Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Labour would be even worse grrrr

194 replies

Explaintome · 27/09/2022 18:27

In the pub last night, rolling news headlines on the TV and we talked briefly about rising interest rates/falling pound.

One man trotted out the now tired line "Labour would be even worse".

"Why?" I said, "what is it that they would do less well?" He couldn't answer, as I find is often the case with people who are certain Labour would be worse. They can't tell me why.

They may be right, they are certainly entitled to that view, but surely to be so convinced about any opinion you must also have some idea of why that is?

This is a middle aged man, does an ordinary, low level management/sales job. He'd tell you himself, he's not particularly clever and he's not interested in/doesn't undertlstand politics or the economy and yet he's so convinced of this view. It was probably unfair of me to challenge him knowing he wouldn't have an argument, but there seem to be a lot like him and frankly it's scary. 12 years and still people are convinced Tory is the best answer, even if they don't know why.

FWIW he's a nice man with other attributes, an encyclopedic music knowledge and good company provided you don't try and talk about the news 😆

OP posts:
cardibach · 27/09/2022 22:10

Unless you are taking about one racist comment which has resulted in suspension and an apology? When racist/sexist/whatever Tories just carry on…

Florenz · 27/09/2022 22:08

"The right wing rags make a play for popularity by printing trash and appeal to base instincts. It works! They then weave in bullshit stuff about how the Tories are the best party for the economy."
If it works, why don't the left wing rags do the same? Print trash, appeal to base instincts, and then weave in stuff about how Labour are the best party for the economy?

cardibach · 27/09/2022 22:07

Kissingfrogs25 · 27/09/2022 19:17

Much of their supporters are violent thugs and scare me quite frankly with their hate speech and anger, I assume that is why Angela has such a leading role as their role model, and their lack of awareness that there are other views, equally as important as theirs.

Their MPs are racist, and what happened today overshadowed the conference, and was just appalling.

I’m. ALabour e member. None of the supporters I know are violent thugs. Or racist.
what happened today that you say overshadowed the conference? What have I missed?

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 27/09/2022 22:07

I wouldn’t worry about one person’s remark OP. I know at least two people who have voted Tory all their lives who are now saying they will never vote Tory again. I’m convinced that Labour will win the next general election. The tories have been absolutely abysmal. How any sane person could vote for them is beyond me

HMSSophia · 27/09/2022 22:07

I've given up on the British public. We clearly have the government we deserve. It's a fucking shame.

Believeitornot · 27/09/2022 22:00

Person18885 · 27/09/2022 21:17

it doesnt matter what party you vote for, the whole system here is a mess, it needs massive reform, politics isnt what its supposed to be, at the end of the day it will always be some idiot making bad decisions until we reform

It does matter. Absolutely matters. It’s lazy to suggest otherwise and deep down you know that.

ilovesooty · 27/09/2022 21:59

CaptainSamCarter · 27/09/2022 21:53

Would love all the 'they don't know what a woman is" folk to explain how women are better off under a government that has seen a huge increase in child poverty, rates of conviction for rape collapse, massive increase in NHS waiting times, and housing become unaffordable. Oh yeah, it's definitely the transwomen in bathrooms that are the biggest threat.

They won't because they can't.

Believeitornot · 27/09/2022 21:58

Cassillero · 27/09/2022 21:55

I haven't read all the responses but I just want to say this.

No-one speaks for us. I was a member of the Labour Party until 2019. I left them because of Self ID.

During covid it became very clear to me that there was absolutely NO opposition. There was no one at all who spoke up and said perhaps we might be a bit fucked if we destroyed small business, continued printing money, transferring wealth to the already rich, and then on top of that transferring billions in a futile war against Russia.

We are where we are. I cannot understand how anyone at all can look at where we are and seriously think we can vote our way out of this shitstorm.

That is the system we live in. You have to work with what you’ve got.

FayeGovan · 27/09/2022 21:57

beachcitygirl · 27/09/2022 21:55

Thank god I live in scotland & have the eminently sensible sturgeon to vote for

Snp make plenty mistakes but im voting independence until we get it.

Bacibaci · 27/09/2022 21:56

Below I will copy and paste a large part of Labour shadow minister Lisa Nandy’s speech yesterday and have highlighted in bold her comment on her plans for housing. All these policies and focus on making the economy work for all I can get behind. I had a quick look on Daily Mail website and no surprise not a squeak from them on all of this.

“Now Liz Truss says her government will grow our economy by turning the North into Singapore-on-Sea. So they can stash their wealth in our towns and cities, pushing up the cost of housing and dodging tax. Slashing taxes for big corporations so the rest of us can grind for a living in an Amazon warehouse. Handing £55,000 to millionaires while people can’t afford to pay their rent, feed their kids and heat their homes. More money for millionaires than the whole North of England. In the words of Liz Truss – That. Is. A. Disgrace.

Conference. It’s time to stand up and fight again. Not just to see off the Tories. But to build the country I’ve believed in all my life – where everyone can contribute and everyone has a stake in our future.

It will be about the real wealth creators – the women and men who work in our shops, who drive our buses, who deliver our mail, who produce our food, who care for our families and teach our children – who make sure we have what we need to live every day of our lives. To those people, we say you are the foundation of our economy.

We believe that when people have a stake in the outcome, they work harder, they try longer, they think more creatively and they do more. The people of our country are our great untapped asset. Labour will tilt the balance of power back in their favour.

In the first 100 days, we will end fire and rehire, repeal the 2016 anti-trade union Act and raise wages for the lowest paid. And we’ll usher in a great rebalancing of power, with wealth, security and opportunity spread across the whole country.

They say you can power a modern economy using only a handful of people in a handful of places in one small corner of the country. We say that’s like trying to fly a jet on one engine. This country doesn’t belong to a few of them, it belongs to all of us.

So we will invest to bring clean energy jobs to the industrial and coastal towns across Britain, so that young people in places that were once the engines of Britain can power us through the next century like their parents and grandparents powered us through the last. The road to net zero is paved with a million good jobs, and we’ll bring them to Britain.

Empowering our brilliant leaders – Steve, Tracy, Andy, Marvin, Shaun – with new powers to drive growth in every part of Britain. And handing power back to our people with a community right-to-buy land and assets – the football clubs, historic buildings and pubs that make a place home. So those with skin in the game, who are in it for the long haul, will feel the whole system pulling in behind them. That – Liz Truss – is how you grow the economy.

But I have learnt that progress is not inevitable. If we want to live in a country where children don’t have to go to school too hungry to learn. Where people with disabilities can live the richer, larger lives they deserve. Where people don’t have to fear growing old without dignity or warmth. If we want that country, we have to go out and fight for it every single day.

So I am asking you today to get ready. Because together, with every person, in every place we’re going to rebuild this country from the ground up. And I can say to you today that in government, I will make it my priority to tackle the housing crisis because nothing, nothing is more important than a home.

The Tories have turned housing into a racket. Incentivising speculation and profiteering while millions languish on waiting lists in cold damp homes. So we will mend the deliberate vandalism of our social housing stock. Because the idea of a home for life handed on in common ownership to future generations. Is an idea worth fighting for.
**
Council housing is not a dirty word. So today, I can announce we will be the first government in a generation to restore social housing to the second largest from of tenure. This will be our mantra. Council housing, council housing, council housing.

We’re going to rebuild our social housing stock and bring homes back into the ownership of local councils and communities. With home ownership opened up to millions more.

And for private renters we will tilt the balance of power back to you through a powerful new renters charter and a new decent homes standard – written into law. Because security in your home, the right to make your home your own and most of all the right to live in a home fit for human habitation, is non-negotiable. Because housing isn’t a market. It’s a fundamental human right.”

User135644 · 27/09/2022 21:55

Cornettoninja · 27/09/2022 19:44

’Labour would be worse’
’Corbyn would have been worse’
’theres no better alternative’

All lazy repetition of propaganda when someone has nothing left to say.

At least it’s a decent red flag that I’m talking to someone who is politically lazy.

It's a defence mechanism to insulate people from themselves and their own voting choices or discredited opinions. They'll always have a reason to back up why they voted Brexit or Boris Johnson or Dave Cameron over 'chaos with Ed Miliband'.

"Okay everything went to shit but it would have been even worse had I chose the other guy". it's themselves they're trying to convince.

beachcitygirl · 27/09/2022 21:55

Thank god I live in scotland & have the eminently sensible sturgeon to vote for

Cassillero · 27/09/2022 21:55

I haven't read all the responses but I just want to say this.

No-one speaks for us. I was a member of the Labour Party until 2019. I left them because of Self ID.

During covid it became very clear to me that there was absolutely NO opposition. There was no one at all who spoke up and said perhaps we might be a bit fucked if we destroyed small business, continued printing money, transferring wealth to the already rich, and then on top of that transferring billions in a futile war against Russia.

We are where we are. I cannot understand how anyone at all can look at where we are and seriously think we can vote our way out of this shitstorm.

CaptainSamCarter · 27/09/2022 21:53

Would love all the 'they don't know what a woman is" folk to explain how women are better off under a government that has seen a huge increase in child poverty, rates of conviction for rape collapse, massive increase in NHS waiting times, and housing become unaffordable. Oh yeah, it's definitely the transwomen in bathrooms that are the biggest threat.

User135644 · 27/09/2022 21:52

MintJulia · 27/09/2022 18:37

YANBU. Everyone is entitled to their opinions but it seems reasonable to have some basis for an opinion.

For me, it's that note Labour left last time, saying 'Good Luck, There's no money left.' That a minister of state could openly admit getting the exchequer into such a mess, be fully aware of it, and think it's a cause for humour was unforgiveable. I'm scared that attitude persists, that it will happen again.

but Truss is no better.

The choice faced by the British electorate is appalling.

That note is a standard joke from departing treasury officials. The Tories used it for their own purposes.

Believeitornot · 27/09/2022 21:51

BirmaBrite · 27/09/2022 21:50

The Conservatives have two more years in power, two more years of making the decisions, two more years of being entirely responsible for what happens next. Its's worrying to say the least, how much havoc could they wreak in that timescale ?.

Look what they’ve managed since Friday!

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 27/09/2022 21:51

It's brainwashing- pure and simple. Rupert Murdoch has made a decent living doing it to people for decades.

Believeitornot · 27/09/2022 21:51

scorpiogirly · 27/09/2022 21:49

The don't know what a woman is.

Fucking bullshit.

the Tories have been in power since 2010, so all of that stuff is on them.

BirmaBrite · 27/09/2022 21:50

The Conservatives have two more years in power, two more years of making the decisions, two more years of being entirely responsible for what happens next. Its's worrying to say the least, how much havoc could they wreak in that timescale ?.

Believeitornot · 27/09/2022 21:50

Florenz · 27/09/2022 21:16

I don't really understand why people moan about the Daily Mail. Left wing newspapers exist. the Guardian website is free to read. You can't make people read newspapers or news websites that you want them to read. Why not try making the left wing ones more popular?

The right wing rags make a play for popularity by printing trash and appeal to base instincts. It works! They then weave in bullshit stuff about how the Tories are the best party for the economy.

Look at the state of the nation. Maybe it’s easier to read stories about celebrities than use your brain and engage with the absolute shit show that’s coming.

Many people won’t notice straight away that their pay packets won’t increase (unless you’re on £150k), that mortgages will go up (when they come off a fixed term mortgage), that their kids schools are crumbling. But when it does happen, it’ll probably be after the Tories have won in 2024 due to the ignorance of many voters.

I am sure there’s research somewhere that suggests that those who are right wing have a lower IQ. Makes fucking sense.

scorpiogirly · 27/09/2022 21:49

The don't know what a woman is.

User135644 · 27/09/2022 21:46

Forelock tuggers. Never get in between an Englishman and his beloved Tories.

Bacibaci · 27/09/2022 21:45

Chocolatefreak · 27/09/2022 21:25

Disappointed that Starmer has dismissed Proportional Representation - now would be the perfect time to bring in electoral reform.

As I have written above, I like the policies Labour have announced this week at their conference but I agree Starmer dismissing PR I don’t like. The motion at the conference was for it and this time some of the unions voted for it. I know a motion is not binding but with some of the unions coming on board he may well revise not endorsing it before the next general election.

Livinghappy · 27/09/2022 21:44

@Florenz, The right wing papers appeal because they offer simple solutions for complex challenges and play the blame game.

I have elderly neighbours who believe the right wing narrative as they have no critical thinking skills. They want simple solutions and catchy phrases and slogans. An elderly ex nurse was blaming the staff in the NHS rather than the funding issues and staff shortages. She had been trained for free, had subsided accommodation, low house prices and now a good pension.

I am a high earner but can't defend the last 12 years. The very, very rich have been protected - its a small club who perhaps do genuinely believe in trickle down..cynically I think they are just selfish. If you stand back and analyse the content you will see the themes.

The tories have shown they are financially reckless - anyone thinking otherwise needs to have their head examined

Perfect28 · 27/09/2022 21:43

florenz I guess because the guardian might not believe in writing lies for sales, to become 'popular'