Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boyfriend - Threesome

35 replies

AmIBeingSillyyyy · 27/09/2022 18:01

Hello

I dont know if I have a point or just being jealous.

I have been dating a lovely man since April and we became official in May. I love him and I am excited to see what happens next. Sex is amazing on both levels - emotionally and physically. I am currently finalising my divorce and kept alot of details from him - I'm a private person (basically, I didnt tell him I was in the process of divorcing!). One evening we spoke about my situation and he told me that I can speak to him about anything as he is very open and understanding of situations... this led to him telling me that 20 odd years ago, his two friends asked him to join their relationship... which he considered but didnt have time for.

One day we were both texting and discussing sex, what we would like to try/what we like with each other, that kind of chat etc. etc. He then asked if I'd ever thought about a threesome... I said I wasnt sure and he said he would be open to it. He said it would have to be with someone we were both comfortable with and suggested that we could hire someone. He then asked if I would be okay with a girl doing things to me.. which I said that I probably wouldnt as I have never done anything with a girl before.. I asked if he would be okay watching me with another man and he said yes, if thats what I wanted. He then asked if I would be okay watching him with someone else if I could join in.. I said no and he said that we didnt need to discuss it anymore as he would only want to do it if I did blah blah blah.

I then asked if he has ever had a threesome and he said yes, 20 years ago with his two friends (well, his friend and his friends gf... then the same people who asked him to join their relationship!). He doesnt speak to them anymore, it was 20 years ago, and he is unlikely to ever see them again (they live in different countries but have mutual friends) - why am I so bothered by this :(

I guess, he is always telling me that he really fancies me, only wants me etc. but then started that conversation. I cant hold his past against him but I feel really bothered by the whole thing. He said he didnt mean the "would I be okay watching him with someone else if I could join in" comment, which is nonsense of course he did! He then said he would only want to do it if we both wanted it and he said that it never has to get mentioned ever again.

Would you be bothered by this?
If yes, what would you do?
If no, what can I do to get past this.

Thanks x

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Cw112 · 04/11/2022 12:13

I'm not generally one to kink shame anybody, I think what consenting adults choose to do is fine as long as it isn't affecting or hurting anyone else. I think that when you start a new relationship you have a period of working out each others boundaries and preferences and this also applies to the bedroom. I think as long as he's brought it up respectfully and has accepted that it's a hard no for you and has since dropped it is fair enough. There's things my dh would like to do that we've talked about that I'm not cool with so we don't do those things and he doesn't continue to bring it up and vice versa. I think what matters is how emotionally safe you feel around him, how respected you feel around him and how he treats you. If he continues to bring up this fantasy/kink shame you/otherwise try to pressure you then he would be bang out of order. But in the context of the convo you had I don't see anything alarming.

Scurryfunge12 · 04/11/2022 12:00

And I’m speaking from personal experience, it usually gets brought up more than once in the hope you might change your mind, even if several months/years later. It’s a burning desire, and he’s clearly definitely into it if he’s done it before.

Scurryfunge12 · 04/11/2022 11:56

You’re probably sexually incompatible if it’s not your thing, and I’d feel the same as you - it’s coming across like you’re not enough for him and he’s likely to keep trying to persuade you. After only dating since April this is big of a red flag to me.

Don’t give in to him if you don’t want to! It’s very dangerous and could lead to insecurity and resentment.

If he keeps mentioning it I’d call it a day. It’s just greedy to me!

cynthiamorriswilliams · 04/11/2022 10:52

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

candycaneframe · 27/09/2022 19:01

@LuckyLil and?

So what if he has already had one and is interested in finding up out whether the OP would be up for it

That's pretty common when initiating relationships, to discuss what you're into, what you've done before and would be open to trying again etc.

Mummadeze · 27/09/2022 18:56

My partner broached the threesome subject with me when we were first dating. He also suggested swinging. I told him flat out it wasn’t for me and I didn’t like the idea. We did later try going to a well known S&M club night to see if I liked it and I wanted to leave after about 10 minutes. It just wasn’t my cup of tea. He respected my feelings and we never discussed any of these things again. I didn’t hold it against him for being open and suggesting things. I wouldn’t have liked it if he had kept pressurising me though. I think you need to make your feelings clear and go from there.

BatshitBanshee · 27/09/2022 18:50

Mostmarriedcouple · 27/09/2022 18:16

These comments aren’t fair. She said they were texting and speaking about things they wanted to explore. It’s pretty tame to ask about threesomes, it’s not exactly something wild. Doesn’t mean he necessarily wants one, he’s just saying he’d be up for it and got turned on speaking about it

This, with bells on. It wouldn't bother me in the context of the conversation - you were discussing things openly about things you'd both like to try sexually. It's a fairly straightforward conversation most couples have now. The pearl clutching on this board will do you no favours OP, I'd relocate this to the Sex board.

wackamole · 27/09/2022 18:50

He said he'd drop any sexual suggestion that you weren't enthusiastic about. Now that you've been clear that any kind of threesome is a no, it's reasonable to expect that he won't bring it up again, and a red flag if he does. Next time, speak up right away if he suggests something you're not happy and comfortable to try.

I'd treat the past threesome like any of his past relationships - none of it reflects his feelings for you, and if threesomes were some kind of necessity for him he wouldn't have waited 20 years. (As a side note, I'm not sure if I didnt tell him I was in the process of divorcing means he thought you were intending to stay married or that he didn't know you were married, but either way the relationship wasn't mongamous, so I wouldn't expect him to act as if it were. That may have changed if your divorce is final and he knows the truth now.)

The suggestion to pay for sex would be a dealbreaker for me, but your boundaries may be completely different.

Ducksinthebath · 27/09/2022 18:45

I’d be more bothered about the fact he’s the type who would pay for sex.

ladyofshertonabbas · 27/09/2022 18:44

Mostmarriedcouple · 27/09/2022 18:16

These comments aren’t fair. She said they were texting and speaking about things they wanted to explore. It’s pretty tame to ask about threesomes, it’s not exactly something wild. Doesn’t mean he necessarily wants one, he’s just saying he’d be up for it and got turned on speaking about it

This.

CapMarvel · 27/09/2022 18:40

If it was bought up as part of a conversation explicitly about sex, and if he means it when he says he would drop it if OP wasn't up for it then these comments are ridiculously over the top.

There is nothing inherently suspicious about a man bringing up what is an incredibly common fantasy. The issues would start - of course - if he continued to pressurise the OP into something she doesn't want to do but that's the same of anything.

Lockheart · 27/09/2022 18:32

It's a pretty common fantasy for men and women. In the context of an open discussion about sex and things you'd like to try, it doesn't raise any red flags that he's bringing it up. People in relationships should be able to be open with each other about their desires and past experiences.

The main thing is OP that he should never pressure you to try something you've said no to. He sounds like he's understood your boundary on this clearly by saying he will never bring it up again.

piegone · 27/09/2022 18:26

I think all the pearl clutching is a bit over the top. Threesomes are an incredibly common male fantasy.

Aww bless the poor man. All these pesky women against him. Poor poor thing.

Darbs76 · 27/09/2022 18:26

I agree it’s a common fantasy and it was said in context - not completely out of the blue. I guess if he sticks to his word and never mentions it again it’s not a problem. If he tries to pressure you, it’s a whole different kettle of fish

Luckingfovely · 27/09/2022 18:23

I think all the pearl clutching is a bit over the top. Threesomes are an incredibly common male fantasy.

In the context of an open convo about what sex & fantasy stuff you like, I really couldn't get upset about it being mentioned, or about one incident 20 years ago, for goodness' sake.

On the other hand - if he keeps bringing it up or pressures you towards doing it, that's completely different - then run for the hills!!

IsThePopeCatholic · 27/09/2022 18:21

‘We could hire someone’. He sounds awful, op. I’d run a mile.

Mostmarriedcouple · 27/09/2022 18:20

20 years ago!!!

FourTeaFallOut · 27/09/2022 18:19

Hire someone? 🙄

AmIBeingSillyyyy · 27/09/2022 18:19

We spoke later that night - he asked if I was annoyed with him speaking about a fantasy and I said yes! I said that I fear it'll come up again and I feel hurt that I am not enough this early on. He said it was only mentioned because we were talking about things we liked / wanted to try with each other. He said I have told him bluntly that I dont want to do it so we will never speak of it again as he only wants to do things that we both enjoy.

OP posts:
LuckyLil · 27/09/2022 18:19

Mostmarriedcouple · 27/09/2022 18:16

These comments aren’t fair. She said they were texting and speaking about things they wanted to explore. It’s pretty tame to ask about threesomes, it’s not exactly something wild. Doesn’t mean he necessarily wants one, he’s just saying he’d be up for it and got turned on speaking about it

He's already done it and wants to know if she'd be comfortable with it too.

Mostmarriedcouple · 27/09/2022 18:16

These comments aren’t fair. She said they were texting and speaking about things they wanted to explore. It’s pretty tame to ask about threesomes, it’s not exactly something wild. Doesn’t mean he necessarily wants one, he’s just saying he’d be up for it and got turned on speaking about it

Clymene · 27/09/2022 18:14

He's a really lovely man who is repeatedly trying to break your sexual boundaries.

Suprima · 27/09/2022 18:14

How handy that you are now official so he can suggest things like this and you don’t feel he’s trampling all over your boundaries

he doesn’t want a life partner love, he wants a swinging partner

Mostmarriedcouple · 27/09/2022 18:13

I understand that you feel hurt thinking about him with his friend and his girlfriend, but I think that is natural as you care for him and of course don’t want to picture him with other people. Our brains don’t really process thoughts with times attached to them, so you are probably hurting as if this happened recently. If it was 20 years ago, that’s a very long time. Try to think that there is worse things you could find out? I.e he still is close friends with an ex girlfriend.

it sounds to me the comment about “could you watch me with someone else” was potentially because he felt a bit hurt when you suggested going with another man. Men are silly sometimes and get hurt by the things that they have suggested.

if everything is fine and you are happy put this down to a one off blip.

ICanHideButICantRun · 27/09/2022 18:11

He's going to push and push, isn't he?

If it's not your thing, I'd end the relationship.