Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Any Conservatives out there?

194 replies

GyozaGuiting · 28/09/2022 07:53

I’m a Conservative party member, (don’t hate me). I am appalled by the party right now.

Conservative politics is about protecting and growing the economy by stimulating growth with open markets, less state intervention, creating conditions for businesses to thrive/self employment etc. It’s about measured competence and at its core is the premise that hard work pays off.

This Conservative party isn’t about any of this, it’s about elitism, which they don’t even try and hide anymore, the top 1-5%. It’s not hard work, it’s who you know.

I run a business and would have been eligible for one of those huge covid contracts, I didn’t even get to apply, but it went to one of their friends. I wrote to my MP and I just got sent a web link (none of the contracts were on there).

I can’t imagine voting labour (for reasons too numerous to mention), but I feel I couldn’t bring myself to vote for my MP right now.

Any other conservatives feel this way? What can we do?

OP posts:
Brefugee · 28/09/2022 11:03

but this isn’t a party of aspiration anymore. It’s a party of grasping.

Not anymore - but as OP pointed out, it used to be and should be the party of aspiration. As several of us have pointed out, good government is about lifting everyone, the only difference is how they do it. Were i a traditional Tory voter i would be spitting feathers at having my party hijacked by late-stage-capitalists. Selling off the utilities, the railways etc was the start of the slippery slope, but it has snowballed in the last 20 years or so.

A Labour council has been awful for my town and I think Kier is a personality vacuum

2 things here. Under the Tories, labour run councils have been starved with cash. Tory politicians blatantly told voters in Labour areas to vote for them and they would then allocate more funds. This is appalling - but frankly, who can blame people for falling for it? Did it actually happen? (I don't know, i am only relatively superficially interested in UK politics as i don't live there). Red Wall voters - well, they have reaped what they sowed, unfortunately. They fell for it.

About Starmer's personality - i think he's trying hard to take personality back out of it. The Cult Of BoJo is frightening. As is the Cult of Truss. She is now using what (hopefully little) time she has in power to transfer wealth and influence to her mates. I agree with pp that the personality cults have been awful for politics, and we need to move away from it.

PP mentioned they won't vote Labour because they never do what they say in the manifesto. Meh. No actual party does. Voters must hold them to account for that. There should also be an actual formula for how money is allocated to regions/areas so that the party in power can't just say "fuckers voted for the others" and cut money that leads to FSM disappearing and other services severely impacted.

Nothing is going to change overnight after an election - except for the worst, as we can see with the latest mini-budget.

But voters must be aware what they are doing: fine, vote for your own self-interest because that is normal. But don't then come bleating to everyone when the logical progression of what you have voted for means that you no longer get what you think you deserve.

CurseOfBigness · 28/09/2022 11:01

@Lottie4 ”I'd really like to see Conservatives prove all us doubters wrong, but if they don't Keir is right that labour will inherit a mess.”

The mess is why I think it’s fairer for the conservatives to win. They made the mess. They should clean it up themselves.

At present, Truss and KK have made a mess. It’s their stubbornness that’s infuriating.

No one who says “I told you so” gets more than a transient satisfaction from being right. They would prefer to have been wrong or listened to from the start.

And Sunak was right on this. He understood economics better than KK and Truss do.

Blossomtoes · 28/09/2022 10:58

CurseOfBigness · 28/09/2022 10:51

^vote anyway for whoever. Just vote. It’s a precious hard won women’s right.

This x 1000. Get out and vote tactically.

@GyozaGuiting, this isn’t the party lifelong Conservatives have voted for all their lives. It’s a travesty. It needs to be told it’s gone too far.

Lottie4 · 28/09/2022 10:57

I'm a floating voter, but lean towards Conservative. Never in a million years would I have ever considered Labour in the past, but I feel like we desperately need an alternative and now. I'd even forgive Boris for all his misdemeanours. I'd really like to see Conservatives prove all us doubters wrong, but if they don't Keir is right that labour will inherit a mess.

LetMeSpeak · 28/09/2022 10:54

Vote labour, green, Lib Dem whichever is going to remove your Tory MP. It’s nice to hear a conservative actually come out against this nonsense.

CurseOfBigness · 28/09/2022 10:51

^vote anyway for whoever. Just vote. It’s a precious hard won women’s right.

CurseOfBigness · 28/09/2022 10:50

@perenniallymessy ”And those who think it's not worth voting Labour/LibDem as they live in a safe Conservative seat- please just go out and vote anyway once we have a general election.”

Exactly this. It’s lazy. And misses the point. If you’ve not tried to vote then you have no say if you don’t like the outcome.

And if women’s rights are so important to those claiming Labour don’t know what a woman is, then they should vote anyway. Women’s right to vote was hard earned. Knowing suffragette history I feel it’s disrespectful to them to not vote at all.

Shortname · 28/09/2022 10:44

@GyozaGuiting Im really glad you started this thread. I have flirted between labour and lib dem all my life but its really great to hear from a measured, reasonable tory voter and read your very sound reasoning for voting that way. We may not agree on politics but I absolutely respect what you have written and in this day and age with the extremely divisive nature of politics its very reassuring to think that actually most people on either side of the party politics is probably a decent human being (you don't often get that vibe here)

CurseOfBigness · 28/09/2022 10:44

@beguilingeyes ”The cult of personality is what got us into this mess.”

Isn’t that a political warning that William Golding points to in ‘Lord of the Flies’?

Piggy was the best one for leadership. But he didn’t look the part and didn’t have charisma.

Voters are shallow…

perenniallymessy · 28/09/2022 10:40

I think many people in this country are fairly centrist in their politics- Labour did well under Blair because they moved towards the centre (and the Conservative part was too busy infighting after 18 years in government), then when they moved to the left under Corbyn they lost votes. In 2010 the LibDems got a lot of support but got tarnished by being part of the coalition.

The Conservatives are busily moving over to the right, so I think a lot of people are moving back to Labour now and they are a more palatable choice to centrists than Tory. Unfortunately I think we need at least some of the media to get behind Labour, as they did in 1997, for there to be a landslide.

And those who think it's not worth voting Labour/LibDem as they live in a safe Conservative seat- please just go out and vote anyway once we have a general election. I live in a seat that had a pretty decent Tory majority in 2010 and 2015; in 2017 the Labour candidate took a short leave of absence from his job to campaign, thinking there was no chance of getting elected. In the end he got over 50% of the votes and just under 50% in 2019. The Tory was ousted because she was vocally pro-Brexit in a constituency that was heavily pro-remain, people felt she was hugely out of touch with her electorate.

beguilingeyes · 28/09/2022 10:37

". A Labour council has been awful for my town and I think Kier is a personality vacuum"

The cult of personality is what got us into this mess. People voted for Boris in large part because he#d been marginally amusing on telly and they thought he was a wag. It's not The X Factor...just give me someone competent.

The right wing press is a huge problem. Corbyn wasn't perfect by any means by he was destroyed by the media. Johnson got a free ride. Can you imagine the uproar if Corbyn had moved his pregnant mistress into no.10? Or had been shagging Jennifer Arcuri?

colddayinhell · 28/09/2022 10:34

I'm won't be voting. Neither party cares about the voters, they are only interested in feathering their own nests and pushing the interests of big business and besides, both parties are almost identical now (Labour are basically the same old nu-Labour with a less charismatic Blair clone in charge) and the Tories are basically blue nu-Labour (none of their policies are that different - mass immigration to suppress wages subsidised by ever increasing unaffordable welfare state paid by the taxes of PAYE plebs, massive push for reckless net zero, unaffordable, poor quality housing because neither party wants to build social homes (nuLabour didn't build any), everyone encouraged to take out massive debt (started under nu Labour )). Whoever you vote for you get the same globalist party.

KLFisgonnarockya · 28/09/2022 10:25

somewhereovertherain · 28/09/2022 08:00

How any business owner could vote for this shower of shit I’ll never know.(and yes I own two businesses)

from Brexit forward it’s all been about party and never about what’s best for the country.

This. I’ve never voted Tory but 100% this!

they’ve ruined this country with their selfish obsessions.

CurseOfBigness · 28/09/2022 10:23

@GottaGetOutofDairy ”Once they identifiy with a camp, it's almost impossible for them to believe criticism that's seen to come from outside. Hence the tags such as 'loonie lefties' or 'remoaners' or whatever it is. It's a culture war tactic to undermine critics so that real debate and scrutiny is avoided.”

This.

But this also is what makes floating voters like me stop and question, because it is obvious that it’s a culture war tactic.

Formula seems to be:

Labour or Lib Dems make a good suggestion.

Conservative respond by name calling them, ‘woke’ or something.

All that makes me want to do is probe the Conservatives’ name calling claims further for the truth. Because name calling is childish. Adults can see through childish behaviour and playground tactics.

The same applies the other way around. When Labour or LibDems call the Conservatives “nasty” or “selfish” or something, I look for the truth. It’s not always true…

But with Truss I do think she’s being very insular with the tax cuts for those on over £150k juxtaposed with higher borrowing and higher cost of borrowing during a cost of living crisis for everyone else under the £150k mark. She might know people on over that amount and sides with those in her circle, but that’s part of her being insular and disconnected with the country.

In principle I agree that people should get to keep more of the money they earn. But what Truss actually means is that the higher tax bracket people should get to keep more of the money they earn because they pay more tax. Truss doesn’t understand that people in the position of £150k are rare and it’s more likely down to luck and networking (who you know).

Truss is being unfair. She just can’t see how or why because of her own bubble.

TeaKlaxon · 28/09/2022 10:23

ChilliBandit · 28/09/2022 09:51

I think the only thing anyone who dislikes this government can do is to vote for the non-Tory party that have most chance of winning in your constituency be that Labour/Lib Dem/Green/SNP/Plaid etc. I am normally a Labour voter but would happily vote Lib Dem if it meant ousting our Tory incumbent MP (who is also a shit local MP and does nothing for our area except for a bit of ribbon cutting in exchange for some free food and drink).

Exactly.

Unless someone is in an ultra safe seat (which there are far too many of thanks to the awful First Past the Post system), if they're not voting, they're essentially voting for the Tories.

Of course people can choose to do that, but they should own it. This bollox of 'I don't like the Tories but can't vote for Labour' is self-serving BS. If someone is going to allow a Tory Government, they should at least have the guts to own that decision.

I'll also vote tactically. Prefer Labour to the LibDems (preferred the LibDems to Labour when Corbyn was leader) but will vote LibDem as they have the best chance of beating the Tories where I am. If everyone who wants the Tories out (about two thirds of voters) also voted tactically, then the Tories would be decimated. This is no time to be a purist.

TeaKlaxon · 28/09/2022 10:18

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Sure Jan.

Bunnyfuller · 28/09/2022 10:17

@Brefugee yes, voting on the one issue of women/GC is so short sighted, the country is tanking and who is what fucking sex/gender/banana pales in the face of what’s happening.

Vote this lot out, then work on that issue, if you want to. Tories only use it as part of their bigger ‘conservative’ views on anything different. Just think where that could creep to if they’re allowed continued free rein.

I would rather my government know what poverty is, and what causes it, before their view on transgender, which frankly is barely talked about.

Eeksteek · 28/09/2022 10:17

GottaGetOutofDairy · 28/09/2022 08:01

As an aside, this is where divisive politics gets us: there have been massive red flags all along the journey to this point (not least in who has been fired, who has been hired and in what posts - in far reaching roles well outside the cabinet) but the culture wars means that people automatically disbelieve 'the other side'.

Once they identifiy with a camp, it's almost impossible for them to believe criticism that's seen to come from outside. Hence the tags such as 'loonie lefties' or 'remoaners' or whatever it is. It's a culture war tactic to undermine critics so that real debate and scrutiny is avoided.

Indeed. You can vote labour so they get the message that it’s not acceptable, and then vote for them once they’ve got some integrity together again. You don’t have to change your identity, just choose the least worst option right now. it doesn’t have to be revolution, and fix everything at once, it can be evolution and gradually improve.

Also, its been obvious for years their strategy was rape and pillage. Expect a fair bit of I told you so if you’ve been defending them. Sorry.

TeaKlaxon · 28/09/2022 10:16

ginghamstarfish · 28/09/2022 09:47

I too have always leaned towards Conservatism but yes their time is coming to an end. Sadly there is no viable opposition in my opinion. Labour have at least got rid of the unelectable Corbyn, but still .... and they can say whatever sounds good at the party conference, as any opposition party does, but are unlikely to follow through.

Of course there's a viable opposition. You have absolutely no reason to claim that Labour won't follow through on what they're promising. One upside of Starmer being an occassionally excessively cautious leader is that it's very likely that pledges are only made after the party knows they can deliver them.

WindsweptNotInteresting · 28/09/2022 10:15

Part of the problem in this country is the press, a very large proportion of which is owned by right-wing supporters (Murdoch, Lord Rothermere etc). The reporting bias is shocking at times.

I was not a huge Corbyn supporter, but when you look at the way he was vilified and ridiculed in the press compared to Boris (who arguably had far more reason to be criticised) it makes you realise how the Tories have managed to stay in power for so long.

People will, a lot of the time, believe what they read in the papers. If your paper is playing down the appalling behaviour by their preferred politicians, people will believe they are not really that bad. If they are harping on about Keir Starmer being a "personality vacuum" (as a PP said for example), that is what people will believe is important ("yes Boris is a liar and a serial womaniser, but Keir is so bland").

The budget actually works in out favour, as we are a high income household. But do you know what? We do not need an extra grand or whatever it would equate to a year. I would much rather that money be put towards those who are struggling - and there is a shockingly increasing number. This idea of a trickle down economy is farcical.

I wish we could have a more balanced and fair press in this country. The hate and vitriol a lot of the papers spout is truly awful.

Brefugee · 28/09/2022 10:09

the tories purport to be about free markets and reducing state intervention - so isn’t that exactly what they have done under this concept of trickle down economics. Ie reduced the additional rate to free up cash for investment and very much reduce state intervention/state benefits that cash would have gone to

What the Conservatives should stand for, based on how they were set up, etc, is probably more (much as i loathed her) what Thatcher wanted. Low state involvement, low regulation and the barest of safety nets. That is obviously not possible, because regulation is vital in so many areas (workplace safety, banking regulations etc etc). What we are now seeing is a massive lurch to a society that is eveyone-for-themselves without the correct amount of time to move away from the safety nets we have now. (you can't suddenly say "from tomorrow no more state pensions" and expect anyone except those who are born that day to accept this abrupt change without problems)

The labour party was founded to fight for the rights of workers. Paid holidays, standardised hours, salaries, sick leave, weekends etc etc. Sure, they started out with solid Marxist principles (that i don't believe are entirely wrong) of public ownership of the means of production. That does not exclude private ownership of non-means-of-production busineses. So health, fuel, water etc - which are essential for life in public ownership, shops and service industries that are not essential for life private ownership is fine (as long as they keep to the rules of non-exploitation of workers and pay fair tax). The current labour party is not close to that any more.

PP mentioned the Labour party being incompetent at economics because they would use tax for breakfast clubs. See above: the need for these things (FSM etc) is accute. You can't just say "nope, they're gone" without a process of moving to a different system. Not without problems.

What i really don't get is how and why people aren't on the streets about these things? And I do get the problem of defining a woman is desperately needed and urgent: but bloody hell, not voting for a party based on that one thing? when everything else is a bloody bin-fire? I also don't understand that. If you are a natural labour supporter how the heck do you vote tory because of that one thing? (yep - I'm pretty much a Marxist. so sue me. I think i gave the Tories a fair go there)

HMSSophia · 28/09/2022 10:06

LifeOnATrain · 28/09/2022 08:08

the biggest problem is the lack of opposition. Good opposition holds the party in power to account. We just don't have any good political leadership anywhere. There's a giant political vacuum at the moment.

What?? WHAT?? You're making out "the biggest problem" is the poor opposition? Fuck my life that's rich.

So you're only responsible for what you do if there is a proper "opposition"?
How the Tories twist and turn to avoid taking fucking responsibility for their abhorrent party and it's actions.

1dayatatime · 28/09/2022 10:05

@GyozaGuiting

"Conservative politics is about protecting and growing the economy by stimulating growth with open markets, less state intervention, creating conditions for businesses to thrive/self employment etc. It’s about measured competence and at its core is the premise that hard work pays off. "

I certainly don't "hate" you for being a Conservative Party member and indeed would 100% share your view that a core competence of any Government is sound economics and growing the economy through open markets and creating conditions for businesses to thrive but not through externality costs to wider society (such as pollution or workers safety)

The problem is that the Conservative Party you originally supported no longer exists or as you put it "This Conservative party isn’t about any of this, it’s about elitism".

The Conservatives started with Cameron then May then Johnson and now Truss - dumbing down every step of the way so that the current Government is effectively the "D Team" and it is very clearly showing.

The fault sadly lies with party members in choosing their leaders and the electorate in 2019 voting for Johnson. The solution is a horrific recession with high inflation, people losing their homes and their jobs for two years. After which a Labour Gov or a Labour/ Liberal coalition and the Conservatives in the wilderness for at least 10 years.

Bunnyfuller · 28/09/2022 10:05

Lots of people aren’t poor because ‘they didn’t work hard’. This is a divisive narrative, designed to soothe the soul of policies which favour the rich and cripple the poor. This narrative generates a hatred of anyone with less, because the assumption is there that they could ‘better themselves’ if they weren’t so lazy.

Does your minimum wage worker, working 3 jobs just to survive not ‘work hard’, do care assistants, nurses, teachers, police officers, not work hard? Say if we all ‘better ourselves’ (by that I mean magically find the money and time to retrain and get a top paying job with no experience) who does those other things? And those with disabilities, learning difficulties, caring responsibilities at home, are they ‘not working hard’.

Success means many things, and penalising those who don’t have the same opportunities or shock horror, have a vocation to help their fellow human, because ‘they don’t work hard’ is a simplistic, utterly inaccurate and selfish way of thinking.

Next time one of you or yours needs an ambulance, or hospital stay, or the police, make sure you tell them ‘they don’t work hard’.

Mardyface · 28/09/2022 10:04

It's not that conservatism had stopped working. It never worked. You've just noticed it's stopped working for you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread