Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think councils should move people to smaller properties when kids move out?

417 replies

Faithin · 27/09/2022 16:20

There's a huge lack of 3 bedroom social housing where I live (and everywhere I think?)
a lot of the people living in the 3 bed places are usually just 1 or 2 adults as the kids have grown up and moved out. Meanwhile there's lots of young families overcrowded in 1 and 2 bed flats with no garden etc
aibu to think those that actually need the space should be in the houses and those who don't should be made to downsize?
as the waiting list is so long, what tends to happen is peoples children are in their teens by the time they are moved into a 3 bed property, the grow up and leave within a couple of years and the parents stay, so the vast majority are under-occupied.

OP posts:
x2boys · 28/09/2022 10:25

ImAvingOops · 28/09/2022 10:18

The councils could build mobile homes to address the housing shortages - the ones that were built after ww2 lasted for decades and these days it's possible to build strong, energy efficient, really nice homes that don't cost the earth to buy. I would happily live in one

Do you mean prefab,or mobile homes?

ImAvingOops · 28/09/2022 10:18

The councils could build mobile homes to address the housing shortages - the ones that were built after ww2 lasted for decades and these days it's possible to build strong, energy efficient, really nice homes that don't cost the earth to buy. I would happily live in one

ThatGirlInACountrySong · 28/09/2022 08:50

If you have a 'mortgage' then it's not YOUR home either until that final payment is made!Wink

SkySmiler · 28/09/2022 08:48

pompei8309 · 27/09/2022 16:29

BigFatLiar- no, it’s not their home , they’re tenants in council/housing association accommodation

Of course it's still their home 🙄

ThatGirlInACountrySong · 28/09/2022 08:47

Openrelationship · 27/09/2022 17:57

It’s not true to say there aren’t smaller properties for them to move into. The majority of people seeking a 3 bed are families who have lived in 2 bedroom council houses for years, and their children have now reached an age where they qualify for 3 beds (usually when oldest is around age 10) but they are waiting for years. I don’t understand why the HA’s (as they’re not usually council owned anymore) don’t just force a swap from the underoccupied with the overoccupied.
The bedroom tax was a farce as it didn’t apply to pensioners.
Social housing needs a huge overhaul.

'Force' a swap? Have a word with yourself!! 😆

Pottedpalm · 28/09/2022 08:47

Elsiebear90 · 27/09/2022 16:50

I think it’s fair given the lack of social and affordable housing. I know that there is this expectation that with council houses they’re your’s for life if you want them to be and people spend a lot of money decorating them, but I think this needs to change given the issues we have with overcrowding and lack of affordable housing.

They also need to stop right to buy, because that’s the main cause of the lack of social housing.

I grew up in a council house, my parents used right to buy, but I can see it’s not right that their neighbours live in three bed council houses as single elderly people while families are cramped in one bed flats. It’s also not right that my parents bought a council house for a huge discount when they could have easily afforded to buy a property on their own. My cousins have recently given their pensioner parents 40k to buy their council home that’s worth more than three times that because “it’s a good investment” and will be left to them as inheritance. Surely people can’t agree with this while we have a shortage of social and affordable housing?

Let’s hope they get their inheritance; it may well go in care fees.

gamerchick · 28/09/2022 08:38

Beezknees · 28/09/2022 07:34

I agree OP, I have one DC and we live in a 2 bedroom council flat. I was very lucky to get this flat as a young single mum and the rent is very low. Once my DC has moved out permanently I'd be happy to move to a one bedroom place, as an adult it's my responsibility to work and stand on my own 2 feet, the council property was to help me raise my DC in suitable accommodation. I don't agree that I am entitled to this flat as my home for life, it should go to another single mum to help them out like it did for me.

You can work and love in a council house you know. In fact the coincil prefers that.

JustLyra · 28/09/2022 08:28

Kendodd · 27/09/2022 18:30

Personally I think the best thing the government could do is a massive council house building programme, so that people have secure home. I think it would be the biggest way to reduce poverty as well.

This.

where I live there’s been a lot of building by two HA’s over the last 5-8 years and the knock on effect had been positive for pretty much everyone.

A lot of private rental properties were freed up when people were allocated a new one. That meant folks looking for a new private rental had more choice. This in turn forced the LL’s who were charging ridiculous prices to drop them down to stay competitive and in combo with a LL registration scheme (sadly a pilot thats now been scrapped due to funding cuts) actually saw quite a number of the shittiest landlords bail out and sell up.

One of the HA’s here has a swap move Team as well. If they class a swap as beneficial to all they properly get involved in helping people move. They have a lorry for removals and a few guys who’ll actually lift and move stuff. They also let people downsize swap, but don’t necessarily insist on an elderly couple going down to a one bed. I know of one recently who downsized from a 5 bed to a 3 bed - the other HA wouldn’t have allowed that so they’d have stayed put as there are no 1 or 2 beds in the bit of town they’re from. That HA have the higher number of downsizers locally going by a recent community meeting and I think that’s a huge part as to why.

scrufffy · 28/09/2022 07:59

Seymour5 · 28/09/2022 07:09

So many here seem to think all council housing is desirable. It's not.There is big demand for social housing here, yet there are estates where only really desperate people will move. There are housing officers whose job is to manage anti social behaviour. Anyone seen an equivalent in the private sector?

And BTW its not subsidised, just run on a different basis to private rentals. Councils have something called Housing Revenue Accounts, perhaps a read of one might prove useful.

This is so true. Where I was was not in the least desirable and still isn't.

scrufffy · 28/09/2022 07:58

Beezknees · 28/09/2022 07:34

I agree OP, I have one DC and we live in a 2 bedroom council flat. I was very lucky to get this flat as a young single mum and the rent is very low. Once my DC has moved out permanently I'd be happy to move to a one bedroom place, as an adult it's my responsibility to work and stand on my own 2 feet, the council property was to help me raise my DC in suitable accommodation. I don't agree that I am entitled to this flat as my home for life, it should go to another single mum to help them out like it did for me.

Why should only single mums get housed?

Also, no harm to you, but your DS isn't an adult yet. What you think you'll be happy to do might change once he is.

Dogscanteatonions · 28/09/2022 07:52

Don't forget that renting from council you generally have to put your own carpets curtains, curtain poles, oven hob, do your own decorating etc so it is different from renting privately. People spend hundreds if not thousands over the years on maintaining their council home

DuckBilledFattypus · 28/09/2022 07:45

Beezknees · 28/09/2022 07:34

I agree OP, I have one DC and we live in a 2 bedroom council flat. I was very lucky to get this flat as a young single mum and the rent is very low. Once my DC has moved out permanently I'd be happy to move to a one bedroom place, as an adult it's my responsibility to work and stand on my own 2 feet, the council property was to help me raise my DC in suitable accommodation. I don't agree that I am entitled to this flat as my home for life, it should go to another single mum to help them out like it did for me.

Why should it go to another single mum?

x2boys · 28/09/2022 07:42

Beezknees · 28/09/2022 07:34

I agree OP, I have one DC and we live in a 2 bedroom council flat. I was very lucky to get this flat as a young single mum and the rent is very low. Once my DC has moved out permanently I'd be happy to move to a one bedroom place, as an adult it's my responsibility to work and stand on my own 2 feet, the council property was to help me raise my DC in suitable accommodation. I don't agree that I am entitled to this flat as my home for life, it should go to another single mum to help them out like it did for me.

So only single mums should get social housing 🤔

Beezknees · 28/09/2022 07:34

I agree OP, I have one DC and we live in a 2 bedroom council flat. I was very lucky to get this flat as a young single mum and the rent is very low. Once my DC has moved out permanently I'd be happy to move to a one bedroom place, as an adult it's my responsibility to work and stand on my own 2 feet, the council property was to help me raise my DC in suitable accommodation. I don't agree that I am entitled to this flat as my home for life, it should go to another single mum to help them out like it did for me.

notdaddycool · 28/09/2022 07:11

I 100% are in principle, but it then gets labelled the bedroom tax and the government are demonised.

Seymour5 · 28/09/2022 07:09

So many here seem to think all council housing is desirable. It's not.There is big demand for social housing here, yet there are estates where only really desperate people will move. There are housing officers whose job is to manage anti social behaviour. Anyone seen an equivalent in the private sector?

And BTW its not subsidised, just run on a different basis to private rentals. Councils have something called Housing Revenue Accounts, perhaps a read of one might prove useful.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 28/09/2022 06:54

ArgieBargie · 27/09/2022 21:10

That’s obscene.

It's also incorrect.

x2boys · 28/09/2022 06:47

Dragonskin · 28/09/2022 06:42

It wouldn't help her financially as 1 bed flats are the same rent as 3 bed houses. All social housing properties in each council/Housing association have the same rate

That is ridiculous, they should be priced according to size. Of course there is no incentive to move, who in earth would happily pay the same money for a worse standard of living in order to help random strangers? No one

They are in most H/A,s .

Dragonskin · 28/09/2022 06:42

It wouldn't help her financially as 1 bed flats are the same rent as 3 bed houses. All social housing properties in each council/Housing association have the same rate

That is ridiculous, they should be priced according to size. Of course there is no incentive to move, who in earth would happily pay the same money for a worse standard of living in order to help random strangers? No one

x2boys · 28/09/2022 06:36

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 27/09/2022 21:00

@ofwarren They are if they're in the same HA. For example, all properties within my HA are £470pm. 1 bed flat up to 6 bed houses

Not in my HA they are not I have a two bedroom house which I pay less for then a three bedroom ,and the one bedroom flats opposite pay less than I do.

x2boys · 28/09/2022 06:28

ArgieBargie · 27/09/2022 20:36

@MessyBunPersonified I consider my situation far from ‘shit’, thanks for that though. Of course social housing ‘rent’ is subsidised, it’s usually under £100/week which is paltry. It’s ridiculously entitled to think people get to stay in as pp said ‘the biggest house they’ve ever needed’ forever and pass it down just cos… why, exactly? Cos that’s nice for them? We cannot build the housing stock to meet that need and once we’re at a point where some people get super cheap or free housing and can stay forever and pass it on once they die, then housing needs to become a right and EVERYONE gets access to it. But we won’t, cos people who once needed help get in and hog it and never leave so that people that need it NOW are cramped into tiny flats or genuinely shit (unlike my nice 2 bed rental home 😘) hostels and bedsits. Those people should be ashamed, and I would be. It’s taking something from someone who really needs it just cos… I’m alright Jack, ultimately. And ‘there are no 1 or 2 beds available’ of course there bloody are, but shock horror you might have to stand on your own two feet and rent or buy yourself, which people should well be able to do after years of cheap housing. But after the luxury of lovely subsidised secure housing why would someone consider the general good and other people; fuck women fleeing DV with young children, eh. You keep your lovely 3 bed with a garage and a big garden cos ‘ohhh it’s my home’. 🤮

Yeah ,you have no idea do you ?
You can't just pass the house down there is only one succession of tenancy so I haveca joint tenancy with my dh If I die before him he succeeds the tenancy as a single tenant and vice versa, it can't continue to be passed down ,as for your subsidy bull shit how about areas ,of the country where social rent is comparable to private?
Embarrassing people talk such nonsense.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 27/09/2022 22:07

It’s an unpopular opinion but I agree.

Yes it’s their home. But they are still tenants.

gamerchick · 27/09/2022 22:04

And for the ‘it’s not subsidised’ brigade; you’re being pedantic. It’s always significantly under market rates; councils SHOULD make profit on

So not subsidised then? That cleared that up Hmm

Pollydon · 27/09/2022 21:52

ImAvingOops · 27/09/2022 21:51

Tenants are also tax payers! They aren't being given free houses and if they are in receipt of housing benefit then it's because HB is needed!

This, 100%.

ImAvingOops · 27/09/2022 21:51

Tenants are also tax payers! They aren't being given free houses and if they are in receipt of housing benefit then it's because HB is needed!