Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To pay a £7K exit fee now

58 replies

millymog11 · 28/09/2022 07:58

For my fixed term mortgage on 1.9% expiring 3 March 2024 (i.e. 18 months to go) in order to get a 10 year fixed at 3.8% with a different mortgage provider which will basically pay off my entire mortgage and also consolidate my small home improvement loan?
£7K seems steep especially as I have 18 months left on my current fixed but my current fixed mortgage provider (Santander) has TOTALLY shut down its website page which, until 48 hours ago listed their other mortgage deals and I waited 55 mintues on their call helpline at about 5pm last night before giving up and putting the phone down.

(Single mum sole earner, two teenage kids live with and depend on my 100% of the time) , cannot afford to default on my mortgage, need certainty of mind, what would you do?)

OP posts:
Princessglittery · 28/09/2022 11:04

As pp state chuck any excess each month at the £10k loan as well as the £7k. The quicker you pay this off the better. Then divert the monthly payments for the loan plus the excess each month at the mortgage - this will reduce the amount owed so even if interest rates go up your payments should be affordable.

No one can tell you what the rate will be in 2024.

A very long time ago I maxed out my mortgage and I needed certainty regarding payments. I did a 5 year fixed rate of 7% which at the time was a good deal. Part way through the term, interest rates dropped to less than 3%. It was hard paying the higher rate but I accepted it as I had needed certainty when I took it out and had seen much higher interest rates.

Manchester1990 · 28/09/2022 10:52

Sounds like a rash decision. You do have time on your hands and you should hold your nerve for 15 months.

Appleblum · 28/09/2022 10:47

Obviously you need to do the maths but a cursory look at the figures you've given here makes me think that it wouldnt be worth it. 140k mortgage left over 10 years isn't alot even on a higher interest rate. 7k exit fees sounds exorbitant in comparison. I would stay put and put the 7k into overpayments.

LadyRoughDiamond · 28/09/2022 10:25

We’re in a similar position @millymog11 - fixed period ends Nov 23, £6.6k early redemption fee. I just spoke to my broker who pointed out that our redemption fee is staggered and so will go down considerably on December 1st. Mortgage offers are valid for 6 months and so we’re going to secure a new rate for 5 years asap and complete after Dec 1st.
Look closely at your deal and speak to a broker who’ll have access to better rates - things may be better than you think.

WimbyAce · 28/09/2022 10:19

If it it doesn't run out til March 24 personally I wouldn't do it. I would just try to overpay as much as possible now.

caringcarer · 28/09/2022 10:03

Also getting a formal offer in writing you can still not activate at all but gives you security blanket in case rates sky rocket. Which I think they will over next year. I also lived through paying 12.2 percent. In those days most mortgages were SVR. I noticed rates go up far faster than they go down.

caringcarer · 28/09/2022 09:58

I have 3 X btl mortgages that were tracking base rate 2 by + 1.25 and 1 by 1 percent. So currently on 2 X 3.75 and 1 by 3.25. They were lifetime trackers. I have applied for all 3 to go onto 5 year fixed rates at 4.03 percent. I have offer in writing and have 4 months to activate. So I am holding off 1 month on 2 and 2-3 months on other one. My broker told me once you have a formal offer made you have not got to activate it immediately. Each one is different but common to be given 4-6 months to activate. In your shoes I would make application for new mortgage, get formal offer, then sit tight whilst you see where rates are going. I am only activating when new mortgage works out cheaper than old one. I am lucky I have no early release penalties.

Ariela · 28/09/2022 09:55

Frankly I think you will struggle to get a deal to suit. Few lenders are going to find the current market stable enough to offer anything but a high rate deal to cover themselves 'just in case', so any unsigned deals will likely be pulled. As you're on a strikingly low mortgage rate for now, I would focus your efforts on reducing what you owe - pay off the home improvement loan - is that a fixed rate or variable? Particularly if variable then focus on clearing that ASAP, and building up some savings so either you can cushion a ride for a year on a variable before fixing once the rate improves, or you can pay a lump sum off the balance and reduce payments (and interest) that way.
Next year we may have extra high interest rates, however we have a general election in January 2025 - or possibly sooner, we don't know. It's quite likely we will get a complete change of government and thus the markets will change dramatically. If the £ rises vs the $ then imports become cheaper, inflation lower and we go back to more stability. I would suggest take a view of 'wait and see' as towards the end of 2023 I can only imagine the long term view will either be 'this policy is working' - we see investment in the UK as it's so cheap to buy from abroad, companies pay less corporation tax if based here etc (so the exchange rate, inflation, etc improves and inflation reduces) or 'we will get a change of government completely in Jan 2025' so either way the long term prognosis IMHO would be interest rates should begin to come back down during 2025, so a fixed term in late 2024 (if you can bear a short while on the variable) is likely to give you a far better price than today, or even March 2024.

I'm with @Singlebutmarried Stick with it

I survived the 16%+ or so interest rates of past years (there were no fixed rates then and many of my friends lost their houses) by taking on more jobs (cleaning pub loos before proper work was disgusting but it paid well) and by paying off capital to reduce interest with any lump sum I got (got a sales job and was paid commission).

Wheretheskyisblue · 28/09/2022 09:39

What is the likelihood that there will be fixed deals at around 3.85% (5 or ideally 10 years) available in March 2024 do you think?

In 1977 rates took 2.5 years to rise from 6% to reach their peak of 17% in 1979 they then took 9 years to fall back to 8% in 1988 before rising again to 15% in 1989, it then took another 4 years to drop to 5%.

I think it is best to prepare for a lengthy period of high interest rates and the £7k to fix might be wise....

Dannexe · 28/09/2022 09:31

I think they’ve pulled the rate anyway. If you go through their calculator with your figures it’s showing their only ten year fix as being 4.85

millymog11 · 28/09/2022 09:25

"Stop paying all the extra amounts off your 1.9% mortgage and put as much money as possible into paying off your 5.9% loan for a start. I would always get rid of the more expensive loan first."

You are right. I do have a tendancy to be fixated on getting my mortgage down. But i was offered a deal on triple glazing (gmt incentive scheme) which would cost me just over £10K and decided it was worth it in light of energy bills. Did it all in a bit of a hurry and to resist the hard sell 11.9% apr over 180 months the window company wanted me to take out (so at least I got that bit right!!!)

OP posts:
onmywayamarillo · 28/09/2022 09:23

Yes agreed pay the loan off! That's a high rate of interest

Wnikat · 28/09/2022 09:22

It’s going to cost you 10k in early repayment charges and extra interest for those 18 months.

you need a broker to give you some scenarios for different interest rates, fixed terms etc to see if that’s worth it.

onmywayamarillo · 28/09/2022 09:22

I would personally save the 7k and all the fees and save save save

In 18 months things could look a lot better ! And you will probably have quite a lot of savings too.

Keep paying your 10% off every year.
When the deal is coming to an end usually 6 months before. See what your options are?

You should have saved at least 20k or more by then..

Unicorn2022 · 28/09/2022 09:19

Stop paying all the extra amounts off your 1.9% mortgage and put as much money as possible into paying off your 5.9% loan for a start. I would always get rid of the more expensive loan first.

There is a calculator on money saving expert which tells you if it is worth switching, but I think
£7k is too much to pay to exit a £140k mortgage when you still have 18 months to go at a low rate.

millymog11 · 28/09/2022 09:09

"and made a few £1k bulk deposits over the last 3 or so years to bring it down)."

My santander mortage is currently £140K but I would wrap up my home improvement loan via Lloyds (£10,500) into that bringing it down from the Lloyds home improvement loan rate of about 5.9% into the 3.85% and that is why I said I would be borrowing about £150K - £157K (if i cannot find the £7K exit fee for Santander)

OP posts:
rookiemere · 28/09/2022 09:08

It's such a hard one to call OP, but I would say that the £7k fee to exit sounds very high and if possible I'd try to plough as much into the mortgage as possible whilst you have the low rate. What are your earnings ?

millymog11 · 28/09/2022 09:07

"and we should have a labour government (surely to goodness these twerps will have given us a GE by then)"

sorry to be thick and ask a dumb question (which if my mind was not racing so much I would know the answer to) but when is the very last deadline when the next GE has to be called? I did know the answer to this but now it has flown out of my head (no guarantee it will be labour of course but the polls at the moment look that way at least on a day to day basis that is)

OP posts:
millymog11 · 28/09/2022 09:04

"I can’t quite grasp how a higher rate with more borrowing is less than your current. Unless you are going over a longer term?"

I don't know, I am rubbish with maths. Although it might have something to do with the fact that i have overpaid my mortgage since I got it (took it out fixed 5 years at 1.9% starting December 2018 basic monthly payment £1190, I have paid £1450 every month since the start and made a few £1k bulk deposits over the last 3 or so years to bring it down).
The lenght of the mortgage started at 18 years in December 2018 but now my Santander online account says duration 13 years which is a bit quicker than straight line.

I don't know.

They will probably pull that rate by Friday and my monthly charge would be more. Who knows.

It is doing my head in a bit.

OP posts:
StillNotWarm · 28/09/2022 09:04

Can you cost up the total amount for a 10 year mortgage at 3.8% and 7k redemption fees.

Then work backwards to see what interest rates would need to be in 18 months to be cheaper overall. Might give you an idea about how much rates would need to rise to make it worthwhile.

But given the statement by the IMF, I'm not convinced there won't be some big chsnges before your mortgage expires.

Carla2601 · 28/09/2022 09:01

March 2024 is a long time off OP, things should have calmed significantly and we should have a labour government (surely to goodness these twerps will have given us a GE by then) so I think your current rate is so good as still has a long time to run I’d wait it out

TheTeddyBears · 28/09/2022 09:01

That's a tough one. But you'd have to work it all out. Work out what your currently paying for the next 18months and then a possible prediction on the rates it could go to and use that for the term of new deal.

In your new monthly payment you'd have to factor in the exit fees and compare the totals over the 10yrs or so. £7K seems a massive amount especially on £150k. Although I know rates at 6% etc make a massive difference even on a low mortgage payment. My first mortgage was £645 at 6.5% interest or similar. Bought just before the crash but only took 2yr fix and it then went down to 2.5% after that and it saved me about £250 a month. So it does make a massive difference. Borrowed just over £100k.

Whymustyoubringinthebirds · 28/09/2022 08:59

I would recommend you speak with a broker also, realistically most lenders have changed rates or will do so by the end of the week and they will probably hold there for a few weeks so you have time to consider your options

Singlebutmarried · 28/09/2022 08:56

It’s not a different system. It’s just they sell only direct to customers.

I can access the rest of the group, just not Lloyds itself.

Id go to an independent broker also as they can do side by side comparisons. At the moment you’ve nothing to compare the Lloyds mortgage to (like for like)

Swipe left for the next trending thread