Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that lots of TAs, LSAs and school administrators leave because of the money?

138 replies

Lulutheevilguineapig · 28/09/2022 10:17

I'm in this situation atm and although I love my job, I'm seriously starting to look for something else.

I get why the money is poor; we get school holidays off. But I'd honestly prefer to work holidays and not take the hit to my salary. I know this is part and parcel of working in a school, but I just don't know how anyone who doesn't have maybe a wealthy partner or some other source of wealth can stay for long in the job.

And on another note, if you were a TA/LSA and left due to the money, what did you go on to do?

OP posts:
Elizabeth110100 · 29/09/2022 07:10

AlinaSquareQueen · 28/09/2022 11:20

Not only are many schools having issues recruiting, but I’ve seen adverts for TA and HLTA positions where they either require applicants to be a relevant degree-holder, or it’s desirable…. surely they’re having a laugh!

How many graduates would apply for a full-time job paying £1000 per month??

Me. I have a degree and work for a full time job paying £1000 a month. In a school. Two of my TA friends so have degrees. One is a qualified teacher.

Whoopsies · 29/09/2022 07:10

I work as a ta. You're right, there is no way I could do this job if it was needed to live on. I'm so fortunate that I don't need to work financially. I actually work at my DCs school so the commute and childcare is a non issue. It's hard work, but I love it so I'm happy to do it, but it is literally for pocket money!!

BusyMum47 · 29/09/2022 06:59

ButMostOfAllWinnieThePooh · 28/09/2022 22:36

Also a TA, I take home 11k a year. I've worked in the same school for over 7 years and I've never had a pay increase other than the annual below inflation pay rise. Despite the fact in that time I've done the level 3 qualification.

I have taught whole classes when the teacher has been ill (including planning what we are doing).
I regularly take groups for interventions and plan/assess what we will be doing.
I do all the reading for my class which means I'm the only person teaching them to read as reading is not taught as a lesson.
I am regularly left in charge of over 80 children alone while they are eating at lunch times as we have no dinner staff whatsoever!
During lesson times my job is exactly the same as the teachers, we do the exact same thing to support their learning.
If I want to get admin jobs done such as cutting sheets, sticking things in I have to come in early and do in unpaid because there isn't time during the day.
And I'm sick of all the extra responsibility, being treated like absolute crap by parents. All for barely above minimum wage!
And yet I would be heartbroken to leave, I adore the children. I love the teacher I work with and I am bloody good at my job but something has to change!

Same! ⬆️

I teach the whole class solo probably more time per week than I do my TA role - in yr6!

School is great, Teachers amazing, SLT supportive etc - I'm really lucky in that regard but the money is appalling & quite honestly downright insulting for what I do on a daily basis!

I stick it out because it suits my childcare situation & I'm also lucky in that my husband is the main wage earner & there is no serious reliance on my salary - for now.

I keep contemplating alternative jobs but have no idea what I'd do. I'm incredibly proud of my role & get huge job satisfaction from it - alongside the extreme frustration & exhaustion!

GoofyIsACow · 29/09/2022 06:42

LivingMyBestLie · 28/09/2022 23:39

Out of interest, what did you go on to do instead?

similar, office based, financial but private sector

LivingMyBestLie · 28/09/2022 23:39

GoofyIsACow · 28/09/2022 22:12

I left my job as a school business manager in July, i LOVED it! The best colleagues and the most wonderful children.
i work full time now only 7 more hours a week and I earn over twice what i earned in school.
I wish i could have afforded to stay at school but sadly i couldn’t.
it broke my heart to leave.

Out of interest, what did you go on to do instead?

NippyWoowoo · 28/09/2022 23:37

Left being and SEN TA to a nanny. Have worked with a mix of children, some having SEN themselves. More than double the salary, I don't regret it, but 5+ years on and I still haven't gotten used to the lack of holidays 😂

StillMedusa · 28/09/2022 23:35

I left this year after 17 years as a Special School TA.
The pay was dire of course but I loved the children . What broke me was the erosion of funds for the school so gradually all the things that made it so amazing were gradually withdrawn.. trips, Riding for the Disabled, Forest School... you name it. There wasn't enough in the budget for basic art supplied let alone anything else.
And all services decreased dramatically... children who 10 years ago would at least get weekly speech therapy from a trained NHS therapist... nope.. lucky if they got a yearly review. ALL to the detriment of the children we were doing our best to educate. it was demoralising.
Then Covid hit and it was ridiculous. We continued (no break) with the children trapped in their classrooms , no mixing, no fun. Staff left (some for better jobs , some just retirement etc) and they couldn't recruit anyone!

When I started there were so many applicants for every job. Now there are very very few, if any. Shortage of teachers, shortage of TAs.

I left and am currently caring for my grandson. I miss the children but I can earn at least as much in jobs that don't require me to be a physio/ educator/ personal carer. Where I don't have responsilbility for medication, for dealing with seizures or challenging behaviour etc.

TA's aren't just pot washers and bum wipers as so many think, but undervalued, underpaid and it is simply no longer a good job.

ButMostOfAllWinnieThePooh · 28/09/2022 23:25

Oops quoted the wrong post! That was for Lindsey!

ButMostOfAllWinnieThePooh · 28/09/2022 23:24

TheRubyRedshoes · 28/09/2022 22:47

The treatment of support staff leaves a lot to be desired as well!

Incredible how rude people are to them and yet many places could not function without them

Because I don't want to leave the teacher I work with/school in the lurch. Because I feel a sense of responsibility to the children in my class. But also because I have a husband who earns a decent wage so I can afford to stay in my badly paid job. Many of my colleagues are now working 2 jobs and are coming into school knackered!

Lulutheevilguineapig · 28/09/2022 23:13

I definitely don't think it's horrendous. I think it's a lovely job, I just can't afford to keep doing it.

Most teachers are very nice to me tbf. I am really friendly irl and also quite direct, so I can take it when students are not being pleasant too.

It's just the money. I know teachers aren't exactly rolling in it either, but if I trained to teach, which I technically could in a year with a PGCE, I'd be able to afford to live. I think the crux of the matter for me is that I don't want to teach, so it isn't really anywhere for my career to progress.

OP posts:
LindseyHoyleSpeaks · 28/09/2022 23:05

So why do all the TAs who say it’s horrendous stay? With flexible working/home working etc, you are not tied to the schools you’re in. Leave!

spirit20 · 28/09/2022 22:52

TAs are paid appallingly badly for how valuable and necessary their work is. We have the same issue at the school I work - I'm a teacher and some classes I teach literally would not be able to function without the help of the TA due to the needs of the kids there. However, the number of TAs are constantly being cut due to budget issues, and those who are hired are on temporary term-time-only contracts for disgustingly little money.

Most of our TAs are young people just out of uni and living at home who are trying to see if teaching might be a career for them, semi-retired people or people who are supported fully by their partners and old enough to have their mortgage paid off. There's no way anyone could survive on what they're paid if they had to pay their own rent etc. Working in supermarkets etc, would let them earn far more, especially given that they'd have the chance to work more hours and work all-year round.

TheRubyRedshoes · 28/09/2022 22:47

The treatment of support staff leaves a lot to be desired as well!

Incredible how rude people are to them and yet many places could not function without them

WyfOfBathe · 28/09/2022 22:43

I'm a teacher in a secondary school which is/was known locally for its SEN provision. We used to have plenty of TAs. Many of them were well qualified and experienced. They often had a real passion for their job.

Most of those have left and the school is struggling to recruit. A lot of the newer TAs are school leavers or new graduates doing it as a stopgap. They're doing their best and some are wonderful, but it doesn't compare to someone who's worked with autistic students for 15 years and really cares about their education.

TheRubyRedshoes · 28/09/2022 22:41

What's happening with the union's because they're were trying to negotiate new pay?

An offer was made of 2.5% and a one off cost of living payment. That would be extremely helpful right now!

What's happened to the negotiations as that offer was rejected.

Do some settings get it but not others?

ButMostOfAllWinnieThePooh · 28/09/2022 22:36

Also a TA, I take home 11k a year. I've worked in the same school for over 7 years and I've never had a pay increase other than the annual below inflation pay rise. Despite the fact in that time I've done the level 3 qualification.

I have taught whole classes when the teacher has been ill (including planning what we are doing).
I regularly take groups for interventions and plan/assess what we will be doing.
I do all the reading for my class which means I'm the only person teaching them to read as reading is not taught as a lesson.
I am regularly left in charge of over 80 children alone while they are eating at lunch times as we have no dinner staff whatsoever!
During lesson times my job is exactly the same as the teachers, we do the exact same thing to support their learning.
If I want to get admin jobs done such as cutting sheets, sticking things in I have to come in early and do in unpaid because there isn't time during the day.
And I'm sick of all the extra responsibility, being treated like absolute crap by parents. All for barely above minimum wage!
And yet I would be heartbroken to leave, I adore the children. I love the teacher I work with and I am bloody good at my job but something has to change!

SpiritedSneeze · 28/09/2022 22:30

I was a TA in an sen school and I absolutely loved it. I was really good at it, I was working with brilliant kids and I was excited for work every monday. I still miss it.
I left because I couldn't afford to do it anymore, and I had three other jobs at the same time. I was exhausted, kept getting given more and more responsibilities which I loved but also brought so much stress and took up my minimal free time for no extra money, had no opportunity for progression, was frequently injured and still struggling to pay bills.

I left and kept up my part time jobs while I trained to be an LD nurse. The money is not great but it is better than TA money and I can afford to live independently and I am safe within that and I can work 12hr shifts and have more days to be with my kids rather than working every day of the week

lightisnotwhite · 28/09/2022 22:29

olddustbag · 28/09/2022 21:10

The annual pay is less than sainsburys (TAs are paid for 44 weeks only)
There are chronic vacancies across the country

They leave when tax credits/ price of petrol to get to work/ childcare make it unsustainable.
Unfortunately women with children tend to go into it for the school holidays and leave was soon as they can afford a better plan B. Women without children at home only stay if the pension is on the horizon.

lightisnotwhite · 28/09/2022 22:18

Incrediblebuttrue · 28/09/2022 10:41

I can't believe how badly TAs are paid. It really is scandalous.

Absolutely. I also think the way the job is advertised at say £20k and the pro rated ie the whole school day (which doesn’t count as full time) minus holidays brings it closer to £14/15k but with a 30 hr week.
I was on a teachers salary which apparently doesn’t pay for the holidays either but is at least double. However often the TA’s would take classes, teach small groups, make resources in their own time and get given paperwork by the class teacher to complete.

liveforsummer · 28/09/2022 22:16

If it's just the school holiday deficit that's a problem then can't you get a job in a holiday club? I'm a TA and a single parent. No way I could survive on the wage alone, especially heading into the current climate. I don't want to do a holiday club as wound defeat the purpose of wanting term time employment to spend time with dc and save on holiday care costs but I do bar work when they are at their dads to top it up or the odd long shift while they go to their grandparents. The good thing is holidays coincide with when hospitality often need temporary extra staff so is a good fit

IncessantNameChanger · 28/09/2022 22:12

whatshouldIdo2022 · 28/09/2022 11:18

Its the content of the role too , I was early twenties when I started as a TA in an SEN school and I was regularly left with the whole class, or asked to cover lessons, I was required to be team teach trained and use it when required, I was injured by pupils on a number of occasions as were my colleagues. It requires a huge level of skill and resilience to be a good TA and the pay should reflect that, or staff don't feel valued and they leave.

This is a very issue and tbh I can't see how some SEN schools will survive. We have 7 TA vacancies

GoofyIsACow · 28/09/2022 22:12

I left my job as a school business manager in July, i LOVED it! The best colleagues and the most wonderful children.
i work full time now only 7 more hours a week and I earn over twice what i earned in school.
I wish i could have afforded to stay at school but sadly i couldn’t.
it broke my heart to leave.

DanglingMod · 28/09/2022 22:09

And, as above, they're all leaving for supermarket, office admin, hospital admin and community care type roles. All better paid.

DanglingMod · 28/09/2022 22:07

Redlocks28 · 28/09/2022 21:14

TA pay is dire.

To be honest, I think the way things are heading, we won’t have any TAs in a few years in schools anyway-save a few for high need children with EHC funding. The government don’t value them, don’t pay them enough and schools can’t afford to pay the ones they do have. Ours are leaving left, right and centre for anything else-shop work, charity, supermarket, care roles etc -all have either scope for more pay or more hours. The ones that leave, we can’t afford to replace due to the massive energy prices.

The problem is that we can't even recruit enough staff to cover the hours of the children with funded hours of support and them alone. Gone are the days of whole class TA support. Long gone.

CollieWobble22 · 28/09/2022 22:07

I was a HLTA in 2005. I was due to go to university to become a primary school teacher in 2006. The school had 6 classes and each teacher was a bullying asshole. The atmosphere was so toxic I decided to still go to university and put my skills elsewhere and become a marketing / design professional instead.

I still can't believe how little I got paid even though I was a HLTA!

Best decision I ever made. My HLTA years make me shudder!