Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I can't dismiss for this?

60 replies

Patchoomi · 27/09/2022 16:36

A month ago our work systems were hacked. No data breaches but man hour costs to rectify it.

The security team identified Dave, not the real name, had clicked on a link in an email. They asked me to start disciplinary procedures for dismissal. Dave doesn't know this.

Our IT rules are standard, don't watch naighty films, don't be illegal, don't download harmful data.

Dave has worked for the company for about 7 years. He's hardworking and honest. It is not rare for our work to click emails. I really believe it was an accident and that if he knew, he would have told the managers and been upset. I don't like Dave but he is good at his job and honest.

I don't know that he breached the IT policy because I don't think he did it on purpose or through neglect. I think too that if we dismiss him it will stop others being honest when they make mistakes.

Work know Dave is dating my best friend so I will refuse to do the process and ask someone else must do it even though I am his manager. I don't know how I can help him.

Or do you think my company are being reasonable and sensible because even if it was a mistake it still made big problems?

OP posts:
Fleur405 · 27/09/2022 16:52

Well I hope Dave got adequate training on cyber security otherwise I expect he will have a claim for unfair dismissal - especially if he’s able to get hold of the internal communications which demonstrate they decided to dismiss him before carrying out any sort of disciplinary procedure/ at least asking Dave what his version of events is.

Patchoomi · 27/09/2022 16:50

We have to complete IT and security training every year. HR will help do the process but it is the manager who must investigate and lead it. I have said I can't do it.

OP posts:
ComtesseDeSpair · 27/09/2022 16:48

Unless there’s an outright policy that links in external emails must never be clicked (and I can’t see how that’s workable for any organisation) it’s very unlikely they can claim he’s breached a policy. I’d put it in writing that you are not qualified in employment law and thus are not in a position to carry out an investigation with the outcome being dismissal.

Patchoomi · 27/09/2022 16:46

I am sorry if I was unclear. HR have said to discipline and dismiss because of what the security team told them. They say he has breached policy and that is gross misconduct. I was not at work during this time.

OP posts:
SirDavidAttenborough · 27/09/2022 16:45

Has Dave had training to say not to click the link?

ComtesseDeSpair · 27/09/2022 16:45

You need to refer this to HR, you aren’t sufficiently qualified or knowledgeable in the area to carry out an investigation yourself, and especially not if you’ve been actively told what outcome you need to find.

Broadly, the company can’t seek to to dismiss him unless it counts as gross misconduct, and for it to qualify as that you would need to demonstrate he had intentionally and maliciously sought to jeopardise your systems, or was grossly incompetent. Accidentally clicking on a phishing link in an email is generally dealt with by sending staff on refresher training teaching them how to recognise a fishing email and what they need to check to ensure all links are genuine in future.

ItsDarkAlready · 27/09/2022 16:44

I work in the NHS and lots of staff accidentally click links in scamming emails. We have an IT phishing department partly for this exact reason. Dave has done nothing wrong! Unless there's more to it?....

Patchoomi · 27/09/2022 16:43

I think they will do the process but do it so he has to prove it was an accident instead of them asking if it was. This is harder.

OP posts:
DysmalRadius · 27/09/2022 16:43

Do HR not get a say? Surely the remit of the security team is to identify the source of the breach, not to decide how to deal with the member of staff?

gatehouseoffleet · 27/09/2022 16:39

I think your firm need to look at their procedures. They can't just dismiss him, they need to carry out a fair investigation (and NOT PREJUDGE THE OUTCOME).

Check ACAS and your HR policies.

If they simply sack him for a simple mistake they'll end up with an employment tribunal case. I'd ask for this to be moved to the employment section and get some proper advice on there.