Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Labour would be even worse grrrr

194 replies

Explaintome · 27/09/2022 18:27

In the pub last night, rolling news headlines on the TV and we talked briefly about rising interest rates/falling pound.

One man trotted out the now tired line "Labour would be even worse".

"Why?" I said, "what is it that they would do less well?" He couldn't answer, as I find is often the case with people who are certain Labour would be worse. They can't tell me why.

They may be right, they are certainly entitled to that view, but surely to be so convinced about any opinion you must also have some idea of why that is?

This is a middle aged man, does an ordinary, low level management/sales job. He'd tell you himself, he's not particularly clever and he's not interested in/doesn't undertlstand politics or the economy and yet he's so convinced of this view. It was probably unfair of me to challenge him knowing he wouldn't have an argument, but there seem to be a lot like him and frankly it's scary. 12 years and still people are convinced Tory is the best answer, even if they don't know why.

FWIW he's a nice man with other attributes, an encyclopedic music knowledge and good company provided you don't try and talk about the news 😆

OP posts:
AdamRyan · 27/09/2022 21:43

caringcarer · 27/09/2022 19:53

I just remember Gordon Brown getting half the country onto one benefit or another when previously no where near that amount of people were on benefits. It is unsustainable for so many people to be on benefits and housing benefit. Employers should pay higher wages. The state should not be subsidising employers. Also the note.....no money left was a rediculous attempt at humour of such a serious situation. Before the benefits cap benefits were a lifestyle choice for many. We need a firm cap on benefits. I think Kier to take cap off. Kier still does not know what a woman is.

Most people were a lot better off when Brown did that, and we were in less debt as a nation than we are now.
This "unsustainable" thing was myth used to justify austerity. Which hasn't worked, as the country is totally borked and still in huge debt.

I have never voted Labour but the Blair/Brown years were the best of my adult life (turned 18 in 1997,)

Florenz · 27/09/2022 21:41

Politics in general in this country is still stuck in Victorian times for the most part. It needs a drastic overhaul.

Bacibaci · 27/09/2022 21:39

Ohsugarhoneyicetea · 27/09/2022 18:40

I dont think Starmer inspires confidence in people, to win elections you need a leader who is a bit inspiring, even bojo managed that. But dull Starmer and gobby 'basic instinct' Raynor just dont. Its so depressing. A bit of spark please Labour!

I am not seeking a PM with buckets of charisma but a govt that will offer policies that will work towards making the economy benefit not only the richest and make it worse for everyone else.

I suggest watching Starmer’s speech today at the Labour conference. He has set out Labour’s stall and I am liking the policies. Of course a party can make pledges and may not fulfil them once in power but I am pleased that many of the policies Labour have set out at their conference this week are socially democratic in nature. Social democrats still work within a capitalist framework but do also intervene when the market produces such inequalities.

Labour pledges to invest in the NHS, green energy and "spread opportunity to all". Labour pledge to set up a publicly-owned green energy company within a year if he is elected, with 100% clean power by 2030. Labour said they would immediately reverse abolishing the top 45% tax rate. They would build much more council housing with Lisa Nandy yesterday describing housing isn’t a market. It’s a fundamental human right. Labour have pledged they would take on an extra 7,500 medical students every year, doubling the number of district nurses, and offering 10,000 extra nursing placements.

AdamRyan · 27/09/2022 21:37

Ohsugarhoneyicetea · 27/09/2022 18:40

I dont think Starmer inspires confidence in people, to win elections you need a leader who is a bit inspiring, even bojo managed that. But dull Starmer and gobby 'basic instinct' Raynor just dont. Its so depressing. A bit of spark please Labour!

Please don't parrot the Conservatives unfounded misogynistic smears about Rayner. Even Bo Jo said it was unwarranted and apologised.
It's disgusting you've posted that and sad if that's the level of information you use to decide who to vote for.

sjxoxo · 27/09/2022 21:32

Ohsugarhoneyicetea · 27/09/2022 18:40

I dont think Starmer inspires confidence in people, to win elections you need a leader who is a bit inspiring, even bojo managed that. But dull Starmer and gobby 'basic instinct' Raynor just dont. Its so depressing. A bit of spark please Labour!

Agree x1000. Why can’t someone give the Labour Party a serious makeover?? Why can they not innovate and see how boring and uninspiring they are. I just don’t get it. In 2022 in any other field, people would give it a total rebrand and repackage it into something brilliant. But no, the one area that does actually really matter, there is zero creativity. They need a complete overhaul to something modern, young, fresh, connected, efficient, polished, ‘normal’. I wish so badly I could just remake labour into something people felt was good!! There is so much creativity out there now and not a single sprinkle of it seems to go in the labour party’s direction!!

Florenz · 27/09/2022 21:30

Perfect28 · 27/09/2022 21:26

Florenz the dailymail has facist roots and repeatedly prints misogynistic shite e.g slutshaming Angela Raynor because she recrossed her legs whilst wearing a skirt.

That might be so but it doesn't stop people reading it. Why doesn't the Guardian try to become more popular instead of only printing negative stories that make people miserable?

Labraradabrador · 27/09/2022 21:27

Have looked at the key points from Starmers speech, I have to say I was thoroughly unimpressed. There isn’t much meat there in terms of actual policy proposals, nothing that inspires (most of it was Tory bashing as opposed to providing an alternative vision), and it doesn’t inspire confidence that they have real workable plans for accomplishing any of the vague aspirations mentioned. So no, based on what I have seen I don’t think Labour would be better.

I don’t sit comfortably with any party, but I am much more interested in some of the Conservative ideas being floated, despite not being a fan of the mini budget. If Labour’s whole electoral strategy is ‘not Tory’, I can’t see them doing great things, even if they manage to squeak through a change in government.

Perfect28 · 27/09/2022 21:26

Florenz the dailymail has facist roots and repeatedly prints misogynistic shite e.g slutshaming Angela Raynor because she recrossed her legs whilst wearing a skirt.

Chocolatefreak · 27/09/2022 21:25

Disappointed that Starmer has dismissed Proportional Representation - now would be the perfect time to bring in electoral reform.

Person18885 · 27/09/2022 21:17

it doesnt matter what party you vote for, the whole system here is a mess, it needs massive reform, politics isnt what its supposed to be, at the end of the day it will always be some idiot making bad decisions until we reform

QueueEtwo · 27/09/2022 21:16

Here we go!

Florenz · 27/09/2022 21:16

I don't really understand why people moan about the Daily Mail. Left wing newspapers exist. the Guardian website is free to read. You can't make people read newspapers or news websites that you want them to read. Why not try making the left wing ones more popular?

Dontevenstart · 27/09/2022 21:15

Never trust a Tory, any kind thereof.

Chocolatefreak · 27/09/2022 21:06

Summerhillsquare · 27/09/2022 19:59

Why? We're not in Venezuela, Venezula doesnt have a Labour Party, Kier Starmer isn't trying to get votes over there.

UK Labour governments down the decades have created more jobs, paid better benefits, borrowed less money, reduced hospital waiting times, increased educational attainment, increased secure housing, secured warmer relationships with neighbours and promoted arts and culture. Oh and less corruption and sex scandals. Judge them by their record.

@Summerhillsquare I think @waffless is equating Labour in the UK to the Communist party in Venezuela!

@waffless - having properly funded public services isn't Communism you know. 🙄

Salacia · 27/09/2022 21:02

These threads always drive home that those amazing mail online readership figures aren’t exaggerated. It’s genuinely scary how much power it has to shape the political landscape.

Sirius3030 · 27/09/2022 20:56

MintJulia · 27/09/2022 18:56

I have. Are you implying it didn't happen? Or that it won't happen again? Because so far I'm not reassured.

So if Labour were to take power tomorrow after 23 years of Tory rule, there is loads of money left, right?

Pieceofpurplesky · 27/09/2022 20:52

There's such rubbish on this thread. How can people possibly still support the tories? The country is in a bloody mess.

Some people would prefer a law breaking, racist, womanising liar than a sensible, steady slightly dull one. I bet you wouldn't say that about the local headteacher at school!

As for the 'he doesn't know what a woman is' I am afraid that I would vote for Labour based on the fact they are pledging to help the lower earners - lots of them are women. Including me. Whilst I can't vote on a single issue, as important as it is, I need to vote on what will help all.

MotherofPearl · 27/09/2022 20:47

HappyHappyHermit · 27/09/2022 19:59

I'd love a boring leader just now, someone solid, boring and steadfast is just what we need.

Totally agree. That's what I meant in my previous post. You would have thought that the horrors we endured from Johnson would have given most people a reality check about choosing charisma over competence (not that I find Johnson charismatic, but other people seem to).

BloodyHellKen · 27/09/2022 20:40

BellaCiao1 · 27/09/2022 20:29

Jeremy Corbyn had an absolute hatchet job done on him my the Tory media.

His policies were liberal and progressive.

But as you say, all you hear is 'at least it wasn't Corbyn'. Not sure what people were scared of, the free wifi or the living wage.

It was Momentum and their insane suggestions like limiting personal inheritance to £275k over a lifetime that put me off.

BirmaBrite · 27/09/2022 20:34

Just thought it might have been spitting image ?

pointythings · 27/09/2022 20:34

MAny of the posts on this thread illustrate perfectly just how much power the right wing media have and how politically illiterate people are. The moment you dig into the data the picture on economic competence is clear - but people don't want data, they want soundbites. They don't want competence, they want entertainment. And so they get the government they deserve and drag the rest of us down with them.

BirmaBrite · 27/09/2022 20:33

DH and I were chatting about a comedy sketch show, where the Consevative candidates go to someones home and basically say they are going to do things which mean he will lose his job, his home, his family will be destitute but still he says he will vote for them. Can't remember who it was , google has been no help so far, does anyone remember it , might have been Harry Enfield ?

BellaCiao1 · 27/09/2022 20:32

Kissingfrogs25 · 27/09/2022 19:17

Much of their supporters are violent thugs and scare me quite frankly with their hate speech and anger, I assume that is why Angela has such a leading role as their role model, and their lack of awareness that there are other views, equally as important as theirs.

Their MPs are racist, and what happened today overshadowed the conference, and was just appalling.

As racist as former PM Boris Johnson?

BellaCiao1 · 27/09/2022 20:29

Jeremy Corbyn had an absolute hatchet job done on him my the Tory media.

His policies were liberal and progressive.

But as you say, all you hear is 'at least it wasn't Corbyn'. Not sure what people were scared of, the free wifi or the living wage.

Chloefairydust · 27/09/2022 20:29

Also I understand where people are coming from talking about discrimination against certain groups of people in the Labour Party, this isn’t right, however that’s down to particular people within the party. Not the party itself. I’m willing to bet there are awful things said amongst all of the parties, conservative included (Boris is a perfect example). But you need to see the bigger picture.

what concerns me when I vote is how is this party going to help my own personal situation and the country as a whole. That mindset leaves me to stand by labour. Because conservatives only benefit the very small percentage of the most wealthy in our country (look at the tax break they have just given them!). The fact that everyone else is struggling so much and unable to put money back into the economy is going to end in disaster. We are heading for a crash under conservatives.

If you want to improve conditions for the majority of people in the country, labour is the only option. (It’s not perfect, but it’s all we have got).