Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think councils should move people to smaller properties when kids move out?

417 replies

Faithin · 27/09/2022 16:20

There's a huge lack of 3 bedroom social housing where I live (and everywhere I think?)
a lot of the people living in the 3 bed places are usually just 1 or 2 adults as the kids have grown up and moved out. Meanwhile there's lots of young families overcrowded in 1 and 2 bed flats with no garden etc
aibu to think those that actually need the space should be in the houses and those who don't should be made to downsize?
as the waiting list is so long, what tends to happen is peoples children are in their teens by the time they are moved into a 3 bed property, the grow up and leave within a couple of years and the parents stay, so the vast majority are under-occupied.

OP posts:
EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 27/09/2022 21:46

I'm not sure HA would agree that they are tax payers houses! And many people pay their own rent. Is that the same for private rentals that are paid for by hb? I don't think so

ArgieBargie · 27/09/2022 21:42

scrufffy · 27/09/2022 21:30

Not everyone is able to make the choices I did @ArgieBargie And I was only able to do what I have due to the stability the house gave me

I know not everyone can and so I think housing stock should be better protected for exactly those people to benefit. And if people knew that if they wanted to pass a property down to their children or have final choice over the size and type of property they live in then they need to try and make choices to enable that I think more people would. Lifetime tenancies should be scrapped (tbh I don’t see why not existing ones as well as new ones, the terms on my student loan are being changed all the time years after I took it out) and social housing presented as being needs based and time limited. That’s still a fantastic resource for the people who do need it and the people who don’t will soon move on.

ArgieBargie · 27/09/2022 21:37

Willowswave · 27/09/2022 16:52

Yanbu. It’s unethical that familes with young children are housed in tiny 1-2 bed flats while 3 bed houses have one occupant.

I get that people may orefer to stay in the 3 bed inatead of downsizing. Who wouldn’t?! But it isn’t their house, it’s the taxpayer’s house and it should be lent to whoever needs it most, not given to one person for life.

Don’t even get me started on the huge profits some people make with ‘right to buy’.

Exactly this. It’s the taxpayer’s house and it’s lent for as long as you need that size house (which is already v generous security) and once you don’t need toast size any more then you will be lent another that is actually suitable for your needs OR you can rent or buy privately. Literally no reasonable argument against this that aren’t just ‘I like ‘my’ house so screw everyone else’.

scrufffy · 27/09/2022 21:30

Not everyone is able to make the choices I did @ArgieBargie And I was only able to do what I have due to the stability the house gave me

ArgieBargie · 27/09/2022 21:26

scrufffy · 27/09/2022 21:23

And for the record. I left where I was to take this house. I moved almost 20 miles. Because there was a house here. And I had nowhere else to live at the time.

As soon as I was able, I bought and moved. But not everyone is able to do that.

The house gave me roots and stability at a time that I needed it and most importantly it enabled my children to have stability which helped them

So it was valuable for you when you needed it and when you wanted something different you sorted yourself out. That’s how this is supposed to work; that’s good. People always have choices, though they like to make out they don’t.

ArgieBargie · 27/09/2022 21:24

Fuwari · 27/09/2022 17:57

This again, yawn!

Everyone has to take their turn. I was also at one time stuck in a 2 bed flat with 2 dc (opposite sexes) looking at all the old people "hogging" 3 bed houses. I had to wait until mine were teens to get a 3 bed. That's how it works.

I then managed a canny swap and got myself into a lovely 4bed. (At the time, 2005, my HA would allow you to swap into somewhere with 1 more bedroom than needed) Beautiful house (Victorian on a private street) brilliant location. Like hell am I ever giving it up and I have a secure tenancy so it is mine till I die! You don't like that, tough.

My HA offer 1k per bedroom to downsize. I'd need at least a 2 bed as autistic DS will probably always live with me. That's 2k I'd get and I have spent several times that on doing up this house. It just isn't worth it. I have paid my own rent since I moved in so the bedroom tax doesn't matter.

I am going to enjoy my house to the fullest. Random strangers stuck in whatever they're stuck in is of no concern to me. That's life.

‘Random strangers stuck in whatever they’re stuck in is of no concern to me’ and there we are. ‘I’m alright Jack’ indeed. Rank.

scrufffy · 27/09/2022 21:23

Sorry - not this house. The council house.

scrufffy · 27/09/2022 21:23

And for the record. I left where I was to take this house. I moved almost 20 miles. Because there was a house here. And I had nowhere else to live at the time.

As soon as I was able, I bought and moved. But not everyone is able to do that.

The house gave me roots and stability at a time that I needed it and most importantly it enabled my children to have stability which helped them

Coucous · 27/09/2022 21:21

If high tax earners are being forced to pay more then the government needs to ensure that money is spent appropriately - that includes rehousing people and moving them on when they are in a position to pay rent privately so others who need the council houses more can have access. Isn't this how it's meant to work?

scrufffy · 27/09/2022 21:20

@ArgieBargie this village has 2 empty council houses at the moment. People don't want to live here. There is no public transport so if you don't have a car it's impossible. Kids have a 90 minute bus journey to school. Each way. It's very run down. So much so my DC got a contextual offer to university.

The way to build up communities isn't by making them transitory - it's by giving people somewhere to feel connected to and put down roots.

I took the council house because I was desperate. My kids deserved the chance to have stability.

The solution isn't to take that from me.

ArgieBargie · 27/09/2022 21:18

NalaNana · 27/09/2022 17:49

Separate issue but I can't believe that they are homes for life with no thresholds! My friend's partner has just got a new job and their annual combined income will now be over £50,000 (up north). I asked them if the new job would mean they would have to leave and couldn't believe it when they said no, when you're in the system, you're in! Surely council housing should be available for those who need it?!

Exactly this. I’m from the NW and £50k household is comfortably middle class. They should at least be charged market rent and ideally evicted (with significant notice of even a year to extend the cushiness social housing tenants are used to). There are people who need that house and this couple aren’t it.

MessyBunPersonified · 27/09/2022 21:18

ArgieBargie · 27/09/2022 21:09

And why do I want access to social housing? Cos it’s a ridiculously sweet deal, I can see that very clearly! Sadly I earn well enough to not force my child into overcrowded accommodation so will always be so far down the list for it never to materialise for me (a broader point there that if you CAN wait as long as needed you probably never actually needed it anyway). I’d love a nice 4 bed I could pass to my son while never needing to cough up for a deposit or a market rate mortgage and have someone else do all my repairs for me. But given I can see there is no way to provide that for everyone in the UK, I’m absolutely happily that doesn’t include me as I work hard and can manage independently. I think it should be for people who need it, who are in crisis or who have no alternatives. And what they’re provided with should be good quality, safe and secure. I’d be ashamed to take that from someone who needed it.

Maybe you should apply for social housing. I think they give extra points for being sanctimonious, that will get you right to the top of the list 🙄

ArgieBargie · 27/09/2022 21:15

scrufffy · 27/09/2022 21:05

@ArgieBargie where would you send me to? There is literally nowhere within 8 miles of where I used to live to send me

My life and friends are in the village. It took me a long time to settle after leaving my ex. Why should I be sent away from where my support is?

Because that’s life. It’s hard sometimes. 8 miles is not that far; I commute over 30 miles to work (I now drive but that used to be a series of trains and buses). Until recently I had little support network here as I had to leave the area I’m originally from as there were no jobs there. Life isn’t always ideal, sometimes you have to set up somewhere new and manage. Or you choose not to do that, which means paying your own way. I’m talking in general; I haven’t read all your posts (nor all of @MessyBunPersonified which is why I didn’t know a lot of her kids are still at home, though why I’d be interested to know that is beyond me). I’m sorry if you have health issues or disabilities that mean you rely more than usual on a support network though and at the same time have limited opportunities to earn enough money to give yourself an alternative. It’s partly for people in that situation why I think people who are under-occupying houses who earn well and whose only additional ‘need’ was having children should be moved on to smaller properties / charged market rent. That way what we could offer people who actually need it would be a lot better.

ofwarren · 27/09/2022 21:12

scrufffy · 27/09/2022 21:03

Not where I am. The council houses are priced per bedroom.

Same here
Never heard of that at all.

ArgieBargie · 27/09/2022 21:10

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 27/09/2022 21:00

@ofwarren They are if they're in the same HA. For example, all properties within my HA are £470pm. 1 bed flat up to 6 bed houses

That’s obscene.

ArgieBargie · 27/09/2022 21:09

And why do I want access to social housing? Cos it’s a ridiculously sweet deal, I can see that very clearly! Sadly I earn well enough to not force my child into overcrowded accommodation so will always be so far down the list for it never to materialise for me (a broader point there that if you CAN wait as long as needed you probably never actually needed it anyway). I’d love a nice 4 bed I could pass to my son while never needing to cough up for a deposit or a market rate mortgage and have someone else do all my repairs for me. But given I can see there is no way to provide that for everyone in the UK, I’m absolutely happily that doesn’t include me as I work hard and can manage independently. I think it should be for people who need it, who are in crisis or who have no alternatives. And what they’re provided with should be good quality, safe and secure. I’d be ashamed to take that from someone who needed it.

scrufffy · 27/09/2022 21:05

@ArgieBargie where would you send me to? There is literally nowhere within 8 miles of where I used to live to send me

My life and friends are in the village. It took me a long time to settle after leaving my ex. Why should I be sent away from where my support is?

ArgieBargie · 27/09/2022 21:04

And for the ‘it’s not subsidised’ brigade; you’re being pedantic. It’s always significantly under market rates; councils SHOULD make profit on people now doing well for themselves in order to be able to offer more support to people who need it. Short of moving people on then absolutely rents should be raised to market rates once people are earning an above average wage. People get to stay in their ‘homes’ but at least help the people they’re shafting by blocking up housing stock by paying properly for the privilege. And succession rights should be scrapped. Tenancies are only passed on to a tenant’s children where those children are adults. ‘Kicking them out of the only hole they’re ever known’ lord above, give me a break. They’re adults; they should manage to support themselves not love forever in (not their) parents’ house. No one is saying kick them out immediately; a year after the actual tenant’s death is more than enough time to source suitable alternative accommodation and get sorted to move slowly. And on the broader point of actually (shock horror) paying market rates for the place you live once on a decent income; social housing would still be a great option as it’s lifetime and you’re still not responsible for your repairs etc. Everyone’s a winner!

scrufffy · 27/09/2022 21:03

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 27/09/2022 21:00

@ofwarren They are if they're in the same HA. For example, all properties within my HA are £470pm. 1 bed flat up to 6 bed houses

Not where I am. The council houses are priced per bedroom.

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 27/09/2022 21:00

@ofwarren They are if they're in the same HA. For example, all properties within my HA are £470pm. 1 bed flat up to 6 bed houses

MessyBunPersonified · 27/09/2022 21:00

ArgieBargie · 27/09/2022 20:58

Why should you leave it? Cos having been there yourself, you know what it’s like to flee DV with young children and need a safe place to live. Yes the gov need to build more housing stock (and people need to stop selfishly buying their council houses for pennies thanks to shit Tory policies which allow it) but until they are, you are the reason someone in need doesn’t have a safe and secure place to live. Cos you’ve spent some money which you’ve saved thanks to super cheap housing doing some painting and decorating. I’d be ashamed to do that, but you’ve done well out of the current system so you keep milking it for all its worth.

Most of my kids still live at home, don't let the facts stand in the way of a good bout of jealousy though 🤣

ArgieBargie · 27/09/2022 20:58

MessyBunPersonified · 27/09/2022 20:53

Why do you want access to social housing when you have your lovely 2 bedroom rental?

I did flee DV and spent almost a year in a reduge (and then got a lifetime tenancy on my beautiful 4 bed home 😘) so I know what its like, but why the hell would Inow leave my home that I've spent thousands doing up, to live in a smaller place that costs me more, and I would have to start doing it up again. I know your landlord is obliged to do decorating and carpets but mine isn't.

Council houses aren't subsidised, private landlords need to make profit, council houses just need to sustain themselves, so they aren't subsidised, they are just cheaper than private.

Why should you leave it? Cos having been there yourself, you know what it’s like to flee DV with young children and need a safe place to live. Yes the gov need to build more housing stock (and people need to stop selfishly buying their council houses for pennies thanks to shit Tory policies which allow it) but until they are, you are the reason someone in need doesn’t have a safe and secure place to live. Cos you’ve spent some money which you’ve saved thanks to super cheap housing doing some painting and decorating. I’d be ashamed to do that, but you’ve done well out of the current system so you keep milking it for all its worth.

MessyBunPersonified · 27/09/2022 20:53

ArgieBargie · 27/09/2022 20:36

@MessyBunPersonified I consider my situation far from ‘shit’, thanks for that though. Of course social housing ‘rent’ is subsidised, it’s usually under £100/week which is paltry. It’s ridiculously entitled to think people get to stay in as pp said ‘the biggest house they’ve ever needed’ forever and pass it down just cos… why, exactly? Cos that’s nice for them? We cannot build the housing stock to meet that need and once we’re at a point where some people get super cheap or free housing and can stay forever and pass it on once they die, then housing needs to become a right and EVERYONE gets access to it. But we won’t, cos people who once needed help get in and hog it and never leave so that people that need it NOW are cramped into tiny flats or genuinely shit (unlike my nice 2 bed rental home 😘) hostels and bedsits. Those people should be ashamed, and I would be. It’s taking something from someone who really needs it just cos… I’m alright Jack, ultimately. And ‘there are no 1 or 2 beds available’ of course there bloody are, but shock horror you might have to stand on your own two feet and rent or buy yourself, which people should well be able to do after years of cheap housing. But after the luxury of lovely subsidised secure housing why would someone consider the general good and other people; fuck women fleeing DV with young children, eh. You keep your lovely 3 bed with a garage and a big garden cos ‘ohhh it’s my home’. 🤮

Why do you want access to social housing when you have your lovely 2 bedroom rental?

I did flee DV and spent almost a year in a reduge (and then got a lifetime tenancy on my beautiful 4 bed home 😘) so I know what its like, but why the hell would Inow leave my home that I've spent thousands doing up, to live in a smaller place that costs me more, and I would have to start doing it up again. I know your landlord is obliged to do decorating and carpets but mine isn't.

Council houses aren't subsidised, private landlords need to make profit, council houses just need to sustain themselves, so they aren't subsidised, they are just cheaper than private.

Calandor · 27/09/2022 20:51

@ChelseaRobertsofMalibu I'm well aware that things change and I do believe that where possible people should swap homes with families. I was simply sharing what the people being forced out of their homes would say to someone slating them as selfish.

That there are criticisms made on both sides and that the fault actually lies with the government and the system.

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 27/09/2022 20:46

Saladd0dger · 27/09/2022 17:33

My sister is in a very large 2 bed house with huge garden. She is disabled and hasn’t been upstairs in her house in 2 years. Luckily the bathroom is downstairs. The housing association block every swap she finds. She’s desperate for a bungalow as she is only going to get worse as she gets older. She’s currently 36. No bungalows ever get built. So she’s forced to keep paying bedroom tax thst she can’t really afford.

May I ask, why are they blocking her swaps? I'm trying to swap for the same reason. Worried now!

Swipe left for the next trending thread