Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Liz Truss - why didn't we realise?

261 replies

ARoyalSubject · 28/09/2022 11:06

Turn the clock back a month, and we knew she was stupid, and that more than likely she was the wrong choice for a sensible, responsible prime minister - but did people join the dots and realise that she was such an ideologue / so in thrall to ideologues?

AIBU to say that the media didn't spell out exactly what a Truss premiership meant?

She and Kwazi have written a book on exactly what's happening now for god's sake! Why wasn't the possibility they would act on it examined in more detail?

I'm not a member of the Tory party - did they realise what they were voting for?

OP posts:
Farmercalmer101 · 28/09/2022 15:11

Xiaoxiong · 28/09/2022 12:09

@vera99 wow - that's really unfair on Kwasi! He delivered what Truss promised - the fact that no one likes it except the Conservative members that voted for her is neither here nor there, you could argue that if he DIDN'T deliver what she promised that she would be letting her electorate of 81k down.

This should bring down the whole government and lead to a general election. That's what should happen when you elect an ideologue in a leadership election who doesn't have a mandate to do those things from the country.

Whether it does or not...who knows. I hope the 81k tory electors realise belatedly that they should have elected someone with more centrist policies if they wanted to hang on in government. It's momentum and labour and corbyn but from the opposite side of the aisle.

Funny how the government have been undermining the civil service in the past few years leading up to this point. I see Rees- Mogg's hands all over this. The very people we rely on to keep everything running smoothly when the government of the day goes to shit. Kwarteng sacking the permanent secretary at the Treasury was a big clue as to the direction he was about to take:

www.ft.com/content/9571c1f7-55b2-42ac-a126-ec0fcdeefca4

I agree that we should have a general election.

The only way out of this is to elect a Labour government. And I hope they will blend with the Lib Dems as an unequivocal sign that they are reinhabiting the centre.

rookiemere · 28/09/2022 15:06

I also think Truss won because the Telegraph wanted her to win.

DH - who unfortunately has a free online torygraph subscription because of some wine purchases- started mentioning her name months ago.

The Conservative party members effectively voted for who they were told to - probably and ironically to their own detriment, as many are like my DPs, well off but certainly not in that ultra high tax band.

Dreikanter · 28/09/2022 15:01

Crikeyalmighty · 28/09/2022 14:57

@Dreikanter don't know about you but I think Rachael Reeves background as an economist and at BOE is a tad more relevant!

Well, quite. I wouldn't call Kwarteng an economist for one thing.

milveycrohn · 28/09/2022 15:01

Well, did austerity work?
Truss is going for growth. A different tactic.
Ultimately, the lockdowns have cost the country approx 300 billion GBP (some estimates are more).
This money has to be found from somewhere. Up to now, it has been quantitative easing (inflation).
My own view. The 45% tax rate apparently did not bring in very much anyway, so why remove it. In other words, I think the tax cuts were a bit too generous.
The pound is suffering because interest rates were expected to rise by 0.75 last week, instead of the 0.5 percent actual.

MelodyPondsMum · 28/09/2022 15:00

The media did point it out. Even the ones who suddenly swung behind her made it clear she was all about the Tory funders, big businesses and didn't give a stuff about anyone else.
I'm watching the 'ordinary' Tories that I know with interest because usually they're quite moderate and quite vocal eg they hated Boris and his complete lack of values. But with Truss ... crickets. Which is odd since even The Times' readers are very unhappy.

SleeplessInEngland · 28/09/2022 14:59

Morbidly curious to see if Truss will try to go the whole week without making a media appearence.

Tangled123 · 28/09/2022 14:58

How is she allowed to do this? She has no mandate from the British people. The English voted Johnson for Brexit but they haven’t voted for this. The Tories have precedent for holding a general election when a new PM comes in (Theresa May and Boris Johnson both held elections). That should have been what she did first.

Are the government not representing the royal family as well? I know they generally stay out of politics but this goes beyond that. I don’t think they should stay quiet on this.

Anyone following Truss during the leadership contest (or even before that) knew what she was doing to do though. She didn’t keep her plans secret.

Crikeyalmighty · 28/09/2022 14:57

@Dreikanter don't know about you but I think Rachael Reeves background as an economist and at BOE is a tad more relevant!

TheAntiTruss · 28/09/2022 14:56

Truss won also because she was seen as Johnson’s rightful heir, whereas Sunak was portrayed as a traitor to the ‘dear leader’. Sunak warned us about these tax cuts and the elderly, well-heeled Tory membership has a lot to answer for for voting for the least capable candidate.

Crikeyalmighty · 28/09/2022 14:55

I'm afraid those 'ordinary people' who thought Brexit was a great idea only bought into the 'less EU immigration and that a shortage of workers would up their rates ' end of the spectrum- they didn't think about the whole ideology of the current Tory party and that is to reduce rights, reduce the state and basically make it dog eat dog.

Anyone with an ounce of 'one party nation' decency has left or been voted out or crossed the floor in a few cases. We are left now with mainly the ideologist , 'libertarian' weirdos- basically the 'Apprentice' candidates.

Their are some people who benefit from these policies, mainly older well off people with savings and no mortgages or high earners still working with savings and no /low mortgages . Now some will give a shit that it's affecting their families (kids) , plenty really don't. However if pension funds totally tank, then they might. It's not hard to see how Truss was voted in- most of those Tory members fit the above criteria, plenty really don't give a shit about others. .

It's very obvious on even mumsnet who is in a good position to benefit. Some benefit but don't like the way things are going , but plenty are still in the 'all is well in my village in Surrey, on £250k a year, no mortgage, plenty of holidays etc.

I am not a radical socialist but I am of the view that a good society is far more balanced than turning it into the wild west, like some kind of USA but without the better wages in certain careers, the weather or neighbourhood school buses etc - we appear to be gaining all the worst aspects of USA but little of the better ones.

MarshaBradyo · 28/09/2022 14:52

Sometimes party members get it right and the leader is elected, last election for example

Sometimes they get it really wrong - on both sides and the person tanks in the election

I haven’t done a tally of which process gets it right more often (not that committed) but as a process it’s not been great for this time

Dreikanter · 28/09/2022 14:52

Discovereads · 28/09/2022 14:19

Except economics History isn’t an economics degree, it’s a history degree. I’ve read the course modules at Oxford where he went, it’s all social history and how historic and ancient economies affected social history. There’s nothing practical in his degree as in how economies actually work.

Kwarteng has a degree in Classics and History, and his PhD is titled Political thought of the recoinage crisis of 1695-7. I don't think Kwarteng is a stranger to debasing currency.

Getofftheladder · 28/09/2022 14:50

YABU. It was pretty clear she would be a disaster and that Rishi was by far the better candidate.

IceandIndigo · 28/09/2022 14:49

I think it was absolutely clear what she would do, I haven't been surprised by any of it!

I'm not a Tory voter so can't really comment on what those people thought they were getting, but in general many people tend to vote very narrowly on self-interest, rather than considering the bigger picture. I think the fact that the Tory MPs wanted Sunak speaks volumes - they are more concerned about electability than the members.

ginghamstarfish · 28/09/2022 14:49

'we' had no choice in the matter, and so those who disagree with their MP's choice can express their feelings at the next election.

IrisVersicolor · 28/09/2022 14:48

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 28/09/2022 14:35

As I said above the ERG plan is to turn the U.K. into a low tax, low, reg, low social protection economy - Singapore meets the US. First the Brexiters needed to get rid of the EU, and now this is Part Deux.

I think you're overestimating the abilities of LT and KK. I think they've fucked up - haven't seen many (any?) MPs rushing out to defend them. I honestly wouldn't be surprised if one or both of them are gone by Christmas.

They have fucked up, because the whole ERG has fucked up - they are delusional. Don’t forget they were gunning for No Deal with WTO rules. Truss does not have the brains to think up this shit on her own. She’s just a puppet.

FangsForTheMemory · 28/09/2022 14:48

Those who gave her the job knew exactly what she would do because they are the ones instructing her. Nothing she’s done is ACCIDENTAL! She made a few rich people a lot of money. That was her job.

RoyalCorgi · 28/09/2022 14:47

I think the newspapers did make it clear what she stood for. She explained what she was going to do - indeed, Sunak explained in a leadership debate exactly what the consequences of her policy would be.

If I'd had a vote (and I'm not a Tory), I'd have voted for Sunak. In fact, as I understand it, Sunak had the support of the majority of MPs. But the Tory members are a different kettle of fish.

IrisVersicolor · 28/09/2022 14:45

Fladdermus · 28/09/2022 14:29

It was a PhD not a degree and from Cambridge. It was on the debasement of currency in England.

In the 1600s.

True, but the principles of debasement/inflation haven’t changed.

Arguably we are all a piece of live PhD fieldwork.

TeaKlaxon · 28/09/2022 14:44

ARoyalSubject · 28/09/2022 14:17

I certainly wasn't fully informed. I'm not a Tory member or voter but follow politics with some interest.... I read a lot in the papers and on Twitter about her; I saw a lot of comments that she was not very bright but I didn't see anything which spelled out her extremist views on economic matters. What has happened in the last few days has taken me by surprise somewhat.

I mean her opponent in the race literally told us this is what the consequence of her extreme economic position would be.

I’m not sure you can claim to follow politics and simultaneously not have been aware that there were warnings that Liz Truss’ economic policy would destabilise confidence in the UK economy, fuel inflation and potentially involve the IMF.

itsnotdeep · 28/09/2022 14:39

I was always in favour of Liz Truss winning as I'm a labour voter and supporter!

Rishi knew. But the Tory voters who voted Liz Truss don't care because they want the tax cuts. The right wing press? They probably don't care either because they're run by media moguls who will make a lot of money from all of this. By the time Labour get in (and they will), all the wealth will have been squirrelled away and we will be in deep recession. Tories don't care because they're handing a poisoned chalice to Labour.

SleeplessInEngland · 28/09/2022 14:39

I think we can all agree this is an absolute indictment on tory membershop voting and if the party has any sense they'll just coronate future leaders in between elections from now on.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 28/09/2022 14:35

As I said above the ERG plan is to turn the U.K. into a low tax, low, reg, low social protection economy - Singapore meets the US. First the Brexiters needed to get rid of the EU, and now this is Part Deux.

I think you're overestimating the abilities of LT and KK. I think they've fucked up - haven't seen many (any?) MPs rushing out to defend them. I honestly wouldn't be surprised if one or both of them are gone by Christmas.

Regularsizedrudy · 28/09/2022 14:35

There’s 2 types of Tory- evil or thick. It doesn’t surprise me that they make the worst possible decision given the opportunity.

Bacibaci · 28/09/2022 14:34

Why wasn't the possibility they would act on it examined in more detail?

Because over 80% of U.K. media is owned by right wing, tax exiling billionaires. They and the many party members who voted wanted this. They think it’s necessary to switch to an even further deregulated state - as has been mentioned a Singapore on Thames.