Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Greedy CSA

38 replies

snoozysuzi · 28/09/2022 00:38

Hi all, my daughter has just turned 15 and due to cost of living crisis I am struggling a bit. Her dad is absent 95% of the time which has always mostly suited me. He has always paid and we have had a mutual agreement. Recently I asked him to review payments, turns out I’m due several hundred more than I have been getting. He is panicking and doesn’t want to give me the full amount, suggests we “talk” first but god knows why. Am I being unreasonable to ask for the (quite substantial) amount I am entitled to?
FYI I am an NHS nurse, he is a civil engineer (who has claimed his tax back the last 2 years).
reason for posting: I don’t want to be one of those women just taking what I can get, I like to earn my way in life but I could use the money 😭😩 His payments just now are reasonable. Thanks

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
limitededitionbarbie · 30/09/2022 20:20

@Soubriquet my ex owes over £10k in unpaid arrears for cms. I never get anywhere with them. They say they will do something then backtrack. I have called them twice this week and spent 4 hours on the phone to them on hold before speaking to a case advisor.

They are worse than doctors receptionists

Paigeycakey · 28/09/2022 19:15

@Getoff I never said anybody was a bad person. However I don't think you did yourself any favours by bringing politicians into it (they themselves are sh*t).

Is your example realistic £900 per month? I don't know anybody who gets half that amount. If your going to give an example perhaps they need to be in line with average CMS. I will spell it out for you.......

If a dad pays £300 per month. This is because MUM usually has the full responsibility in terms of pick ups/drop offs and school holidays. I'm not saying all men but the majority can't be arsed to parent they do just the minium and expect some kind of reward. Why shouldn't a guy offer to cover 50% of school uniforms, school trips, spending money for the holiday. He can work 60 hours a week if he wants. I used to do that before being a mum. Now I'm limited unlike DS dad....... he does EOW which includes Fridays... but he claims he can't commit so it's as a when due to HIS work commitments. For me it's not just the money... but my point remains the same.

Getoff · 28/09/2022 17:35

I've lost track of the thread, I've no idea what you're talkng about with regard to me asking a question. What question did I ask?

Are you really suggesting we should go by a politican? Seriously?? Minium means exactly that. There's no middle ground what your saying is wrong

If someone is paying CMS amount of £900 a month, implying that £1800 a month should be spent, but in fact the child is costing £500 a month, and neither parent thinks more than £500 a month needs spending, and the parent receiving the £900 is earning the same as the parent paying the money, how much more than £900 do you think the paying parent should pay, in order not to be considered a bad person? The post I'm responding to suggests that is never acceptable to only pay the CMS amount.

LoveBluey · 28/09/2022 17:26

Thanks, I'm working out what I could reasonably ask for but as my youngest is still at nursery the childcare bills are huge. In a couple of years I could survive on less but I'm panicking how I can afford everything on my own right now and wasn't sure if I should be suggesting a maintenance amount plus 50:50 on nursery.

Paigeycakey · 28/09/2022 17:15

@Getoff thats not the question you asked. Sorry but you lost me at politicans. The fact you need to ask says it all..

Are you really suggesting we should go by a politican? Seriously?? Minium means exactly that. There's no middle ground what your saying is wrong.

Getoff · 28/09/2022 16:45

Paigeycakey · 28/09/2022 15:45

Yes absolutely you should WANT to contribute more if possible. CMS is the sheer minium this seems to go over people's heads unless your in the minority paying a huge amount each month.

This sentiment often expressed on here, but it's wrong. It's conflating two different interpretations of "minimum".

CMS is not necessarily a lower bound on what is reasonable, it's a lower bound on what is legal. Presumably it is actually middle-of-the-range for what politician consider reasonable, bearing in mind it is produced by a very crude calculation that can't take individual circumstances into account.

It would make no sense for the legal minimum to be same as the moral minimum, as that would imply legislators expected people who had to be compelled to pay a small amount to somehow be inspired by the experience and voluntarily pay extra.

justusandmoo · 28/09/2022 16:16

@Getoff yes that is what I meant. Sorry I'm not sure I was very clear. I meant that you can't back claim for the last 15 years. Absolutely agree that it should be changed going forward though.

Paigeycakey · 28/09/2022 15:45

LoveBluey · 28/09/2022 13:57

Can I ask what the CMS calculation is supposed to cover - should it be you pay that amount and that's it done and dusted or should you also contribute towards nursery fees/after school club / school uniforms / trips etc?

Yes absolutely you should WANT to contribute more if possible. CMS is the sheer minium this seems to go over people's heads unless your in the minority paying a huge amount each month.

LoveBluey · 28/09/2022 13:57

Can I ask what the CMS calculation is supposed to cover - should it be you pay that amount and that's it done and dusted or should you also contribute towards nursery fees/after school club / school uniforms / trips etc?

Paigeycakey · 28/09/2022 13:23

@Getoff but why now after 15 years? CMS will be ending soon did it not dawn on OP that her ex could be lying about his salary and short changing her daughter.

Getoff · 28/09/2022 13:13

Fuuuuuckit · 28/09/2022 08:45

You absolutely can. My ex was earning less than half his current salary when we split up 15 years ago. Should he pay the same towards his kids' upbringing whilst now having double salary? CMS is a MINIMUM and comes nowhere close to the actual cost of raising a child (at the very basic level, never mind if you need to pay for childcare, new trainers, school trips).

OP go straight to the CMS. They don't backdate, and it looks like he's been enjoying his pay rise for years without passing on the benefit to your dc. Call them this morning.

I think the person you are replying to is saying you can't ask for 15 years of back-payments, not that you can't change the amount going forward. At least that's my interpretation, otherwise I don't see why "How on earth does he find that money now?" would necessarily be an issue.

I don't think CMS will collect payments for period before they were involved, so I think the back-payment scenario isn't one we need to talk about. I don't think that's what OP was proposing.

caringcarer · 28/09/2022 09:44

I would agree to meet him to talk. I'd say he has not been paying enough and as a consequence you have had to overpay from your salary. Ask him to pay correct amount going forward and set up a catch up of back payments over time. Your child is entitled to that money. Going to uni and saving a deposit is expensive. This would give your child a helping hand. Sounds like this Father spends very little time with DC so he needs to make sure child is financially provided for. If he refuses involve CSA.

Paigeycakey · 28/09/2022 08:49

CuntyMcBollocks · 28/09/2022 08:03

Don't be such a martyr. The money is his contribution for your shared DD that he should be paying for. You'll get no thanks for struggling and letting him get away with paying less than he should.

Absolutely my mum now says this same exact phrase you you sure as hell don't get any thanks for being a mother.

I make sure I live by it too!

Fuuuuuckit · 28/09/2022 08:45

justusandmoo · 28/09/2022 06:44

Genuine question so please don't jump on me. You can't agree on an amount and decide to keep it way from CSA involvement and then 15 years later decide that you do want to go according to their guidelines on amount? How on earth does he find that sort of money now?

I'm asking as I'd be in the same situation although my daughter is 13.

You absolutely can. My ex was earning less than half his current salary when we split up 15 years ago. Should he pay the same towards his kids' upbringing whilst now having double salary? CMS is a MINIMUM and comes nowhere close to the actual cost of raising a child (at the very basic level, never mind if you need to pay for childcare, new trainers, school trips).

OP go straight to the CMS. They don't backdate, and it looks like he's been enjoying his pay rise for years without passing on the benefit to your dc. Call them this morning.

EvilRingahBitch · 28/09/2022 08:14

Nothing stopping you from taking the extra money and putting it straight into a savings account for your DD.

ReneBumsWombats · 28/09/2022 08:09

I don’t want to be one of those women just taking what I can get

Where did you get this idea from? Especially regarding a man's responsibility to his child?

CuntyMcBollocks · 28/09/2022 08:03

Don't be such a martyr. The money is his contribution for your shared DD that he should be paying for. You'll get no thanks for struggling and letting him get away with paying less than he should.

Stag82 · 28/09/2022 07:00

If you’ve managed to do it amicably this far you could try having a conversation. Do you know what you should be getting? Otherwise go through CMS. Being main carer limits earning potential. My ex just told me he won’t be picking up on his own night a week anymore. Think he’s in for a shock when he realises after school
club is £15 per child per session!

Cwcwbird · 28/09/2022 06:53

justusandmoo · 28/09/2022 06:44

Genuine question so please don't jump on me. You can't agree on an amount and decide to keep it way from CSA involvement and then 15 years later decide that you do want to go according to their guidelines on amount? How on earth does he find that sort of money now?

I'm asking as I'd be in the same situation although my daughter is 13.

Of course you can. You think these princes among men who are underpaying didn't check the cms calculator first to make sure they didn't offer too much? They've been duping the mothers of their children and their own children for years and now it's time to pay the piper.

girlmom21 · 28/09/2022 06:51

This isn't about being one of "those women" whatever that is...

That's his child too. He's equally responsible for raising her. It's not a woman's job to raise a child and be grateful for whatever 'help' they get.

He doesn't want them looking into his finances - that's why he wants to talk.

SunThroughTheCloudsAt6am · 28/09/2022 06:49

If it's been the same amount for 15 years, of course it can be revised - unless you're suggesting that his salary hasn't changed in 15 years? Back payment I suspect is unlikely though (although if he strings out upping it I would push for it from the time you asked for revision)

Second, the amount due from the absent parent is based on their income, not the (minimum) cost of providing for the child's needs.

This is an important point - it's not based on what the child can survive on, it's based on the lifestyle they could expect commensurate with their parent's earnings - if he's buying Hugo Boss coats, they should have enough to get a premium children's brand coat, not only have enough for a Primark one.

Paigeycakey · 28/09/2022 06:46

@justusandmoo agree, it's a good question.

justusandmoo · 28/09/2022 06:44

Genuine question so please don't jump on me. You can't agree on an amount and decide to keep it way from CSA involvement and then 15 years later decide that you do want to go according to their guidelines on amount? How on earth does he find that sort of money now?

I'm asking as I'd be in the same situation although my daughter is 13.

WalkingThroughTreacle · 28/09/2022 06:32

First and foremost, child maintenance is for the benefit of the child so the notion of you being greedy is a nonsense. Second, the amount due from the absent parent is based on their income, not the (minimum) cost of providing for the child's needs. This may seem unusual at first glance but the underlying principle is that the child has a right to benefit from the wealth of the parent(s). So the better off the AP is, the more they should contribute towards their child.
Take what the calculator says your child is entitled to. It is their legal right.

OzziePopPop · 28/09/2022 06:30

But cms is the minimum…. He wants to pay less than the minimum? 😂 and no.

cms, keep it all professional, no ‘talks’ aka as him trying to talk you out of what your daughter deserves!

Swipe left for the next trending thread