Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I can't dismiss for this?

60 replies

Patchoomi · 27/09/2022 16:36

A month ago our work systems were hacked. No data breaches but man hour costs to rectify it.

The security team identified Dave, not the real name, had clicked on a link in an email. They asked me to start disciplinary procedures for dismissal. Dave doesn't know this.

Our IT rules are standard, don't watch naighty films, don't be illegal, don't download harmful data.

Dave has worked for the company for about 7 years. He's hardworking and honest. It is not rare for our work to click emails. I really believe it was an accident and that if he knew, he would have told the managers and been upset. I don't like Dave but he is good at his job and honest.

I don't know that he breached the IT policy because I don't think he did it on purpose or through neglect. I think too that if we dismiss him it will stop others being honest when they make mistakes.

Work know Dave is dating my best friend so I will refuse to do the process and ask someone else must do it even though I am his manager. I don't know how I can help him.

Or do you think my company are being reasonable and sensible because even if it was a mistake it still made big problems?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Patchoomi · 30/09/2022 19:11

I must make sure the investigation is fair but will not do ot myself. I can't tell Dave tips.

OP posts:
Patchoomi · 30/09/2022 19:10

I have said I will not be involved with the investigation because he is dating my best friend for 3 or 4 yrs. Work already know that because we told them in writing as soon as we realised. I have been told I must as I am his manager but I will not. I don't know who has decided I must do it. But he is also my staff and I should protect my staff and not just let things happen to them.

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 30/09/2022 19:00

If the security team aren't supposed to have spotted it why should Dave have? Presumably they had much more intense training than his annual 20 minute multiple choice quiz

LIZS · 30/09/2022 18:56

Has anyone asked Dave for his version of events? At best he needs training about IT use, possibly organisation wide, to reiterate it. You should not be involved though die to potential conflict of interest.

Patchoomi · 30/09/2022 18:50

I don't know why but he has found out he pressed the link and my friend says he will resign on Tuesday. I said he should wait but she said he said he is a looser and does not deserve to work at company. It is not true. He says he does not know how he pressed the link and I believe him. I think he is embarrassed and shamed and didn't want to speak to me.

I do not think he knows about the disciplinary or plans to dismiss but I could not ask.

It is hard being his manager and friends with his girlfirend. It is hard to know when I must be a friend and when I must be boss.😔 I have to be very careful.

I am sorry I was not clear. HR said that I should start a disciplinary process but it was gross misconduct and would result in dismissal and the process was for formality. I am sorry I was not clear.

After the previous advise I spoke with ACAS and printed documents to give to HR who said they are going to look onto it. They laughed at me. I asked what was happening to the people in the security team who let the email through and they said they did not think that was relevant and could not discuss it. I said that if it was only Dave punished that he could say it was unfair and take legal action. She said security was automated and scammers change all the time so it was inreasonable to expect security to know everything all the time. She said that Dave had training and knowingly cicked the link. I asked what investigation was being done in security or if they had just accepted it. She said nothing but wrote lots of things down. I said I wanted another discussion with them on Monday. They have not arranged anything so I will make myself a nuisance and show that I will not go away.

I spoke with my manager today who will also speak with HR to investigate.

I don't know if it is best that Dave does resign because he feels bad or whether I try to make him stay and try to make the process fair but then if it goes wrong he might be dismissed and that is worse.

OP posts:
CapMarvel · 27/09/2022 19:27

Your company is on incredibly shaky ground here for all sorts of reasons.

You can't dismiss an otherwise reliable employee over 1 mistake without a full and proper investigation, and it's insane to consider accidentally clicking on a link as gross misconduct. That label usually covers things like theft, physical violence or serious and sustained insubordination.

Redqueenheart · 27/09/2022 19:22

Not unless they want a nice little employment tribunal case and to have to fork out a huge pay out...

Also you are missing an important point: the company IT system should have effective anti-virus software in place that would have quarantined the email in the first place.

So the IT team and the IT system has also failed in this instance.

The staff member will be easily able to argue at the tribunal that if the company IT system whose job it is to protect the company did not even spot and stop the email, why should he be blame for accidentally clicking on the email he had received thinking it was legitimate?

I would say your ''security team'' are the issue here not that poor guy they are trying to blame.

DorsetCafes · 27/09/2022 19:19

there must be more too this surely?
at our place they run monthly phishing exercises and without fail about 3-5% of staff click on the link they weren’t supposed to. We don’t sack all of them!

Willbe2under2 · 27/09/2022 19:18

chilliesandspices · 27/09/2022 18:33

My work sent out a fake link from the CEO as part of a security test. Well over half of our 2,000 employees clicked it.... including the CEO who forgot he had agreed to it and wondered what it was 🤦🏻‍♀️ It was a 2 line email with a link whereas his normal company-wide correspondence tends to be at least a couple of paragraphs.

🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

An old workplace of mine did a cyber security week where they sent out loads of reminders/training about not clicking on dodgy links etc. Early the following week they sent an email which looked a bit odd and asked you to click on a link... then got throughly pissed off when everyone either ignored it, queried it or reported it to IT (it was genuine). If you're going to tell people not to click on dodgy looking links don't then send them 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

LeoEisor · 27/09/2022 18:54

As Dave has worked for more then two years they want to be very careful not to miss anything. Surely he needs to have an investigation to state his side of the story before he gets dismissed? As he would need to see evidence etc?

candycaneframe · 27/09/2022 18:51

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 27/09/2022 18:43

I work in the City and have done so for decades hence all the phishing simulations! HR can’t say investigate for dismissal. First you determine what has happened, then you assess it against your defined disciplinary standards etc. then you determine a fair and proportionate response.

We only have the OPs poorly written post that says that

It's not written well so one also can assume the op might not have understood or been paraphrasing in the post

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 27/09/2022 18:43

My post is to @candycaneframe

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 27/09/2022 18:43

I work in the City and have done so for decades hence all the phishing simulations! HR can’t say investigate for dismissal. First you determine what has happened, then you assess it against your defined disciplinary standards etc. then you determine a fair and proportionate response.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 27/09/2022 18:38

I work for a Local Authoritt. One of my colleagues clicked on anattachment in an email which he thought was genuine as it apparently came from someone he knew professionally. In fact, that person's account had been hacked and when my colleague clicked, he inadvertently downloaded malware which then infected the rest of his contacts.

In short, business was disrupted for about a week, loads of us had to have our laptops stripped and rebuilt, and it was a nightmare. Absolutely nothing happened to my colleague as it was a mistake. We did all get a reminder about IT security but that was it.

candycaneframe · 27/09/2022 18:36

@ChazsBrilliantAttitude the op has said they think Hr will go through the process

Which will include an investigation

If you're given training on what not to click on, and click on scam links then yes in many sectors this would be a serious action which would likely lead to dismissal after them disciplinary process is concluded. Banking for one.

chilliesandspices · 27/09/2022 18:33

My work sent out a fake link from the CEO as part of a security test. Well over half of our 2,000 employees clicked it.... including the CEO who forgot he had agreed to it and wondered what it was 🤦🏻‍♀️ It was a 2 line email with a link whereas his normal company-wide correspondence tends to be at least a couple of paragraphs.

TokyoTen · 27/09/2022 18:30

Something to consider: did the email look like it was malicious or not. For example if it was from a client you deal with (but they had a virus and their system sent it on); or if the name was someone you deal with then that would also be reasonable to click on it. Was it something that could be related to work (e.g. a document on a technology you use).

If it's from BigKnockers72 and it says "Click here for P0rn" then harder for him to justify. But hopefully you get my thought process.

MintJulia · 27/09/2022 18:27

Wow, a company that would dismiss a long standing, hard working employee for accidentally clicking on a link. Once.

If Dave is dismissed, I hope he sues the company, wins big time, makes the head of security look really petty, and the company is shown up in public for being a truly dreadful employer.

And then you'll have the added expense of recruiting a replacement, training them up and trying to replace Dave's experience.

Good luck with that one.

ABBAsnumberonefan · 27/09/2022 18:27

Sounds more like it’s a failure on the IT / security side for not mitigating the risks of such event!

Gemmanorthdevon · 27/09/2022 18:19

On the info given, to move in, having predetermined the result makes it completely void. Every employee has the right to fair and impartial investigation of any accusation relating to their performance. No investigation and consideration of any mitigations ( like unblemished record etc ) will get this laughed at if taken to ET.

It doesn't even matter if there is " more to it" there is still a process they have to follow, and you simply cant " start disciplinary proceedings to dismiss" ...because those proceedings are there to protect the employee from unfair dismissal by way of proper and sound investigations.

. Is he already on suspension or is he still working? Because they also can't start a process with a view to say performance is so poor they have a right to dismiss, whilst letting him carry on until said process is finished!

Sounds like the extra training is required in HR.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 27/09/2022 18:10

candycaneframe · 27/09/2022 17:55

So to clarify

Dave has yearly training that explains not to click links such as these

He has signed a policy saying he has received said training and acknowledging acting outside of this policy would be considered gross misconduct in your business

He still clicked a dodgy link

Erm I'd think your HR team is more up to speed on what's right to do in this situation than you are OP

Links such as what? The OP says they are required to click links in emails as part of their job. He got one wrong. Unless it was really obvious, then it may be difficult to show it was a breach of the policy because there was no intent and if it was a clever fake it might be hard to argue negligence either.
I work in an industry where we get regular phishing simulation emails. So I have seen dozens of dodgy emails over the years and I can tell you that me and my colleagues have all messed up on these simulations from time to time.

HR cannot determine he should be dismissed before the investigation has happened.

Blueblell · 27/09/2022 18:03

I think it depends on what he clicked on? Or what he thought he was clicking on

greenacrylicpaint · 27/09/2022 17:59

no, you can't dismiss him.

but do talk to him.
and have a general information to all staff about scams, phishing and internet use.

it's your IT system fault he was able to (unwittingly) download unsafe software.

ExtraOnions · 27/09/2022 17:59

I would be asking the security team how the email got through in the first place, and why no security warning flagged it as a potential issue.
Emails like this shouldn’t even be in a position to be opened.

candycaneframe · 27/09/2022 17:55

So to clarify

Dave has yearly training that explains not to click links such as these

He has signed a policy saying he has received said training and acknowledging acting outside of this policy would be considered gross misconduct in your business

He still clicked a dodgy link

Erm I'd think your HR team is more up to speed on what's right to do in this situation than you are OP

Swipe left for the next trending thread