Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To pay a £7K exit fee now

58 replies

millymog11 · 28/09/2022 07:58

For my fixed term mortgage on 1.9% expiring 3 March 2024 (i.e. 18 months to go) in order to get a 10 year fixed at 3.8% with a different mortgage provider which will basically pay off my entire mortgage and also consolidate my small home improvement loan?
£7K seems steep especially as I have 18 months left on my current fixed but my current fixed mortgage provider (Santander) has TOTALLY shut down its website page which, until 48 hours ago listed their other mortgage deals and I waited 55 mintues on their call helpline at about 5pm last night before giving up and putting the phone down.

(Single mum sole earner, two teenage kids live with and depend on my 100% of the time) , cannot afford to default on my mortgage, need certainty of mind, what would you do?)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
millymog11 · 01/10/2022 20:33

Who knows it might not be that good a deal. The paperwork says I can accept or reject until 28 February 2023.

OP posts:
millymog11 · 01/10/2022 20:30

I've been offered a 3.8 on a 10 fixed year deal.
But it might be because I have been with Llyods since 1985 and I have got my kids onto their child saver.

OP posts:
RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway · 29/09/2022 09:59

You would have to have the £7k upfront in a debit card to make payment and progress the new fixed-rate.

We've just fixed and paid an ERC and the system only accepted debit card.

Ariela · 29/09/2022 09:42

millymog11 · 28/09/2022 12:05

Ariela · Today 09:55 thank you so much for your post and your excellent advice.
My home improvement loan is fixed rate interest over 6 years.

Then focus on clearing that - I assume no penalty for early repayment ? (check this).
As your mortgage rate is so low I'd consider taking out a monthly paid cash ISA and pay into that each month rather than pay off your mortgage monthly - you need to look for a rate higher than your low 1.9% mortgage rate - you may find these increase especially if you leave it a month or two, and the interest is free of tax. I quickly googled - this isn't the best rate I'm sure, but found Yorkshire do a fix for 1 year at 3% interest - so your payments each month will earn 1% more than it will paying off your mortgage.

Then when it matures, you pay the lump sum off your outstanding mortgage balance - do check the best time to pay off a larger lump sum, it may be that you hold till the renewal to give you the greatest benefit.

Sparklybanana · 29/09/2022 09:06

There are lots of excel spreadsheets available online that do the calculations for how much you'd pay at different interests and different overpay scenarios. I'd do one for your current mortage and then estimate an exit rate - I try and do 10% as that's what hopefully worst case would be and 5% as a more realistic estimate. Then do the same with the 10 Yr fixed plus exit fee.
You can then directly compare what exactly you'd spend on the 10 year fixed and with the current mortage.

millymog11 · 29/09/2022 08:50

Carla2601 · Yesterday 22:29 thank you so much for this. I kind of know these things but when this "mini budget" type situation hits all normal recall on things like then next GE goes out the window.

Thank you so so much to everyone who posted on this thread. You might think I am being sensible, or you might think I am being hysterical, but either way I am really grateful for your views.

I am going to spend some time talking to

  • lloyds on my pre booked video call tomorrow at 16.00pm - he will probably tell me all the deals I looked at on Tuesday night have been pulled but it is probably worth the conversation
  • as predicted Legal and County called me and left a message when i was cooking dinner last night after I filled in their online call so i might call them back to see what their take of the market is at the moment
  • as lots of people have suggested, until i have consolidated my £14K home improvement/double glazing fitting loan into my mortage i should probably focus on that and then building up some reserve for when i end up dropping onto variable rate in March 2024 if i have not re mortaged by then.

Really kicking myself now that at the end of my divorce i did not insist to my financial adviser i wanted a 10 year fixed instead of a 5 year fixed mortgage in December 2018. I did have that conversation with him as I am an ultra cautious kind of person but he spoke to me like i was a crazy woman as there were such good rates about at that time and he said "who knows what will happen in 5 years you might want to move to a bigger house?"

hahahahaha

if i can just keep the one i am in (which I love and is fine for me and the two kdis) I will feel really grateful and lucky! (its actually not that small but it is in one of the most expensive parts of the country unfortunately (all thanks to my ex husband) so lets just say it is the "right size for keeping the heating bills down silver linings and all that!)

OP posts:
Carla2601 · 28/09/2022 22:29

@millymog11 sorry missed this, the absolute latest I think is Jan 25 but it feels like it can’t go on without one for much longer, there’s no mandate whatsoever for this lot or their god awful policies and people are getting angry. Hopefully a seminal poll tax type moment coming.

don’t get me wrong it won’t be instantly rosy under labour particularly inheriting this but they will care about people like us not just the top 1% so it can’t really get worse based on that

Huiyt · 28/09/2022 16:26

Personally I wouldn’t. I’d take the risk that things will be more settled in 2 years.

MrAutumnal · 28/09/2022 16:18

@fromdownwest

I think partly this is why some have stopped offering because it’s so uncertain they can’t be sure what to do without potentially making a huge loss themselves. Crystal ball time!

fromdownwest · 28/09/2022 15:40

PeloFondo · 28/09/2022 15:34

Barclays have a similar offer

Well worth a view, if people are in the end of their fixed rate period.

I wonder if this leads to the banks thinking that rates will not go up as much as the media is reporting.

No way a bank the size of barclays would lock in 10 years at 3.8% if their analysts foress 5% BOE.

Or maybe the flat 5% erp will cover the potential loss?

PeloFondo · 28/09/2022 15:34

fromdownwest · 28/09/2022 13:03

No way are you getting a 10 year fix at 3.8%. Have you been offered this, literally?

Barclays have a similar offer

To pay a £7K exit fee now
CRbear · 28/09/2022 15:15

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Singlebutmarried · 28/09/2022 14:52

And even the the lender can pull the offer even after exchange leaving you on the hook for at least the deposit.

Singlebutmarried · 28/09/2022 14:50

monotonousmum · 28/09/2022 11:50

After reading all these very sensible replies, I think I would:

  • get the best AiP currently available, for as long as possible (ideally 6 months)
  • use those 6 months to pay your minimum agreed amount off the mortgage and as much as you can off the higher interest loan
  • reasses in 5 months (or a month before AiP expires.

At that point, calculate how much extra per month any new mortgage would cost you, and how much you'd have in savings if you put that away. How many months could you then use those savings to top up mortgage payments if the rate is higher?

I don't envy anyone going through this at the moment, but at least you have a little time.

AIP will last a max of 3 months

You need an actual mortgage offer to secure the product.

AuntSalli · 28/09/2022 13:48

MountainSnow · 28/09/2022 12:50

@AuntSalli I am checking this! I did speak to my broker but will look at the mortgage offer (I think I would expect the offer to be conditional on certain
things - e.g. jobs still being in place and information provided being correct).

It’s not you that’s gonna change anything, it’s the lender honestly I am convinced I read it in the small print that nothing was guaranteed until literally the funds were sent because I remember thinking oh that works out well for them doesn’t it.

fromdownwest · 28/09/2022 13:05

monotonousmum · 28/09/2022 11:50

After reading all these very sensible replies, I think I would:

  • get the best AiP currently available, for as long as possible (ideally 6 months)
  • use those 6 months to pay your minimum agreed amount off the mortgage and as much as you can off the higher interest loan
  • reasses in 5 months (or a month before AiP expires.

At that point, calculate how much extra per month any new mortgage would cost you, and how much you'd have in savings if you put that away. How many months could you then use those savings to top up mortgage payments if the rate is higher?

I don't envy anyone going through this at the moment, but at least you have a little time.

An AIP counts for nothing, that is a theoretical 'we can lend this amount'

To secure a rate you need a submitted application, and ideally a mortgage offer.

fromdownwest · 28/09/2022 13:03

No way are you getting a 10 year fix at 3.8%. Have you been offered this, literally?

MountainSnow · 28/09/2022 12:50

@AuntSalli I am checking this! I did speak to my broker but will look at the mortgage offer (I think I would expect the offer to be conditional on certain
things - e.g. jobs still being in place and information provided being correct).

MadinMarch · 28/09/2022 12:43

Have you considered asking your existing lender to increase the loan by 10K so you can pay back the expensive loan for your windows?
Your lender may charge you a higher rate than the rest of the loan, but it may well be considerably cheaper than your're paying now.
I think I'd be inclined to not pay the &k exit fee at the moment, and reassess the situation in the meantime. If interest rates are still high in a year/18 months time, I'd consider remortgaging over a longer period. You could always change the mortgage again if the outlook is better.
Ensure that you speak to an independent broker who has access to the whole market- it makes a world of difference!

AuntSalli · 28/09/2022 12:41

@MountainSnow are you 100% certain that the rate they offer you in the mortgage in principle is the one that they are legally bound to because I am 100% certain that I read in my mortgage offer that until they hit the button and transfer the funds the rate can go up or down.

MountainSnow · 28/09/2022 12:38

Hello,
We did exactly the same a few months ago - our fixed rate had 18 months left to run but we were able to lock in a new rate on a 10 year fix (at less than half the rates now on offer in the market). Whilst at the time it looked like a gamble and our mortgage broker thought we were unwise (your mortgage broker should be able to work out the maths for you) we worked out that if rates rose by more than 1.5% over 2 years we would break even considering the early redemption charge. Since then I have also realised

  1. once you have the mortgage offer approved in principle, generally speaking you are given 6 months to complete. We were able to delay completion so that we had just 1 year less to run on the mortgage and our early redemption charged halved (which make the sums better we had originally anticipated) (you should check your early redemption charge and see if works the same way as you mind find it will be lower than you have been currently quoted)
  2. if you wait 18 months to re-mortgage, if the value of your property falls (which is possible if current press reports are to be believed) you may find that you can't get the best rate as you have less equity in your property at that point (by re-mortgaging now you are not just locking in today's interest rates but also today's asset prices)
  3. whilst it is expensive to roll the early redemption fee onto the mortgage, you could over pay in the future to reduce the costs of borrowing this
  4. peace of mind in so far as your mortgage payment being fixed is invaluable
Best of luck.
millymog11 · 28/09/2022 12:05

Ariela · Today 09:55 thank you so much for your post and your excellent advice.
My home improvement loan is fixed rate interest over 6 years.

OP posts:
AuntSalli · 28/09/2022 11:53

monotonousmum · 28/09/2022 11:50

After reading all these very sensible replies, I think I would:

  • get the best AiP currently available, for as long as possible (ideally 6 months)
  • use those 6 months to pay your minimum agreed amount off the mortgage and as much as you can off the higher interest loan
  • reasses in 5 months (or a month before AiP expires.

At that point, calculate how much extra per month any new mortgage would cost you, and how much you'd have in savings if you put that away. How many months could you then use those savings to top up mortgage payments if the rate is higher?

I don't envy anyone going through this at the moment, but at least you have a little time.

You realise that the agreement in principle does not fix the bank into the right right ? Literally right up until the moment they press the button to transfer the cash my understanding is that they can change the rates in fact it actually said that on my mortgage offer.

AuntSalli · 28/09/2022 11:52

I’m preparing to take the £5000 hit and add it to the mortgage so that it doesn’t actually really affect the cash in the bank so to speak. I am only gonna fix for another five years though because I anticipate the current landscape will look entirely different then.

monotonousmum · 28/09/2022 11:50

After reading all these very sensible replies, I think I would:

  • get the best AiP currently available, for as long as possible (ideally 6 months)
  • use those 6 months to pay your minimum agreed amount off the mortgage and as much as you can off the higher interest loan
  • reasses in 5 months (or a month before AiP expires.

At that point, calculate how much extra per month any new mortgage would cost you, and how much you'd have in savings if you put that away. How many months could you then use those savings to top up mortgage payments if the rate is higher?

I don't envy anyone going through this at the moment, but at least you have a little time.