Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I can't dismiss for this?

60 replies

Patchoomi · 27/09/2022 16:36

A month ago our work systems were hacked. No data breaches but man hour costs to rectify it.

The security team identified Dave, not the real name, had clicked on a link in an email. They asked me to start disciplinary procedures for dismissal. Dave doesn't know this.

Our IT rules are standard, don't watch naighty films, don't be illegal, don't download harmful data.

Dave has worked for the company for about 7 years. He's hardworking and honest. It is not rare for our work to click emails. I really believe it was an accident and that if he knew, he would have told the managers and been upset. I don't like Dave but he is good at his job and honest.

I don't know that he breached the IT policy because I don't think he did it on purpose or through neglect. I think too that if we dismiss him it will stop others being honest when they make mistakes.

Work know Dave is dating my best friend so I will refuse to do the process and ask someone else must do it even though I am his manager. I don't know how I can help him.

Or do you think my company are being reasonable and sensible because even if it was a mistake it still made big problems?

OP posts:
AchatAVendre · 27/09/2022 17:54

Disproportionate to dismiss him for this if it was innocent clicking of a link as a one off. Surely he can be given a written warning instead?

Does he have a history of misuse of work internet? If not, then it sounds like an easy case for unfair dismissal, since placing access to such links and not blocking them with a robust firewall is putting individual employees at too much risk of making an innocent mistake.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 27/09/2022 17:54

I does sound like HR have prejudged the outcome. That is a big problem. Additionally, if the error he made was no worse than others i.e. he clicked on a dodgy link then it may be disproportionate to discipline him harshly if the others weren’t for also clicking dodgy links. Also are all policy breaches subject to the same process. So if your disciplinary policy said turning up to work drunk was gross misconduct and clicking a dodgy link was gross misconduct but the drunk person was sent home, lost a day’s pay and got a written warning but the dodgy link clicker got sacked - how would that be justified.

HR really need to get some proper advice and make sure the whole process is fair, transparent, robust and proportionate.

CantGetDecentNickname · 27/09/2022 17:51

I would definitely try to avoid being the one to do any dismissing in these circumstances. I've seen companies tell a manager to dismiss someone as a way of getting rid of the manager because they will then be seen to have made a bad management decision when it turns out that the dismissed person has a good case for constructive dismissal. No investigation and a predetermined decision sounds very dodgy. Are you sure Dave is their actual target?

AlisonDonut · 27/09/2022 17:42

Surely HR know you cant just dismiss without investigating.

I'd be keeping that email for if they force you to dismiss to show that it was decided before the investigation started and accidentally bring it into the appeal. Which you would of course tell your friend to tell him to do.

Personally I'd tell HR they were wrong and you have investigated, have found it an accident and not a breach of policy [I'd quote the policy] and refuse to discipline him. I would suggest though the first item on the next meeting agenda to be the topic of internet safety. It is always better to train rather than to dismiss in situations like this.

Sapphire387 · 27/09/2022 17:35

I work for a trade union and from what you have said, I think any TU official or rep worth their salt would tear your HR dept to shreds over this. Totally unreasonable response and likely to be a solid case for unfair dismissal at the ET.

Darbs76 · 27/09/2022 17:34

Agree context is relevant here. Surely an investigation is standard? At my work whenever there is an incident there’s an investigation conducted by a manager not in the management chain and independent staff to interview people. This sounds a bit odd that they’ve just asked you to dismiss without an investigation. My advice to Dave would be to contact his union and ACAS

SummerInSun · 27/09/2022 17:31

Tell HR to talk to the legal department or get external legal advice, or if you have an internal legal department, copy them yourself. Remind them that their internal emails about the decision to dismiss him before conducting any sort of investigation will be disclosed to Dave's lawyers in any subsequent unfair dismissal claim.

Worth exploring why they want to dismiss him. Possibly someone in HR mistakenly thinks that because breaching IT policies CAN be gross misconduct, that any breach automatically IS gross misconduct and that they have to fire him, eg in case it happens again and the Information Commissioner's Office asks how they dealt with similar instances in the past. If so, they have totally the wrong end of the stick, especially for an innocent mistake by a good employee.

OfficiallyBroken · 27/09/2022 17:30

Context is crucial here. Clicking a phishing link accidentally because it was a spoof of a company email/looked official enough to warrant clicking could only reasonably be argued as gross misconduct if you're a cyber security specialist trained specifically to spot these things. Anyone else, frankly it's the IT team who are responsible for educating and reducing the risk around these events - ours actually run campaigns to "phish" for people who are likely to click on these things so they can attend extra training.

Clicking a link in an email that doesn't belong in a work account full stop, they could claim gross misconduct...for example if the email was about young Bavarian women and a link was clicked there's no professional defence for doing that and an investigation could result in gross misconduct being the outcome.

You can be a good conscientious and diligent worker but still be caught out in the second example because you didn't think for a split second. For what it's worth, I think your company are on shakey ground unless there's literally no defence for not immediately deleting the email received. A predetermined outcome to an investigation has tribunal written all over it.

Hope Dave is a member of a union!

Wonnle · 27/09/2022 17:26

Depends on your definition of what is gross misconduct doesn't it

Patchoomi · 27/09/2022 17:26

My phone will run out of batteries but thank you for answering.

OP posts:
Patchoomi · 27/09/2022 17:24

The link downloaded something that damaged our systems. I don't know what Dave thought he was clicking. We have to click a lot of links in our emails so it would be normal. Unless it said to click here for porn or something which would be different of course.

OP posts:
cansu · 27/09/2022 17:21

It is utterly ridiculous to think they can dismiss him for clicking a link. Surely they would need to prove that he knew it was a scam and that it would download data.

Patchoomi · 27/09/2022 17:16

I will speak to HR tomorrow about already deciding the outcome and tell them they can't do that. I think they still will but will be more secret about it. I have emails saying they want to dismiss so I will keep them. I will try to guide them to ask my fair colleague to do it instead of me.

I will think about how to find out what has happened when people have clicked things they shouldn't before. He won't be the first person and it would be unfair to punish him if they were not.

Thank you for giving me hope. I don't like Dave but I don't think this is fair.

OP posts:
Cosycover · 27/09/2022 17:13

Do you know what the link was for?

I feel this should come into play with the decision making.

catfunk · 27/09/2022 17:13

HR here. Despite the fact it was an accident/ people sometimes make mistakes - No investigation first? They're on very dangerous ground.
If they try to dismiss I suggest he appeals and also does an SAR whereby it would be clear they'd discussed trying to dismiss him before an investigation.

Patchoomi · 27/09/2022 17:09

They say he didn't follow the IT policy because he downloaded harmful data when he clicked the link. The policy says if you don't follow it that is gross misconduct. He did download the data and so didn't follow the policy but I think it was accidental. He did not intend to.

The hack damaged our systems and caused data loss but no information was shared outside the company. Our security team are happy it was only an internal issue and no one saw anything they should not.

We must do IT and security training each year. He has not been in trouble before.

OP posts:
BoredOfGrey22 · 27/09/2022 17:08

Firstly, if the outcome of a disciplinary hearing is pre-determined then it is automatically unsound. There might be some extenuating circumstances no one is aware of. No HR person worth their salt would ever tell you it's dismissal without a proper investigation and hearing first.

Secondly, what do your policies state? If clicking on a phishing email is listed as gross misconduct... that is still shaky ground as that in itself is quite unreasonable. Unless EVERYONE who has ever clicked on one of these links has been dismissed?

MrsPinkCock · 27/09/2022 17:04

With 7 years service and an unblemished(?) previous disciplinary record, and no catastrophic consequences, it would be a little risky to dismiss based on a simple mistake. They’d have to show it was gross negligence for the dismissal to be fair.

if he’s had annual training specifically on this issue and they can demonstrate that, plus a written policy, and they can also demonstrate that a fair procedure was followed then it’s possible he could be fairly dismissed.

However, it won’t be a fair procedure if it’s been pre judged, and their reason for dismissal is borderline. On balance I think dismissing him would be likely to be unfair (unless something similar has happened before).

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 27/09/2022 17:01

l left education last year. Staff were always accidentally clicking on emails, even why IT told them not to!

No one was ever disciplined for it.

Goldenbear · 27/09/2022 16:58

What policy has he breached? I work in data protection and if there is an actual data breach, an employee would be dismissed if it was malicious and the breach was high risk personal data and they may be disciplined if they had had extensive training on data protection and kept repeating the same mistake but in some of those cases they would argue they hadn't received enough training and the fault lies with the employer, in fact in nearly all of those cases. However, I don't see how they'd get away with this treatment of an employee if there is no actual breach!

ComtesseDeSpair · 27/09/2022 16:57

Patchoomi · 27/09/2022 16:53

If they say it is gross misconduct he can be dismissed.

There’s a legal definition of what sort of actions would amount to gross misconduct - your employer can’t simply decide that accidentally clicking a phishing link or spilling your tea on your desk is gross misconduct and sack you at will. How big is this company? Do any of these people in HR have any qualifications whatsoever?

WatchoRulo · 27/09/2022 16:56

Patchoomi · 27/09/2022 16:53

If they say it is gross misconduct he can be dismissed.

They can - but it isn't and he'd have an excellent case at ET.

namechange30455 · 27/09/2022 16:56

Patchoomi · 27/09/2022 16:53

If they say it is gross misconduct he can be dismissed.

But they can't just say it's gross misconduct if it's not, surely

Patchoomi · 27/09/2022 16:54

I understand what you are saying Fleur

OP posts:
Patchoomi · 27/09/2022 16:53

If they say it is gross misconduct he can be dismissed.

OP posts: