Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think councils should move people to smaller properties when kids move out?

417 replies

Faithin · 27/09/2022 16:20

There's a huge lack of 3 bedroom social housing where I live (and everywhere I think?)
a lot of the people living in the 3 bed places are usually just 1 or 2 adults as the kids have grown up and moved out. Meanwhile there's lots of young families overcrowded in 1 and 2 bed flats with no garden etc
aibu to think those that actually need the space should be in the houses and those who don't should be made to downsize?
as the waiting list is so long, what tends to happen is peoples children are in their teens by the time they are moved into a 3 bed property, the grow up and leave within a couple of years and the parents stay, so the vast majority are under-occupied.

OP posts:
gamerchick · 27/09/2022 20:45

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 27/09/2022 20:26

It wouldn't help her financially as 1 bed flats are the same rent as 3 bed houses. All social housing properties in each council/Housing association have the same rate

No they aren't 🙄

ofwarren · 27/09/2022 20:44

ArgieBargie · 27/09/2022 20:36

@MessyBunPersonified I consider my situation far from ‘shit’, thanks for that though. Of course social housing ‘rent’ is subsidised, it’s usually under £100/week which is paltry. It’s ridiculously entitled to think people get to stay in as pp said ‘the biggest house they’ve ever needed’ forever and pass it down just cos… why, exactly? Cos that’s nice for them? We cannot build the housing stock to meet that need and once we’re at a point where some people get super cheap or free housing and can stay forever and pass it on once they die, then housing needs to become a right and EVERYONE gets access to it. But we won’t, cos people who once needed help get in and hog it and never leave so that people that need it NOW are cramped into tiny flats or genuinely shit (unlike my nice 2 bed rental home 😘) hostels and bedsits. Those people should be ashamed, and I would be. It’s taking something from someone who really needs it just cos… I’m alright Jack, ultimately. And ‘there are no 1 or 2 beds available’ of course there bloody are, but shock horror you might have to stand on your own two feet and rent or buy yourself, which people should well be able to do after years of cheap housing. But after the luxury of lovely subsidised secure housing why would someone consider the general good and other people; fuck women fleeing DV with young children, eh. You keep your lovely 3 bed with a garage and a big garden cos ‘ohhh it’s my home’. 🤮

There is no council house where I live that is under £100 a week.
As for "passing it down" are you referring to succession rights? When a person (more often than not, the tenants child) can carry on the tenancy when they die. I think it's perfectly fair for them to take on the tenancy if their mum/dad has died. Much kinder than just kicking them out of sometimes the only home they have ever known.

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 27/09/2022 20:44

@Ahbisto Every time a tenant moves out of a council or HA property, the flooring has to be ripped up by law. That's why PP said that about having no flooring.

gamerchick · 27/09/2022 20:43

ArgieBargie · 27/09/2022 20:36

@MessyBunPersonified I consider my situation far from ‘shit’, thanks for that though. Of course social housing ‘rent’ is subsidised, it’s usually under £100/week which is paltry. It’s ridiculously entitled to think people get to stay in as pp said ‘the biggest house they’ve ever needed’ forever and pass it down just cos… why, exactly? Cos that’s nice for them? We cannot build the housing stock to meet that need and once we’re at a point where some people get super cheap or free housing and can stay forever and pass it on once they die, then housing needs to become a right and EVERYONE gets access to it. But we won’t, cos people who once needed help get in and hog it and never leave so that people that need it NOW are cramped into tiny flats or genuinely shit (unlike my nice 2 bed rental home 😘) hostels and bedsits. Those people should be ashamed, and I would be. It’s taking something from someone who really needs it just cos… I’m alright Jack, ultimately. And ‘there are no 1 or 2 beds available’ of course there bloody are, but shock horror you might have to stand on your own two feet and rent or buy yourself, which people should well be able to do after years of cheap housing. But after the luxury of lovely subsidised secure housing why would someone consider the general good and other people; fuck women fleeing DV with young children, eh. You keep your lovely 3 bed with a garage and a big garden cos ‘ohhh it’s my home’. 🤮

Jolly good. Maybe you can enlighten us to how it's subsidised. Nobody else has been able to in the decade I've been on here.

ofwarren · 27/09/2022 20:38

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 27/09/2022 20:26

It wouldn't help her financially as 1 bed flats are the same rent as 3 bed houses. All social housing properties in each council/Housing association have the same rate

No they aren't.
I've just looked what's available on our local council website and the 1 bed flats and 3 bedroom houses on the same estate are different prices. The house more expensive.

ArgieBargie · 27/09/2022 20:36

MessyBunPersonified · 27/09/2022 18:23

"Because I'm in a shit situation I want everyone else to be too or its not fair, blah blah some bullshit about rent being subsidised even though it isnt"

Are you not embarrassed to think that everyone should be in a crap situation because some people are?

@MessyBunPersonified I consider my situation far from ‘shit’, thanks for that though. Of course social housing ‘rent’ is subsidised, it’s usually under £100/week which is paltry. It’s ridiculously entitled to think people get to stay in as pp said ‘the biggest house they’ve ever needed’ forever and pass it down just cos… why, exactly? Cos that’s nice for them? We cannot build the housing stock to meet that need and once we’re at a point where some people get super cheap or free housing and can stay forever and pass it on once they die, then housing needs to become a right and EVERYONE gets access to it. But we won’t, cos people who once needed help get in and hog it and never leave so that people that need it NOW are cramped into tiny flats or genuinely shit (unlike my nice 2 bed rental home 😘) hostels and bedsits. Those people should be ashamed, and I would be. It’s taking something from someone who really needs it just cos… I’m alright Jack, ultimately. And ‘there are no 1 or 2 beds available’ of course there bloody are, but shock horror you might have to stand on your own two feet and rent or buy yourself, which people should well be able to do after years of cheap housing. But after the luxury of lovely subsidised secure housing why would someone consider the general good and other people; fuck women fleeing DV with young children, eh. You keep your lovely 3 bed with a garage and a big garden cos ‘ohhh it’s my home’. 🤮

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 27/09/2022 20:32

AlwaysChangingNames123 · 27/09/2022 19:42

I dunno, I understand what your saying but

My parents owned their own home ( well, mortgaged ) it's an absolutely beautiful property. Then, when they split up my dad refused to pay the mortgage, my mum couldnt afford it on her own ( single woman, 4 children, 4 bed house ) she worked as many hours as she could and she still couldnt afford the £800 a month mortgage

She had no choice but to sell the house to the council, they let her continue to live there and she still lives there now with one of her adult daughters

She technically has 2 spare bedrooms, but we all visit, all stay over, the grandchildren visit and stay over. And it's all of our families home. I'd be really upset on my mums behalf if she was forced to move out of the home shes spent the last 25 years in so another family could move in

It may well be a council property now, but it's still all of ours home

That's quite a unique set of circumstances though. In fact I hadn't realised you could do that!

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 27/09/2022 20:29

Calandor · 27/09/2022 16:44

Plus, those people could equally say why did you have more children when you couldn't afford a home with enough space.

Criticism can go both ways you know.

People's lives change! Women & children escaping domestic violence, house burnt down, lived in adequately sized privately rented house for years and suddenly the landlord sold etc etc etc

Don't be so judgmental!!!!

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 27/09/2022 20:26

RadFad · 27/09/2022 16:36

My mum is one of these people. 3 bed house just her and her partner. I often say to her she should apply to move to a smaller place as it would help her financially. She works full time but low paid job and pays full rent/council tax etc.
Her reluctance to downsize is mainly losing her garden. Her passion is gardening, and it's hugely beneficial for her mental health.
I can see both sides of the argument.

It wouldn't help her financially as 1 bed flats are the same rent as 3 bed houses. All social housing properties in each council/Housing association have the same rate

DuckBilledFattypus · 27/09/2022 20:14

When it's being funded by housing benefit it kind of is

Except many people in LA housing work and pay their rent. So, it kind of isn't.

Pollydon · 27/09/2022 19:56

candycaneframe · 27/09/2022 18:05

When it's being funded by housing benefit it kind of is

I was in social housing for 23 years and received precisely £0.00 in housing benefit. I worked FT, DH worked FT.
Save your sneers for the private landlords that get the housing benefits from their tenants.

Branleuse · 27/09/2022 19:44

Its so shit that after the budget that is showing the total landgrab the government is doing that will only benefit the top 1% of earners, that people are even discussing whether council tenancies should be less secure

AlwaysChangingNames123 · 27/09/2022 19:42

I dunno, I understand what your saying but

My parents owned their own home ( well, mortgaged ) it's an absolutely beautiful property. Then, when they split up my dad refused to pay the mortgage, my mum couldnt afford it on her own ( single woman, 4 children, 4 bed house ) she worked as many hours as she could and she still couldnt afford the £800 a month mortgage

She had no choice but to sell the house to the council, they let her continue to live there and she still lives there now with one of her adult daughters

She technically has 2 spare bedrooms, but we all visit, all stay over, the grandchildren visit and stay over. And it's all of our families home. I'd be really upset on my mums behalf if she was forced to move out of the home shes spent the last 25 years in so another family could move in

It may well be a council property now, but it's still all of ours home

Kendodd · 27/09/2022 19:41

We need more decent social housing built. We have had it drummed into us that social housing is just for those in poverty or low wages. This is not the case in other countries in Europe and was not the case pre 1979. But hey that's crazy mad communism isn't it !(not)

Completely agree

Branleuse · 27/09/2022 19:39

candycaneframe · 27/09/2022 18:05

When it's being funded by housing benefit it kind of is

What makes you think that social housing = housing benefit?

x2boys · 27/09/2022 19:37

candycaneframe · 27/09/2022 18:05

When it's being funded by housing benefit it kind of is

You are aware many tenants pay their own rent?
And before we go back to the old subsidised housing chestnut, in many parts of the country social housing rent is comparable to private rent.

x2boys · 27/09/2022 19:32

scrufffy · 27/09/2022 18:17

So I should've lived in a house with concrete floors downstairs, uncovered floorboards upstairs and black mould stains and damp marks on the walls?

On another threadvm somebody wanted all social housing to only be allowed basic utilities and food ,so obviously we should all be naked too 🤷‍♀️

Damnautocorrect · 27/09/2022 19:27

Decent maisonettes would solve a lot of the social housing issues. Always harp on about it, gardens, driveways. People would be more tempted to swap if the properties were attractive. They would also suit small families as well as retirees

SadPanda · 27/09/2022 19:05

I've got splinters from fence sitting on this one. On the one hand I think it's their home and forcing elderly people out of the homes they may have lived in for many, many years is pretty shit. But on the other hand my mother has lived in her 4 bedroomed council house for 35 years, the last 10 of which have been entirely by herself. But then her house is in a village where she knows everyone and downsizing would mean moving away completely. Away from neighbours who pop in for a cuppa, away from kids who help her carry her shopping, away from the only community she knows.

So maybe the answer is to build more council houses rather than pit younger families against older people.

Dragonskin · 27/09/2022 19:03

It's also interesting how many people are talking as if they could all be moving into care homes/sheltered housing.

Yet how many people of normal working age are under occupying social housing? Would you like be happy kicked out of your home in your mid 50s and shoved in a flat? Maybe nowhere near work? Then everyone would just be moaning about grandparents not helping out with childcare....

Seymour5 · 27/09/2022 19:00

XenoBitch · 27/09/2022 18:47

The bedroom tax only applies to people on housing benefit.

Yes, it isn't a tax. Its a level of benefits appropriate to the household size. People paying their own rent aren't penalised.

My inlaws downsized from a largish 3 bedroomed house to a smaller ground floor flat. A blessing in terms of heating costs back then, even more so now.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 27/09/2022 18:56

The elderly are exempt from bedroom tax, all it does is have an effect on people like me who when my eldest moved out was classed as having an extra room as the 11 and 9 year old could share

As it is they've never shared as the youngest has autism and no one would ever get any sleep. Luckily I moved onto universal credits who used common sense and I'm now exempt from bedroom tax again

6 months of paying it and having even less to live on though. Not sure how I was supposed to find the money to move into a smaller property at that point

Threadkillacilla · 27/09/2022 18:54

If Starmer added a social housing build to the manifesto he could bank my vote. His speech today impressed me but we've got to address the housing crisis with equal gusto.

Blossomtoes · 27/09/2022 18:50

We should fix the private rental market, not screw over people who have been lucky enough to get some security.

This. And it looks as if Starmer’s planning to do that. I’m looking forward to seeing the detail of how Labour plans to achieve it.

Takingtigermountain · 27/09/2022 18:49

Unfortunately where I live there are a lack of 1/2 bedroom homes that suit alot of older peoples' need. ( Disability access etc). We need more decent social housing built. We have had it drummed into us that social housing is just for those in poverty or low wages. This is not the case in other countries in Europe and was not the case pre 1979. But hey that's crazy mad communism isn't it !(not)

Swipe left for the next trending thread