 28/09/2022 20:57

For me, my pension isn’t something I think about much as I’m in my 20s. Half consider opting out most months. Therefore mortgage changes are more pertinent. Short term hassle vs long term hassle

edwinbear · 28/09/2022 20:57

www.itv.com/news/2022-09-28/why-the-mini-budget-threatened-to-bankrupt-pension-funds

This article describes the situation better - and it’s primarily the final salary schemes that were affected. The BoE stepped in precisely to avert the situation - as it should/would.

Hayliebells · 28/09/2022 20:57

I'll get most of my retirement income from the Teachers Pension. I'm not worried about that as there is no actual Teachers Pension fund. The money that I and my employer pay into that just goes towards paying retiree teachers today, so likewise the teachers working in 20 years time will be paying my pension. I have a small private pension too though, which hasn't actually lost much value at all. It's invested in global whole of market trackers, so not particularly exposed to the UK markets, I guess that's why? Are the people who have lost a big chunk of their pension over the last week invested in company defined benefit schemes, with a major UK focus? I'm not really clued into how all this works, I've just read some blogs which recommended whole of market global trackers as a wise investment and went with that. If they are invested predominantly in the UK, I've got to ask why is that? As this crisis exemplifies, wasn't that a pretty risky strategy? Or have I completely misunderstood? As I said, I haven't really got much of a clue about how pensions work!

BorgQueen · 28/09/2022 20:56

Stayathome - what do you mean by ‘buying out’ your sipp?
You only need enough cash in to take your tax free lump sum, ( so 25% or a smaller percentage of your choice) or you could sell just enough funds to use UFPLS, which leaves the rest of your pension uncrystallised.
You don’t need to put all your Sipp into cash in order to crystalise, nor do you need to fully crystalise.
I took a 10% lump sum from my sipp , so I sold enough from my best performing fund to cover it, and it’s now split into two parts, crystalised and uncristalised, which is still growing with my ongoing contributions.