Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think councils should move people to smaller properties when kids move out?

417 replies

Faithin · 27/09/2022 16:20

There's a huge lack of 3 bedroom social housing where I live (and everywhere I think?)
a lot of the people living in the 3 bed places are usually just 1 or 2 adults as the kids have grown up and moved out. Meanwhile there's lots of young families overcrowded in 1 and 2 bed flats with no garden etc
aibu to think those that actually need the space should be in the houses and those who don't should be made to downsize?
as the waiting list is so long, what tends to happen is peoples children are in their teens by the time they are moved into a 3 bed property, the grow up and leave within a couple of years and the parents stay, so the vast majority are under-occupied.

OP posts:
Bideshi · 27/09/2022 17:01

Yeah good idea. Worked well in the Soviet Union and allocated housing works efficiently in China now. Probably equally good in North Korea if only we knew.

x2boys · 27/09/2022 17:00

Ahbisto · 27/09/2022 16:55

I think there is a lot of emotion tied to this and that’s why tenancies for life are being scaled out. I personally believe social housing should be reviewed annually as to the need and if the need no longer exists then end the tenancy And move to either a smaller property or to a private rental if income has increased past the level you’d currently be eligible/

my opinion is they should be there to fill a need for as long as it is an actual need/

How do you suggest they renew tenancies annually ,?have you a idea of the time and money that would take?

Pengwinn · 27/09/2022 16:58

Ahbisto · 27/09/2022 16:55

I think there is a lot of emotion tied to this and that’s why tenancies for life are being scaled out. I personally believe social housing should be reviewed annually as to the need and if the need no longer exists then end the tenancy And move to either a smaller property or to a private rental if income has increased past the level you’d currently be eligible/

my opinion is they should be there to fill a need for as long as it is an actual need/

The amount it would cost to set up a system and conduct annual reviews would be eye watering, not to mention when we look at other judgements made as part of gov initiatives it would undoubtedly be very unfair. Depending where you live there aren't actually always a tonne of 1 or 2 bed properties, there are hardly any here and the wait list for a one bed is longer than for a family home. The better thing surely would be for the gov to actually address the mess that is housing.

Voila567 · 27/09/2022 16:58

I agree

MessyBunPersonified · 27/09/2022 16:58

Ahbisto · 27/09/2022 16:55

I think there is a lot of emotion tied to this and that’s why tenancies for life are being scaled out. I personally believe social housing should be reviewed annually as to the need and if the need no longer exists then end the tenancy And move to either a smaller property or to a private rental if income has increased past the level you’d currently be eligible/

my opinion is they should be there to fill a need for as long as it is an actual need/

What a great idea, that will definitely encourage people to better themselves 👍 🙄

If I were to take a job with a pay just over the threshold which would then double my living costs, I just wouldn't take the job, it wouldn't be viable.

Mrsjayy · 27/09/2022 16:58

I think my parents would benefit from a smaller house I suggested putting in for the new build but they like their home so that's where they will be stay.

Sisiwawa · 27/09/2022 16:57

Yes, people's needs should be assessed every 5 years, I know people that got houses or flats 20 or 30 years ago when they needed them, now they are all earning good money and have 2nd houses abroad, its rife but obviously kept quiet. They could afford to now rent privately. It's a micky take

Faithin · 27/09/2022 16:56

feellikeanalien · 27/09/2022 16:50

There are quite a few people on MN who really don't like those on benefits or in social housing.

As for the comment that people who rent social housing are not entitled to call where they live their home, well I think I've heard it all now.

What a nasty society we are becoming.

i certainly don't hate those people as I am one of them, I live in social housing myself and receive benefits as I am a single parent with a disabled child

OP posts:
Pengwinn · 27/09/2022 16:56

No, it's their home. My aunt lives in social housing in a 2 bed, her DS has moved out but has complex mental health issues so stays over often. She's also paid in rent over the years circa £210k which is much more than the house is worth on the market even with repairs included, if she had been fortunate enough to be able to club together a deposit years ago she would happily own the family home for substantially less than she's actually paid and be able to live in it for life and her son get money once it sold. As is that's not the case.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 27/09/2022 16:55

Well there are some quite nice 1/2 bed flats in this area with gardens. I lived in one myself at one point with 2 dc.

I'll quite happily move into one like that again when the dc leave home. I'll not go into some tower block though or somewhere with no outdoor space

Ahbisto · 27/09/2022 16:55

I think there is a lot of emotion tied to this and that’s why tenancies for life are being scaled out. I personally believe social housing should be reviewed annually as to the need and if the need no longer exists then end the tenancy And move to either a smaller property or to a private rental if income has increased past the level you’d currently be eligible/

my opinion is they should be there to fill a need for as long as it is an actual need/

Mrsjayy · 27/09/2022 16:54

pompei8309 · 27/09/2022 16:29

BigFatLiar- no, it’s not their home , they’re tenants in council/housing association accommodation

What is wrong with you of course it is their home!

Circleoflife2057 · 27/09/2022 16:52

Instead of forcing people out of their home the government should increase the supply of social housing. You are looking at the problem from the wrong angle and blaming the wrong people. The government has sold off council houses and doesn't build enough new ones with an increasing population so demand outstrips supply.

Willowswave · 27/09/2022 16:52

Yanbu. It’s unethical that familes with young children are housed in tiny 1-2 bed flats while 3 bed houses have one occupant.

I get that people may orefer to stay in the 3 bed inatead of downsizing. Who wouldn’t?! But it isn’t their house, it’s the taxpayer’s house and it should be lent to whoever needs it most, not given to one person for life.

Don’t even get me started on the huge profits some people make with ‘right to buy’.

SpinningFloppa · 27/09/2022 16:52

I don’t know where people live but in my part of London there are loads of 1 bed flats way more than 2/3/4 beds significantly more!

MadeInChorley · 27/09/2022 16:52

It’s their home. They are settled and comfortable and they will likely get less space for more money. Plus the hassle of moving house, getting rid of half your possessions to fit and often a sentimental attachment to a home where you brought up your family. People don’t want to move away from existing support networks of neighbours and family and often. Councils do offer incentives to downsize, but if they are happy, then effectively the Council would have to evict them.

Look, it’s not even about Council tenants - you get the same discussions about elderly homeowners sitting in 4 bedroom properties with gardens, while families are desperate to move into larger homes. Same issues apply.

lannistunut · 27/09/2022 16:52

FarmerRefuted · 27/09/2022 16:50

Why don't you direct your anger at the government who allowed, and are still allowing, the selling off of social housing stock and who are doing the sum total of Jack fucking shit to address housing issues?

Exactly this.

Eastangular2000 · 27/09/2022 16:52

Calandor · 27/09/2022 16:44

Plus, those people could equally say why did you have more children when you couldn't afford a home with enough space.

Criticism can go both ways you know.

This. Why are all these families in 1 and 2 beds having children they can't house?

maranella · 27/09/2022 16:52
  • A lot more social housing needs to be built.
  • When (if) it is, planners should take a look at successful social housing communities in many countries in Europe where 1, 2, 3 and 4-bedroom properties are all mixed into the same community, so that people can move into a more spacious one as their family grows and into a smaller one again after DC move out, thereby not losing their community and friends when their circumstances change.
  • While I agree with you in principal OP, the UK social housing stock is not set up to do this, so you get streets full of family homes and tower blocks full of 1 and 2 beds. We need a better mix of home sizes and types within one single community to allow for greater housing flexibility. But I do think if you are a social tenant you should accept that your home isn't a home for life - it's a home while you need that size of home - and when your needs change so will your housing.
lannistunut · 27/09/2022 16:51

Faithin · 27/09/2022 16:43

Because it doesn't belong to them and there is a lack of adequate social housing?
why should children spend their entire childhoods in over crowded tower blocks with no outside space so that a single couple can have 2 spare bedrooms and plenty of space?

We need to build more suitable homes, not try to steal the ones already allocated.

You are just encouraging a further reduction in tenants' rights - so trying to speed up the race to the bottom.

Cillery · 27/09/2022 16:50

Of course logically people should move out from social housing when they have no kids into something smaller but of course there is more to a house and an area than just rooms and people have lived their life there and have all their contacts and memories

Mrsjayy · 27/09/2022 16:50

I think people should be offered a smaller home but they shouldn't be forced to take it and anyway smaller council properties are rare where I live a couple of years ago our council built 6 1 beds and that's it.so where have people to go ?

ChocolateCakeYum · 27/09/2022 16:50

I’m always conflicted about this. On the one hand that’s their home.

On the other hand I think of my MIL rattling around a 3 bed house when she’s been offered a nicer albeit smaller property and refuses to move and I just think there’s a family in need and you’re causing a nuisance. Plus she’s surrounded by young families and hates the noise and yet she clings to it like she thinks she can pass it down to her own children (which obviously won’t happen as she doesn’t own it). Ridiculous.

(for the record, this is not a house that she’s been in all her life, she’s been there maybe 20 years and given all her children were adults by that point so it’s just incongruous as to why she wants to keep it).

FarmerRefuted · 27/09/2022 16:50

Why don't you direct your anger at the government who allowed, and are still allowing, the selling off of social housing stock and who are doing the sum total of Jack fucking shit to address housing issues?

dudsville · 27/09/2022 16:50

I would like to know the stats for this before getting into it. I knew someone who lived in a 2 bed flat with her mother for decades, until her mother died and in her 70's was moved to a 1 bedroom flat far away from work and eventually was a part of her deciding to retire. So I know it happens. What are the stats for this?