Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Baby names - the last bastion of acceptable classism on here

67 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 28/09/2022 12:18

I see so many threads on here picking at things which are working class - tattoos, certain clothes, council housing etc - and posters generally respond in fury, accusing the OP of snobbery/classism.

So why is it so okay on here to call a baby name ‘chavvy’ or ‘something you can imagine being screamed in ASDA’?

Personally I either like the sound of a name or I don’t, I don’t obsess over the class angle.

OP posts:
Cheeselog · 28/09/2022 23:15

@SarahAndQuack is turquoise Le Creuset non-U? I’ve just bought a casserole in deep teal so shall get back in my box 🤣

GardenShack · 28/09/2022 23:15

@MrsHarrisgoestoTimbuctoo I'm fairly sure it was Sandra and Tracey.

The head of English at the school down the road is called Tracey.

bedtimestoriesforbears · 28/09/2022 23:15

@Cuppasoupmonster

You do know that you can refuse to do "news stories" or even just move on and do your work experience elsewhere?

Cheeselog · 28/09/2022 23:11

It’s naive to think that giving a child a name with a strong connection to a particular class won’t lead to them being perceived in a particular way, be that Wayne or Horatio. And that happens plenty in the real world, not just on MN. Obviously no one looks at baby Nevaeh and thinks ‘what a chav’ but it can have an impact throughout a person’s life - see Freakonomics.

Personally I prefer a name that doesn’t have baggage and I appreciate finding these things out on MN. For example Pippa used to be high on my list for a girl until I came on here (not class based but unwanted connotations).

Mojitoo · 28/09/2022 23:09

As pp have mentioned, I judge people using the word 'chavvy' because it's so incredibly offensive, rather than the names people choose for their children.

So why is it so okay on here to call a baby name ‘chavvy’ or ‘something you can imagine being screamed in ASDA’?

It's not, and I strongly suspect you know that. But it's way of introducing a thread where people reel off the usual names that get a drubbing here, isn't it?

RedToothBrush · 28/09/2022 23:04

J0y · 28/09/2022 22:27

I think it's lower middle class fear. And it's not a ridiculous fear, it's a real one.

The aristocracy is such a tiny percentage of the population, but it really fuels classism. The new middle class can't be grateful or proud, relieved or relaxed about class, not when they have a rung above them, silently shaming them for two things simultaneously 1) rising too high; passing as the great grandchild of middle-class folk, and yet also, 2) any behaviour that gives away that this is very unlikely to be the case.

Ie, calling your baby Taylor Ray. You don't see the Americans pigeon holing a child for having a terrible name in the same way. It's interesting imo. I'm not trying to offend.

Insecurity and a desperate need to conform and not stand out are the order of the day.

I have issues with that (and named child accordingly!)

I've heard it said that the most privileged group in society - upper middle class and aristocratic and the least privileged feel the need to conform least and therefore go for the craziest names - an aristocratic name could easily pass as working class.

5128gap · 28/09/2022 22:50

YANBU. There is much snobbery on MN, all of which is distasteful. But its really hitting rock bottom to describe anything connected with a baby as 'chavy'. What sort of person attaches a label like that to a child on the basis of the name they were given?

Tinkity · 28/09/2022 22:48

But isn’t that why people come on here & ask opinions about baby names in the first place? No one is going to say this stuff to your face in real life but that doesn’t mean they won’t be thinking it. Yes they’re stupid / ignorant / un-PC but that’s the point, isn’t it? To find out what someone really thinks even if they’re wrong or uniformed.

Grendalsmum · 28/09/2022 22:46

Eh? What on earth is wrong with Lola? Was she worried about getting grief from people who hate the Kinks? (Or the tomato appreciation society ... )

SarahAndQuack · 28/09/2022 22:35

Well, I have to say YABU because MN has vast subterranean reservoirs of what might be considered acceptable classism, and baby names are barely a lily pad floating on the top.

But, I guess baby names are slightly different from many other indicators, in that your feature wallpaper or your turquoise le creuset only bother you, but a child called Lily-Mae April or Jabeth Beelzebub is going to have to live with that name for the rest of their life (or until the reach deed poll age). I taught a very bright young woman who suffered under the name of Lola. It might be cute for a child but it really did bother her as an adult, and I know she submitted job applications under her middle name.

mamabear715 · 28/09/2022 22:30

I don't get the obsession here with class?

J0y · 28/09/2022 22:27

I think it's lower middle class fear. And it's not a ridiculous fear, it's a real one.

The aristocracy is such a tiny percentage of the population, but it really fuels classism. The new middle class can't be grateful or proud, relieved or relaxed about class, not when they have a rung above them, silently shaming them for two things simultaneously 1) rising too high; passing as the great grandchild of middle-class folk, and yet also, 2) any behaviour that gives away that this is very unlikely to be the case.

Ie, calling your baby Taylor Ray. You don't see the Americans pigeon holing a child for having a terrible name in the same way. It's interesting imo. I'm not trying to offend.

LoupsGarous · 28/09/2022 22:00

Mn skews very lower-middle class (not entirely, obviously, but I would say that’s the preponderant class bias), so there’s an assumption that everyone’s socially aspirational and desperate to dermarcate themselves from the WC, while at the same time not being overly aspirational, because that’s ‘try-hard’.

BloodyHellKen · 28/09/2022 21:47

Snugglemonkey · 28/09/2022 20:46

I can definitely imagine a lawyer called Cosmo. I know one called Wolfie too.

I love Cosmo, it's such a nice name for a cat 😁

Sandysandwich · 28/09/2022 21:32

I think it doesn't help that people are generally so wrapped up in their own lives that they assume the way they experience the world is the same as everyone else.
So they say that a child will get judged for being called Harvey or Chanay because that is what what might happen in their world, full of Matildas and Jaspers.
But to the poster whose child will go to the local comp full of kids with those names, with cousins with those names, that child will not stand out for being called Kai, Jax or Demi. They might stand out (not in a good way)for being called Euphegenia or Gideon.
I think people have those classist opinions about what makes an acceptable name- and then decide that the way they are comfortable with is the only good way

MummyJasmin · 28/09/2022 21:29

A lot of people are sadly racist and full of disdain for the poor, some may not be as obvious as others, but it's definitely there.

RoseAndRose · 28/09/2022 21:15

I think that anyone using the term 'chavvy' would be rounded on. Because it's a slur

But thinking that one class is somehow lesser than others is your prejudice. There is nothing whatsoever wrong with being working class, nor in naming your DC what you like and what reflects you.

Glitterspy · 28/09/2022 21:11

Oh yes, baby names come out and the gloves are off. Truly, the baby names forum is the UFC of Mumsnet.

I mean the situation calls for it - imagine getting stuck with a horrible chavvy wet name that’s everywhere this year without being told beforehand!

Houselamp · 28/09/2022 21:08

I think the style threads can be awful for this- like the ones about styles that people don't like or understand.
It always starts lighthearted with people who find a certain style of jeans don't flatter them or their kids fashion is new and bizarre.
Then ends with 60 posters thinking they are so original in hating leopard print, block eyebrows, eyelash extensions, sports clothes, chunky shoes, fake tan, leggings insert any type of clothing they think the poor/wc people wear. Like we get it, you are full of disdain for the poor, we are all thrilled you had to share your brave and hilarious opinion..

AndTwoFilmsByFrancoisTruffaut · 28/09/2022 20:57

MrsHarrisgoestoTimbuctoo · 28/09/2022 19:51

I could never look at a girl called "Sharon" or Tracy" without laughing, after seeing two characters with those names in Viz.....

You really need to get out more.

No one laughs at those names anymore. We’re not in 1995 Confused

Snugglemonkey · 28/09/2022 20:46

NewYorkLassie · 28/09/2022 19:41

And the ever-so-subtle "I can't imagine a lawyer or a doctor with that name

No, that’s different. It’s about style of name. I can’t imagine a lawyer called Cosmo, but it’s potentially the poshest name going.

I can definitely imagine a lawyer called Cosmo. I know one called Wolfie too.

Pilipalapal · 28/09/2022 20:38

MrsHarrisgoestoTimbuctoo · 28/09/2022 19:51

I could never look at a girl called "Sharon" or Tracy" without laughing, after seeing two characters with those names in Viz.....

Do people often comment that you seem a bit…well…thick?

JenniferBarkley · 28/09/2022 20:35

Definitely far from the last bastion of classism, and yes frequently xenophobic.

However, it's a well known long established fact that some names are strongly associated with particular social classes, or have clichés attached to them.

When you give a DC a name, it's not you who has to carry it through life. I wouldn't want to saddle my DC with a name that made people instantly think "chav", or "who does she think she is with a posh name like that, notions". It might not be enlightened for people to think like that but the fact is that many do and I wouldn't want to expose my DC to that unnecessarily, especially if there were other names I liked as much that didn't have those connotations.

The baby name forum is a great place to find that stuff out because in real life people will just say "oh lovely", regardless of what they're actually thinking.

Yarboosucks · 28/09/2022 20:15

You don't stress over the class angle, yet you saw fit to start a thread with that at its very core.

Admit it, you love it and are hungry for more!

erikbloodaxe · 28/09/2022 20:11

@honeylulu you are right.