Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think impending higher interest on mortgages is not comparable with when rates were higher in the past

34 replies

Shortjanet · 27/09/2022 19:59

I keep reading on here that people should not have taken out mortgages without "stress testing" them to interest rates of 7, 8, 9, 10, whatever %. The implication is that people have been borrowing irresponsibly to buy their homes. It doesn't take into account at all the relationship between house prices and earnings which, given the low interest environment for years has meant they people have had no choice but to stretch beyond what would be affordable at higher rates if they wanted to buy a home. In a lot of cases people would have been much better off paying a higher interest rate on a much lower house price than the situation we have now. This is not the fault of the average mortgage paying homeowner.

We are lucky that our last fix ended six months ago and we remortgaged with a ten year fix then, by which time we will have almost paid it off. I really feel for people who will need to remortgage in the coming months.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Cuppasoupmonster · 28/09/2022 14:12

RovenderKitt · 28/09/2022 13:36

Exactly. I am a bit too young to have been affected myself, but there were a LOT of people in financial difficulties at that time, I was an estate agent a couple of years after the 15% and we had plenty of repossessions on our books. It was bad then, let’s hope this time it’s doesn’t get to that level.

The difference is people can’t afford houses to have repossessed to start with. So it’s actually worse.

Cuppasoupmonster · 28/09/2022 14:11

CaptainSamCarter · 27/09/2022 21:46

So fed up of people saying "well we had 15% interest when we were young so I don't know why you are complaining about 6%" when IT'S NOT COMPARABLE.

Yes the interest rate was higher then. But you didn't need to borrow at 10 x average salary to buy a house in the first place.

It's just typical of the boomer "I'm all right Jack" attitude that has ruined this country.

This. They always, always have to find a reason that they were worse off and had it harder, even when facts disprove it. I don’t know whether it’s because they don’t want to face up to the mess they’ve created for working people today or sheer pride, but it’s maddening.

RovenderKitt · 28/09/2022 13:36

FlounderingFruitcake · 28/09/2022 12:27

You’re not wrong per se, it’s never anyone’s fault (except the government), but my godmother had her home repossessed in 1990 because she couldn’t afford the rate rises, was in negative equity and just had to give the keys back. It was shit then and it’s shit now. The whole comparison of who had/has it worse isn’t massively helpful and achieves nothing.

Exactly. I am a bit too young to have been affected myself, but there were a LOT of people in financial difficulties at that time, I was an estate agent a couple of years after the 15% and we had plenty of repossessions on our books. It was bad then, let’s hope this time it’s doesn’t get to that level.

MintJulia · 28/09/2022 13:17

Err, it's exactly the same.

I took out my first mortgage just before the attack on the £ and our exit from The ERM. Due to politics, the rate shot up in one day, I found myself unable to pay an extra 5%. Such a large rise was then unprecedented.

On that occasion it was sorted quickly, John Major was infinitely more competent than Kwaeteng, but hopefully this will be sorted too when our idiot chancellor does a uturn and then falls on his sword.

You have my complete sympathy, I know exactly how frightening it was

boxybox · 28/09/2022 12:38

but I blame the government for allowing house prices to rise to stupid levels. For not doing something 20 years ago.

plenty of people have been delighted by the growth & made to feel rich & that they are now a millionaire on paper.

My aunt wants to downsize next year & is in a right tizz. Her home is worth about 1.5m & the ones she's looking at buying are 800k. She doesn't want to move now as she's going to be "poor". It doesn't make any sense.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 28/09/2022 12:33

It's just the usual race to the bottom. Same as the "you are turning your heating on at 2 degrees? in my day we had no heating, no walls and no clothes and were perfectly fine in -15".

Most people will have done what was sensible for them to adequately house their family. It is NOT the same situation as previous high mortgage rate periods where housing was substantially cheaper. The rate increases have also happened really fast, faster than anyone could have expected.

That said, I remember all the doom and gloom of the crach in 2008. Everyone thought everyone would be bankrupt and homeless. Some people ended up in precarious positions, and for many more it was a time of tighetening belts, but eventually things evened out. I hope - given that this is caused by someone very specific - that that will be the case this time as well.

CasaDelSoot · 28/09/2022 12:30

YANBU
Totally agree with you OP.

Bought my 1st house (with DP) in mid 90s. My salary was £14k and house cost £60k

Equivalent pay for grade I was on then is now £32k, so increased nearly 2.5 times. So the house should now cost about £150k going by those figures.
Last house sold in that street for £240k, so a 4 fold increase

FlounderingFruitcake · 28/09/2022 12:27

You’re not wrong per se, it’s never anyone’s fault (except the government), but my godmother had her home repossessed in 1990 because she couldn’t afford the rate rises, was in negative equity and just had to give the keys back. It was shit then and it’s shit now. The whole comparison of who had/has it worse isn’t massively helpful and achieves nothing.

Londongent · 28/09/2022 12:11

FatFilledTrottyPuss · 27/09/2022 21:53

My friend’s dad used to tell her that when he bought his first house interest rates were 15% and she didn’t realise how lucky she is blah blah blah. She pointed out that in the 70s you could buy a house for 3 x your income and keep a family on a single wage. It’s just not comparable at all. Now we’re all forced to buy or rent on 10 x our joint salaries and we’ll be in big trouble if interest rates go up that much. I’m really worried about it.

This is so true.
15% interest rates in the past are just not comparable. If you stress tested to that level no one would have bought a house over the past 10 years.
House prices are always going to be dictated by current interest rates and salaries. People had to take out mortgages that were cheap.
The only way that this would not end up as a bubble bursting is if rates rose slowly in a managed way. But it is the speed of these rises which is frightening.

Cottagecheeseisnotcheese · 28/09/2022 11:59

it is very true that housing costs were a much smaller part of take home pay in 60-80's at least and they have risen substantially since then; but back then food and fuel were proportionally more of wages relatively speaking food and clothing is now much much cheaper even with recent rises. Which is why we had a lot less clothes growing up apart from school uniform ( and most people managed with 1-2 trousers /skirts and jumpers and 2 or 3 shirts not 5 of each; most people had about 3-4 outfits max a sunday best/ party outfit and play clothes for holidays weekends, most kids wore the same coat all winter whether for school or out and about and the same with shoes 1 pair plus wellies in winter and sandals in summer plus slippers and trainers or pumps

maddening · 28/09/2022 11:52

15% of 30k is 4500
6% of 350k is 21000

House prices have increased several times the rate of wages.

QuebecBagnet · 28/09/2022 11:50

I don’t think anyone blames individuals who borrowed the new normal amounts and indeed needed to do so to get on the property ladder.

but from a maths point of view it’s the same. If not worse now from an affordability pov due to cost of living.

but I blame the government for allowing house prices to rise to stupid levels. For not doing something 20 years ago. This has been a ticking timebomb for decades.

Oldrockingchair · 28/09/2022 11:46

YANBU op. I hate that stupid boomer attitude. They have no idea how much better off they were.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 28/09/2022 11:40

I think that the people who go on about the 15 % days being as bad/worse either don't understand percentages or have no idea how much houses cost these days. Either way it's best to just ignore them.

BorgQueen · 28/09/2022 11:33

People also have much higher outgoings. Broadband, phone contracts, nursery fees, massive utility bills incoming. To go back to living like we did in the 70’s would mean no life at all because even stuff that everyone could afford, like weekly cinema visits, or fish and chips, now cost a fortune.

FatFilledTrottyPuss · 27/09/2022 21:53

My friend’s dad used to tell her that when he bought his first house interest rates were 15% and she didn’t realise how lucky she is blah blah blah. She pointed out that in the 70s you could buy a house for 3 x your income and keep a family on a single wage. It’s just not comparable at all. Now we’re all forced to buy or rent on 10 x our joint salaries and we’ll be in big trouble if interest rates go up that much. I’m really worried about it.

CaptainSamCarter · 27/09/2022 21:46

So fed up of people saying "well we had 15% interest when we were young so I don't know why you are complaining about 6%" when IT'S NOT COMPARABLE.

Yes the interest rate was higher then. But you didn't need to borrow at 10 x average salary to buy a house in the first place.

It's just typical of the boomer "I'm all right Jack" attitude that has ruined this country.

Calmdown14 · 27/09/2022 21:42

I think that up to about 5 per cent is to be expected over the lifetime of a mortgage. I do wonder if perception is skewed by those who have borrowed in the last decade.

When I took mine out it was a 0.5% tracker over the base rate and in 2007 that rate was 5.75%.

I continued to pay at the same rate as the lower rates seemed artificial and unlikely to last.

The speed of increase is a concern but we are still well within a very normal range over the last 30 years.

Expecting to stay under 3% probably foolish, not being prepared for 8% quite understandable I would say

Howdoisawwithnosaw · 27/09/2022 21:02

I did stress test my mortgage at 10%. Knew I couldn’t afford it.

Then I stress tested my rent if my landlords mortgage was 10%. Also couldn’t afford it.

So I could have bought a house and risked homelessness if rates went up to 10%. Or I could have not bought a house and risked homelessness if rates went up to 10%.

I did the first one. Who wouldn’t?!

Shortjanet · 27/09/2022 21:00

I'd be interested to hear from some who have voted IABU.

OP posts:
BorgQueen · 27/09/2022 20:57

I’m worried for my DD, &250k mortgage and fix ending next April, she’s currently paying 3.75% and the 10 year fix has just risen to 4%. It’s a month until she can lock in a fix and she can’t afford the ERC to end her current fix early. If rates go up again within a month then that 4% could become 5%.!

PatientlyWaiting21 · 27/09/2022 20:51

It’s 2007 all over again.

Dissimilitude · 27/09/2022 20:49

GasPanic · 27/09/2022 20:37

Suddenly the stupidity of ever increasing house prices championed by many becomes apparent.

This.

Unfortunately, we have a complete misalignment of incentives all round, such that there isn't enough of a coalition around dealing with the problem before the shit hits the fan.

We should have engineered a long, slow real-terms drop in prices via large and consistent building and above all a loosening of planning laws. We needed huge numbers of new affordable homes coming on stream, keeping prices reasonable.

We didn't, because nobody cared enough. So now we'll run the risk of prices collapsing under the weight of enormous interest rate rises and growing defaults. Bad for absolutely everyone.

KLFisgonnarockya · 27/09/2022 20:44

We need to storm parliament and overthrow the incompetent, cheating, heartless cunts who caused this unnecessary and entirely self inflicted chaos. They can reverse the poxy budget and windfall tax the energy companies. Then things will settle. The bloody banks can also take some of the slack as they still owe the taxpayer billions.

Imagine the chaos we’d have suffered under Ed Milliband…🙄

GasPanic · 27/09/2022 20:37

Suddenly the stupidity of ever increasing house prices championed by many becomes apparent.